Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask you to see who girl guides support.

391 replies

RedCarpetRebellion · 23/11/2021 23:46

www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10235539/amp/Girlguides-launch-probe-trans-Commissioner-58-saucy-dominatrix-style-picture.html

A woman sacked for speaking up for girls safety was replaced by this person.

Girl guides are not safe for girls. AIBU?

OP posts:
RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 09:53

@Sillydoggy

Signing a letter in support of a person does suggest you support that person - seems a bit odd to have to point that out. This GG leader has declared their support for Challenor which leads to people questioning their judgement at the least.

It is very noticeable that the standard for judging the suitability of trans candidates for roles in GG is completely different from the standards for women. No woman who photographed herself in a dominatrix outfit would be permitted in GG.

It suggests you support the views set out in the letter.

I only know one Aimee Challenor open letter off the top of my head, the one that sought to silence lesbian having their own group and own right to peaceful protest about issues they feel impact their rights.

I’d be concerned anyone in a position of trust over girls safeguarding sought to silence lesbian rights.

If it’s a different letter then please post here.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 24/11/2021 09:51

[quote PumpkinGin]WTF.

I googled this travesty to find out more and what do I find? Girl guides fired someone for raising safeguarding concerns. And then they hired the dominatrix with guns and started to hand out condoms.

www.newarkadvertiser.co.uk/news/amp/investigation-launched-into-guide-commissioners-social-medi-9227238/[/quote]
"Monica, who referred to herself as Mistress on her Instagram page, took over the role after Helen Watts, a supporting member of the Guides for more than 15 years, was expelled from the organisation.

"She stated girls had a right to female-only spaces — specifically toilets, showers and accommodation — following the introduction of a transgender-inclusive policy.

"Last night, Helen Watts tweeted her reaction: "In case you forgot, I was thrown out of Girlguiding, ostensibly for breaching the social media policy, when I objected to sex self ID.

"But posting inappropriate violent and sexual content on social media (that any girl could find) gets a self-identified woman promoted."

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 24/11/2021 09:47

@DrSbaitso

If feminism is the only movement to give a toss about child safeguarding, you can count me right in, and draw your own conclusions about those who sneer at it.
👏 👏
DrSbaitso · 24/11/2021 09:46

The person in question is also involved in Scouting. As an inclusion advisor but given they posted a photo in uniform, probably in a youth facing role too.

Fuck.

I wonder if I can send her to PGL. Is there anywhere that will accept that men aren't women and child safeguarding is necessary?

Lockheart · 24/11/2021 09:46

@HoardingSamphireSaurus I agree on all points, but holding up this person as having a connection to Challenor on the basis that they signed one open letter is IMO misleading and intended to do nothing more than aggravate further.

Surely there's enough to be concerned about here without having to stretch the truth.

idontlikealdi · 24/11/2021 09:46

I find it terrifying the amount of people that rent aware of what's happened to GG. My kids are older now but I would not be sending them to guides or brownies now.

It's awful for all the decent people that have dedicated their time over the years volunteering and providing a safe fun space for girls. My local pack is merging with another one because of the rate of girls leaving, and this has a lot to do with the reasoning.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 24/11/2021 09:46

@EverNapping

YABU - go back to the Feminism boards, that's what it's for
Putting such nonsense to the side for a moment - there will be many mums here who don't consider themselves feminists but would still prefer their daughters not to be provided with condoms whist at GG by a non appropriate adult Confused

I expect your going to be very busy policing AIBU for all the threads you feel should be elsewhere. Good luck with that.

brighousepres · 24/11/2021 09:44

For anyone else woefully behind like me - here are what some of the terms / people keep referring to actually mean…

autogynophilia - sexually turned on by fantasies of being a woman

GRC - gender recognition certificate

Aimee Challenor - en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aimee_Challenor

(This woman recruited family - ie VERY close connections (!) ie her known paedophile father to be her managing agent at the Green Party and husband expressed disgusting sexual fantasies of children on Twitter.)

