Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do people believe Covid was made in a lab?

181 replies

Disabrie22 · 23/11/2021 21:49

I saw this on another thread about someone having a cold - where does this theory come from? I only know one person who believes this, who interestingly is in medicine. I have no strong opinion, just trying to live through this like most people. But I’m interested in why people might believe this.

OP posts:
mindutopia · 24/11/2021 10:48

I’m a scientist working in infectious diseases. I’m not at all a conspiracy theorist, very pro-can, all that stuff. I do think a lab leak is the most likely source. I don’t think it was ‘made’ in a lab per se, there are lots of coronaviruses in the world, though this one may be slightly mutated from a naturally occurring form. But you’d be amazed how often mistakes happen, especially when people are under stress (which you may expect amongst Chinese scientists given government pressures). I don’t necessarily think it was malicious, but it wouldn’t be a difficult mistake to make if security measures and infection control is weak.

FluffyBooBoo · 24/11/2021 10:47

This is the report that made me take the possibility seriously

www.reuters.com/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/wuhan-lab-staff-sought-hospital-care-before-covid-19-outbreak-disclosed-wsj-2021-05-23/

ColinTheKoala · 24/11/2021 10:44

@Sunshine1235

I do think it a very weird coincidence that the virus originated from Wuhan where there is a lab where they study Corona virus’. I don’t think that means it was man made but more likely a leaked lab situation.
I agree. Also it seems to be such an effective virus. It's annoying in every way possible - doesn't show up on tests immediately, doesn't show symptoms immediately, mutates really quickly, symptoms differ widely between different people etc.

I read an article a few months ago from a scientist who was convinced it was man-made but then satisfied himself it was natural. But he took some convincing!

knittingaddict · 24/11/2021 10:42

[quote KurtWildesChristmasNamechange]@knittingaddict that's my experience of how it felt. It's not nonsense just because you don't understand tit. [/quote]
I'm not saying that feelings don't matter, but in a debate that is largely about science, facts have much more weight than feelings. Science matters and the rise of the anti science movement is dangerous, in my opinion.

A lay person's feelings about a virus do not equal the knowledge of a trained virologist. That is a fact.

bookworm14 · 24/11/2021 10:40

Deliberately created in a lab as a biological weapon and then released on purpose? Vanishingly unlikely.

Accidentally released from the lab where it was being studied due to poor infection control/decontamination procedures? Seems very likely to me.

Skysblue · 24/11/2021 10:36

Because COVID-19 is a bat coronavirus that was first discovered in Wuhan. And the Wuhan institute of virology laboratories had been studying bat coronaviruses for some time. And the year before covid, US inspectors visited the Wuhan laboratories and found that they had serious failings in safety procedures.

I don’t think it was ‘made in a lab’ but I do think someone in the lab was studying a highly contagious disease and didn’t decontaminate perfectly when they left work for the day.

Read this article below about the UK’s last smallpox outbreak, and note that they never worked out how the smallpox escaped the laboratory, which should have been impossible. The lady working on the floor above the lab still died of it though.

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1978_smallpox_outbreak_in_the_United_Kingdom

JunoMcDuff · 24/11/2021 10:28

To be honest it's one of the more plausible conspiracy theories, at least there's some circumstantial evidence to support it.

I don't believe it, but I also wouldn't be completely shocked to find it was accidentally released from a lab.

HarrietsChariot · 24/11/2021 10:26

Usually when there is a virus that leaps from animals to humans there is plenty of evidence of it or similar viruses being transmitted animal to animal.

With Covid-19 there is not yet any evidence of this having happened. Until such evidence is found the idea that it was designed in a lab is a viable option, indeed every day that goes by without the evidence of it being a natural development makes it more likely it was manmade.

China's attempt to cover it up and their ongoing refusal to cooperate with international investigators don't do anything to dissuade people from thinking it accidentally leaked from their lab. Note too that the Wuhan lab had had repeated leaks and incidents of bad practice over the past few years.

On the balance of probabilities it is likely it was an accidental leak, and until it is independently proved otherwise it certainly has to be considered as a leading contender.

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 24/11/2021 10:00

I don't think anyone is claiming that coincidence is the standard of proof, more that it makes for a plausible theory in the absence of other evidence. There is lots of other evidence in the Skripal's case which was kind of embarrassing for the Russian government because they didn't manage to hide the trail at all!

The issue is important because there are a lot of vested interests involved- the Nature Feb 2020 article declared to the world that Covid-19 was natural in origin and that anything else was 'conspiracy' and was signed by a large number of scientists- it turned out they were pressured to do so, and led by someone with a finger in the pie at the Institute of Virology.

Preventing a similar event is important- even if you concluded it was through zoonotic transmission from a wet market, that highlights the dangers of wet markets. Of course it is important to know where a disease that killed nearly 10 million people in a short space of time came from...

OrangeJuiceAndNoodles · 24/11/2021 09:56

never know why it matters to ordinary people like me whether the virus escaped from that lab

Errr, because its impacted pretty much every person, country and economy in the world.

