Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you ever privately judge people for bringing a baby into bad circumstances?

315 replies

Boilthekettleplease · 23/11/2021 20:41

I've wondered how other people feel about this.

I'm coming to terms with not having a child of my own, because ultimately it would be putting my own needs ahead of any child to risk trying to have one. There's a high chance it would be a medical disaster and I'd be permanently seriously affected, which means I wouldn't be as able to look after the child, or die a few years later from kidney failure.

I'm curious if people would judge me for (hypothetically) trying to be a mum in a situation like this? Or do most people feel that the drive for a child is so strong they understand why people try against all the odds?

Do you ever judge people for having a child in situations where there are predictable risks or downsides?

OP posts:
Hoolahupsaresquare · 24/11/2021 15:59

Yes. Not so much when it is accidental but when people admit to deciding to have a child while their lives are an utter mess or have an inheritable disease. I think it is utterly selfish and they are doing it for their needs and not thinking of the child’s.

Part of the reason I do not want children is because of what they might inherit from me.

Lavender24 · 24/11/2021 15:54

I judge people like my next door neighbours. Benefit scamming arseholes who emotionally abuse the child they already had. Lord knows why they had another.

thebear1 · 24/11/2021 15:48

I do tend to judge parents who have already had children removed or are barley coping and unable to meet the needs of existing children. I try not to judge in other circumstances.

MMMarmite · 24/11/2021 15:22

I feel sympathy rather than judging you.

If I was in your situation, it would depend for me just how high "high risk" is - a higher risk relative to an average person could still be quite low. If your death is a likely outcome, then I think you are making the right decision all round Flowers

Larryyourwaiter · 24/11/2021 13:41

I have a friend who had an accidental pregnancy with a boyfriend. It was clear fairly on he was a bit useless and had issues. She had 4 more children with him. Guess what, he was useless still. She complains like it’s a total shock all the time. They split up and she’s taken on most of the burden of child rearing, no one else is surprised but her.
She also constantly goes on about the cost. I can’t believe anyone wouldn’t think 5 children wouldn’t be expensive.

I think having a society where working means people can afford to have children is right. Having as many children as you feel like, no. I’m sure lots of wealthy people can’t afford to house and educate (if they want private education) 10 kids. Everyone needs to cut their cloth accordingly.

AudacityBaby · 24/11/2021 13:30

Absolutely, I judge. I came from people who shouldn't have had kids, and the lifelong impact is devastating. I think the reason people don't say they'd rather not have existed is because it's taboo and makes others feel super uncomfortable, but I'd rather not have existed. I wouldn't have known any different.

If anything I think it's a bit of an odd way to look at it, as though any life is better than not having lived. It really isn't, and it sort of lets negligent parents off the hook a bit.

I'm really sorry, OP. I'm infertile and it really, really sucks.

Shallwegoforawalk · 24/11/2021 13:27

@RubyTuesday70

Having been a child who was suddenly thrust into a life of poverty when Dad walked out on Mum, yes I do judge people who have children that they knowingly can't afford to raise well. I remember coming home from school, being hungry and looking into empty cupboards/fridge and knowing tomorrow would be the same. Not being able to turn the heating on because we knew Mum would stress about the bill even though the house was freezing. Not being able to meet your school mates in town at the weekend because you can't bear to ask Mum for the bus fare let alone money to eat/drink or shop like your friends did. Turning down party invites because you've got nothing to wear let alone be able to give someone a gift. Not being able to go on any school trips and you bin the letters without even taking them home as you don't want to stress Mum out.

Kids don't just need love, they need food, warmth, clothing and to be able to live alongside their peers without every single day feeling that they're the odd one out.

Yes this is the sort of impact I'm talking about. Grinding merciless poverty is soul destroying. And, despite MN stories of children that have gone on to get 1st class degrees at Oxford, quite likely to be repeated with the next generation.
Shallwegoforawalk · 24/11/2021 13:17

I especially hate when people say you shouldn't have children you can't afford. Having children shouldn't be just for the well off.
Saying you shouldn’t have children you can’t afford is not the same as saying only the well off should have children. I don’t know why this line is constantly trotted out on MN

Exactly! Judging someone for having yet more children when in a cramped unsuitable house with no money is not saying everyone has to be "well off" to have kids, it's saying think about the impact on those children of being raised in circumstances that are difficult rather than placing your desire for a larger family first, before their actual needs.

