Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you ever privately judge people for bringing a baby into bad circumstances?

315 replies

Boilthekettleplease · 23/11/2021 20:41

I've wondered how other people feel about this.

I'm coming to terms with not having a child of my own, because ultimately it would be putting my own needs ahead of any child to risk trying to have one. There's a high chance it would be a medical disaster and I'd be permanently seriously affected, which means I wouldn't be as able to look after the child, or die a few years later from kidney failure.

I'm curious if people would judge me for (hypothetically) trying to be a mum in a situation like this? Or do most people feel that the drive for a child is so strong they understand why people try against all the odds?

Do you ever judge people for having a child in situations where there are predictable risks or downsides?

OP posts:
Eastie77Returns · 24/11/2021 00:04

[quote SparrowNest]@Eastie77Returns the point is still the same, even if the % of the population who’re excluded from having children under your rules is smaller.

It’s not something that should be denied to anyone because of economic circumstances.[/quote]
I wasn’t suggesting excluding or forcibly preventing anyone (except for people who have a history of abusing children but that would be impossible to enforce..). However I 100% stand by my opinion that if you do not have the means to provide the basics you have no business bringing children into this world.

That may sound harsh but the reality for kids growing up in poverty is much, much harsher. Do you think someone’s ‘right’ to have a child, regardless of any awful situation they may be in, trumps the well-being of a child?

OneEpisode · 23/11/2021 23:16

I don’t admire Kim Kardashian for her decision to commission a 3rd and 4th child from surrogacy, fathered by a man who was already known to have severe mental health problems. The marriage to Kanye has of course come to an end. They have money, but they already had two healthy children. They could, but could have stopped at two.

Suzi888 · 23/11/2021 23:13

Yes, but the circumstances were extreme. Drug user, multiple births, all handed over to social services after birth. I don’t understand why she wanted to go through pregnancy so many times.

If a child is safe, clean, fed and cared for then no.

Tiredalwaystired · 23/11/2021 23:09

@MeltedButter

Sorry to say this but I do feel like people who are above 55 years old who have children are selfish. It's not nice for a 20 odd year old to start worrying about the death of their parents.
My friends wife died 12 days after the birth of their third child. She was 36 without any known health issues. He had three under five including a newborn. No one knows what’s round the corner.
ImInStealthMode · 23/11/2021 23:09

@PlanDeRaccordement Picture a couple. Chaotic relationship, lots of arguments and drama. They rely on family or the state for a roof over their heads and food on the table. They already have a toddler so she's at home without an income, he's been fired from his last 2 jobs for his attitude and is currently out of work. Would you judge if they planned to bring a second and then third baby into the situation?

It's completely different from another couple (or single for that matter) who have healthy relationships, stable income and a safe home, having a baby (or two) but then finding that an unexpected redundancy or illness or break-up after the fact tips the scales in the wrong direction for them.

If the first couple really want another child they have the option to change their situation, to work hard, work together, get themselves into to a more stable position FIRST because it wont get any easier the more kids they have. If they choose not to do that and plough ahead bringing more lives into their chaos and hardship that others then become responsible for financially or otherwise, then yes I would (quietly) judge them.

I would just like to add that OP your situation is entirely different and I don't feel you should be judged at all for your decisions either way. A medical condition can't be planned, foreseen nor changed in the same way that other life circumstances can. Thanks to you x

gogohm · 23/11/2021 22:57

I'll be honest, yes - but the devil is in the detail eg having one baby young, poor etc fair enough, these things happen but having multiple children in bad circumstances then I do judge

RobertaFirmino · 23/11/2021 22:57

I freely admit that I do judge in certain situations. When it is inevitable that the child question will become a young carer. When it's a deliberate 'oops...'. When it gets to Yorkshire Shepherdess amounts as it's a drain on the NHS. When it is almost a certainty that the child will inherit a life limiting/painful condition.

Porcupineintherough · 23/11/2021 22:56

@PlanDeRaccordement wet to circumstances changing, well we all know they can change. If you can afford child 2/3/4 you can afford to save a bit of money as a financial cushion, afford some contents insurance for your home, some life insurance, maybe even some critical illness cover . Because, yeah, things change and not always for the better but there are things we can do to lessen the chances of that change being catastrophic.

