Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour seems to think he has the right to jump our fence

337 replies

Twatforaneighbour · 22/11/2021 20:24

We moved in about 3 years ago and put up a fence on top of an existing low height wall (which we own) across the front of our front garden which has a footpath the other side. We got planning to do this.

One of our neighbours had an issue with this, because his adult son (early 20s) liked to walk across our front garden and hop over our wall to save him from walking around. He put in a complaint when we went for planning saying that if the fence went up, we would need to make it safe as his son would be climbing over! The council made no comment on this.

This has made it inconvenient for him as it adds 5 mins walking time to walk down the road and up the public footpath. Since the fence went up, we clarified with the neighbour (the dad) that this was our property and our fence/wall, to make 100% sure there was no misunderstanding with who owns what, which he agreed.

We have now got video from our ring doorbell of "someone" walking across our garden and jumping the fence. It is unlikely to be anyone else as we are at the end if a small road.

What would you do? Trespassing is not a criminal offence. So far we cannot for sure identify the person as it was at night and not a great image.

They obviously see no issue with doing it so speaking to them wont help, Considered anti climb spikes but have seen you can be liable if trespasser gets injured on your property.
WIBU to get spikes if I put a warning with it?
Any suggestions? If he keeps doing it, it will end in damage to the fence and probably us paying for it Angry

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
ElephantOfRisk · 23/11/2021 12:33

The son is around 19 or 20ish so an adult, he jumps by getting his foot into the wall then levering himself over.

In order to do that does he need to get his toe under any gap on the fence or is the remaining bit of wall still wide enough for him to get his foot on? If the former find some way on closing off the gap so he can't get a decent toehold.

Just to add, I have boys aged 20 and 21 and doing this wouldn't even occur to them. You just walk round. This should have been stamped on when the lad was a kid by his parents.

ElephantOfRisk · 23/11/2021 12:30

It's a minefield OP, I think you are probably best sticking with things that one could reasonably expect to find along a fence/in a garden. So hanging baskets, wind chimes, maybe some bird feeders and since it's nearly christmas, strings of bells along the inside of the fence. And jaggy shrubs, wet mud, a rockery, a tree or whatever planted below.

Twatforaneighbour · 23/11/2021 12:29

@Santaischeckinglists

Big Bush.

Big parka.

And a loud speaker.
Ho fuck face - get off my garden....
Job done.

Love this!
OP posts:
Twatforaneighbour · 23/11/2021 12:29

The son is around 19 or 20ish so an adult, he jumps by getting his foot into the wall then levering himself over.

We've knocked and asked the dad who answered if we could speak to the son or if he could ask him to stop jumping as it will cause damage and just got a very vague nod and grunt.

I do wonder where we'd stand with cat spikes as they're not as lethal as some of the anti burglary spikes and are technically aimed at cats so may not need warning signs?? It would definitely make it harder to pull himself over.

In the meantime, I'll do the wet garden trench idea, I like that I can still grow things there and its good for the wildlife!

OP posts:
Twatforaneighbour · 23/11/2021 12:21

Thanks for all the great suggestions, some answers to the questions:

Its strange, Ive not seen him coming over from the footpath into our garden much, more from ours over to the footpath. Maybe because he can check we're not out there first that way around.

We could put a gate across the drive but it would make it really awkward to get our cars in and out and I think he'd climb it anyway.

I'd like to put some form of spikes across the top of the fence or the anti climb paint but I had a quick google and you can be liable if trespassers get hurt or their clothes damaged (unbelievably!). Apparently you need very visible warning signs or they can sue you. The family are so entitled, they probably would too.

OP posts:
ElftonWednesday · 23/11/2021 11:37

Trespassing isn't a criminal offence, but it is actionable in the civil courts.

As you've already told them not to do it verbally, the next step is to write a legal letter, or ask a solicitor to, and push it through their door, saying that you reserve your right to take further legal action to obtain and injunction or recover damages if they persist. Even if you have no intention of taking it further, it may just focus their minds enough to stop them.

2bazookas · 23/11/2021 11:27

You want some anti-climb paint. It never sets so will make a mess on the hands and trousers of anyone who touches it.

IamwhoIsayIam · 23/11/2021 11:27

@Cattenberg - you sound like you live in a lovely place where your neighbours are considerate and helpful toward each other.
Our back gardens are also unfenced and people frequently mow each other's lawns or put out each others bins.
My garden is the 'short cut' before I moved in I thought of ways to block it off and make people walk round but now I realise the benefit of being communal with our neighbours.
I guess we are very lucky!

DaisyNGO · 23/11/2021 11:16

That's a good idea.

I am baffled that trespass isn't a criminal offence.

DaisyNGO · 23/11/2021 11:16

@whitehorsesdonotlie

What a CF!! Amazing.

Could you climb his back fence and wander about in his back garden, see how he likes it?

