Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you ever privately judge people for bringing a baby into bad circumstances?

315 replies

Boilthekettleplease · 23/11/2021 20:41

I've wondered how other people feel about this.

I'm coming to terms with not having a child of my own, because ultimately it would be putting my own needs ahead of any child to risk trying to have one. There's a high chance it would be a medical disaster and I'd be permanently seriously affected, which means I wouldn't be as able to look after the child, or die a few years later from kidney failure.

I'm curious if people would judge me for (hypothetically) trying to be a mum in a situation like this? Or do most people feel that the drive for a child is so strong they understand why people try against all the odds?

Do you ever judge people for having a child in situations where there are predictable risks or downsides?

OP posts:
SunscreenCentral · 24/11/2021 21:30

@Boilthekettleplease

I especially hate when people say you shouldn't have children you can't afford. Having children shouldn't be just for the well off.

Agree with this.

We all do our very best for our children, we really do, I think, for the most part. But actually bringing another human being into existence is simultaneously biologically wired into us and often utterly separate to what is rational in modern life
Moooning · 24/11/2021 21:29

@Musttryharder2021 I know, I don't really understand that either 😂😬

Romantic love it infatuation has always been something I've viewed as a bizarre chemical reaction that makes people do things they never normally would. The main goal or point of any 'relationship' has been the regular sex for me, but I meet those needs with fwb and/or toys now. It would be nice to have companionship sometimes, but I have always ended things once the subject of intertwining lives i.e. moving in together comes up. I cannot endure commitment or compromise in the name of romantic love. The risk of failure and the limits to my freedom in terms of other people and places is not worth it for one person who may or may not turn out to be a cunt. That's the thing - I think we're all capable of cuntishness. The only person I can be sure of is myself.

LaMagdalena · 24/11/2021 21:21

@FanGirlX Okay, you just seem to want an argument for argument's sake now, so let's part ways and never interact again.

FanGirlX · 24/11/2021 21:19

@LaMagdalena
Your comments are mumsnet maths. Unfortunately for you society doesn't run on mumsnet maths.

LaMagdalena · 24/11/2021 21:12

@FanGirlX

Presumably the hypothetical single mother had two incomes at one point.

I always say single parent in my comments because I'm not sexist. You are showing your own prejudice with your comments.

I also live in the 21st century and understand that not all children have 2 parents at some point.

I said 'someone else USUALLY needs to be involved to have children', which is correct, usually someone else is involved. I'm going to hazard a guess and say that people who adopt as single parents or use donor sperm are less likely to be on low incomes or use benefits, so aren'treally relevantin what I'm talking about.

You think I'm showing my prejudice because I say single mother rather than single parent? Okay, I'll check my privilege and apologise to all the single dads for excluding them.

I really don't know what that has to do with anything though. My points remain exactly the same Hmm

GreyhoundG1rl · 24/11/2021 21:04

there are also no tangible benefits to being in a romantic relationship either
Not tangible, certainly, but not all good things have to be?

Musttryharder2021 · 24/11/2021 21:03

@Moooning

Tbh I judge people for wanting to have children full stop. I know that sounds ridiculous but I have never had that biological drive. Looking at it purely logically and without an emotional lens there seems to be no tangible benefits without significant risk in modern times.

I just don't get it! 🤷‍♀️

Looking at it purely logically, there are also no tangible benefits to being in a romantic relationship either but many have been driven/conditioned to pursue it relentlessly.
FanGirlX · 24/11/2021 20:55

Presumably the hypothetical single mother had two incomes at one point.

I always say single parent in my comments because I'm not sexist. You are showing your own prejudice with your comments.

I also live in the 21st century and understand that not all children have 2 parents at some point.

Moooning · 24/11/2021 20:32

Tbh I judge people for wanting to have children full stop. I know that sounds ridiculous but I have never had that biological drive. Looking at it purely logically and without an emotional lens there seems to be no tangible benefits without significant risk in modern times.

I just don't get it! 🤷‍♀️

GreyhoundG1rl · 24/11/2021 20:31

I would imagine very few people whose mothers died when they were children would genuinely prefer not to have been born because of that. And they are the only ones with a right to judge.
I imagine there are vanishingly few people who would claim they wish they'd never been born...
It doesn't make knowingly having a child you're unlikely to live long enough to raise the right thing to do, for either the child or the parent.
Not remotely right.

LaMagdalena · 24/11/2021 20:31

@FanGirlX

Despite the fact that if you have an income, you're presumably working and paying taxes yourself anyway?

Do you understand what a net contributor is?

If you are on min wage and have a couple of kids as a single parent then you will be getting far more in benefits than you are paying in tax / NI.

Yes I understand what a net contributor is.

But since someone has to do the low paying work, I don't really begrudge lower earners two children when they are contributing to society.

Also, someone else usually needs to be involved to have children. Presumably the hypothetical single mother had two incomes at one point.

isadoradancing123 · 24/11/2021 20:25

I would not willingly subject a child to living without its mother. Who is going to love it, dads move on, a new girlfriend or a stepmum is not going to have the same bond esp when she has her own biological children

LaMagdalena · 24/11/2021 20:23

@TractorAndHeadphones You might not object to state help for those people, but I've spent enough hours idly scrolling the Internet to know that people tell any struggling lower income person that they shouldn't have had children. People say it all the time!

TractorAndHeadphones · 24/11/2021 20:18

@LaMagdalena

So people object to single parents on low incomes getting help from the state, because these single parents had children wanting other people to pay for everything? Despite the fact that if you have an income, you're presumably working and paying taxes yourself anyway?