PlanDeRaccordement · 23/11/2021 22:53

@theleafandnotthetree

The diagnosis of very serious illness
This falls under depends in my opinion. Terminal cancer, yes I would agree with you. Schizophrenia, no I would not agree with you. COPD, also no would not agree with you. It depends on manageability and life expectancy really.

knowing the children's would be father is a shithead/abusive
Yes if they stayed. But no if they just used him as sperm donor and promptly left and were a single mum.

being in very poor living circumstances with little chance of change
This is relative because one person’s very poor is another person’s normal. So I would personally hesitate to judge. So long as basic needs have reasonable likelihood of being met even if counting on state benefits, then would not judge.

changed12344 · 23/11/2021 22:51

Yes. Watching a close relative who has so far had two babies with different mothers. One is in a hostel. Mother's are on the breadline, the father spends his money on weed. I just feel it's very sad that these kids will miss out

Boilthekettleplease · 23/11/2021 22:49

No, but honestly, if you mind being judged, motherhood is not for you anyway. There are hoardes of people whose main business in life seems to be judging mothers on a variety of factors.

I know this is just a throwaway comment, and not nasty etc, but I don't think this is a tactful thing to say to anyone who is trying to come to terms with not being able to have a child.

It's not like it made me feel oh, phew - that's a good job I can't have one then, because I'd just be judged all the time for all my parenting choices. Advising me "that it wouldn't be for me anyway" stings a bit. It actually seems a bit dismissive of the tremendous hurt this is causing me.

I understand the point you are making and I agree that mothers are harshly judged for every decision it seems at times, but respectfully I don't think this thread is the place to make it.

OP posts:
Workyticket · 23/11/2021 22:48

Argh - wish I could edit.

The above is a badly written response to @PlanDeRaccordement

Poor circumstances that have little to no chance to improving can't be ignored because someone wants another child

The money won't stretch further, the cupboards won't become magically full, the grandmother already overloaded won't get younger.

However much glitter you pour on, some people's lives are too shit to have a child

catfunk · 23/11/2021 22:47

I'd do the same in your situation Op as I'm quite risk averse. I'm sorry for your situation Thanks

godmum56 · 23/11/2021 22:47

@TheYearOfSmallThings

I sometimes judge.

Not so much for wanting to be parents and pretending everything will turn out fine, but I have seen couples having third, fourth and fifth children in situations where the parents have significant health issues and the first and second children are severely disabled. The parents have no expectation that they themselves will be responsible for coping with the situation they are creating - somebody else has to find the (immense) resources to do that, and it is never enough, but they are having another child. I just don't know what they are thinking, because their children suffer greatly.

I think this too...and I have reservation about saviour siblings.....but I am grateful never to have been put in that position.

This is going to sound rude but I will say it anyway........I do find people (not you OP) who excuse behaviour on the basis that "the drive to have a child is so strong" difficult to understand. I am childless not by choice but it seems to me that we aren't animals or alcoholics and not being able to bear one's own children for whatever reason should not wreck someone's life or drive then to extremes.

RobinPenguins · 23/11/2021 22:46

@NoSquirrels

I think you’re doing a selfless and sensible thing. I expect it’s horrifically hard. Flowers

I do think there’s a difference between knowing circumstances are bad and may worsen, and circumstances changing unexpectedly. Bad luck can happen to us all, but deliberately rolling the dice when you know there’s a good chance a child might have a poor quality of life or heartbreak in their future is not something I can applaud.

I’d like to think I don’t judge, but I’m not sure I’d be 100% honest in saying that, no.

Completely agree with this.
theleafandnotthetree · 23/11/2021 22:46

@PlanDeRaccordement

What we are talking about here is something which has definitely and incontrovertibly ALREADY happened so the person KNOWS exactly what the consequences will be.

Something such as? I did not realise you were being so specific.

The diagnosis of very serious illness, knowing the children's would be father is a shithead/abusive, being in very poor living circumstances with little chance of change.....just some examples
Workyticket · 23/11/2021 22:45

But the social workers have to deal with yet another child in an already struggled family, the grandmother has to watch yet another kid, the state has to pay put even more etc.

I feel like you've missed the point of this thread completely

Cameleongirl · 23/11/2021 22:44

Yes, I've privately judged when someone with serious MH problems decided to become a single parent. I didn't condemn her decision, I genuinely wondered whether it was a good idea given her medical history. She's managed with significant support and I hope everything works out for them. My main concern was what happens if she gets seriously ill again, as there isn't an obvious family member to look after her child.

