Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you ever privately judge people for bringing a baby into bad circumstances?

315 replies

Boilthekettleplease · 23/11/2021 20:41

I've wondered how other people feel about this.

I'm coming to terms with not having a child of my own, because ultimately it would be putting my own needs ahead of any child to risk trying to have one. There's a high chance it would be a medical disaster and I'd be permanently seriously affected, which means I wouldn't be as able to look after the child, or die a few years later from kidney failure.

I'm curious if people would judge me for (hypothetically) trying to be a mum in a situation like this? Or do most people feel that the drive for a child is so strong they understand why people try against all the odds?

Do you ever judge people for having a child in situations where there are predictable risks or downsides?

OP posts:
TractorAndHeadphones · 24/11/2021 12:17

Also i don’t get why the ‘strong drive to reproduce’ is sufficient justification for anything.
Animals can’t control their natural drives. Humans can.
That’s why we expect people to restrain themselves, to be inclusive and unprejudiced (even when humans are inherently tribal). To not fuck anything that moves when they want it.

However when it comes to reproducing it’s supposedly all good

Soopermum1 · 24/11/2021 12:13

My ex has a baby with a woman he was (using his words) having a bit of fun with. He now barely sees the baby and has a new girlfriend. They barely knew each other, so not enough time to gather what a twat he is. So, yes, I judge both of them.

5128gap · 24/11/2021 12:12

@PlanktonsComputerWife

I would never judge. Life is both precious and precarious, and as none of us is granted a single day, it would be stupid in the extreme to judge someone for having a baby when her own time might be short. Any of us posting here could be dead by tonight, after all.

Also, my husband lost his mum when he was a toddler. Her condition was exacerbated by the birth, from which she never fully recovered. The world is a better place for having him, and for having had his by all accounts lovely mother, in it.

I agree with you. Childhood experiences, though important are not the be all and end all of life. Nor is having a healthy living mother throughout your childhood. There are many of us, like your husband who didn't have this yet are functional adults who contribute to the world. To suggest a child would be better to have no life than to have a life without a mother somewhat overplays the (albeit important) role of a mother.
SENmummy73848 · 24/11/2021 12:11

I think I judge people in certain circumstances because of personal experiences of seeing the outcome. For example, one of my friends (firstborn) was born with CF and nearly died as a child. They have now had a lung transplant but is still unwell all of the time, has no real quality of life, will still die before her time. Her mum went onto have 4/5 more kids knowing there was a very real possibility of them all potentially having CF and suffering the same fate as her. 2 more of them was born with CF and if not given a lung transplant could potentially die before reaching a teenage age. That to me is selfish because she is knowingly having more and more kids knowing they could have a whole lifetime full of illness and hospitals - that is if they all even survive.

PlanktonsComputerWife · 24/11/2021 12:08

I'm not looking for an internet slanging match with someone who can't or won't appreciate the frailty of our existence. Thanks, though.

IncompleteSenten · 24/11/2021 12:06

TTC is not sensible in certain circumstances. Judging is such a negative word. If you form an opinion on a situation based on the facts and that opinion is that something isn't the sensible choice, that doesn't mean you are judging the person (judging as in negatively viewing them and thinking you're better than them)

Do I have opinions on what, to me, are and are not sensible things? Yes.
Do I view the person negatively and think I'm better than them? No.

Porcupineintherough · 24/11/2021 11:59

I guess statistical probability isnt a thing in your world then @PlanktonsComputerWife? And you live each day as though it's your last ? (will save on washing at least). Hmm

PlanktonsComputerWife · 24/11/2021 11:57

I would never judge. Life is both precious and precarious, and as none of us is granted a single day, it would be stupid in the extreme to judge someone for having a baby when her own time might be short. Any of us posting here could be dead by tonight, after all.

Also, my husband lost his mum when he was a toddler. Her condition was exacerbated by the birth, from which she never fully recovered. The world is a better place for having him, and for having had his by all accounts lovely mother, in it.

sqirrelfriends · 24/11/2021 11:46

In your situation, no. The drive to have children is strong.

