Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask you to see who girl guides support.

391 replies

RedCarpetRebellion · 23/11/2021 23:46

www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10235539/amp/Girlguides-launch-probe-trans-Commissioner-58-saucy-dominatrix-style-picture.html

A woman sacked for speaking up for girls safety was replaced by this person.

Girl guides are not safe for girls. AIBU?

OP posts:
RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 10:58

@stingofthebutterfly

I don't agree with the appointment and don't believe that trans women should be allowed to join the organisation, but to say the girls are not safe because they've come into contact with someone who has/had a penis is a huge leap. Presumably all safeguarding checks have been done on this person. What they choose to do in their own time is fairly irrelevant.
They post it on a public platform for those 13+

Private lives should be kept private.

If a teacher did this there would be hell to pay.

It also breaches the GG social media policy. And every rule of good safeguarding practice. It shows very poor boundaries, or an entire disregard of boundaries.

OP posts:
PeeAche · 24/11/2021 10:58

I'm trying to take a balanced view here, but it's very difficult to see this as anything other than a safeguarding issue.

I was a girl guide for many years and I enjoyed it very much. But it does require absolute trust from parents. You are allowing girl guide leaders access to your children, in privacy, often overnight and without other people around.

Some of our activities included going to a guide leaders house, going in a guide leaders car and sharing sleeping space with guide leaders.

Would I be totally comfortable with my daughter doing these things with this person? No. I would probably remove them from the GG unit altogether.

I don't feel as though I'm being transphobic (although trans people would certainly disagree) I'm just thinking "better safe than sorry". I can't believe I find myself saying these things. I have never identified as a person that is "against" the trans movement, but somewhere along the way, a line has been drawn in my mind.

I believe that allowing MTF trans people to join the girl guiding unit and take young girls on camping trips etc does put young girls at unnecessary risk.

And, although I find the posting of sex stuff on Instagram a bit weird and unprofessional, I'm not leaping to conclusions that they are a pervert because they like BDSM. That would obviously be reductive.

Genderless · 24/11/2021 10:57

@WholeClassKeptIn

Brighthouse - but isn't that why we keep men away from girls in general /separate accomodation/toilets etc.

I don't think any of the men I know would abuse. But some do and it is safer to have some same sex spaces/let different sexes sleep separately etc.

A girls only organisation doesn't mean we think all men are dangerous. Similarly excluding male bodies isn't to say all male bodies are dangerous.

Agree again.

And the risk of my daughters having sex on a girl guide sleepover is something I hadn’t even considered. It is only girls.

You do know girls can have sex with each other, right? It's the risk of pregnancy and rape that is the main issue, plus sex with penises, tbf.

nolongersurprised · 24/11/2021 10:55

*I’d, not of

Magicpaintbrush · 24/11/2021 10:54

Sex education is already happening in schools, so why GG feel the need to get involved in this side of things at all is beyond me. I think when most parents sign their girls up to GG they envision a wholesome and nurturing space where girls can make friends, be creative and learn skills, run by women who can be trusted to keep their daughters safe. Wholesome is the furthest thing from what I have been reading about GG this week, they have absolutely lost their way. They are so busy virtue signalling and making sure the world knows how woke and inclusive they are that they are compromising the safety of the girls in their care and throwing under the bus those leaders who have dared to object or highlight these issues by kicking them out of the organisation - the very people who, it seems to me, care the most about the safety and well being of these children. It feels like children are being subjected to an endless deluge of talk about sex, whether it's the act of sex or the nature of a person's sexual orientation, like there is literally nothing else worth discussing in life, as though it's the only thing of importance, shoving it down their throats constantly. Kids are all talking about this stuff on a daily basis now because it's all they are bloody well being exposed to. There is no balance any more. Sex is a part of life, but it's not the only thing in life - but somehow at the moment it really feels like the opposite is true. And it's all very handy for sexual predators that confused and impressionable kids across the country are being prepped like this.

lifeturnsonadime · 24/11/2021 10:54

How interesting that what a man who claims to be a woman does in their free time is irrelevant even when it is a major safeguarding red flag.