If you have a partner or other family who could help raise your child, OP, that makes a huge difference.

RampantIvy · 23/11/2021 22:44

I agree with PixieLaLa. There are often threads on mumsnet where the couple are TTC, yet the partner is an abusive alcoholic. I don't believe that anyone wouldn't judge under those circumstances.

Having a child isn't a right.

Constance1 · 23/11/2021 22:44

I do judge for sure. Acquaintances of ours are having a (planned) third when they barely spend anytime with the two they already have, the dad has some serious anger management issues and the mum is obsessed with her career and prioritises that above all else. They are always bickering in quite a mean toxic way with each other, and the two children they already have are both showing signs of social and emotional problems. And to top it all off they are always preaching to others about environmental issues, when everyone knows one of the best things you can do for the environment is stick to one or two children.

RedDeadRoach · 23/11/2021 22:42

I judge those who have more than 2 or 3 kids. No two parents can possibly give more children than that all the time they need individually. No children should have to bring up their siblings, as in the cases of really big families where the older children are used as free childcare. They deserve to have a childhood too and shouldn't have to pay for their parents decision to keep having babies.

Also judge when someone's in a shit relationship and they have a baby. The baby deserves better than that. I know a couple who did that - freely admitted they were having a baby in the hopes it would fix their shit relationship. 6 months after the baby was born, they'd split up. How is that putting your child first?

But in the case of ill health and the impact that will have - that's more nuanced. My dh carries the gene for cystic fibrosis. I was tested and luckily, I'm not. But if i had been a carrier, we would have had some really serious decisions to make about whether to roll the dice, knowing that a baby had a 1 in 4 chance of suffering with a life limiting condition which would mean massive struggles and daily medication and therapy routines every day for their entire life. I don't think i could have done it. But i wouldn't judge someone who did go for it.

PlanDeRaccordement · 23/11/2021 22:40

What we are talking about here is something which has definitely and incontrovertibly ALREADY happened so the person KNOWS exactly what the consequences will be.

Something such as? I did not realise you were being so specific.

PlanDeRaccordement · 23/11/2021 22:39

[quote Workyticket]@PlandeRaccordement people can predict that their life isn't going to suddenly become easier / that they're suddenly going to be able to feed and clothe a 4th child when they can't manage the 3 they have etc[/quote]
They can say their life probably would not become easier, but no they cannot predict it with certainty.

I guess what I am saying is that lining up all your ducks....good income, good partner, nice home, good health doesn’t guarantee you a successful pregnancy, childbirth or good child raising environment for next twenty years. Anything could happen. And often something bad does happen.

So the flip side applies you may not currently have ideal circumstances, but if you think things will be improving soon or it is worth the risk, that is your choice to make. And people should not judge because just like ideal circumstances now are no guarantee of future ideal circumstances, less than ideal now are no guarantee of less than ideal in future.

theleafandnotthetree · 23/11/2021 22:38

@PlanDeRaccordement

people consciously choosing to have children in full possession of the facts

But no one is ever in full possession of the facts because no one can predict the future (not even doctors). You have only some of the facts, with some risks and probabilities thrown in just to make a choice that much harder.

You might have a good income now...fact...but will you for next twenty years? No way to know as there is always risk of unemployment, injury, disability, death.

You might have great partner now....fact...but will you after the child is here for the next twenty years? Maybe, maybe not.

You might be in good health...fact...but you can’t know if your pregnancy will be easy low risk or hard and high risk. You can’t know if you will even survive childbirth....odds can be either in your favour or not, but you cannot know.

You might have lovely parents all eager to do free childcare...and then after baby arrives they can’t due to illness, disability, death or changed their minds and retired to a tropical island.

I think you are being wilfully obtuse. Of course anything might happen to anyone and we take our chances to an extent. Mostly, things go alright for most people. What we are talking about here is something which has definitely and incontrovertibly ALREADY happened so the person KNOWS exactly what the consequences will be. Can you really not see the difference?
PixieLaLa · 23/11/2021 22:33

Yes, depending on the situation but I’m general if someone is bringing a child into an unstable relationship/abusive/drug dependency/financial difficulties then yes that is irresponsible and cruel on some level.