Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked at neighbour's false accusation

67 replies

Hdksla133 · 23/11/2021 08:49

My intuition has told me for years, that next door neighbour is not all he seems. My DP has had run-ins with him on and off. The latest escapade was when he decided to hire a skip. He was emptying stuff out of the skip and putting the rubbish by our back door. DP confronted him and said it wasn't him putting our stuff in the skip and the rubbish he was emptying didn't belong to us. So DP put the rubbish back in the skip. Neighbour took it out and literally said it was "tough shit" and chucked the stuff by our door again. A scuffle between them started which got physical, however DP walked away before the contact got serious and told him he wasn't worth it. I wasn't there and wasn't aware of this.

However last night DP let it slip that one week ago at 9pm, two police officers knocked on the door. They said they received an anonymous phone call regarding our two week old baby. At the time I was having a sleep upstairs before taking over 'shifts' with my DP (I do the night shift). They wanted to check the baby was being fed and was warm and they checked the house. DP was obviously more than obliging, as the baby couldn't be more looked after. The house was all warm and tidy and the baby was peacefully napping after feeding. It was obvious that the phone call was a malicious accusation made. It is also blaringly obvious it's the neighbour.

This has both shocked and upset me. It's one thing having a scuffle over some rubbish in the backyard, but to stoop so low to make a malicious accusatory phone call to the police accusing us of neglecting our newborn. Have felt numb ever since. It got me worrying where does someone like this stop. What will he do next... phone social services and falsely accuse me of harming my baby. Feel so stressed. I feel like contacting the community police and having my concerns documenting. Apparently DP got chatting to a bloke that lives a few doors up and he was saying how this neighbour has put nails in tyres in most of the cars on the road including his and he now has a camera up. DP had a nail recently in a car tyre, I have recently had one too. So I also have the safety of my car each time I get in it to worry about now.

OP posts:
LemonSwan · 23/11/2021 11:41

Its awful but the previous people would also have known.

They didnt declare to you. Why should you be the ones to loose a shit load of money and be stuck there.

Just keep your head down and move out.

ESGdance · 23/11/2021 11:39

I am so sorry that this has happened to you at this precious time.

You are emotionally very vulnerable here because you have just given birth and I would be aware that you are feeling raw and something like this could have a disproportionate impact (I suspect this is why your DH didn’t mention it immediately).

Concentrate on your emotional well-being and the positive stuff around your new born. Try to detach in your head from the stuff with this man.

It’s great that you are under offer - seems like as PP have said you currently don’t have to declare anything so I would have my eyes on the prize of moving on.

LittleGwyneth · 23/11/2021 11:24

I'm so glad that you are moving. This is absolutely horrible. There are some real nutters out there.

MakeMineAdoubleChocolate · 23/11/2021 11:24

A dear friend if mine is having an issue like this, her neighbour an older chap is retired and actually regularly creates problems. Even the kids walking, he calls the council to complain, goes through their shed and throws rubbish out of it onto the ground then goes knocking on the door to say can you please sort it out because I have just called the council to report it. He also went through their green bin and brought nappies out and threw them on the ground and then taped a note onto the communal notice board, please put your nappies in the bin. He also phoned social services and made horrid claims about my friend and her dh that they were abusing the kids, the house is filthy, kids are scruffy and the best one is they don't have car seats so all the children get thrown in a boot. I was literally gobsmacked. My friends dh went round to confront them by saying someone rang the house. They said well I didn't call social services. Basically dropped themselves in it. But he kept on denying and he was even pointing the finger at other neighbours and calling them names saying I bet it was she/him/that couple.

NOW they just ignore them completely and haven't seen him for months. I'm glad about that. But they still go into their bins and my friends back garden and have to keep putting stuff back that they touch. Can't wait for them to move. Sounds like a real nightmare next door programme

So sorry about your situation op, I'd get cameras to be honest with you. It's not acceptable at all

catsareme14 · 23/11/2021 11:18

I had this with my Neighbour too . Called 101 to get an incident number & start a 'Paper trail ' I would declare this in the unlikely event I want to move . Solicitors letter sent with a warning & cameras installed . All gone quiet now . Unpleasant but I refuse to be cowed by ignorant , entitled arseholes . ( I'm also a petty bitch who now parks right up against their house albeit in my space )

2bazookas · 23/11/2021 11:15

Harassment is a criminal offence and the good news is, the police already have a record of one of the incidents because they were suckered into it.

Now is the perfect time to make a formal complaint to them, tell them about the skip incident and seek their advice. Keep written records of any further incidents.

Mwanwhile, find out if the neighbour is a tenant of his home, because if so he is probably breaking a clause in his tenancy agreement forbidding any nuisance to neighbours. You can pursue that with his landlord.

Lambtales · 23/11/2021 11:12

Sounds like my neighbour who has form for dropping nails whenever someone has a tradesman round. He's a botch it and scarper type handy man and gets jealous when others don't use him for work.

Don't log it with the police as it's not worth getting it official in case you need to declare it when moving.

My neighbour has slashed tyres and thrown food waste into my garden. I put up cameras so that's stopped now, but he's sly so I never let my guard down around him.

I'm biding my time, as awful as it sounds his elderly mother is nearing the end of her time. Once she goes and he (late 50's never married) inherits he will spunk all the money on drugs and gambling and will eventually have to sell up.

SmallWaistFatFace · 23/11/2021 11:04

Log with police on 101 and get cameras. Things like this tend to escalate.

Ubiquery · 23/11/2021 11:00

"blaringly obvious" is an unusual phrase.

seethesuninwintertime · 23/11/2021 10:53

I've been there OP.