Graham Linehan - anti trans activist who argues that transgender activism endangers women, and he has likened the use of puberty blockers to Nazi eugenics programmes. (Wikipedia)

FreeBritnee · 24/11/2021 09:44

[quote HoardingSamphireSaurus]@DrSbaitso yes. Girls wanted to join the scouts for the activities. So Socuts became a mixed sex organisation, with all the safeguarding that entails.

But men want to join the Guides as women. Girl Gudies have acquiesced and accepted them as wmen. So no safeguarding has been done as Guides remains single sex by dint of being single gender.

Which is why so many women stronly object to that change in terminology!

This is about safeguarding. An issue often highlighted by some now permanently banned posters. I doubt we could shout I told you so loudly enough![/quote]
Absolutely. It relies on the belief that males are literally female on the utterance of a sentence that says it is so. So no extra safeguarding takes place.

hangrylady · 24/11/2021 09:42

Gross. They don't let boys in to guiding but a middle aged dominatrix with a cock is just fine. Vote with your feet and send your daughters to Scouts instead.

MoveAhoy · 24/11/2021 09:41

There's something about someone being unsuitable for roles involving children who is found out to have volunteered to multiple children involved organisations.

I don't like it.

Have we reached the NATWALT stage yet?

PumpkinGin · 24/11/2021 09:41

WTF.

I googled this travesty to find out more and what do I find? Girl guides fired someone for raising safeguarding concerns. And then they hired the dominatrix with guns and started to hand out condoms.

www.newarkadvertiser.co.uk/news/amp/investigation-launched-into-guide-commissioners-social-medi-9227238/

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 24/11/2021 09:39

@Lockheart

But no one said anything about a ‘close connection’ they just said ‘connection’ which is true. If you often sign letters by people without checking their background and credentials then that’s on you I’m afraid.

I've signed letters in support of Graham Lineham, does that mean I'm connected to him? Because as far as I'm concerned I have no connection to him at all. I don't know him, I've never met him, never spoken to him.

Signing a letter someone has written does not give you a connection to that person.

But you are aware of him and agree with some of what he has to say.

So you have, at some level, an ideological connection with him.

But Glinner doesn't carry the long and openly disturbing baggage that the Chellenors do!

Sillydoggy · 24/11/2021 09:36

Signing a letter in support of a person does suggest you support that person - seems a bit odd to have to point that out. This GG leader has declared their support for Challenor which leads to people questioning their judgement at the least.

It is very noticeable that the standard for judging the suitability of trans candidates for roles in GG is completely different from the standards for women. No woman who photographed herself in a dominatrix outfit would be permitted in GG.

Makinglists · 24/11/2021 09:33

This makes me so sad. Im a guide leader having a break for personal reasons. I loved guides as teenager - my leaders were wonderful, strong women who showed me that I could do anything. We had fun doing things we would never have had the chance to do - camping, hiking, campfires, first aid, canoeing. We did do a few crafty things but guides was about trying new things, gaining skills, giving service. I feel sad the organisation I love has become so politicised. My experience on the ground is that most units try to run despite the missives from HQ. Grassroots guiding and Hq guiding are two different things. Sad times.

lifeturnsonadime · 24/11/2021 09:33

Signing a letter written by someone who is an activist indicates an interest in their position.

If you sign a letter written by Graham Lineham it says something about your views on women's rights. If you sign a letter by Aimee Challinor it says something else.

There is a connection. But this is semantics and missing the point of the thread which is about Guiding and the safeguarding of girls.

Lockheart · 24/11/2021 09:28

But no one said anything about a ‘close connection’ they just said ‘connection’ which is true. If you often sign letters by people without checking their background and credentials then that’s on you I’m afraid.

I've signed letters in support of Graham Lineham, does that mean I'm connected to him? Because as far as I'm concerned I have no connection to him at all. I don't know him, I've never met him, never spoken to him.

Signing a letter someone has written does not give you a connection to that person.

