Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you ever privately judge people for bringing a baby into bad circumstances?

315 replies

Boilthekettleplease · 23/11/2021 20:41

I've wondered how other people feel about this.

I'm coming to terms with not having a child of my own, because ultimately it would be putting my own needs ahead of any child to risk trying to have one. There's a high chance it would be a medical disaster and I'd be permanently seriously affected, which means I wouldn't be as able to look after the child, or die a few years later from kidney failure.

I'm curious if people would judge me for (hypothetically) trying to be a mum in a situation like this? Or do most people feel that the drive for a child is so strong they understand why people try against all the odds?

Do you ever judge people for having a child in situations where there are predictable risks or downsides?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Starcup · 02/12/2021 16:51

beggers the question

Starcup · 02/12/2021 16:48

Yes, I think sometimes it's wishful thinking and believe that the guy will change after the baby is born. Never works

Exactly, then there’s a child born who hardly gets to see their dad. When t mother says but he’s abusive, I’m sure he is, but still nights the question why would you chose to bring a baby in to the mess….

buntybanana · 02/12/2021 10:52

@Starcup

Tbh yes. Currently reading another thread about an abusive ex and I just find it difficult to imagine that they were fantastic guys initially, so the woman has a baby with him then all of a sudden, baby is born and he turns in to a psycho.

Yes it will happen sometimes, but I don’t believe it happens every time. I believe the signs would have been there but they were ignored. Then low and behold, another child doesn’t get the chance if a descent father figure.

Yes, I think sometimes it's wishful thinking and believe that the guy will change after the baby is born. Never works.

Starcup · 01/12/2021 23:24

Tbh yes. Currently reading another thread about an abusive ex and I just find it difficult to imagine that they were fantastic guys initially, so the woman has a baby with him then all of a sudden, baby is born and he turns in to a psycho.

Yes it will happen sometimes, but I don’t believe it happens every time. I believe the signs would have been there but they were ignored. Then low and behold, another child doesn’t get the chance if a descent father figure.

dutchessmom · 30/11/2021 21:04

Not really, as I am dealing with secondary infertility I usually focus on the baby stuff and how it's a new beginning and everything, and also as I don't want people to judge me for having or not having children, I cannot judge them either.

Greygreenblue · 26/11/2021 22:17

My sister had a baby with an alcoholic with some serious mental health issues who was frankly quite abusive. Unfortunately none of us realised any of this before she got pregnant. At one point before she left him (but after his problems became apparent) she was talking about giving her son a sibling. Thank f*ck she did leave before that happened.
But I can see how women in abusive relationships end up with multiple children with these men even though it was obvious who he was to everyone after the first. The level of manipulation that man used on her was next level.

She has a good job (can support herself and kid), supportive family and friends and she’s so smart and it was still hard for her leave and not go back. There are so many factors involved with the time she did finally successfully leave I can see how easily it could have been that she stayed and had more children with him.

So I find it very hard to judge women who keep having children with shit men.

bluetongue · 26/11/2021 21:45

@BettyBag

The economic imperative is becoming horrifyingly clear.

The biological imperative is pretty obvious too. Staying alive long enough to successfully pass on our DNA is literally our entire purpose, we would be utterly fucked as a species if we didn't have an incredibly strong drive to do this.

Are you saying as a deliberately childfree woman that I am some kind of traitor to the species?It’s not as though there’s a shortage of humans in the world. If anything you could argue the opposite.

Therefore it’s more important that children that are born are wanted and well provided for.

RobertaFirmino · 26/11/2021 19:53

@Fluffmum

I have a family member who keeps having children in bad circumstances. The kids are adorable and we just get on with it
Yes, bugger the cost to society and the fact that these children may well grown up into damaged adults. Just as long as we can all coo at an adorable ickly wickle baybeee eh?
spanishquestion · 26/11/2021 18:59

I absolutely do, although sometimes with more sympathetic horror than judgement. I have two small DS and the urgent, constant need they have of me - physically, emotionally, financially - is so huge that I frequently worry about not being around for them if something happened. Before you have kids, you logically know how much they need you. But I found it a pretty brutal shock to understand in practice. I try not to think what would happen if one of us were seriously ill or died- they would be devastated.