LaMagdalena · 24/11/2021 13:13

@FanGirlX I believe you quoted me.

I've written a long post on page 7 as to why I hate it when people say that. As I say, I'd prefer it if we had a more equal society in which people on lower incomes could have 1 or 2 children and give them a decent quality of life, rather than the situation we have now, in which people have children, struggle to cover the high cost of living, and then get shamed for it.

I see it all the time on the Internet, there's a family or single mother struggling, so people inevitably say, 'Well you shouldn't have had children if you couldn't afford it.' And what does it achieve? Nothing, it just makes people feel shit about themselves.

You don't really know much about my personal situation so I'm not going to justify having a baby to you.

MorrisZapp · 24/11/2021 13:07

Yes, all the time. I find it baffling. See also adding more kids and pets to already chaotic circumstances.

FanGirlX · 24/11/2021 13:06

@TractorAndHeadphones

I don't think children should just for those who can afford big houses and multiple holidays. I do think people who bring children into the world, knowing that they can't afford to pay for their basic needs, are reckless, irresponsible and selfish. There's a whole variety of situations between these two extremes though.

TractorAndHeadphones · 24/11/2021 13:03

@Wheresmywoolyjumpers

*A friend of mine had a little boy who was 2 when they found our her husband had a terminal brain tumour. A year into intense chemo and radiation they decided to have another baby. I remember listening to the reasons and I didn't judge out loud but it was very hard not to. The dad died when the new child was 2 months old. It was heartbreaking. I think she wanted to have as much of him left as she could.*

I would see that as different though - it's not necessarily a 'bad' situation, even if not ideal for her, as this will be a valued and loved child with a loving mother and sibling (hopefully about the sib!). To me it is people who know they wont be able to care for their children adequately and who don't think they will be able to provide a safe secure environment. No one can foresee everything that may happen, but in a bad situation, why foist that on a child?

YeH I don’t think this is bad. The child still has a mother. How is it different from a single woman having a child with donor sperm? I have knows people with illnesses etc have kids but they have had enough assets put aside for kids, family all on board and ready to step in. That’s not wrong.

What’s wrong is just having it because one wants it and hoping it’ll all work out.

TractorAndHeadphones · 24/11/2021 13:01

@FanGirlX

Like a pp, I also hate it when people say shouldn't have kids you can't afford.

This is selfish though. Why bring children into the world if you can't afford to house, clothe and feed those children? Your decision will have a terrible impact on those children's lives and prospects in life. But your right to be a mother comes above that does it?

Different people have different opinions about affordability as well. Many people are poor but manage to raise kids in loving homes, they don’t have the best of everything but parents are fully aware of their responsibilities. I don’t think this is a problen(although others do).

However others have kids with no thought or care - no thinking about how they’re going to feed them, clothe them. They can’t manage one and go on to have multiple. This, I judge.

Sadly our culture reveres parents -and ‘parents always want the best for their kids’. This isn’t true, reproducing doesn’t automatically make you competent.

HelplesslyHoping · 24/11/2021 12:52

I don't judge them, but I do question if the parent is okay when they're choosing (as in, are deliberately ttc) to bring a child into the world when they live in poverty/an abusive or unstable relationship/ have a demanding job/life that means the kid will be in nursery every minute possible.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 24/11/2021 12:48

A friend of mine had a little boy who was 2 when they found our her husband had a terminal brain tumour. A year into intense chemo and radiation they decided to have another baby.
I remember listening to the reasons and I didn't judge out loud but it was very hard not to. The dad died when the new child was 2 months old. It was heartbreaking. I think she wanted to have as much of him left as she could.

I would see that as different though - it's not necessarily a 'bad' situation, even if not ideal for her, as this will be a valued and loved child with a loving mother and sibling (hopefully about the sib!). To me it is people who know they wont be able to care for their children adequately and who don't think they will be able to provide a safe secure environment. No one can foresee everything that may happen, but in a bad situation, why foist that on a child?

