Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask you to see who girl guides support.

391 replies

RedCarpetRebellion · 23/11/2021 23:46

www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10235539/amp/Girlguides-launch-probe-trans-Commissioner-58-saucy-dominatrix-style-picture.html

A woman sacked for speaking up for girls safety was replaced by this person.

Girl guides are not safe for girls. AIBU?

OP posts:
Shedmistress · 24/11/2021 08:15

@EverNapping

YABU - go back to the Feminism boards, that's what it's for
Even Owen Jones said the other week 'why aren't the feminists speaking out about X' when it was pointed out, they had been but he has blocked them all.

Feminism is for all women. Even those that don't even realise why it is there.

Shedmistress · 24/11/2021 08:13

@Insidelaurashead

My best friend had a baby at 13. Most of my friends were having sex at that age. I wish guides had given out condoms
Did your friend conceive their child at an overnight guides camp?
EverNapping · 24/11/2021 08:12

YABU - go back to the Feminism boards, that's what it's for

EishetChayil · 24/11/2021 08:11

@Insidelaurashead

My best friend had a baby at 13. Most of my friends were having sex at that age. I wish guides had given out condoms

I'd rather we had organisations that encourage girls NOT to be having sex at 13, quite frankly. But that probably makes me a pearl-clutcher of the highest order.

Clymene · 24/11/2021 08:10

My best friend was also having sex at 13. We didn't need guides to give out condoms though because guides were a single sex organisation

IrishMumInLondon2020 · 24/11/2021 08:04

@Insidelaurashead

My best friend had a baby at 13. Most of my friends were having sex at that age. I wish guides had given out condoms
With respect, that is pretty unusual.
WholeClassKeptIn · 24/11/2021 08:02

Brighthouse - but isn't that why we keep men away from girls in general /separate accomodation/toilets etc.

I don't think any of the men I know would abuse. But some do and it is safer to have some same sex spaces/let different sexes sleep separately etc.

A girls only organisation doesn't mean we think all men are dangerous. Similarly excluding male bodies isn't to say all male bodies are dangerous.

PumpkinGin · 24/11/2021 08:02

I am very supportive of transpeople. I think it must be so hard to be uncomfortable with your body and want to change it.

But nobody is allowed to sexualise my children. This is the second time in a short period I hear about GG and inappropriate sex communications. First promoting asexuality (and the likely discussions about sex) and now a leader in BDSM gear on social media.

And the risk of my daughters having sex on a girl guide sleepover is something I hadn’t even considered. It is only girls. And now it seems the bastards planned so it could happen and parents wouldn’t find out as they would dish out condoms and not tell the parents. For 13 year olds. On a sleepover with girls with penises - are they discussing casual sex for 13 year olds as well?

These people are insane. They should have their hard drives checked. Every single one of them.

Clymene · 24/11/2021 08:02

I'm so glad this has been picked up by MSM. This person should not be in a position of responsibility around children.

Where the hell is their due diligence? It took 2 minutes of googling to find all this and Sulley clearly stated they were a guide leader in their Twitter bio which has a very dodgy photo.

It's deeply deeply worrying.

PenguindreamsofDraco · 24/11/2021 07:59

@RedCarpetRebellion

Trans boys and non binary females should be included.

Transwomen and transgirls have scouts which is mixed sex. They can be transgirls there without needing to take away the only organisation solely for girls.

Just confirming, since this is a point that often confuses outside the naughty corner of FWR, transboys = girls who are identifying as boys. Transgirls/TW are boys or men who identify as women. And yes, I agree entirely that all girls, however they currently identify, should be allowed into GG.
brighousepres · 24/11/2021 07:58

This makes me very nervous of my DC joining Guides in the near future. Are girls safe anywhere these days?

brighousepres · 24/11/2021 07:57

‘’If parents buy into transwomen being actual women then the transwoman in the daily Mail article could be handing out condoms to your 13 year old daughter on GG camp, endorsed by the GG policy above.

This isn’t some unexpected one off. GG policies sexualise children and place male bodies people in a position of trust over these girls, handing them condoms on GG camp. Following GG policy.’’

Fucking hell! SadEnvy

It feels like SOME trans people are slowing dismantling girls and women’s rights. Yet the trans woman I know would NEVER do this.

RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 07:53

@PumpkinGin

We can be respectful of trans people in day to day life, supportive of their right to not be discriminated against, and still recognise that women and girls have different needs and rights based on our sex.

No one is exempt from safeguarding laws.

We should never put girls at risk to ‘be kind’ to any group.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 24/11/2021 07:49

I was a Girl Guide. I'll be sending my daughter to Scouts.

BogRollBOGOF · 24/11/2021 07:45

As a leader, it's infuriating that the words "I am a girl" are what distinguishes the safeguarding rules applicable to my sons. They're the same age as my unit, and as they get older it's easier to separate them off from my life in GG. When they were younger and came on residentials it was only viable where we had seperate accomodation/ toileting.

Hypothetically I could train them to say "I am a girl" and then they could share accomodation with their peers.

