Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you ever privately judge people for bringing a baby into bad circumstances?

315 replies

Boilthekettleplease · 23/11/2021 20:41

I've wondered how other people feel about this.

I'm coming to terms with not having a child of my own, because ultimately it would be putting my own needs ahead of any child to risk trying to have one. There's a high chance it would be a medical disaster and I'd be permanently seriously affected, which means I wouldn't be as able to look after the child, or die a few years later from kidney failure.

I'm curious if people would judge me for (hypothetically) trying to be a mum in a situation like this? Or do most people feel that the drive for a child is so strong they understand why people try against all the odds?

Do you ever judge people for having a child in situations where there are predictable risks or downsides?

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 24/11/2021 03:48

@Doona

Everyone has a slim chance of dying though
But op doesn’t have a slim chance. That’s why it’s so unhelpful to say things like ‘oh just go for it op, anything bad could happen to any person.’

In op’s case it isn’t just possible, it’s quite likely. And she’s decided not to take that risk, so comments like ‘just go for it’ are unhelpful.

Doona · 24/11/2021 03:44

Everyone has a slim chance of dying though

Kanaloa · 24/11/2021 03:42

A good chance generally means a good chance. As in, it’s quite likely. And for many even a slim chance of dying and not being able to care for your child is too much of a chance.

HarryHarryHarry3 · 24/11/2021 03:34

Yes I have read the OP. I don’t know what a “good chance” means in this case as it means different things to different people. Eg a doctor told me once without even examining me that there was a “good chance” I would miscarry and I didn’t. My feeling about the OP’s decision to have a child or not depends on the actual likelihood of something happening. Without knowing anything about her condition I can’t say for sure. But why am I even bothering to explain that to you, random person on Mumsnet trying to start arguments for no reason? There’s always someone like you trying to pick holes in other people’s post to make yourself feel clever, it’s very tiresome and unhelpful.

Kanaloa · 24/11/2021 03:15

@HarryHarryHarry3

In your particular case, well, I guess it would depend on how likely it is that something would happen to you to prevent you from taking care of the child after giving birth. If the risks are low, I would say go for it, since everything to do with having children carries a risk anyway.
Have you read the op? She has stated very clearly that she’s been told there would be a good chance she would become so unwell she couldn’t care for the baby, and would possibly even die a few years later.
HarryHarryHarry3 · 24/11/2021 03:05

In your particular case, well, I guess it would depend on how likely it is that something would happen to you to prevent you from taking care of the child after giving birth. If the risks are low, I would say go for it, since everything to do with having children carries a risk anyway.

Doona · 24/11/2021 03:01

What I meant to say was don't worry about bein judged (you will be whatever you do) and that all of us decide to have kids in uncertain circumstances. Nobody knows the future and only you can judge for yourself.

HarryHarryHarry3 · 24/11/2021 02:59

I live overseas and I’m currently taking full-time language lessons provided by the government for immigrants like myself. There are a lot of people at my school from much poorer countries than the UK. Many of them have come here with no skills, qualifications or job prospects. Often they don’t even have work permits. Some have brought their children; others have had then since arriving. It always amazes me when they say they are planning to have more children soon. I can’t imagine actively TTC when your situation is so precarious, when you have no job and no money, when you are dependent on financial aid from the governmment and can barely support yourself. I don’t think I “judge” them, per se, I just know I would never even consider doing that.

But if you’re talking about people who get pregnant by accident and decide to continue the pregnancy despite unfavourable circumstances, no, I don’t judge them at all.

Doona · 24/11/2021 02:59

@Boilthekettleplease

No, but honestly, if you mind being judged, motherhood is not for you anyway. There are hoardes of people whose main business in life seems to be judging mothers on a variety of factors.

I know this is just a throwaway comment, and not nasty etc, but I don't think this is a tactful thing to say to anyone who is trying to come to terms with not being able to have a child.

It's not like it made me feel oh, phew - that's a good job I can't have one then, because I'd just be judged all the time for all my parenting choices. Advising me "that it wouldn't be for me anyway" stings a bit. It actually seems a bit dismissive of the tremendous hurt this is causing me.

I understand the point you are making and I agree that mothers are harshly judged for every decision it seems at times, but respectfully I don't think this thread is the place to make it.

I'm so sorry. I didn't mean it that way, but you're right, I could have made the point more thoughtfully.

I think I got sidetracked by your question about being judged when actually it's about your own choice.

CheeseMmmm · 24/11/2021 02:45

Apologies OP. What other situations though?