MrsFionaCharming · 24/11/2021 09:24

@DrSbaitso

I was a Girl Guide. I'll be sending my daughter to Scouts.
The person in question is also involved in Scouting. As an inclusion advisor but given they posted a photo in uniform, probably in a youth facing role too.
Beefcurtains79 · 24/11/2021 09:23

Lockheart

Beefcurtains79
Lockheart

Smokeahontas
Why am I unsurprised to hear a connection to Aimee Challenor?
She was one of 2,000 signatories on a letter written by Challenor. Hardly a connection.

Of course it’s a connection? Do you know what connection means?
I do, but the implication of a close connection to Challenor because this person signed one letter is false and unnecessary. Let's stick to the facts.

I've signed many open letters or petitions over the years, it doesn't mean I'm connected to any of the authors.

But no one said anything about a ‘close connection’ they just said ‘connection’ which is true.
If you often sign letters by people without checking their background and credentials then that’s on you I’m afraid.

brighousepres · 24/11/2021 09:22

@EverNapping

That’s potentially quite a sinister comment when you consider that a lack of awareness can result in young girls being put at massive risk…?

Women are tired of being cancelled labelled named and shamed just for bloody existing.

I for one hope the daily Mail do one of their campaigns highlighting how dangerous this is.

I’ve lost all respect for Guides association. What are they thinking??

My DD wants to join as she’s now old enough- and she will want to go to the camps. I’m trying to get my head around how the heck I tell her she can’t go on the camp.

I never thought I’d have this issue. I’m quite gutted for her.

Thanks to Mumsnet in the last month I’ve learnt (just in time) that my daughter is at a stonewall school (deceitful school trip practices) and now Guides isn’t necessarily safe either. For fucks sake!

I’m all for everyone being accepted as who they want to be BUT NOT AT THE EXPENSE OF GIRLS.

Couchbettato · 24/11/2021 09:21

Girls aged under 13 should not be given contraception as they are not legally deemed to be capable of consenting to sexual activity

The age of consent is 16 in the UK. Not 13.

I think contraception should be available because when teens decide they're ready to have sex they'll find a way come hell or high water regardless of whether they're permitted to. That's why it's great to promote sexual health clinics usually run by medical professionals where it's safe for teens and adults to go.

But Christ, the age of consent is not fucking 13. It's 16.

EishetChayil · 24/11/2021 09:15

Why do some posters not want this discussed?

I think there are two possible reasons:

  1. A lot of naturally left-leaning members of MN have bought wholesale into the trans lobby, mistaking it for an extension of the gay rights movement. They are too firmly entrenched now to admit that possibly it isn't the best idea to allow men free rein on female spaces.
  1. They're plants from Stonewall and other lobby groups, trying to shut us up.
Lockheart · 24/11/2021 09:15

@Beefcurtains79

Lockheart

Smokeahontas
Why am I unsurprised to hear a connection to Aimee Challenor?
She was one of 2,000 signatories on a letter written by Challenor. Hardly a connection.

Of course it’s a connection? Do you know what connection means?

I do, but the implication of a close connection to Challenor because this person signed one letter is false and unnecessary. Let's stick to the facts.

I've signed many open letters or petitions over the years, it doesn't mean I'm connected to any of the authors.

PumpkinGin · 24/11/2021 09:13

Are some posters insane as well? Are we not allowed to discuss sexualisation of children on the main boards? This is a parenting website.

Either you are

a) so sensitive about sex that you don’t want to see it - in which case you need to find your spine and protect your children. Or,

b) finding it more important that some BDSM dressed, gun toting idiot can hand out condoms to 13 year old girls and put them in situations where they might be pregnant without them, and without parental knowledge!!!

If it is b), I honestly think your hard drive should be checked as well. We are discussing children. Our children and their safety.

RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 09:12

@Wtfdoipick

When the policy was changed by GG to allow boys who identify as girls to be allowed to join and parents not informed i raised the safeguarding risks with GG headquarters and got told tough they had to do this legally as males identify as girls are legally girls (not true) so had no choice. Although my daughter still attends she won't be going on any camps. I do trust her pack however I don't trust who they could mix with on the camp site.
Anyone can read the equality act and see this isn’t true. Even when people have a grc single sex exemptions still apply.

It’s highly disingenuous for GG to claim that’s why.

OP posts: