Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you ever privately judge people for bringing a baby into bad circumstances?

315 replies

Boilthekettleplease · 23/11/2021 20:41

I've wondered how other people feel about this.

I'm coming to terms with not having a child of my own, because ultimately it would be putting my own needs ahead of any child to risk trying to have one. There's a high chance it would be a medical disaster and I'd be permanently seriously affected, which means I wouldn't be as able to look after the child, or die a few years later from kidney failure.

I'm curious if people would judge me for (hypothetically) trying to be a mum in a situation like this? Or do most people feel that the drive for a child is so strong they understand why people try against all the odds?

Do you ever judge people for having a child in situations where there are predictable risks or downsides?

OP posts:
Muchuseaschocolateteapot · 24/11/2021 09:00

I am sorry for your situation OP, I understand the drive to become a mother and the grieving that goes along with it. Would surrogacy be an option? Maybe not your dream but a baby at the end of it without the strain of a pregnancy.

I do judge people for having children thoughtlessly, whether it is an abusive home, chaotic lifestyle or if they can’t afford it. I don’t understand people who don’t want the absolute best for their child and that includes the situation they are bringing them into.

The urge or desire for a child should not outweigh the quality of the baby’s life.

lastqueenofscotland · 24/11/2021 08:51

Honestly yes.
My father was quite old and unwell when my parents started having children, dealing with the death of a parent in your early teens is grim.

Also I know people say not only the well off deserve children but if you literally don’t have a pot to piss in why does the child deserve that? My DPs mum had two kids before she was 20 and could barely afford to feed herself. Loved the idea of a baby but hadn’t really thought through actual children, my DPs childhood memories until he was about 10 and they moved in with his step dad are almost entirely just that he was bored and really hungry. Sad

HardbackWriter · 24/11/2021 08:46

I think I did judge when I was younger, but I've found in general as I've got a bit older I've been a bit more aware of the shades of grey in life, and more aware that you shouldn't judge people until you've walked in their shoes, and that's it's very easy to say what you'd do in circumstances you won't actually face. We all think we'd be saints, hypothetically.

There was a point where MN was awash with threads about how terribly irresponsible people like me, who got pregnant on purpose during the first lockdown, were. At the time I found it quite upsetting and disquieting, now I look at my 9 month old and think how stupid it would have been to have not had him on the advice of some judgemental people (almost all of whom already had all the children they wanted) on an internet forum.

AlternativePerspective · 24/11/2021 08:43

I know a woman who had a lung transplant at 14, and was desperate for a baby. With careful management they made it happen, very much an ‘against the odds’ story and she had a beautiful girl when she was about 22. She’s obviously very very happy, her mother and father have a large role in the little girls life as Mum is often struggling with health. But she can do all the things she’s dreamed about like Santa visits, Christmas and birthdays etc and they do so much with the little one. Unfortunately I don’t think the prognosis is good for this woman and she is unlikely to see her child make high school. The child is healthy. It’s just sad because the child will inevitably have to watch her mum suffer and pass away at a young age, and be without her in later childhood and as she progresses into adulthood. It’s just a different experience I suppose. You could say it’s selfish or you could say she’s selfless because she does literally live for the child, I don’t know. You could have kids and then find out you have a terrible illness and die. You could be hit by a bus. Anything could happen. I suppose it’s the knowing that something will happen and you will be affected medically that you have to take into account, and how much you think this would impact a child and your ability to parent. on what planet should people feel happy that they get to do Santa visits and birthdays and all the wonderful things they dreamed of while knowing they’ve brought a child into the world who is unlikely to remember the Santa visits over the memory of watching them die, something they knew was going to happen before they were even conceived? There’s absolutely nothing selfless about her. If she was selfless she wouldn’t have had a child in the first place. She’s not living for her child, she’s had a child to make her last few years bearable. Selfish in the extreme. Angry

Chocolatewheatos · 24/11/2021 08:38

I would. I judge anyone for trying to bring a baby into the world that they know has a high chance of disability or that they're not going to be able to look after.

Can't you adopt or use a surrogate if it's the pregnancy that will hurt you?

eastegg · 24/11/2021 08:32

@0verth1inker

If I’m being brutally honest yes, sometimes. I don’t mean an unplanned pregnancy at 18 but actually the partner gets onboard, there’s a supportive family etc but the ‘DH is an abusive dick and I’m planning how to leave, oh and I’’ 8 months pregnant with DC3’ are a bit Hmm.
I think you’ve picked a bad example there. The mother might have got pregnant because her oh is an abusive dick.
BeeDavis · 24/11/2021 08:28

Yeah I do judge. Especially the ones that come on here to moan that their partner has never helped with night feeds or nappy changes… yet has baby number 2 on the way suddenly expecting that their partner will step up!

londonrach · 24/11/2021 08:11

I know one couple in my childhood who had alot of things their child could have inherited. They thought long and hard and planned for the worse and decided on one child. By luck their DC had the only none life threatend one that was sorted by an operation as a child. Child is a carrier now but works in NHS as grown up and decided not to have own children and gives alot back. I never judged the parents (they my parents friends).

gannett · 24/11/2021 07:54

I'm personally baffled by people who have children without some security in their financial circumstances, just because I can't imagine embarking on something so massive without making absolutely sure it wouldn't be a struggle. I wouldn't even get a dog unless I knew I had the time, money and space to take care of it properly. However I DON'T judge those people, it's too close to thinking that poor people shouldn't have children. If they can make it work fair play to them.

