Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you ever privately judge people for bringing a baby into bad circumstances?

315 replies

Boilthekettleplease · 23/11/2021 20:41

I've wondered how other people feel about this.

I'm coming to terms with not having a child of my own, because ultimately it would be putting my own needs ahead of any child to risk trying to have one. There's a high chance it would be a medical disaster and I'd be permanently seriously affected, which means I wouldn't be as able to look after the child, or die a few years later from kidney failure.

I'm curious if people would judge me for (hypothetically) trying to be a mum in a situation like this? Or do most people feel that the drive for a child is so strong they understand why people try against all the odds?

Do you ever judge people for having a child in situations where there are predictable risks or downsides?

OP posts:
LaMagdalena · 23/11/2021 22:33

@Doona

No, but honestly, if you mind being judged, motherhood is not for you anyway. There are hoardes of people whose main business in life seems to be judging mothers on a variety of factors.
This is true.
notanothertakeaway · 23/11/2021 22:30

@Spottybotty20

I would judge also, I grew up next to a family where the mum was likely to have Huntington’s, she had 4 kids at least one has now been diagnosed, 2 were taken into care as she is now dying herself. Horrific circumstances for the children.

The family believe the stress of pregnancy brought the symptoms out (but I’ve no idea if this is medically possible)
If you have no idea what’s for you then anything could happen, but if you have a good idea of the toll it would take then it’s reckless.

Could you adopt or foster?

@Spottybotty20

Prospective adopters and foster carers are carefully screened for health conditions, as they are caring for children who are already vulnerable

amazeandastonish · 23/11/2021 22:29

yes

A former friend was in a relationship where her DH dumped her just before the wedding claiming depression. Demanded she moved out when she had nowhere to go - she went back to her DMs in the other part of the UK but her DM had cancer (since died) at the time. Friend was devastated and I was her shoulder to cry on but they did get back together. I never trusted him though. He was a wierdo.

As for friend, she has multiple physical and sensory impairments. She has no family (all dead) and relies heavily on her DH (another reason I don't like him). Her DH's family has a lot of children with ASD.

I was surprised when she fell pregnant as I wondered how she would cope with a depressed arsehole unreliable husband, and her disabilities, she also did not work and his income was not high. She told me doctors had told her her child had a 50% child of being disabled and she'd need a planned C section to deliver.

Child was born with learning disabilities, mobility difficulties, visual impairment. My former friend still has disabilities and no family around. Her DH is still around but no idea how their relationship is. Saw former friend a few months ago and she was very thin, limping (due to her condition), pushing a heavy wheelchair with child in it, whilst husband sauntered behind smoking a fag.

So yes, I judged her for having her child. Never said anything though and let our friendship fizzle out.

Workyticket · 23/11/2021 22:28

@PlandeRaccordement people can predict that their life isn't going to suddenly become easier / that they're suddenly going to be able to feed and clothe a 4th child when they can't manage the 3 they have etc

TheYearOfSmallThings · 23/11/2021 22:28

I sometimes judge.

Not so much for wanting to be parents and pretending everything will turn out fine, but I have seen couples having third, fourth and fifth children in situations where the parents have significant health issues and the first and second children are severely disabled. The parents have no expectation that they themselves will be responsible for coping with the situation they are creating - somebody else has to find the (immense) resources to do that, and it is never enough, but they are having another child. I just don't know what they are thinking, because their children suffer greatly.

Itsokay2020 · 23/11/2021 22:26

No clear cut answer, in my opinion, as it depends on the individual’s situation. However, it would be high risk for me to have another child and I therefore haven’t. But, I am a mum and feel incredibly fortunate for what I have. Would I judge? I wouldn’t want to, but I would feel sad if a child is brought into the world by a parent who knows they are unlikely to survive/see their child reach adulthood, but that sadness is for both the child and parent. It is one of my worst fears.

PlanDeRaccordement · 23/11/2021 22:26

people consciously choosing to have children in full possession of the facts

But no one is ever in full possession of the facts because no one can predict the future (not even doctors). You have only some of the facts, with some risks and probabilities thrown in just to make a choice that much harder.