If it is a lab leak, accountability needs to be had and every other lab needs to learn the lessons of Covid19.

kistanbul · 24/11/2021 09:54

@doublemonkey Yes, the people who are experts in corona viruses now are experts because they have worked with research into corona viruses for years. That’s just how expertise develops. Would you feel more comfortable if the people giving the advice had no background in coronaviruses?

It’s like saying that it’s suspicious that someone leading a cancer unit has been working with cancer-related research for decades. Do you think that people trying to cure cancer are secretly trying to keep it going cos it’s a money earner?

KurtWildesChristmasNamechange · 24/11/2021 09:54

@HunkyPunk

I find it interesting that some people are saying on this thread that it felt like something artificial when they had it. A friend of mine has recently got over a rough time with cv and she said the symptoms were like nothing else she had ever experienced, She used the word ‘synthetic’. I must admit, I didn’t really know what she meant, just interested to see some people echoing it on here!
Synthetic is how it felt. Artificial. Not like anything I'd ever felt before, and I've had tons of viruses and a couple of nasty more prolonged illnesses in my 45 years. Nothing about it felt organic. I tried explaining it to a family member who wasn't really sure what I meant until they caught it and I received a text saying oh.. I see what you mean now!

Clearly there's something about it that makes some of us experience it that way.

TheKeatingFive · 24/11/2021 09:53

I never know why it matters to ordinary people like me whether the virus escaped from that lab

Why wouldn't you be interested in finding out the truth of something? I don't get that.

MedSchoolRat · 24/11/2021 09:43

Skripal attacks happened in the town nearest to the only UK lab that keeps NoviChok supplies. As long as you think "big coincidence" is proof enough -- that proves the Russians didn't attack Skripals but rather there was an accidental leak from Porton Down and it just happened some random Russian-born local residents were the ones who got exposed to NoviChok.

Must be true, As long as "big coincidence" is your level of proof...

fwiw, I know people with PhDs in microbiology -- they suspect there was an accidental leak from Wuhan lab. That the lab was working on some methods to neutralise this virus (or develop vaccine against it, etc). That result would be very high impact scientific research but not legal to undertake in most western countries, yes legal to do in China. I reckon my acquaintences are biased just because they greatly dislike Chinese govt so they want to assume dishonesty and deception must be central part of the story.

I never know why it matters to ordinary people like me whether the virus escaped from that lab.

Notdoingthis · 24/11/2021 09:37

How can this be the first time you have heard of this OP? Do you never read the news?

HunkyPunk · 24/11/2021 09:35

I find it interesting that some people are saying on this thread that it felt like something artificial when they had it. A friend of mine has recently got over a rough time with cv and she said the symptoms were like nothing else she had ever experienced, She used the word ‘synthetic’. I must admit, I didn’t really know what she meant, just interested to see some people echoing it on here!

IWishToAnswerInTheAffirmative · 24/11/2021 09:32

Well that’s ruined ham for me 🤢

PinkMochi · 24/11/2021 09:31

The USA have had several lab leaks too, but they’re kept hush hush until someone blabs. They still have the plague. But of course, Asia is “evil.”

KurtWildesChristmasNamechange · 24/11/2021 09:28

*it not tit Confused

KurtWildesChristmasNamechange · 24/11/2021 09:28

@knittingaddict that's my experience of how it felt. It's not nonsense just because you don't understand tit.

Chocolatewheatos · 24/11/2021 09:20

Because Wuhan has a lab that studies Coronaviruses. And it's happened before alot actually en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_laboratory_biosecurity_incidents

I think there's every chance it escaped from a lab.
I think IF it was maliciously released then it wouldn't have been by the Chinese but by America but that's not an accusation.

doublemonkey · 24/11/2021 09:13

Also to note that it was Dr. Fauci's organisation the National Institute of Health which funded the experiments, conducted by Eco Health Alliance in the Wuhan Lab.

And coincidentally, it was Peter Daszak, head of Eco Health Alliance who was in charge of the team who were sent to Wuhan by the WHO to investigate Covid origins.

People think we're crazy because it sounds crazy. It IS crazy. But it's also true.

We should be asking why mainstream media aren't covering this as they should.

23MinutesfromTuIseHill · 24/11/2021 09:05

Said to me today he had been eating a ham sandwich and the change in taste made him think he was eating human flesh
And did you ask him how he knew what that tastes like, OldPodge?

SilverDragonfly1 · 24/11/2021 09:04

It's because imagining it coming from a lab is less scary. If it's man made or even just a normal virus that escaped the lab, we can stop it happening again by banning some types of research, closing the lab that leaked it and making sure the scientists there are not allowed to work in the field any more and so on.

If it came from nature, it could happen again at any time and there's nothing anyone can do.

doublemonkey · 24/11/2021 09:00

Because there is a lab in Wuhan which was doing gain of function experiments on bat coronaviri.

Here's a CNN inverview which sheds some light..

Swipe left for the next trending thread