But a woman who holds the belief that a person cannot change sex is anti trans and must be hounded out of her job or threatened in her home.

Double standards.

nolongersurprised · 24/11/2021 10:54

Of kids without their identities obscured
In GG uniform

If this transwoman’s Twitter feed included posted pics of my DD with her face visible as well as pics of them dressed as a dominatrix of worry that my daughter was being used as a prop for her fetish.

RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 10:53

[quote PumpkinGin]**@Cryingbutstilltrying but how do we know that our guide leaders think like you? I am desperately worried for my niece now and to be honest, I don’t think I can trust GG.

I read the sex guidelines. Apparently there can be girls with penises at sleepovers. Condoms are handed out to over 13s. And if a girl under 16 has unprotected sex, a leader can take her for STD check and the morning after pill.

But I may not find out that my 13 year old has been abused (because this is likely to be abuse if the penis person is older). Because according to the guidelines they can only encourage the girls to tell their parents.

And here are articles about female girl guide leaders being sacked for safe guarding concerns. How can I trust this organisation?[/quote]
This ^^

There will be teachers in schools who don’t care about safeguarding, who are predators themselves (the minority I’m sure) but schools have policies to safeguard children and these policies get enforced where needed.

Girl guides could have 99% of leaders who feel like @Cryingbutstilltrying but their policies support and enable the 1% who don’t. And that has devastating consequences.

The institution of GG chose to implement anti girls and anti safeguarding policies.

That should be all any parent needs to know.

And all parents or carers need to know about this.

OP posts:
Ikeepbuyinganimals · 24/11/2021 10:53

GG Leaders aren't allowed to voice a 'transphobic' opinion which may be against the current policies as they will be thrown out of the movement. I can assure you many leaders disagree with recent changes, we don't leave because we are providing an important service for girls in our local communities and love what we do.

When it lands on my doorstep, in our unit, I will have no choice but to leave.

As for condoms, teenagers are full of hormones and I would much rather them have access to them than not (no matter who they get them from), especially when GG camps could technically have hormonal teenage penis' on site now as a result of current policies.

Genderless · 24/11/2021 10:50

@WholeClassKeptIn

Well yes if "girls with penises" are sharing tents/accomodation with "girls with vaginas" as per policy if being treated the same what do you think might happen?

It's a rather logical outworking. Really "girls with penises" shouldn't be sharing accomodation/tents with "girls with vaginas. " Girls with vaginas should be able to have their own safe space where they meet and camp etc eithout risk of pregnancy fromb"girls with penises.".

GG realky needs to be for "girls with vaginas" as if "girls with penises" are allowed everywhere "girls with vagjnas" are then yes condoms etc will need to be available. As will rape counselling etc.

There's a reason that for most of history "people with penises" had separate facilities to "people with vaginas. "

(If only there was a word for "people with vaginas" that acted as a shorthand and could help keep girls safe in situations like this. Language is so important.)

I agree with all of this.
RandomUser18282 · 24/11/2021 10:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 24/11/2021 10:48

@stingofthebutterfly

I don't agree with the appointment and don't believe that trans women should be allowed to join the organisation, but to say the girls are not safe because they've come into contact with someone who has/had a penis is a huge leap. Presumably all safeguarding checks have been done on this person. What they choose to do in their own time is fairly irrelevant.
I can only repeat, as often as needed, that the fact that such pictures existed to be found shows a lack of safeguarding.

Of kids without their identities obscured
In GG uniform
With a range of firearms
As a dominatrix
Barely dressed
With comments about possibly seeing more

Most, if not all of those, would have had me heavily censured at work, as a teacher. My free time pursuits were relevant to my day job. As are those of many others. That has been the case snce way before social media became a thing.