It's awful to think of something like this being on your paperwork isn't it, even if it has been identified as just malice?

Like you I worry about selling but also worry about staying.

In terms of the declaration, the ideal person to advise would be the sort of solicitor who actually does the suing in these situations. It's easy for people to say "you could get sued" but suing is actually very complicated - plus what are the damages if the antagonism is personal and directed at you?

nocnoc · 23/11/2021 10:42

@SheikhMaraca that is incorrect

nocnoc · 23/11/2021 10:42

Google when to declare disputes. I did. You do not have to declare any dispute unless it has been formally recorded eg a complaint to the police or council. Taken from a selling website

“ While what constitutes a dispute and what doesn't is left open to interpretation, there a few general rules that are useful to follow. If you have made a complaint to the council or another authority about the behaviour of your neighbours, or if you have contacted them directly in writing, then you are duty-bound to declare this on the SPIF form.”

So the answer is no and if anything comes back then everything else was resolved. You do not have to report anything that is not ongoing or hasn’t been reported.

SheikhMaraca · 23/11/2021 10:40

@Cherrysoup

Surely you can be sued if you don’t declare issues? So if another neighbour mentions a physical fight between your dh and this bloke, the new buyers would have recourse to sue? Please declare.
Yes, you can be, not just actual disputes, but things that might lead to a dispute in the future.
vera99 · 23/11/2021 10:38

I feel bad for you and the buyer that may end up buying your house. Before we made our final offer I knocked on both the neighbour's houses to just say I was thinking of buying. I was invited in by both for lovely chats and tea, Sounds like your nightmare neighbour wouldn't have passed the test.

Cherrysoup · 23/11/2021 10:36

Surely you can be sued if you don’t declare issues? So if another neighbour mentions a physical fight between your dh and this bloke, the new buyers would have recourse to sue? Please declare.

Rissole · 23/11/2021 10:18

@nocnoc

Unless you’ve got documented disputes then you don’t have to declare. Your house is under offer. Put up obvious cameras outside front and back. Night lights. Big signs saying CCTV is recording. It’s not directed at him just personal security but it makes it obvious that you are recording everything. See if you can get a sign that says trespassers will be reported to the police. Do nothing official. You’re under offer anyway. Can you put up fencing that stops him accessing your property. Spikes on top. Barrier your property.
Don't do this. Your prospective buyers will almost certainly do drive bys. This might put them off and they might withdraw. Just make a chuff chart and tick the days off until you leave.
lanthanum · 23/11/2021 10:12

A canny buyer might wonder why a vendor has suddenly bought a ring doorbell/camera/higher fences when they're about to move...

dontgobaconmyheart · 23/11/2021 10:01

I sympathise OP but also for the unaware buyer of your house, how awful for them. As someone who suffers anxiety that would finish me off moving in and working out the neighbour was as you describe and that I'd essentially been duped and would be stuck there.

Ultimately all you can actually do is pop a camera up (within legal remit) and report to the police. He can report you to whoever he likes but nothing is going to come of it since it is untrue and eventually he would be prosecuted if anyone would actually report him. Your DP should not have engaged in a fight in the street at all, I would be mortified.

nocnoc · 23/11/2021 10:01

Unless you’ve got documented disputes then you don’t have to declare. Your house is under offer. Put up obvious cameras outside front and back. Night lights. Big signs saying CCTV is recording. It’s not directed at him just personal security but it makes it obvious that you are recording everything. See if you can get a sign that says trespassers will be reported to the police. Do nothing official. You’re under offer anyway. Can you put up fencing that stops him accessing your property. Spikes on top. Barrier your property.

User57327259 · 23/11/2021 09:56

It is awful to have to move because of a nasty neighbour. Moving costs a lot of money and it is not easy to find a house that you like. I dont see why neighbours like this should be allowed to get away with this kind of persecution.
I had a similar experience as a young mum. I moved but I was unhappy about it. The person in question went onto make others have a miserable time. Why not put a stop to this kind of bullying

Mammy55 · 23/11/2021 09:55

I had a similar situation with false accusations to social services, from a person who I wouldn’t allow contact with my child. They hadn’t even met the child once, I called my health visitor and explained incase of any malicious calls so a note was added. And what I was doing to protect my children maybe you could try that but you need to get out ASAP

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 23/11/2021 09:55

Cameras everywhere, review the footage. Don't worry too much about the reports, if they are malicious it will be pretty obvious to the authorities and will actually be in your favour long term. The more they look into them and find the are baseless the better.

ancientgran · 23/11/2021 09:54

@Silvershroud

Do you think it a bit unfair that a buyer of your house will not know about the neighbour and may not be able to leave like you are doing? I would feel I have to warn them even at the cost of a lost sale.
I can't see why neighbour being annoyed because he thinks OPs husband put stuff in his skip would be a problem for new people. He's hardly going to blame them is he.

OP doesn't know who reported about the baby, she assumes it's him but it might not be.

Blinkingbatshit · 23/11/2021 09:51

Your dh is right, do not put anything in writing or on record re the dispute if you are selling!! Just stay calm in the knowledge you won’t be there forever.

JennieLee · 23/11/2021 09:48

I think child protection people are quite busy. There are loads of kids whose parents neglect them,/who have addiction or obvious mental health problems/learning difficulties or who come from severely dysfunctional backgrounds meaning they can't parent properly themselves. There may be other red flags in terms of health records etc

It will be very clear to social services when parents don't fall into those categories.

Sadly malicious calls of this kind will occur from time to time.

Swipe left for the next trending thread