Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask you to see who girl guides support.

391 replies

RedCarpetRebellion · 23/11/2021 23:46

www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10235539/amp/Girlguides-launch-probe-trans-Commissioner-58-saucy-dominatrix-style-picture.html

A woman sacked for speaking up for girls safety was replaced by this person.

Girl guides are not safe for girls. AIBU?

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 26/11/2021 09:31

offense by someone else

Sorry.

Helleofabore · 26/11/2021 09:29

So one last thing I still don’t really see the benefit of siphoning off the debate around this stuff to a separate topic. Why should we be dictated where to put stuff? It makes some people appear very guilty of wishing to smother debate.

Because MN will sometimes listen to those who complain about these threads. (Thank you MNHQ for leaving this one here).

Some pundits compare this movement as a particular religious group (a four letter word starting with ‘c’ that gets deleted if mentioned). And when you look at it from the outside, I can see why it is analogous.

People need to smother debate because they believe that to discuss or even acknowledge the conflicts is to do so only from a position of hate. Those people have outsourced their critical thinking to social media influencers, self identifying as influencers anyway. The trope they roll out has come from a diet of twitter or youtube. Not from original sources or from studies themselves. Everything has to be regurgitated into the correct parlance and the right framing of offence by some else. Who rarely has any expertise at all.

They attempt to smother discussion on threads because they cannot provide any information or even balanced thinking to the thread. They are ploppers. They plop down one or two posts that seek to shame and to censure, and censor, and go away with the feeling that they ‘got’ those haters.

Meanwhile, knowledge gets imparted by informed posters, discussion continues and those ploppers are forgotten or any point they raise gets completely overwhelmed by being negated by evidence or counter points.

It plays out this way all the time. Not just here on MN but on twitter.

Still, the call to be kind does mean there are many places you cannot have these discussions. Because the people with the power to control discussion believe kindness should only go one way, to trans people. And any discussion that might mean males will not be included is to be rejected. Such as Facebook groups and some organisations, such as Girl Guides.

brighousepres · 26/11/2021 09:09

A lot to take in. I’ve been walking around with my eyes closed…

Some useful reference points. I’ll check them out. I still don’t get all the abbreviations but the starter thread is a good idea Smile.

I argued about JK with a friend once and she didn’t even let me speak…

So one last thing I still don’t really see the benefit of siphoning off the debate around this stuff to a separate topic. Why should we be dictated where to put stuff? It makes some people appear very guilty of wishing to smother debate. And keep the powerful people happy… And the rest - well just pissed off. When did we lose our rights to just … be?

DrSbaitso · 26/11/2021 09:03

Terf is such a shit insult. Quite apart from the very obvious and deliberate attempt to denigrate feminism itself and lump any protesters as "radicals" as if they're saying something unbelievable (because we don't want a women's rights movement being taken seriously), it's just....a shit insult. Make up a crap insult and call people by its acronym. It's not clever or punchy. It's just...shit.

Helleofabore · 26/11/2021 08:27

It is incredibly telling that this needed to be said

Those posters who still use the words ‘anti-trans’, ‘transphobic’, ‘terf’ and ‘bigot’ don’t seem to have got the message. Thankfully, there are less and less. When challenged they simply can never produce evidence behind their statements and only have emotional manipulation.

DrSbaitso · 26/11/2021 08:20

However, the EHRC chairperson released a statement recently that stated that women have every right to discuss these conflicts without being persecuted or silenced.

It is incredibly telling that this needed to be said.

Helleofabore · 26/11/2021 07:56

Some excellent posts and excellent questions.

Anyone who wants further reading and further resources to look at, it might be a timely reminder to look at the Break it down for me thread.

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/3145470-Break-it-down-for-me

It starts off answering questions but has become an archive of studies, articles etc for further reading.

And the sex and gender discussion board has many issues being discussed.

It is very important though to remember that the discussions are happening from the perspectives of maintaining the rights of all females (ie including those who transition to men, and of course, girls) and children in general. It is the areas of conflict that are discussed.

It is portrayed by a few posters as ‘anti-trans’. This is absolutely not true and is just the new speak since the word ‘bigot’ is generally, and quickly, deleted. However, the EHRC chairperson released a statement recently that stated that women have every right to discuss these conflicts without being persecuted or silenced.