You might have a good income now...fact...but will you for next twenty years? No way to know as there is always risk of unemployment, injury, disability, death.

You might have great partner now....fact...but will you after the child is here for the next twenty years? Maybe, maybe not.

You might be in good health...fact...but you can’t know if your pregnancy will be easy low risk or hard and high risk. You can’t know if you will even survive childbirth....odds can be either in your favour or not, but you cannot know.

You might have lovely parents all eager to do free childcare...and then after baby arrives they can’t due to illness, disability, death or changed their minds and retired to a tropical island.

Gardeningtipsneeded · 23/11/2021 22:25

Not the first baby. I think we can all be idealistic and hopeful with our first baby.
Subsequent babies, yes. People bringing kid after kid into crap situations I absolutely judge (privately, and to myself).

ImInStealthMode · 23/11/2021 22:25

Honestly, to a degree yes.

I know that accidents happen, and that circumstances can change unexpectedly (I grew up from age 3 in a council house with a young single Mum on the breadline & a dad nowhere to be seen. They'd been married with their own home when I was born) but as someone who's waited for the right relationship, career stage, secure albeit very small home and healthy bank balance to have a child and now fears it's too late, I can't help but wince a bit at tales on here of those who happily plan a family or extension of a family into being without the means to support them, or into a chaotic, dysfunctional or even dangerous situation.

Having children shouldn't only be for the rich at all, but I think it's irresponsible to plan a baby when you're not in a position (at the planning stage) to at least feed, clothe, protect, nurture and shelter them independently.

I would not judge anyone on their decisions made from a medical stand point.

Nottogetapenny · 23/11/2021 22:24

I think you are an incredible selfless person! Putting so much thought into what could/might happen if you had a child.
I think you would make a wonderful foster parent, so a number of needing children could enrich your life.

Nevermindthesquirrels · 23/11/2021 22:22

A friend of mine had a little boy who was 2 when they found our her husband had a terminal brain tumour. A year into intense chemo and radiation they decided to have another baby.
I remember listening to the reasons and I didn't judge out loud but it was very hard not to. The dad died when the new child was 2 months old. It was heartbreaking. I think she wanted to have as much of him left as she could.

GreyhoundG1rl · 23/11/2021 22:19

I especially hate when people say you shouldn't have children you can't afford. Having children shouldn't be just for the well off.
It's not just for the well off. It's for people who can afford to pay for their child's needs Confused
Who do you think should fund them?

theleafandnotthetree · 23/11/2021 22:19

@supremelybaffled

There seem to be rather a lot of people these days who are all too ready and willing to judge others.

When I was a child, I was taught not to be judgemental towards other people, and my parents were very fond of the saying 'There, but for the grace of God, go I".

Yes but we're not talking about bad circumstances befalling people, we're talking about people consciously choosing to have children in full possession of the facts. That is what we are talking about here.
Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 23/11/2021 22:18

It is not selfish to not have children. It is selfish to have them without thinking about whether you can give them what they need (I don't mean foreign holidays and ponies, I mean love, care and attention).

Workyticket · 23/11/2021 22:17

Yep - I do. Those who have multiple children removed by SS then get pregnant again. A friend of a friend was guardian to 3 of her sister's children at the age of 22... the sister fell pregnant again and the guardian was devastated. She was struggling but how do you take 3 kids on and not a 4th?

I judge those who know they can't afford more children and still have them too.