I would advise finding someone else to do it with though.

sqirrelfriends · 24/11/2021 11:44

Yes I do. Not women who have children with useless fathers, but those who bring new people into the world and then make no effort to nurture them. I sometimes wonder, why do they even bother?

I know someone who fostered a child who was born addicted to heroin, was abused by his mothers boyfriends and was regularly left alone in what was essentially a drug den for extended periods of time. Even when his mother was clean and working towards custody, visitation involved her scrolling on her phone instead of engaging with the child she had made.

LizzieW1969 · 24/11/2021 11:36

@SugarlumpsesBumpses

Depends how bad!

It hurts me to see when people have multiple children removed as they're in dire circumstances, and still keep having kids year after year, as I know how hard it is to be in care for those children and what life will be like if you don't get lucky with a good/stable adoptive/foster placement.

That’s so true, speaking as an adoptive mum to 2 DDs who are birth siblings. They also have 2 other siblings placed with other families.

The reality is that even those who are adopted into loving families can still be badly damaged. My DD1 (now 12) has attachment issues as well as SEN. So do her 2 siblings placed elsewhere. Thankfully, DD2 doesn’t;

Adoptive parents, however loving they might be, can’t undo the trauma done to children who are removed from their birth mothers. I don’t judge my DDs’ birth mum for giving birth to multiple children, as she herself was badly damaged after growing up in care.

It’s all just very sad, and does demonstrate that there are people who shouldn’t have children.

ColinTheKoala · 24/11/2021 10:32

@TurnUpTurnip

People won't admit it but yes people.will
Yes. I do admit it.

For example silly women who know their partners are useless arseholes and then have babies with them. For goodness sake leave them and find someone less useless!

But in your case it sounds like the downsides would be more for you? But then if it affects your health, could you look after a child well? I don't think I would risk having a child if there was a high chance I couldn't look after it - childbirth is a bit of a case of Russian roulette as it is, you never know what state you will be left in afterwards.

Tal45 · 24/11/2021 10:25

Yes I judge people, there are so many unhappy children living in awful circumstances. It's not about being well off, it's about being in a stable situation for several years so you know you can provide all the things a child needs. Obviously disaster can strike anyone but that's even more reason why you need to be as stable and prepared beforehand as possible.

I think you have to think of yourself too OP. How would you feel to give birth and then find out you're dying due to kidney failure and never going to see your child grow up? For me that would be worse than never having a child.

PanettoneSeason · 24/11/2021 10:12

@Boilthekettleplease It sounds like you’ve really put a lot of thought into your situation OP and I think you’ve made a very brave and selfless choice. I truly hope that you get to experience motherhood one day - I think your idea of adoption is amazing.

@SadHermit Im so sorry for what you’re going through. I really hope you get everything you long for ❤️

Reading about people having such medical issues makes me so thankful for my own health and what I have. I could never judge anyone in those situations having no experience of it myself!

Personally, I do judge people who intentionally get pregnant despite being in an awful situation and not being able to provide for the child - be that financially or emotionally.
I grew up on a council estate with a self employed dad and SAHM who absolutely hated each other but “stayed together for the kids”. My older sibling and I used to sit on the stairs and listen to them fighting every night, either one or the other would leave for weeks at a time, yet they still went on to have more children. I’m now in my 30s, they’re still together because neither is in a financial position to leave. They still fight daily. I vowed to myself that I wouldn’t have children unless I was confident I could offer them a much happier home than I grew up in. Where I grew up, nobody ever really seems to leave either. The done thing is to get your name on the housing list as soon as you are “of age”, have children young (usually with a boy from the estate) and moving in to your own property on the estate. And the cycle continues.
I’m very thankful that I’ve been able to break that cycle for myself. I worked as hard as I could to get out of the area, I met a really good man who I have now been with 12 years and we have just had DC1.

5128gap · 24/11/2021 10:09

@motherofthelittlescreamingone

Yes, to be honest I would not judge you in the moment, but later on if your child later grew up and said how awful it was growing up without a mum and how awful it was knowing that their birth contributed to that, I would probably think that you had done the wrong thing. And that is a possibility.