So, discussing these issues is NOT anti-trans. There are many trans people who respect the needs of females and who respect the needs of single sec spaces. Those who use the term ‘anti-trans’ generally believe they are on the ‘right side of history’ but ultimately the right side of history is to have a solution that works to protect all females, all children and to protect transitioned males. There can be no ‘sacred’ sub groups of humans that are exempt from being held accountable for the actions of those within the group. And transitioned males are just a subset of all males. Calling them transwomen implies they are a subset of women, of females.

There is absolutely no evidence that by transitioning, a male decreases the rate of committing sex crimes. Ie. Transwomen still do not commit sex crimes at a rate anywhere near that of females.

Therefore when discussing safeguarding of children, this subset of males need to be treated as if they were male. This is one of the times SEX actually matters and needs to be prioritised over GENDER.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 26/11/2021 07:55

Pleased to see this thread is still here. The recent post from Bosky summarises perfectly the awful position that women and women's organisations are now in.

DrSbaitso · 26/11/2021 07:34

It occurs to me that Rowling has received backlash in the past when she spoke in support of same sex marriage and a black actress being cast to play Hermione in Harry Potter and the Cursed Child. Which I guess you have to expect, sadly. But even then, it didn't start off a neverending tirade of misogynistic and sexualised abuse that saw people trying to silence and intimidate her with threats of rape and murder.

Even the fucking racists and homophobes, as a collective, didn't do this. Yet piss off the loudest layer of this particular lobby by stating that women need some same sex spaces - and look what happens.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 26/11/2021 07:27

Perfectly put @Bosky

Now (thanks to the work of stonewall) The only way to ensure the single sex exemptions in the equality act are applied is for individual women & girls to complain & if necessary take an organisation to court which is fucking nuts!

Imagine - you are a traumatised woman who has suffered from male violence & rape. You go to your local womens refuge and a man identifying as a woman is assigned to be your counsellor. When you object you’re told TWAW Abd that if you can’t accept that, they can’t help that.

What is most likely to happen a) you’ll be off to the nearest solicitor to take them to court? Or b) you just stop using the service.

The refuge congratulates itself on its inclusivity & says no one has ever complained about its TWAW policy

RedCarpetRebellion · 26/11/2021 06:15

[quote Terfydactyl]@Bosky
Here here, damn good summing up.[/quote]
It is.

But I’d add the other reason is ‘sacred caste’.

Create a sacred caste who can’t be questioned (Catholic church, Jimmy Savile, scout volunteers, or in this case gender ideology) and silence anyone who does speak up by any means, no matter how violent, and you create a caste that will inevitably attract those who have nefarious intent.

When people, women, and initially it was lesbians, realised the reality of the scope of harm calling transwomen women had and spoke up they received extreme violence or threats or attacks on their characters. Silence detractors and quickly all people become silenced. And then it becomes the sunken cost fallacy and people find that very compelling.

It’s straight out of Stalin’s play book.

OP posts:
Terfydactyl · 26/11/2021 06:00

@Bosky
Here here, damn good summing up.

Bosky · 26/11/2021 02:04

@Zotter

This means trans women and any man who self ids as woman (without even the need for hormones or surgery - on their say so alone) will have access to all women’s single sex safe spaces. This includes toilets, changing rooms, hospital wards, prisons and rape crisis centres and refuges

If there are no changes to the Equality Act then surely the current exemptions in law that are designed to protect single-sex provision for women will still apply? I think the key is to ensure the Equality Act is not changed.

Sadly, you can see how little use in practice the "current exemptions in law that are designed to protect single-sex provision" are by the very example of Girl Guiding.

GG could have chosen to use the current exemptions in the Equality Act to maintain GG as a single-sex organisation.

GG chose not to use the single-sex exemption.

Edinburgh Rape Crisis could have chosen to use the current exemptions in the Equality Act to maintain a single-sex service. In fact, this sort of service is even given as an example in the Act and in Statutory Guidance by the EHRC.

However, despite advertising a post as for "Females only" with explicit reference to the Equality Act exemption, Edinburgh Rape Crisis chose not to use the single-sex exemption. It did not discard an application from a male who does not have a Gender Recognition Certificate but who "identifies as a woman".

That person, male, is now the CEO of Edinburgh Rape Crisis and describes raped women who are scared of males as "bigots" who need to be "re-educated".