Safeguarding protects agains the unlikely. That's why Scouts are now a mixed sex organisation and have done al safeguarding, made it all available, advertise themselves as such.

Girl guides remain single sex and so have not done any of that.

A penis is not a female appendage. Girls deserve a space free of them, especially if that space advertises itself a single sex.

Or do you think the wants of a man should override that basic premise?

PumpkinGin · 24/11/2021 10:46

@Magicpaintbrush actually, they can give condoms to your 13 year old DD. And maybe show her how to use it?

And don’t worry, if it breaks, guidelines also tells them to take your DD13 for STD check and the morning after pill. But they won’t tell you unless your DD agrees.

I am so angry that I cannot speak.

I have read the guidelines over and over and also googled this. The female leaders talking about safeguarding were fired. And the gun fanatic dominatrix hired instead. In a senior leadership position.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/11/2021 10:45

We don't have official statutory rape in law but any sex with a child below 13 is classed as rape. Sex (if consensual) with a child between 13 and 16 is a criminal offence, but not automatically classed as rape. And this extends to 18 if there is an imbalance of power, such as teacher and student, or there is exploitation.

brighousepres · 24/11/2021 10:44

@HoardingSamphireSaurus - YES I also thought feminist was a more apt term… Shouldna just copied Wikipedia.

So the ‘critic’ link was a great summary, thank you.

@Mummyoflittledragon - thank you for clarifying that Aimee Challenor was born a man. I’m so bloody incensed by an organisation like the Guides treating girls like they’re less than - I’m not summarising very clearly, sorry.

@TheOriginalEmu
it’s NOT just a suspect individual though is it - that’s the whole point! It’s the Girl Guiding Association attitude and policies as their jaw dropping treatment and expelling of Helen Watts & Katie Alcock when they dated to suggest that by deviating from single sex safeguarding = zero safeguarding from girls with penises at your local guide camp. In fact - they’ll be given condoms from age 13 …

MsFogi · 24/11/2021 10:43

@ElftonWednesday

I agree with the comments but I'm not going to take DD out of Guides for this. I feel like it would be punishing her leaders who I'm sure don't agree with this nonsense either, they have been doing it for 20+ years.
It is probably worth emailing GG (copying in the leaders of your group) to raise your concerns about this issue and their policies/direction of travel and so that your local leaders know that you have this view (too many leaders have left the organisation because of their concerns but also because they are concerned but worried that if they speak out/raise concerns they will be lynched for being transphobic.
Magicpaintbrush · 24/11/2021 10:40

"it is an absolute offence to have sex with a girl under 13" - what on earth? Just what??? The age of sexual consent in the UK is 16, unless I've been living on another planet??? So GG are happy to hand out condoms to 14 year old children.... has the world gone insane? Am I wrong in understanding that sex with a CHILD below the age of 16 is statutory rape?? And that if a child below that age is approaching a GG unit leader for condoms then actually the first thing that should be flagged up is safe guarding them? WTF is going on?

Horizons83 · 24/11/2021 10:40

@stingofthebutterfly

I don't agree with the appointment and don't believe that trans women should be allowed to join the organisation, but to say the girls are not safe because they've come into contact with someone who has/had a penis is a huge leap. Presumably all safeguarding checks have been done on this person. What they choose to do in their own time is fairly irrelevant.
Do you really think if a woman guide leader had posted all of that stuff on their social media that GG would have been fine with it?

Of course they wouldn't. It would be a clear breach of the social media policy and would set up all sorts of red flags.

Shedmistress · 24/11/2021 10:40

Presumably all safeguarding checks have been done on this person.

Risk assessments done on this person will be completed as if they are a female, not a male. Because trans women are women.

So the higher risk factors that are accounted for in risk assessing a male, are not accounted for here.

That is the point that Katie and Helen were trying to make and they got booted out for it.

You cannot presume anything once you subscribe to the ideology. Because people are what they say they are and nobody is allowed to question it.