MrsColon · 24/11/2021 12:47

I think, OP, that you're doing a very brave and selfless thing - not many people are able to put their putative children before their own almost overwhelming desire to have a child. You are doing a really good thing. Flowers

I'm so very sorry you're in this situation Sad

VestaTilley · 24/11/2021 12:46

Well I’m strongly judging Liz Kendall today. And not in a good way.

Ohpulltheotherone · 24/11/2021 12:43

Yes I think on face value most people would give a little side eye to anyone bringing a baby into the world knowing that the situation is far from desirable.

That said, I would understand. I would truly understand the maternal pull because I’ve felt it myself and know how utterly bereft it can leave you.
So whilst I might make a snap judgement, I know it’s far more complicated than just “I wanted a baby so fuck it”

troobleflooble · 24/11/2021 12:39

It depends! In a case like yours OP, no I wouldn't. We could all become ill or disabled at any moment. Your health is not necessarily in your control and with the right support it can work.

I do judge people who knowingly bring a child into poor circumstances due to their own selfish desire to have a baby. Part of your responsibility as a parent or prospective parent is to consider what kind of life your child will have with you.

One of my oldest and dearest friends tried for many years to have a baby but unfortunately wasn't successful. I hate to admit it but I did (privately) judge her because as much as she's a lovely person and really wanted a child she couldn't have reliably looked after or provided for one. Her child would have at best ended up as a child carer living in poverty, at worst ended up in care.

Someone else I know has just had a baby and I judge her too (again, privately). She is apparently too ill to work and lives in a spare room at a relative's house. Her baby daddy is an unemployed drug addict, a massive misogynist and just generally the most useless man child you could have the misfortune to meet. He was also someone else's boyfriend when she got pregnant. Her MIL hates her and openly wished for her to have a miscarriage, so she'll either end up with no support (financial or otherwise) or squabbling over who has 'rights' and access to the baby for the next 18 years. How anyone can think it's a good idea to bring an innocent baby into that shit show I have no idea. She seems the think parenting is all cute newborn snuggles on Instagram and comes with a free council house. Completely deluded.

Franca123 · 24/11/2021 12:26

I don't think badly of people who bring a baby into the world who they can't fully care for as I do understand. But I do have thoughts about it and I know other people do, as they've told me their thoughts..... For example, I have a family friend who has Epliepsy which has severely effected their ability to function. The oldest child (primary age) takes responsibility way beyond his age and in what could be potentially dangerous situations. The grandparents are a lot more involved than they would like to be through necessity. So there were definitely 'opinions' being quietly shared when they purposefully became pregnant with a second child. None of this was nasty or uncaring. But people did think it was not fair on the existing family to add to the burden. Not saying this is comparable to the OP's situation.

BurntO · 24/11/2021 12:26

Yes I would judge.

FanGirlX · 24/11/2021 12:26

Like a pp, I also hate it when people say shouldn't have kids you can't afford.

This is selfish though. Why bring children into the world if you can't afford to house, clothe and feed those children? Your decision will have a terrible impact on those children's lives and prospects in life. But your right to be a mother comes above that does it?

FanGirlX · 24/11/2021 12:22

I have a friend who has a condition that means she can barely get out of bed on a regular basis. This condition is progressive and incurable. She's currently having IVF as she can't get pregnant naturally.

I don't know if I'm judging but I do have concerns. How will she tend to the baby when she can't move?

PlanktonsComputerWife · 24/11/2021 12:21

@5128gap you said that very well.

theleafandnotthetree · 24/11/2021 12:19

@SENmummy73848

I think I judge people in certain circumstances because of personal experiences of seeing the outcome. For example, one of my friends (firstborn) was born with CF and nearly died as a child. They have now had a lung transplant but is still unwell all of the time, has no real quality of life, will still die before her time. Her mum went onto have 4/5 more kids knowing there was a very real possibility of them all potentially having CF and suffering the same fate as her. 2 more of them was born with CF and if not given a lung transplant could potentially die before reaching a teenage age. That to me is selfish because she is knowingly having more and more kids knowing they could have a whole lifetime full of illness and hospitals - that is if they all even survive.
That is frankly horrifying. And I know it's not the main focus - though it would be a real consideration for me - but wider society is asked to pay the price for this in terms of extremely expensive medical interventions, use of resources, etc. It is selfish and cruel on so many levels.
Swipe left for the next trending thread