(Most "women only" organisations and services are not single-sex. Any that say they are for "all women" will definitely not be single-sex: "all women" is code for "includes anyone who calls themselves a woman".)

It is up to the Service Provider whether it chooses, or not, to use the single sex exemptions in the Equality Act.

It is up to service users, in the case off GG that means parents, to either:

  • put pressure on GG to apply the EA2010 single sex exemptions
  • or set up an alternative organisation.

However, if the latter then, as a PP has mentioned, they will come up against some venues (and funding organisations) that refuse to have anything to do with single-sex groups/services.

This problem is so much bigger and pervasive than most people realise. This is because:

  • it has all been done by stealth
  • when news of any of it gets out it is so insane that it is hard to believe that it is true
  • only "disgusting right wing papers" like The Mail, The Times, The Telegraph, The Economist and The Spectator have been covering it - so anyone who relies on The Guardian and/or the BBC for information is completely in the dark
  • even on Mumsnet, as seen in this thread, there are efforts by some (often male MN members) to hide information from the wider membership by getting threads like this moved to the FWR Board, as "niche interest".

Despite women's rights and safeguarding children hardly being niche interests on a Parenting website, this has usually been successful, so a "thank you" to MN Mods for letting this thread stay in AIBU.

Anyone who wants to know what the hell is going on and what it means for women and children, I highly recommend a spot of lurking on the "Feminism: Sex & gender discussions" Board

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights

Zotter · 26/11/2021 00:33

This means trans women and any man who self ids as woman (without even the need for hormones or surgery - on their say so alone) will have access to all women’s single sex safe spaces. This includes toilets, changing rooms, hospital wards, prisons and rape crisis centres and refuges

If there are no changes to the Equality Act then surely the current exemptions in law that are designed to protect single-sex provision for women will still apply? I think the key is to ensure the Equality Act is not changed.

HermioneKipper · 25/11/2021 23:12

@brighousepres

I had a post removed and then reinstated on the feminism board asking about why so many trans women keep their penises. It got quite heated.

(The reason it was deleted was likely because of mentions of A**)

I’d go over to the feminism and sex & gender boards. There’s loads of background and info for someone getting to grips with this stuff.

For me, it’s all about women’s rights and spaces being impacted. For TRAs to get everything they’re asking for, comes into direct conflict with women’s rights.

This means trans women and any man who self ids as woman (without even the need for hormones or surgery - on their say so alone) will have access to all women’s single sex safe spaces. This includes toilets, changing rooms, hospital wards, prisons and rape crisis centres and refuges. And obviously women only organisations like girl guides. These “women” nearly always keep their penises.

It also means trans women will have the right to compete in women’s sports. And from the ground level up, impacting women’s opportunities, safety and right to compete in a fair competition.

It was JK Rowling that peaked me. I came from a place of feeling sorry for the old school transsexual who was “born in the wrong body” and likely depressed, who then had full surgery and hormone treatments etc. Also of the view of, what harm could it do to call them a woman and indulge them. Be kind etc.

When in reality now, a huge proportion of trans women keep their penis, take no hormones and take great delight in violating women’s spaces and rights for their own validation. The TRAs are misogynistic and turn on any woman who dares speak out in favour of women, and protecting the rights of women and girls.

Read JK Rowling’s essay. It sums everything up really well. And then look at the abuse she got and continues to get for speaking out on behalf of women. It’s a disgrace. Search her name on Twitter and reams of nasty stuff comes up.

I’m sure there’s plenty of trans people that don’t wish harm to women and support our rights to safety, privacy and dignity in our single sex spaces but there is also a frightening number who wish us ill if we dare to question what’s currently happening. And all backed by Stonewall.

The erasure of the words woman and mother are also something to be deeply concerned about. NHS trusts across the land are taking steps to remove the word woman and mother from their literature. “Pregnant person” is something that’s popping up all too often

HermioneKipper · 25/11/2021 22:34

Well done for putting this on AIBU OP. If its manage to get through to even a few then it’s fantastic.

And thank you to Mumsnet for keeping it here and not bowing to the pressure I’m sure they’re getting from TRAs on this

RedCarpetRebellion · 25/11/2021 22:27

@brighousepres glad it made you realise the every day reality this means for women and girls.