There are other options in your situation - I know adoption is a difficult route and has its own challenges, but it might be better.

So when someone reveals they had an unhappy or challenging childhood due to parental circumstances or choices, your response is to look at that person and think it would be better if they had not been born?
NoBetterthanSheShouldBe · 24/11/2021 10:06

I would judge someone who set out to become pregnant in your circumstances if the father was not in agreement and prepared to step up as the main parent. I do think every child needs at least one competent parent about for the foreseeable future - and it’s also putting a huge burden on anyone to know that their arrival hastened their mother’s death or disability.

I wouldn’t judge for having a child in poverty. All of this is largely hypothetical because I wouldn’t assume any pregnancy was deliberate.

I don’t like being judgemental, but I am.

motherofthelittlescreamingone · 24/11/2021 09:57

Yes, to be honest I would not judge you in the moment, but later on if your child later grew up and said how awful it was growing up without a mum and how awful it was knowing that their birth contributed to that, I would probably think that you had done the wrong thing. And that is a possibility.

There are other options in your situation - I know adoption is a difficult route and has its own challenges, but it might be better.

rhowton · 24/11/2021 09:56

I would, yes.

Aggy35 · 24/11/2021 09:55

Currently pregnant at age 33.Wanted children for quite a while but didn't have own property,relationship hadn't settled with partner,income wasn't the best.When all of this was sorted I came of the pill.We both wanted to give our child best start.This was our choice of course however I do think there would be a lot more stable,happy children if they would have been considered carefully

SadHermit · 24/11/2021 09:38

I’m kind of in a similar situation. I’ve had a reproductive cancer(in remission now), and while I had fertility sparing surgery (leaving me with 1 ovary, 1 tube and my uterus) there’s a good chance if I got pregnant - especially if I needed IVF/hormone stimulation*, then the cancer could come back. If it came back, I could leave my child without a mother.

*I probably require IVF due to PCOS that was already an issue pre cancer, and these stimulations can set off ovarian cancers again….

But I’m still trying. It is a deeply held need of mine. Even if I only have one baby and let them take everything out after (so they don’t have to worry about the cancer coming back in the reproductive system). I feel like I need to have That.
I might die in pursuit of that but for me life isn’t worth living if I don’t get that.

But there are many childless women who had my cancer who chose to lose their entire reproductive system to prevent their deaths/reoccurrence. I understand both sides.

Tldr: I know how you feel and seriously offer my sympathies.

Bettyboop3 · 24/11/2021 09:35

I definitely judge someone close to me for intentionally bringing a child into this world while they are homeless & in a very volatile relationship.

5128gap · 24/11/2021 09:22

No. I am a child of similar circumstances and however painful parts of my childhood were, I am grateful to my mother for the gift of my life. If no one had children outside of optimum circumstances, the contribution of many people made strong and resilient through adversity would be lost. My life has been useful, and is of value. I am happy and have made a positive impact on many others. I think there are no grounds to judge my mother for my existence.

TractorAndHeadphones · 24/11/2021 09:21

@supremelybaffled

There seem to be rather a lot of people these days who are all too ready and willing to judge others.

When I was a child, I was taught not to be judgemental towards other people, and my parents were very fond of the saying 'There, but for the grace of God, go I".

Judgement simply means to have an opinion. As society is expected to take care of children born into less than ideal circumstances why is it bad to have an opinion on something that affects us? This is different from judging someone’s hair, clothes or whatever.
Leislmann · 24/11/2021 09:04

In your case I absolutely wouldn’t judge, I would think it was extremely tragic
I do judge people who are in massive financial issues or people who are addicted to drugs

theworldsastage · 24/11/2021 09:01

I'd never say anything, but yes, if I knew for sure that the person had knowingly brought a child into bad circumstances.

The thing is, rarely do we know enough details.

Personally, I'm not having children for many reasons, but one of them like you OP, is medical related. My parents couldn't have foreseen my medical issues, but the difference is, I can foresee the issues any of my offspring would have.

There are enough children in the world. I'm not vain enough to think my crappy genes are necessary.

Swipe left for the next trending thread