Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unvaxxed dilemma

114 replies

TheRussianDoll · 22/11/2021 23:12

Having a small family get together for sons 21st. Surprise “do”. My friends and DH’s family all vaccinated and lots of boosters too. My family … quite a few anti vaxxers. I had absolutely no idea but now, DH wants me to stop them coming or, tell others that some at the gathering aren’t vaccinated.

I have told my family “no fax no invite” but it’s causing very bad feeling. My son has Aspergers so, it’s not a big “do” but I’ve put a lot of thought and love into the plan and now I feel very deflated. It’ll cut the guest list by half.

DH is 62. Has pulmonary sarcoidosis and diabetes and as a family unit, “we” have followed every rule going and still mask, even outside in crowded places.

What should I do?

OP posts:
RogueV · 23/11/2021 10:34

Your DH has pulmonary sarcoidosis
For that reason alone he is not being unreasonable

Trinity69 · 23/11/2021 10:33

I'm double jabbed and currently have COVID having caught it from an unvaccinated person. Being double jabbed decreases the transmission rate, therefore if all attending were double jabbed it would be much safer. LFT's are all well and good but I know I was exposed on the Tuesday but I still didn't get a positive LFT until the following Sunday and I passed it on to someone else who is immunocompromised on the Thursday after I was exposed. In summary, I think you're well within your rights to not invite the unvaccinated. It's too dangerous for your husband.

SomewhereEast · 23/11/2021 10:02

Also an unvaxxed person who has recently had a confirmed Covid infection is much safer than a vaxxed person who hasn't, statistically (reinfections are still not that common judging by PHE stats). And I'm saying that as someone who is fully vaxxed / very pro-vaccination. The vaccines are great, but the vaccination = magic anti-Covid forcefield some people are slipping into is actually quite dangerous. My home country has vaccine passports for most indoor things + the highest vaccination rate in western Europe and we're still having a big spike with significantly worse infection rates than the UK. There isn't a magic wand to make anything 100% Covid secure.

SomewhereEast · 23/11/2021 09:55

From a preventing an infection POV, you would be a million times better asking everyone (vaxxed or unvaxxed) to do a lateral flow in advance though? We all know by now that vaxxed people can catch and spread Covid to a significant degree. The primary utility of vaccination is to protect the person vaccinated from serious illness (and I think that will hold true even post-boosters, as they will no doubt wane). I'm vaxxed and wouldn't be at all offended if a CEV person made that request before a social event at their home.

Hadjab · 23/11/2021 09:54

Their vaccination status makes no difference - you can still catch and pass on the virus. What matters is whether or not anyone has the virus at the point of the meet up. Everyone should do a lateral flow test beforehand.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 23/11/2021 09:54

Stick to your 'no vaccine, no invite plan.'

@Seenoevil1

Perhaps your partner would like non vaxx-ed people to be branded or identified in some way...this situation where freedom of choice is under attack makes me feel very sad

I feel sad for the partners and families of people I know who have died due to COVID.

But if stupid people continue to die, I suppose that's Darwinian.

Anyone else heard of the Darwin Awards?

heldinadream · 23/11/2021 09:49

His life is very, very small.
And just as inherently valuable as anyone's. Wishing him a hugely happy birthday and a life full of peace and fulfilment. He doesn't have to live up to anyone else's (apparent) achievements, he has his own worth.

Any yes do whatever protects your guests, the last thing you want from this event is anyone vulnerable to catch covid - your DS would be upset if that happened apart from anything else. I'm so happy for you that you still have him. Flowers

As for the anti-vaxxers, I'm soooooooo fed up with their nonsense.

Onceuponatimethen · 23/11/2021 09:41

Really emotional

Onceuponatimethen · 23/11/2021 09:41

@TheRussianDoll how lovely that he has work and they cheered. I’ve got covid so really em my original and that has set me off again Flowers

NeverDropYourMoonCup · 23/11/2021 09:40

@Seenoevil1

Make them shower then walk through a bleach trough just like we did in public swimming pools in the 1970s Grin On a serious note I think it is wildly unreasonable not to invite some people in your family who have, for whatever reason, chosen not to have the vaccine. We are teetering on the brink of totalitarianism. Perhaps your partner would like non vaxx-ed people to be branded or identified in some way...this situation where freedom of choice is under attack makes me feel very sad. It reminds me of many occasions in history where groups were scapegoated and isolated in society.
I think that from the point of view where the guest of honour is so vulnerable, he's perfectly entitled to be as dictatorial as possible, seeing as it's his life that's at stake.