GG should be same-sex. Male unit helpers have been recognised for a long time mainly as spouses of Leaders that tend to regularly help in the logistics of camp and specialist activity advisors often overlapping with Scouting. That's clear and transparent.
If a member thinks that she may be a trans-boy, a same sex environment may be helpful in understanding her sex and gender expectations. There isn't a safeguarding threat in continuing to include female bodied trans-boys.

It is a top down activists issue and at this point isn't having much impact on individual units.

WholeClassKeptIn · 24/11/2021 07:30

Well yes if "girls with penises" are sharing tents/accomodation with "girls with vaginas" as per policy if being treated the same what do you think might happen?

It's a rather logical outworking. Really "girls with penises" shouldn't be sharing accomodation/tents with "girls with vaginas. " Girls with vaginas should be able to have their own safe space where they meet and camp etc eithout risk of pregnancy fromb"girls with penises.".

GG realky needs to be for "girls with vaginas" as if "girls with penises" are allowed everywhere "girls with vagjnas" are then yes condoms etc will need to be available. As will rape counselling etc.

There's a reason that for most of history "people with penises" had separate facilities to "people with vaginas. "

(If only there was a word for "people with vaginas" that acted as a shorthand and could help keep girls safe in situations like this. Language is so important.)

PumpkinGin · 24/11/2021 07:23

I am trying to get my head around this. Thank you for the explanation OP.

I am very trans supportive but this is wrong. Regardless of whether you are trans or not, a girl guide leader should not pose in dominatrix dress on social media. That is horrific. Teachers aren’t allowed to do that surely? Doesn’t GG have any similar rules?

I am also very unhappy with the condoms. The only people who should discuss anything related to sex with children are parents or teachers under safeguarding guidelines. GG is a place to get away from sexual pressures on girls in a girls only environment.

I would not have expected any risk of anything sexually inappropriate at GG. Why do they need condoms on residentials? Is this because they anticipate that some girls with penises has sex with some girls with vaginas? This is actually shocking.

It was only recently that someone posted that they were discussing sex and asexuality in the meetings for primary school children. I was very concerned about that as well and about the lack of safeguarding principles around that. Now they are handing out condoms on sleepovers and don’t tell the parents?

This organisation needs to be thoroughly investigated.

FreeBritnee · 24/11/2021 07:02

It doesn’t matter that GG want it to disappear. It won’t. It will have been archived and will be pulled out again and again when discussing the lack of safeguarding in the organisation. They need to vet the people within the organisation and stop focusing on diversity points. There are bad eggs within every walk of life.

RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 06:59

@WholeClassKeptIn

Agree. But its all across those that run guides isn't it. Regardless what all the loyal guiders views are.

And they're silencing Facebook groups etc the conversation literally can't happen within the movement. All talk of it is "transphobic".

I think gg will just make this disaapear on SM and crack on. The leadership won't change from their very entrenches views (activists...)

Agree. Their policies make that obvious.

Girls aren’t safe in GG. Parents need to know this.

OP posts:
WholeClassKeptIn · 24/11/2021 06:54

Agree. But its all across those that run guides isn't it. Regardless what all the loyal guiders views are.

And they're silencing Facebook groups etc the conversation literally can't happen within the movement. All talk of it is "transphobic".

I think gg will just make this disaapear on SM and crack on. The leadership won't change from their very entrenches views (activists...)

RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 06:50

Trans boys and non binary females should be included.

Transwomen and transgirls have scouts which is mixed sex. They can be transgirls there without needing to take away the only organisation solely for girls.

OP posts:
SnackSizeRaisin · 24/11/2021 06:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 06:27

@Insidelaurashead

My best friend had a baby at 13. Most of my friends were having sex at that age. I wish guides had given out condoms
I had plenty friends who had babies young. I was having sex young.

We knew we could get condoms from the school nurse when she was in or from local health centre.

It’s entirely inappropriate and very poor safeguarding for other adults to be giving them out. Trained and licences HCP absolutely, but GG or teaches or kids sport coaches or church leaders etc giving them out is a huge safeguarding red flag. If kids asked GG and they pointed them in the direction of HCP that’s fine, but personally handing them over is a line they shouldn’t be crossing.

The policy linked above also covers sex Ed. The DfE are very very clear in their PHSE policy that parents are responsible for children sex Ed and that only very well trained teachers following a strict policy should be delivering this in schools to compliment that. The idea GG think this is their place is horrifying. The one place girls had to be with just girls without the sexual pressures that exist in every other area of life and GG thought it was a good idea to throw that away…..

OP posts:
WholeClassKeptIn · 24/11/2021 05:57

It makes me sad too. I loved guiding as a movement and put my girls into it originally. But I think whereas transactivists will move onto the "next thing" to destroy that leaves so much damage and so many wjth a history to the movement. Its women that suffer of course :(

Its from the top down, the management is intentionally using guides to carry out its ageda which angers me. It isn't from the ranks of local guiders that have served for years.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 24/11/2021 05:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.