LovelyIssues · 26/11/2021 16:49

I don't judge the person with serious health issues. I do judge the person knowing that child will never have a normal life and is now in pain daily. A single mum can re marry etc not that is a necessarily to happiness at all. Health is.

TarasCrazyTiara · 26/11/2021 16:46

@LovelyIssues

If you would judge someone with serious health issues which meant they wouldn’t be there for the child and the other parent may end up a single parent, then why wouldn’t you judge a single Mum?
After all she has also decided to have a child knowing it will be deprived of the other parent.

LovelyIssues · 26/11/2021 16:39

Entirely depends on the circumstances. Single mum - I don't judge at all (and no I'm not a single Mum)
I do know someone who was told her and her partner would have a child with certain defects that meant they would never have a normal life and she went ahead and planned a baby and now has a baby with many additional health and mental needs. I do judge that

buntybanana · 26/11/2021 15:22

@FarDownTheRiver Carer* not career!

buntybanana · 26/11/2021 15:21

@FarDownTheRiver

What? Should you not have kids if they’ll get bullied?

No, you shouldn't have kids if they're going to end up being your career. There are studies on how damaging this is.

FarDownTheRiver · 26/11/2021 15:17

What? Should you not have kids if they’ll get bullied?

buntybanana · 26/11/2021 15:02

@Ducksareruiningmypatio

Yes I do sorry. I have a friend that has significant disabilities and decided to go ahead and have a child. That child is now bullied because children are cruel, she's on her second school, doesn't get to do the activities other kids do because of her home life, has caring responsibilities etc. It's not fair She's loved, but that isn't always enough.
This is terribly sad. I do judge over stuff like this too. It's so selfish
buntybanana · 26/11/2021 14:57

@Eastie77Returns I completely agree with you. It's extremely unfair to bring children into the world when you knowingly cannot clothe or feed them. You absolutely do not have to be "well off" or able to pay all their university tuition, but they deserve basic needs met. I find it v selfish when families who are obviously financially struggling deliberately bring multiple children into the situation.

thelegohooverer · 26/11/2021 13:59

I don’t think I can answer the question directly. I judge people who can’t grasp the personhood of a baby (or a child, or a woman, or a person of another race, ethnicity or religious persuasion), and I judge their decisions when they put their own needs and desires ahead of another because they haven’t recognised that there’s a separate reality and experience involved.

I can absolutely understand the biological drive to reproduce and how painful that can be, but to have a child with a realistic chance that you won’t be able to care for them, or live until they are adults is not something I would actively choose for my children.

Plumbuddle · 26/11/2021 12:57

If it's any reassurance, you can speak to them or social services anonymously, the law protects you from having your name revealed though of course he might guess. It's a tough one but incredibly upsetting for you.

Darlingx · 26/11/2021 12:17

Yes I have just been discussing it with my partner . I could hear her crying in the night waking him and assuming her mother has died I felt like that might be why it’s hard to know was he the cause but it was hearing him swear at her and my partner saying he didn’t like the way he spoke to her now I have heard it but it was trying to get her to have a bath. It’s really tricky and yes I feel I need experienced advice on whether anything could be done. Hopefully in a positive way .

Plumbuddle · 26/11/2021 11:18

@Darlingx

Any children that I had duty of care of I never let down. I will need to discuss with a neighbour about my fragments of what I have heard or seen and get their advice on what to do. I certainly don’t think I know the full picture and will try and find some people that do. It’s troubling me which is why I mentioned it but its something I have to do correctly. My concern is that to have intervention could be creating him to lose his temper more at the child it has to be handled very delicately with help from other neighbours I imagine who might know more about his situation. Swearing at a child or smoking weed are probably not enough to have social services involved its if the child is not being looked after correctly as in fed, clothed, being at nursery or the park. Was he shouting at her to have a bath because he cares but is overstretched it could be this. Should anyone smoke around children or have a weed habit . Its not good but I imagine its a quite a common thing? I heard the swearing only yesterday and tied this in with my partner mentioning he doesn’t like the way he speaks to her and she cries a lot. We are piecing things together and keeping a watchful eye. I will discuss this with an older neighbour who has spoken to him.
It's the lots of crying that sounds worrying. It's tough with neighbours I know but u could phone nspcc anonymously to talk it through.
Kanaloa · 26/11/2021 11:04

I was born into awful circumstances. But I'm glad I was born. Do you wish you didn't exist? Many great people (both influential and not) were born into horrifying circumstances.