The ones I do judge (in my head) are the parents who bring children into shit relationships. The ones who think a baby can fix a relationship on the rocks, or who hate their partners and are using them for their sperm, or who are in abusive relationships and yet keep having babies with absolute arseholes. I want to scream whenever I see that happen. The poor children and the stupid, stupid parents.

CounsellorTroi · 24/11/2021 07:30

I certainly judged the 65 year old German mother of 13 who had IVF treatment, ended up pregnant with quads, all because her youngest child said she wanted a younger sibling!

OP I think you are brave and responsible.

CounsellorTroi · 24/11/2021 07:22

@Blueeyedgirl21

I know a woman who had a lung transplant at 14, and was desperate for a baby. With careful management they made it happen, very much an ‘against the odds’ story and she had a beautiful girl when she was about 22. She’s obviously very very happy, her mother and father have a large role in the little girls life as Mum is often struggling with health. But she can do all the things she’s dreamed about like Santa visits, Christmas and birthdays etc and they do so much with the little one. Unfortunately I don’t think the prognosis is good for this woman and she is unlikely to see her child make high school. The child is healthy. It’s just sad because the child will inevitably have to watch her mum suffer and pass away at a young age, and be without her in later childhood and as she progresses into adulthood. It’s just a different experience I suppose. You could say it’s selfish or you could say she’s selfless because she does literally live for the child, I don’t know. You could have kids and then find out you have a terrible illness and die. You could be hit by a bus. Anything could happen. I suppose it’s the knowing that something will happen and you will be affected medically that you have to take into account, and how much you think this would impact a child and your ability to parent.
Does this child have an involved father?
Minceandonions · 24/11/2021 07:18

There are lots of people on here who are much better than me because, yes, I judge people for this all the time!
I don't have kids but have been planning to pull the trigger on getting a second dog for about 5 years, but our circumstances haven't been quite right (a holiday coming up, a wedding to attend, a house move etc). So when people dive in to having a baby without thought then, yes, I judge.
It irks me when my mum says, with a beam of joy on her face, "Oh good news, X and Y (a neighbour's, cousin's sister etc) are having a baby!" and I sit there thinking 'brilliant, they're in masses of debt, he's just lost his job and their relationship's on the rocks. Smart move'.
Like I say, I'm a monster, but I'm being honest!

NumberTheory · 24/11/2021 07:08

I'm so sorry for your situation, I think you've made a brave and mature choice.

It's easy for people to justify having a child, it takes real character to look beyond that drive to reproduce and acknowledge the impact of having a child you might not be able to parent. The cost of a child being brought into the world in circumstances where the parents can't cope for some reason is huge. It's hard to see that cost in the child - who even if their life isn't ideal seems to be doing better out of it simply by virtue of existing - but the ripples of inadequate parenting, and perhaps especially of a mother lost too soon, are felt by everyone who touches the family. If the risk is significant, though it must hurt to give up on a dream, it's a good choice for all those others around you. I hope you can find some solace in the love you are showing for them (and I hope they are supporting you too).

LaMagdalena · 24/11/2021 07:01

My problem with 'you shouldn't have a child when you can't afford it/can't afford the basics/can't afford it without state help' is that in the UK, the basics are so expensive - housing and childcare being the most obvious expenses, but then add council tax, rising food prices, rising cost of living - and even being able 'to afford' one child seems impossible for people on low (or even middle) incomes. And instead of trying to make society more equal, so poorer people can reasonably afford to have 1 or 2 children and give them a decent quality of life, we just say, you must be able to afford these eye-wateringly expensive things by yourself, no help from the state, and if you can't then you shouldn't be having children.

My parents are quite working class, they had 3 children and they could give us a decent quality of life, but I think it would be incredibly difficult for a working class family of 5 to do so now. Obviously times have changed, but people haven't stopped wanting children.

I also remember reading a thread on here a while ago, by a woman earning what, to me, was a decent wage (in the £30,000s pa), but she lived in the South and was having trouble making ends meet, as a single mother with one child. I'm pretty sure the 'you had a child you couldn't afford' line came up then. Confused So to me, 'you shouldn't have children you can't afford' does just seem to be a line throw out to shame people for not being high earners.

AlternativePerspective · 24/11/2021 06:52

There’s a difference between someone having children while in poverty and someone having children with an illness they know is likely to kill them before that child’s childhood ends.

People who have children in poverty should have the ability to be pro-active in changing their circumstances. if they don’t. If they think that they have a god-given right to keep reproducing and that the government should just continue to provide then yes, I judge them.