I judge those who have kids then expect their elderly mother to have them all the time. I was in the library in the holidays and this lady in her 70s had 3 kids with her - all.running wild. She was on the phone begging her (assuming) daughter to leave work early as she was past it

I understand the urge, we have 1. Couldnt afford to put more through nursery and didn't want to put onto the grandparents

Fuck, I'm more judgement than I thought

Missrabbitt · 23/11/2021 22:16

Sorry to hear about what you are going through OP. You are showing what an amazing mother you would be by making this sacrifice to avoid bringing children into a world where you might not be around to protect them. I hope you go ahead with fostering in the future- I’m sure you would be an incredible foster parent

theleafandnotthetree · 23/11/2021 22:16

Yes I'm afraid I do judge, especially when it's the 4th or 5th child (well I'd be judging them anyway Smile). I know of a few families where a diagnosus of a very serious life limiting or debilitating illness came when they already had 2 or 3 children but where they then proceeded to have more. That is not fair at all on ANY of the children, is selfish and may well end up also costing the state money in time.

RubyTuesday70 · 23/11/2021 22:16

Having been a child who was suddenly thrust into a life of poverty when Dad walked out on Mum, yes I do judge people who have children that they knowingly can't afford to raise well. I remember coming home from school, being hungry and looking into empty cupboards/fridge and knowing tomorrow would be the same. Not being able to turn the heating on because we knew Mum would stress about the bill even though the house was freezing. Not being able to meet your school mates in town at the weekend because you can't bear to ask Mum for the bus fare let alone money to eat/drink or shop like your friends did. Turning down party invites because you've got nothing to wear let alone be able to give someone a gift. Not being able to go on any school trips and you bin the letters without even taking them home as you don't want to stress Mum out.

Kids don't just need love, they need food, warmth, clothing and to be able to live alongside their peers without every single day feeling that they're the odd one out.

Doona · 23/11/2021 22:14

No, but honestly, if you mind being judged, motherhood is not for you anyway. There are hoardes of people whose main business in life seems to be judging mothers on a variety of factors.

supremelybaffled · 23/11/2021 22:13

There seem to be rather a lot of people these days who are all too ready and willing to judge others.

When I was a child, I was taught not to be judgemental towards other people, and my parents were very fond of the saying 'There, but for the grace of God, go I".

De88 · 23/11/2021 22:11

I do judge, unfortunately! But that's because I work in a field where I see the utter devastation it can cause. So my view is completely skewed.

Starcup · 23/11/2021 22:09

@Cookiejarmonster

Yes I do.

Bringing babies into grown adult mess i can't get behind.

By that I mean living in poverty with a crap unsupportive partner and no support but being pregnant with baby number 2 despite things being shit with baby number 1.

Totally sucks for the kids.

Agree
OverTheRubicon · 23/11/2021 22:05

I try not to judge in most situations, because things change and because sometimes the difficulties that make it hard to raise kids also make it hard to look ahead.

However, if your consultants really are clear on the dangers you describe then I'd absolutely judge you and pity your child if predictably goes wrong. The situation is so unfair to you, but even more unfair to them. Surrogacy is a morally complex area but works for some, or there are other ways to make a meaningful contribution to the life of a child or children, from 'big sister' mentoring programs to fostering to fundraising.

sunnyandshare · 23/11/2021 22:01

Inwardly, yes. I'm certainly not proud of it and I'm sure others have judged me too.
I judge anyone who knows they will not be able to meet a child's needs but still go onto purposely have one. I wasn't as judgy until I came into contact with child carers, many of whom their parents knew that they would rely on future young children to help them with basic care. They have to miss school, sacrifice friendships, socialising, education to care for their parents, who knew that would be the case.
I knew of a woman who had a heart condition and was told she could never get pregnant. Her and her husband decided to take the risk, and she died when the baby was very young (under a year). He got with a new partner a year later and went on to remarry, and the step mum treated him like her own, so his life was largely unaffected. Because of that I don't judge his bio mum, just feel very sorry that she missed out on his life.

Wildrobin · 23/11/2021 21:59

I’ve worried more than judged for my relative’s family whose older dc are doing a large share of work looking after their many younger siblings - I don’t judge large families per se for this as my own MIL was so hands on and devoted to her also numerous DC that she carried most of it and was amazing and brought them up in such love and beautifully .

I totally hear the poster who is fed up of people feeling crammed in their own living conditions when it’s of their own making ! I feel strongly we are responsible for our own families and social support is there for unexpected events and those who really need it .