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 24/11/2021 10:36

@stingofthebutterfly

I don't agree with the appointment and don't believe that trans women should be allowed to join the organisation, but to say the girls are not safe because they've come into contact with someone who has/had a penis is a huge leap. Presumably all safeguarding checks have been done on this person. What they choose to do in their own time is fairly irrelevant.
I've said this in another thread about the matter, but if a female guide leader had posted guns and boobs 'do you want to see more' shots, very publicly, all over the internet - make no mistake she'd be flying out of the door.
ElftonWednesday · 24/11/2021 10:34

I agree with the comments but I'm not going to take DD out of Guides for this. I feel like it would be punishing her leaders who I'm sure don't agree with this nonsense either, they have been doing it for 20+ years.

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 24/11/2021 10:31

@YouSetTheTone

This is what the trans rights ideology ‘be kind’ means. It means girls and women are not allowed safeguarding or boundaries or single sex places. Why have GG not been able to say ‘we are not transphobic, we welcome girls who identify as boys, but we are a single sex organisation. Gender identity does not trump biological sex in this particular group. Girls are allowed exclusively female groups to provide them some freedom away from the opposite sex’. It’s really not that hard to say, and it’s empowering to show girls that they’re ENTITLED to it. There’s nothing wrong with it. Give them some inkling of respect in their own sex, their own rights and their own activities.

It would also be entirely legal of GG to take that stance. It’s sad that they didn’t.

This.

There are activists in and on behalf of a particular demographic (not all the demographic I must add, some of them are probably horrified at this) that as far as I can tell only goal seems to be removing any single sex spaces for women and girls. Any sex based language or biological function linked to the word 'woman' removed. They threaten 'transphobia' and a long with 'guidance' from a particular lobby group, organisations bend to their will. You've got the leader of the Lib Dems on tv saying there shouldn't be anywhere a female can go without a male fgs.

It's alright for the head of that lobby group to go on womens hour saying there's refuges that employ single sex exemptions so what's the fuss, but then we see those refuges losing funding for not being 'inclusive'

On FWR right now there's a woman kicked out of a make up group on facebook because she politely requested that while the new member's make up was lovely, she'd rather not see them posing in bed in their underwear. One cry of 'transphobia!' and she was out.

Like Helen Watts and Katie Alcock. Booted from girlguiding because they raised concerns for the single sex spaces of girls. And then GG employed this individual.

And now it's bitten them on the arse. Good. They could have stood up for girls, they didn't, and now they face the consequences. It's the girls I feel for in all of this though.

stingofthebutterfly · 24/11/2021 10:31

I don't agree with the appointment and don't believe that trans women should be allowed to join the organisation, but to say the girls are not safe because they've come into contact with someone who has/had a penis is a huge leap. Presumably all safeguarding checks have been done on this person. What they choose to do in their own time is fairly irrelevant.

brighousepres · 24/11/2021 10:31

[quote PumpkinGin]@Cryingbutstilltrying but how do we know that our guide leaders think like you? I am desperately worried for my niece now and to be honest, I don’t think I can trust GG.

I read the sex guidelines. Apparently there can be girls with penises at sleepovers. Condoms are handed out to over 13s. And if a girl under 16 has unprotected sex, a leader can take her for STD check and the morning after pill.

But I may not find out that my 13 year old has been abused (because this is likely to be abuse if the penis person is older). Because according to the guidelines they can only encourage the girls to tell their parents.

And here are articles about female girl guide leaders being sacked for safe guarding concerns. How can I trust this organisation?[/quote]
Disturbing as hell

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 24/11/2021 10:30

Graham Linehan - anti trans activist who argues that transgender activism endangers women, and he has likened the use of puberty blockers to Nazi eugenics programmes. (Wikipedia)

To be fair I think he'd describe himself as a feminist or feminist ally. The anti trans thing has been forced upon him by some quite spectacular actions against him. He has lost so much for speaking up - his marriage included.

Swipe left for the next trending thread