I hope there’s a few that have peaked with this thread. That’s the point of it being in AIBU. Because any safeguarding concern should be discussed where the most parents will see it.

OP posts:
brighousepres · 25/11/2021 22:14

So, 5-10 % remove penises... how many is that? Versus how many keep them? How big is this group of people?

Is there a key for the abbreviations? I’m getting lost… sorry if I’m missing something obvious.

Women are allowed no boundaries, no ability to voice concerns - even on a mums’ forum?

I have seen a lot of upset over these types of threads but never really considered what it actually means for women and girls and the huge impact on daily lives before this thread.

MovedByFanciesThatAreCurled · 25/11/2021 21:58

@ShinyHappyPoster

I feel sad about this. Yy Girlguiding deserve all the negative publicity and hopefully this will create more pressure on them to reconsider. But I also feel this has been deliberate targeting by TRAs and MRAs. Girlguiding was brilliant at saying no to male members. They were amazing at carving out a space for girls and empowering them to enforce their boundaries. And then somewhere funding requirements and aggressive lobbying blew all that away. They threw away everything they stood for and let's be honest TRAs and MRAs don't give a shit about the principles of Girlguiding. They just didn't want an area where women and girls were supported to have boundaries. They wanted to stamp all over women's and girls' rights to say 'no'. It's a disgrace.
Agree with every word of this. Women are not allowed to have any boundaries.
Helleofabore · 25/11/2021 21:52

I believe it is 90-95% of transitioned males retain their penises.

brighousepres · 25/11/2021 21:46

So in raising genuine (not to mention rather obvious) concerns … women are being silenced. Just like the Guide leaders.

OnlyTheTitosaurusOfTheIceberg · 25/11/2021 19:44

This may well be deleted (despite being factual) but for those who don’t yet know: references to The Acronym That Dare Not Speak Its Name are ruthlessly stamped on and reported by the external monitors who circle FWR like sharks sniffing for blood, because the more widely-known it becomes that a proportion of this “most oppressed” demographic are not in seeking support, counselling or surgery for genuine dysphoria but are in fact aroused by images of themselves dressed as/acting as women and get off on violating women’s boundaries, the less sympathy their movement will elicit and the less likely it is the doors to female spaces will be thrown open to anyone claiming to be a woman.

80-85% of TW retain their penis. Of these, a proportion retain their penis but do get breast implants. Often when they refer to “sex reassignment surgery” or similar that’s what is meant. It suits the more unpleasant TRA contingent to leave people assuming, not unreasonably, that SRS means removal of the penis to treat dysphoria.

brighousepres · 25/11/2021 18:25

@Terfydactyl - crumbs!

So… where ARE we permitted to talk about this then?

Terfydactyl · 25/11/2021 17:42

Tangent but for me personally - and I'm sure this would be considered 'transphobic' - I would feel differently about someone who has gone through a full transitioning process (surgery etc) with appropriate counselling & support over several years. I fully grasp that some people spend their whole lives feeling deeply at odds with their birth gender and are willing to make massive sustained sacrifices to live as women. But I struggle with stuff that just feels like thoughtless insensitive cosplay

Yes that would be considered transphobic, I'm not sure how long you've been aware of the issues and not wanting to teach granny to suck eggs and all so this is for lurkers.

The "full transitioning process" is very expensive, difficult, not often an option because medical and other reasons. So the best and most optimistic estimate I ever heard was 20% have had major surgery, not necessarily all the surgery.
The acronym we are not allowed to use means plenty get excitement out of keeping certain genitalia whilst enhancing other aspects so they definitely do not get full transitioning surgery.

SomewhereEast · 25/11/2021 14:14

@DaphneDeloresMoorhead That's a good point. Scouting is open to both genders and has lots of women involved at various levels (like me). I have no idea what the policy is re trans issues but I'd be highly surprised if they couldn't have continued as 'she', assuming there were no other concerns.

Tangent but for me personally - and I'm sure this would be considered 'transphobic' - I would feel differently about someone who has gone through a full transitioning process (surgery etc) with appropriate counselling & support over several years. I fully grasp that some people spend their whole lives feeling deeply at odds with their birth gender and are willing to make massive sustained sacrifices to live as women. But I struggle with stuff that just feels like thoughtless insensitive cosplay.