But on the illness front, I read an article on the BBC recently about a woman with Huntington’s who despite her diagnosis decided to go ahead and have a baby, in the knowledge that that baby will have to grow up seeing her deteriorate, probably become her carer, and then to add to that, the possibility that he/she will have inherited condition and will get a snapshot of what their life is going to be and how it’s going to end.

Yes. I judged. Harshly. It becomes much harder to empathise with someone in that position when they essentially stick two fingers up at the situation and say “I don’t really care who this affects, I want a baby, and well, if the baby inherits the condition then so be it, after all, by the time they get to the point of deterioration they will already have watched it happen to me.” No obviously that’s not what she said but she might as well have.

OP as parents we should strive to do the best for our children. And sometimes doing the best means accepting that you (as in one in general) would be best off not to have any.

I have a genetic heart condition which hadn’t been diagnosed before I had my DS. I have had some serious illness since then, cardiac arrest, heart surgery, and at some point I will be heading for the transplant list as I have exhausted all other interventions I can have (although fortunately I’m still stable so fingers crossed.) I’m fortunately too old to have more children, but knowing what I do now, I would never have had more, not only because of the risk to me, but because I wouldn’t want to put a child of mine through what I’ve been through.

In fact if I’d known what I know now before I had DS then I wouldn’t have had him. As it is there’s a chance he’s inherited my heart condition, but he’s over 18 now and needs to find that out for himself if he wants to know (a lot of people choose not to,)

TarasCrazyTiara · 24/11/2021 06:51

@Kendodd

I actually don’t think it’s because of lack of contraceptives, I think it’s like a human instinct to have more kids in bad times. I bet if the climate crisis got worse you’d actually see more kids not less - it’s just now when it’s not affecting people you hear stuff labour how terrible it is to bring a child into this world etc.
It’s like we have a drive to bang out more kids so they can carry on to better times. Weird stuff.

SugarlumpsesBumpses · 24/11/2021 06:44

Depends how bad!

It hurts me to see when people have multiple children removed as they're in dire circumstances, and still keep having kids year after year, as I know how hard it is to be in care for those children and what life will be like if you don't get lucky with a good/stable adoptive/foster placement.

Kendodd · 24/11/2021 06:41

Yes.
But I also realise life happens.
I've heard that during war times, while bomes are actually falling, the birth rate goes up. Don't know if due to lack of contraception though.

Fuuuuuckit · 24/11/2021 06:36

@Okbye

Yes, I do.

I work in social housing and get shouted at pretty much every other day by mums who have 5/6/7 children in a 2/3 bedroom property demanding a bigger property ‘because my kids are all sharing a room and I’m pregnant again blah blah blah’.

It INFURIATES me that these people keep getting pregnant when they already haven’t got enough room and demanding 4, 5 and even 6 bed houses when (where I work) they’re like fucking gold dust, hence the long wait on the housing list. They seem to think the Councils/Housing Associations can just pull a property out of thin air for them 🤨🤬🙄

Same. And I think that anyone who claims they don't judge is lying. Or has zero experience of dealing with children who have had appalling starts to life - 5 kids in a 2 bed, back to back terrace, sharing dirty mattresses on the floor with no sheets, no carpets, where the free school meal is the only guaranteed food the kids get in a week.

A school friend of mine was bor with fetal alcohol syndrome and this has had quite an impact on him (plus the inevitable challenges of growing up in an alcoholic home), he judges his own parents harshly, as well as his wider family for not stepping in to support.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 24/11/2021 06:21

i judge those who have children taken away who continue to have children

Cowpad · 24/11/2021 06:21

@Eastie77Returns.well said!

Upamountain43 · 24/11/2021 06:13

i would not judge - i mean people going through difficult circumstances are going to be the most likely to forget or find it difficult to access contraception or act without thinking just to get some relief from their circumstances.

According to all government figures myself, my children and Grandchildren have all been born into difficult circumstances/poverty and yet we have had great lives - there is such a wide spectrum of circumstances that could be impacting on people it is so difficult to make any sweeping statement.

Fernando072020 · 24/11/2021 05:53

It depends on the circumstance, I wouldn't say it's black or white. but yes I would judge. Knowing there is a huge risk / bad situation is different from something maybe happening down the line. It's completely different if you have children and your circumstances change. But bringing children into an already bad situation is selfish and irresponsible.

TarasCrazyTiara · 24/11/2021 04:23

Yes tbh. I do privately judge when I see a woman saying she has got pregnant by accident by a man she isn’t coupled up with and intends to keep the baby as it may be her last chance. And usually goes on to say (and be supported by some posters) she doesn’t want the father to play a significant role in the child’s life but will ask for cmHmm

Pretty bad form to me to both cut the man out (but expect money) and to have the child know this is what you thought of the other parent. What kind of warped views will that child grow up having?

Beseen22 · 24/11/2021 03:58

I had a colleague who had a perfectly healthy son then her cousin and her husbands cousin were diagnosed with cystic fibrosis. They had genetic counselling and discovered a 1/4 chance of cystic fibrosis as both were carriers. She decided to have another baby and thankfully he was also healthy, I personally wouldn't have had a second in those circumstances but not sure its really fair to judge her as I have 2 healthy kids.