Or do you think that him and people with cancer should sacrifice themselves in order for you to feel happier about your decision not to be vaccinated?

TheRussianDoll · 23/11/2021 09:37

@MissHavershamReturns… thanks. I just want it to be a bit memorable for him. His life has been so bleak over the years. He’s just got a little job and the people at work have sent a lovely little video of them all cheering and wishing him a happy birthday. I want him to know, his life IS worth it and people care about him.

He takes a LOT of convincing!

@user1493494961… thank you 😊

OP posts:
user1493494961 · 23/11/2021 09:34

Wishing your DS a very happy 21st birthday, I hope you all have a lovely time.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 23/11/2021 09:27

I’m not sure people with the third jab carry it or pass it on though. It’s meant to stop transmission.

TheRussianDoll · 23/11/2021 09:27

@bluelavender… that’s a lovely idea. As I say, we are utilising the outside a bit, opening the French windows onto a gazebo and fire pit. No one will be hugging. They all know DS doesn’t do displays of affection. The four Yr old and 7yr old excepted.

OP posts:
Onceuponatimethen · 23/11/2021 09:26

Ah op you sound like such a lovely mum. My dd has asd and your reply just now brought tears to my eyes. I hope he has a really special day

TheRussianDoll · 23/11/2021 09:25

Good morning. Thanks for so many replies.

I’m thinking several things.

I understand that doing a LFT might be he way to go. We will be having an outdoor bit in the form of the gazebo and patio heater to stick on the back of our (small) house. Heat full on. Windows on. Not good for the planet but it’s for a few hours only. It starts at 5pm and it’ll all be over by 8pm. I know this because a 4yr and 7yr old are coming and they live two hours away and will need to get home. My pregnant niece will be there. She’s had one vaccination and following a miscarriage decided not to have a second. Her choice. She’s newly pregnant again. She is a social worker working with children and is in constant contact with people. As I say, it’s her choice.

My son tried to end his life in 2018. Then Covid. We, as a family want to celebrate his 21st. There’ll be no friends there. He doesn’t have any. His two PAs will attend, again just for a couple of hours. They’re taking him bowling at 2pm (his choice) so we can set up our little “surprise”. I don’t want to not mark the occasion. None of us know what’s ahead but, I’m just thankful he’s still here. I’ve organised “video celebrations” from others. Family who live down south. His 87 Yr old grandad. 92yr old great aunt etc. so they can be “part of it” without taking part.

Everyone, apart from the two PAs, will be close family. Have heard from a friend of mine last night saying she can’t come as she’s too worried for her own husband. I think another friend will also not actually come, as it’s a long way for them and they’re nervous (her adult son has an Crohns).

I take the point that we are all, vaxxed and non vaxxed, rubbing shoulders at work, in the street, in the supermarket etc. Vaxxed people can and do get it and pass it on. I think therefore, Lateral Flow Testing is best.

Sorry for the lengthy reply. I could scrap the whole thing but really, just want DS to know that 14 or so people, wanted to be with him, on a special birthday. He doesn’t do gifts (never has, since he was about 7 or so. Not at Xmas or birthdays. Very cheap to run!). He only goes out with his two PAs. His life is very, very small.

OP posts:
bluelavender · 23/11/2021 09:24

Could you hold your event outside in the garden? Gazebo, fire pits, twinkly lights/ hot chocolate/ hot toddies and perhaps fireworks?

And I've heard at some parties, there are badges; tinsel for people who do not wish to be hugged or have close contact with others

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/11/2021 09:22

On a serious note I think it is wildly unreasonable not to invite some people in your family who have, for whatever reason, chosen not to have the vaccine. We are teetering on the brink of totalitarianism. Perhaps your partner would like non vaxx-ed people to be branded or identified in some way...this situation where freedom of choice is under attack makes me feel very sad

Rubbish. It’s the opposite. We are all at perfect liberty to decide who we want in our homes.