It really doesn’t work like that. You can judge that this is a bad situation to bring a baby in without wishing the person hadn’t been born.

Objectively my parents shouldn’t have had any children (and they’ve had a LOT). It doesn’t mean I wish I would die/hadn’t been born, but objectively I can see that they’ve done more damage than good. My siblings and I have basically been a 70/30 tossup as to who will have an okay like and who will have a miserable existence and that’s because of my parents.

Again - I do not wish I hadn’t been born, and I love all my siblings and wouldn’t want them gone. But if I met someone in my parents situation I wouldn’t advise them to have children at all.

Darlingx · 26/11/2021 10:55

Any children that I had duty of care of I never let down. I will need to discuss with a neighbour about my fragments of what I have heard or seen and get their advice on what to do. I certainly don’t think I know the full picture and will try and find some people that do. It’s troubling me which is why I mentioned it but its something I have to do correctly. My concern is that to have intervention could be creating him to lose his temper more at the child it has to be handled very delicately with help from other neighbours I imagine who might know more about his situation. Swearing at a child or smoking weed are probably not enough to have social services involved its if the child is not being looked after correctly as in fed, clothed, being at nursery or the park. Was he shouting at her to have a bath because he cares but is overstretched it could be this. Should anyone smoke around children or have a weed habit . Its not good but I imagine its a quite a common thing? I heard the swearing only yesterday and tied this in with my partner mentioning he doesn’t like the way he speaks to her and she cries a lot.
We are piecing things together and keeping a watchful eye. I will discuss this with an older neighbour who has spoken to him.

Plumbuddle · 26/11/2021 09:10

@Darlingx

I think it’s more the case that it’s frustrating that you would be a good parent and that some lousy awful people that get to have children with ease and mistreat them. I think if you were involved in the services which help children fostering it would balance the world out a bit. I believe in the disadvantaged children having good parental role models . My father was hopeless and caused a lot of misery but I had a lovely Grandfather but he lived overseas. He taught me to ride a bike about the stars etc. Next door through the walls I can hear a man shouting get in the effing bath 3 times. He smokes drugs and has sole care of a 4/5 yr old who cries a lot. I think the mother died she smoked a lot of drugs whilst that baby was needing breastfeeding ?? I told her to her face to please stop smoking mainly because I was pregnant at the time and the drug fumes were throughout our flat . It was distressing me . I had a miscarriage she had a lovely healthy baby but choses her addiction over the health of that babies lungs. Now it has a father that shouts because raising a child solo is tough . It’s a hopeless situation . I would not get services involved because I don’t really know what the full story is and he gets up early gets her out of the house like clockwork she is well dressed fed etc but he swears shouts at times and sometimes the fumes of drugs drift in not as much as before. I suppose he is doing his best but it’s not ideal what in life ever is though. I am just glad that I haven’t bought a child into a life of tensions. I would not want the trauma on my hands but some people create human wreckage. You can love children as a whole as in children you can care for which is very rewarding . I vowed to never let a child down and I kept my promise . I expressed my need to nuture and it does fill that gap. I bump into them now they are at Uni and stop to speak to me which is lovely . I can see a mother cooing at her beautiful baby and enjoy the beauty of that moment without longing so badly . It is possible to make peace with it .
You vowed to never let a child down? You are letting the child next door down. Report this man so he can get help to stop damaging this child.
KisstheTeapot14 · 26/11/2021 09:09

@GeorgiaGirl52 That is such a sad story.

Poor woman, and poor children.