I think loads of posters have missed that as plenty posts about poverty etc.

I am sorry you are so ill.

Reading that now I immediately thought of a friend I knew from school who was found to have very aggressive breast cancer while Pg.

She could be treated which would have meant an abortion, or not be treated have the baby knowing she wouldn't live much longer.

She and her OH chose the second option.

I don't judge her for that.

HoppingPavlova · 24/11/2021 02:44

It’s not something that should be denied to anyone because of economic circumstances.

How does that make sense in practical terms?
Someone wants ten kids but can’t afford to even house, clothe, feed, practically or emotionally support one kid. Their want to have ten (let alone one) must be ensured as they are entitled to this. Let’s be honest, it’s actually happening at present but the issue is everyone all round says it’s not working- the people with kids they can’t afford are saying they are hard done by as everyone else is not supporting their kids well enough and they have no obligation to do so (because as you have pointed out they should not be denied this), and the people who are stumping up to support the kids believe their obligation for total support is not right.

Yournamehere007 · 24/11/2021 02:39

Some people don't realise at that moment thatvtgey are in less than desirable circumstances. I do often question why people have more children when they were struggling with the ines they have or the number if children exceeds the practical space in their house (when the house has come first so they know how much space is available)
I worked in housing, people would move into a two bed house with two children (fine) and then come back to the council at the fourth or fifth expecting a priority score because they are overcrowded and need to be re-housed.

fabricfanatic · 24/11/2021 02:31

I don't know how I'd feel about specific people... It would depend on all their circumstances, but taken on the whole, I do think it's better not to have children if there's a high, predictable chance that they'll be left without a living parent before they're adults, themselves.

I also think it's morally wrong to have children if the parents don't have the means to feed, clothe, and house them. That's not saying that only the wealthy should have children, just that we should be able to cover the bare minimum of caring for our children ourselves. It's different, of course, if circumstances change after a child has already been conceived, but I do think it's selfish and wrong to have children knowing they'll be supported and paid for by 'society' because you can't or won't do it yourself.

Boilthekettleplease · 24/11/2021 02:31

@CheeseMmmm

No of course not.

Op you haven't as far as I can see what you consider to be 'bad circumstances'.

That would really help rather than posters assuming all sorts of different things and so the conversation will involve pretty much everyone talking about different things.

Not really sure what you mean? From my OP:

There's a high chance it would be a medical disaster and I'd be permanently seriously affected, which means I wouldn't be as able to look after the child, or die a few years later from kidney failure

Those circumstances are potentially very bad indeed, from the point of view of the child's wellbeing.

But yes, there are other kinds of bad circumstances too of course.

OP posts:
Midlifemusings · 24/11/2021 02:28

I judged my sibling and spouse when they decided to try for a 3rd child despite not being mentally well enough to parent the kids they already had. They felt they had never gotten to enjoy the early years due to their MH issues so they wanted a Take 2 - except their illnesses are exacerbated by stress and sleep deprivation and it would have just been a disaster. They were devastated by a late pregnancy loss but inside I really felt it was for the best. / breathed a sigh of relief. Thankfully they found that experience too painful to try again.

CheeseMmmm · 24/11/2021 02:19

Having said that and the lack of specifics or caveats I would mention-

  • Women in situations where they are not realistically free to use contraception/ access abortion. Could be various religious communities that are pretty closed or totally closed. Being controlled by horrible man/ men. Etc.
  • Girls who are being abused (some circs and does happen)
  • Girls who are terrified/ naive/ etc
  • Whatever circs you mean presumably it's large groups. Judging whole groups for reproducing is extreme
  • If you mean things like poverty then surely addressing those issues should be important rather than just passing judgement
  • I assume you don't mean NI which obviously is part of UK and despite law change fairly recently, abortion is very hard to actually access. One way to avoid a baby into circs in the country that you would judge as 'bad'
  • Assume you're not talking globally? If you are then that's really interesting. Assume you aren't though.
CheeseMmmm · 24/11/2021 02:10

No of course not.

Op you haven't as far as I can see what you consider to be 'bad circumstances'.

That would really help rather than posters assuming all sorts of different things and so the conversation will involve pretty much everyone talking about different things.

itsjustnotok · 24/11/2021 01:43

I do judge. Once you have children you’re circumstances might change. This could happen to anyone and is generally unavoidable, you plan as best you can. What I judge are those who choose to have children and knowingly bring them into a situation where they are living at a significant disadvantage. Sometimes it feels like a persons right to have children overrides that child’s right to as best a start as possible. It also feels like some of those in these situations then expect society to resolve their problems but take no responsibility for the fact they chose to knowingly.