Or do you have a gate that you could install over your front drive so he can't get into your garden?

That's a good idea.

I am baffled that trespass isn't a criminal offence.

Santaischeckinglists · 23/11/2021 11:00

Big Bush.

Big parka.

And a loud speaker.
Ho fuck face - get off my garden....
Job done.

AdobeWanKenobi · 23/11/2021 10:45

Those suggesting adding a gate further down the drive, do you not think if this guy has the brass neck to jump the fence he wont jump the gate as well?
😂
As for carpet gripper, I promise you that one wont end well legally should he be injured.

The best bet is proactive planting of spiky, fast growing bushes and see if you have a local PCSO to step in for you and speak to them.

coconuthead · 23/11/2021 10:28

We had almost this exact same scenario being the house at the end of the cul de sac and we got a ring camera with a loud alarm that we could set off if we saw him doing it. We also put pots all along the wall to make it harder for him and got a really, really bright security light with sensor. So far it has worked.

Peacocking · 23/11/2021 10:22

Cheap, easy and no fuss solution...cut some blackberry canes, tack the blackberry canes along the top of the fence. Nearly invisible, hurt very much and will rot away and fall off in time, by which time he will have learnt not to climb. Much less harmful than carpet track and free, and really not obvious. It could also be dismissed as a cat deterrent if it's ever raised.

whitehorsesdonotlie · 23/11/2021 10:17

What a CF!! Amazing.

Could you climb his back fence and wander about in his back garden, see how he likes it?

Or do you have a gate that you could install over your front drive so he can't get into your garden?

Loudestcat14 · 23/11/2021 10:10

Does he just come from the footpath over your fence to go home, OP, or is he leaving his house and taking the short-cut when he goes out as well? The reason I ask is earlier up the thread you said you didn't want visible anti-vandal/climb paint signs on the fence that you can see from your house – if he's just coming over it from the footpath, stick them on the side that faces out. You've done your legal obligation then.

faw2009 · 23/11/2021 10:00

I would smear something really greasy and gross to touch on top of the fence. Oil used on bike chains, peanut butter, something that looks like poo.

LindaEllen · 23/11/2021 09:44

@Cattenberg

I was on your side until I read that it takes the neighbour an extra five minutes to walk round. That adds up to a lot of wasted time. I’m not surprised he jumps the fence when he thinks you’re not looking.
Well I could get to the Co-Op quicker if I jumped over into the garden behind me and then through their side alley as it's on that road, rather than having to walk through the estate, but I don't do that..
Billybagpuss · 23/11/2021 09:33

Is there a way you can prevent access to your back garden completely gate across the drive etc?

londonrach · 23/11/2021 09:20

Looking at the diagram next door needs a door in their fence. Raise the fence higher. Next door is CF

Theteapotsbrokenspout · 23/11/2021 09:08

To make a flower bed you don't even need to dig it over, just use the no-dig method. Cover the area with a thick layer of cardboard, then a thick layer of (wet squelchy ) manure. Worms will do the work and next summer you will have a lovely bed to plant in.

Alleycat1 · 23/11/2021 08:57

Unless I have missed it nobody has commented on the insurance side of it. If C.F. Neighbour's son injured himself climbing the fence or crossing the garden then O P would probably be sued. CFNS would be trespassing but OP would still be liable because, as we all know, the law is an ass. So, OP must put a stop to it somehow.
Also, CFNS will eventually wear a path across the garden ruining the lawn, also set a precedent for other CFs to use the route none of whom would pay for repairs should the fence break.
SuggestOp applies to the court for an injunction.

user1471538283 · 23/11/2021 08:57

Well it is good news that your garden is by the fence! I would buy mature scrubs or something thorny (holly?) and plant it all along the fence.

For people questioning why the OP is cross, it is her land and her fence. She has told the neighbor to stop so he has to stop.

From your diagram he can jump his own fence onto the footpath.

I will never understand the entitlement of people.

DontTellThemYourNamePike · 23/11/2021 08:56

He's a lazy git. He shouldn't be trampling through your garden or climbing over your fence. If he had an illness which caused him difficulty with walking for an extra five minutes, I'd have some sympathy, but he must be physically fit if he can climb over your fence. I agree with suggestions that a motion detector sprinkler would be a good call.

And to those invoking the spirit of neighbourliness, how about HE behaves like a decent neighbour and stops using OP's garden as a convenient shortcut?

BewareTheBeardedDragon · 23/11/2021 08:24

But Colin he's not just cutting across a corner of an unfenced patch of lawn, he's climbing over 2m of fence that he doesn't own. Would you seriously be ok with that - if one of your neighbours decided they needed to climb over your high fence every day? I don't believe anyone would be. Jumping over a 2ft wall would be cheeky but climbing an actual fence taller than most people - that is something else.

No postie would climb a fence - it's really not comparable to cutting across where there's nothing in the way (by a person providing an actual public service)