BonnesVacances · 23/11/2021 09:19

Your DH is clinically vulnerable. Anyone who can't respect that and take appropriate precautions when spending time in his house doesn't come into the house. End of.

DD is CEV and I would be livid if anyone thought her health was worth playing Russian Roulette with. We ask everyone who comes round to do a LFT before coming and so far everyone has agreed that this is very important. I haven't asked any unvaccinated people to do that, so I don't know if they'd respond differently. But I don't know any openly unvaccinated people anyway.

They are also not allowed to come if they have colds, sniffles etc. This was before Covid. And for anyone who jumps on that and asks how she copes in the big wide world, she doesn't. She's been housebound for 6 years since she was 14.

Open windows and ventilation are key though OP. Even with all negative LFTs.

Sadiequeenofscots · 23/11/2021 09:09

On a serious note I think it is wildly unreasonable not to invite some people in your family who have, for whatever reason, chosen not to have the vaccine. We are teetering on the brink of totalitarianism. Perhaps your partner would like non vaxx-ed people to be branded or identified in some way...this situation where freedom of choice is under attack makes me feel very sad

Oh come on. It’s a small family gathering!

OP given your are being very careful in all other aspects of your life I don’t think this is unreasonable of your DH.

Of course it is sad that it has come to this but that is out of your control.

Of course you can’t control who is vaccinated when out and about but you can control who you spend time with for long periods in your home.

Yes those vaccinated can catch Covid and carry it but they are less likely to and less likely to pass it on also.

So do what you need to do to keep DH safe.

Chasingaftermidnight · 23/11/2021 09:08

Anyone who makes comments like this has no idea of what living in a totalitarian society is like. In a totalitarian society you would not be making comments like that, indeed you would not have an anonymous forum where you can write anything at all. I'd argue the system you appear to favour, someone not being allowed to determine who comes into their home or attends their event, is a more "totalitarian" way of running things that the idea the OP only wants to invite vaccinated people.

Exactly - the hyperbole is so boring. People get to choose who they invite to a private party at their home. Nothing could be further from totalitarianism.

Chasingaftermidnight · 23/11/2021 08:59

It’s your home. You and your DH don’t have to have anyone in your home that you don’t want to. People who don’t accept the vaccine must surely have realised that CEV people would probably want to keep their distance from them.

I certainly wouldn’t tell other guests at the party about their fellow guests’ vaccination status (I can’t see what that would achieve anyway) but if I had someone in the house as vulnerable as your DH I would stick to no vax, no invite.

nannybeach · 23/11/2021 08:57

Some sensible posts on here. I know quite a few people all vaccinated, some with serious health issues,and they automatically do a LF test before getting together. I asked my oldest DD to wash her hands,and boy was she sarcastic. The tests are round about 70% accurate. Hire a patio heater maybe if you have outside space. Cannot see there is any relevance in sons age. My DGKs have been invited to birthday parties, because of asthma, allergy health issues my DD has refused,under vax ages

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/11/2021 08:51

Pinkchocolate

I am double vaccinated and so not anti-vax but we cannot assume in any setting that everyone is double vaccinated“

Indeed but our own hone is the one place where we don’t need to assume.

HarrietsChariot · 23/11/2021 08:49

This vaccine does not stop transmission or you catching the virus. The jab only protects the vaccinated individual.

The vaccine reduces transmission. It reduces the chance of a person being infected. If they get infected, it reduces the chance of them being seriously ill. A person who has the virus but is not symptomatic is less likely to spread the disease because they are not coughing and projecting the virus. The jab protects others in this way, the more people who have the vaccine the fewer non-vaccinated people will get the virus.

We are teetering on the brink of totalitarianism. Perhaps your partner would like non vaxx-ed people to be branded or identified in some way...this situation where freedom of choice is under attack makes me feel very sad. It reminds me of many occasions in history where groups were scapegoated and isolated in society.

Anyone who makes comments like this has no idea of what living in a totalitarian society is like. In a totalitarian society you would not be making comments like that, indeed you would not have an anonymous forum where you can write anything at all. I'd argue the system you appear to favour, someone not being allowed to determine who comes into their home or attends their event, is a more "totalitarian" way of running things that the idea the OP only wants to invite vaccinated people.

Swipe left for the next trending thread