SudokuWillNotSaveYou · 24/11/2021 01:35

OP and @PlanDeRaccordement - for me, it is when the mother has a painful disease that she knows is genetic, and chooses to have children, knowing she could or will pass it to them. One of my doctors even tried to tell me, “Oh, you could still have children, love,” but I have a rare and incredibly painful disease and they DONT know enough about heritability and it would just be unforgivable; I can barely stand the pain some days; a small child would be just inconsolable. My friend also has a painful disease but she knows for certain that hers has a large genetic component (her mother also has it, and was diagnosed after having children) and my friend still chose to have two children. Our friendship fizzled to some extent after that because I didn’t want to judge her, and it’s just difficult to watch it come to fruition. She’s almost in a wheelchair full time now, and while her symptoms didn’t start until her 20s, now her first DC is already having joint swelling at 8.

A lot of these things, I can see with shades of grey. Though I can understand why @Okbye is frustrated and I feel terrible for the situation @MobyDicksTinyCanoe was in. Bringing a third child into a home with sexual abuse is just horrific.

Scottishskifun · 24/11/2021 01:26

I don't judge on majority of medical grounds no my friend has a liver disorder was told she should never have children but she now has a daughter. Tbf she was also told she wouldn't live past 20 and she's now 40.

I do judge my nephews mum though who so far has had 5 children all taken away from her as she refuses to manage her very serious MH disorders and refuses to take her medications. DN hasn't seen her in 7 years as she stopped bothering to show up to contact and DN has lived with DB for majority of his life.

So I suppose I judge those who bring children into the world knowing they won't look after them and cause that child serious damage with their behaviour and actions yes.

Marvellousmadness · 24/11/2021 01:21

Of course I'd judge.

Like some people who are 50 and decide having a kid is a good idea.

Or people who already have 1 child is a terrible and unhealthy marriage and then decide to have another kid..

Or people who are so poor that they can't afford clothes and food /shelter but still have kids.

Why would you bring a kid in this world knowing you could potentially not look after it or even die a few years later. Adopt a child or foster a child then. You could still have a baby AND be healthy.
Passing on your genetics means nothing if you end up paying with your life and mentally scaring your kid for life

Fros · 24/11/2021 01:13

I try not to, but everyone judges:

The bloke with multiple kids with multiple women who doesn't even attempt to provide for them or even keep in contact
The woman with more children than fingers on both hands, who can't remember her kids names and who relies on the older kids to raise their younger siblings
The parents who, suffering from a debilitating genetic condition, knowingly choose against medical advice to have children who are highly likely to suffer from the same condition
People who already have severely disabled children, who then have more children (as in most cases they are either also disabled or expected to become their siblings' carer)

OverTheRubicon · 24/11/2021 01:07

My friends wife died 12 days after the birth of their third child. She was 36 without any known health issues. He had three under five including a newborn. No one knows what’s round the corner.

On that basis, would you say that driving drunk is ok, because you know someone who had a crash when completely sober?

Op is making a heartbreaking choice. I never understand why some women are so keen to push others to have babies regardless of circumstance (No money? Babies just need love. Already have 4 young boys, no time.and a 1.5 hour school trip and work commute in each direction? You should try for a girl.
Poor health and very high chance of early maternal death? No problem, even totally healthy people die.)

Kanaloa · 24/11/2021 01:00

That may sound harsh but the reality for kids growing up in poverty is much, much harsher. Do you think someone’s ‘right’ to have a child, regardless of any awful situation they may be in, trumps the well-being of a child?

This is the unfortunate thing really. So many people think ‘I want a kid’ but they don’t really think ‘would a kid want me?’ As in ‘would I be a good parent, would I give a child a good life?’ Not op, but others.

OP is in fact making the extremely selfless and, I imagine, terrible painful decision that she couldn’t care for a child due to her health, and is placing her health and the well being of that child’s life above her own wants. It must be an awful and difficult decision to have to make.

I don’t know if this would interest you op, but I have a friend who is sadly childless (sad because it’s not her choice, not because it’s inherently a sad thing). She saw some sort of therapist to help come to terms with it when she was finished having ivf - would you consider something like that?

EmeraldShamrock · 24/11/2021 00:28

No, but honestly, if you mind being judged, motherhood is not for you anyway. @Doona wtf did you have an empathy bypass?
Seriously did you put any thought into it?