Firstly, we all know the stories of the single mothers with 7 children wanting the council to pay for a mansion for them, but I'm sure they're probably in a minority, based on the fact that benefits are not particularly high, and if benefits could give you a good quality of life then I don't know why food banks have become so prevalent? My working class parents, who I mentioned previously, never needed to go to a food bank, so the state has definitely screwed over lower income earners somewhere along the line.

The point I'm trying to make is that there are many normal people working hard on low incomes, or surviving as single mothers on benefits until they can get a job or whatever, many of these people are struggling with the rising cost of living (not their fault) and rising house prices (not their fault either) and they could probably do without all the goady 'Well you shouldn't have had children then, blah blah blah.'

No - people object to state for help for those who know they can’t afford to care for the children they already have, but decide to go ahead and have more anyway. If someone had 3 kids, then broke up, house prices cost of living rose etc etc all fine. If said someone however went on to have a 4th - that is irresponsible!
FanGirlX · 24/11/2021 20:17

Despite the fact that if you have an income, you're presumably working and paying taxes yourself anyway?

Do you understand what a net contributor is?

If you are on min wage and have a couple of kids as a single parent then you will be getting far more in benefits than you are paying in tax / NI.

LaMagdalena · 24/11/2021 20:07

So people object to single parents on low incomes getting help from the state, because these single parents had children wanting other people to pay for everything? Despite the fact that if you have an income, you're presumably working and paying taxes yourself anyway?

Firstly, we all know the stories of the single mothers with 7 children wanting the council to pay for a mansion for them, but I'm sure they're probably in a minority, based on the fact that benefits are not particularly high, and if benefits could give you a good quality of life then I don't know why food banks have become so prevalent? My working class parents, who I mentioned previously, never needed to go to a food bank, so the state has definitely screwed over lower income earners somewhere along the line.

The point I'm trying to make is that there are many normal people working hard on low incomes, or surviving as single mothers on benefits until they can get a job or whatever, many of these people are struggling with the rising cost of living (not their fault) and rising house prices (not their fault either) and they could probably do without all the goady 'Well you shouldn't have had children then, blah blah blah.'

AudacityBaby · 24/11/2021 19:27

@theleafandnotthetree Weirdly it felt really good to read that, it kinda released a whole bunch of feelings in me. Thank you for saying it.

FanGirlX · 24/11/2021 18:01

My problem with 'you shouldn't have a child when you can't afford it/can't afford the basics/can't afford it without state help' is that in the UK, the basics are so expensive - housing and childcare being the most obvious expenses, but then add council tax, rising food prices, rising cost of living - and even being able 'to afford' one child seems impossible for people on low (or even middle) incomes.

A single parent on a low income will get most of the basics paid for by the state though. I think that's perhaps what people object to - someone deliberately having a child they can't afford to feed, house, clothe in the expectation that others will pick up the tab. Then complaining on mumsnet that there isn't enough state support available for them.

5128gap · 24/11/2021 17:39

@RobertaFirmino

To suggest a child would be better to have no life than to have a life without a mother somewhat overplays the (albeit important) role of a mother

That doesn't even make sense. There is either a child without a mother or no child at all. It can't have 'no life' because it does not exist.

OK, I'll rephrase it. To say it's better not to exist than to exist without a mother somewhat overplays the (albeit important) role of a mother. I would imagine very few people whose mothers died when they were children would genuinely prefer not to have been born because of that. And they are the only ones with a right to judge.
Canunot · 24/11/2021 17:32

I used to work with a woman who had 3 daughters who were in care due to neglect, she then got pregnant with a son. The baby was taken off of her in hospital. Yes I do judge her and the partner.

Antsgomarching · 24/11/2021 17:16

I remember watching a documentary about the charity Pause. I came out of that with much more sympathy with women who have multiple children removed but my primary sympathy is always with the kids. These women often were care leavers themselves just recreating their own childhoods for the next generation. Children don’t get to choose what they are born into, parents choose for them and sometimes people are not making rational choices. Thres something like 80’000 children in care in the UK. That’s horrifying. For those people I just feel immense sadness, for the women, for the kids.

I would judge if someone had a heritable condition or life limiting illness which would mean a child would definable grow up without a parent or become a child carer. I would judge that pretty hard.

RobertaFirmino · 24/11/2021 17:04

To suggest a child would be better to have no life than to have a life without a mother somewhat overplays the (albeit important) role of a mother

That doesn't even make sense. There is either a child without a mother or no child at all. It can't have 'no life' because it does not exist.

theleafandnotthetree · 24/11/2021 16:58

@AudacityBaby

The other thing, I think, is that it's far harder not to judge when you can't have kids yourself, because there's an emotional jealousy to it.

I know it haunts me, and probably always will haunt me, that my abusive parents had fertility that was like a running tap, but after 20 years of working on myself, becoming independent, and building a life in which I could comfortably raise a child, I can't have them.

That is very honest of you and I think it must be gut-wrenching to see people who are terrible or selfish parents seemingly pop them out no bother when you can't. It would take a bigger person than I am not to be hugely angry and resentful about that.
Musttryharder2021 · 24/11/2021 16:53

@Hoolahupsaresquare

Yes. Not so much when it is accidental but when people admit to deciding to have a child while their lives are an utter mess or have an inheritable disease. I think it is utterly selfish and they are doing it for their needs and not thinking of the child’s.

Part of the reason I do not want children is because of what they might inherit from me.

Having children is always a selfish act I think.

What other reason is there?

AudacityBaby · 24/11/2021 16:00

The other thing, I think, is that it's far harder not to judge when you can't have kids yourself, because there's an emotional jealousy to it.

I know it haunts me, and probably always will haunt me, that my abusive parents had fertility that was like a running tap, but after 20 years of working on myself, becoming independent, and building a life in which I could comfortably raise a child, I can't have them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread