Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Freezing schools

321 replies

Ineedapuppy · 22/11/2021 20:18

DD8 has cried this afternoon at how cold it is in her classroom with all the doors and windows open. Apparently she’s not allowed a blanket from home and the only response from school is to wear layers under uniform Hmm

AIBU to think that this is unkind? At work (large multi National company) staff would NOT work in these freezing conditions. How can it be fair to expect young kids to do it and if so, why make them wear flimsy uniforms?

OP posts:
Britneyb · 22/11/2021 23:35

I’m sending mine with some of those self warming heat pads and a large scarf to drape over their legs. Obviously we’ll layer up too.
As for what should be done… Anyone working in places like schools should be fully vaccinated if they can, open internal doors all the time and windows occasionally and then accept there’s a level of risk. As per usual this is exactly what other professions have had to do supermarket staff and dentists haven’t decided they can’t work without open windows and CO2 detectors. All this for an illness which mostly doesn’t affect children at all, as a PP said this is only happening because they can force the children into these conditions.

ThousandsOfTulips · 22/11/2021 23:34

@GreenLakes

Personally I am vehemently anti lockdown, restrictions and especially school closures. I think it was a huge mistake to close schools.

However, I do think we should be using common sense measures like ventilation and hand washing to help get through the winter period.

Having windows open in a classroom is a common sense measure at this time.

Ventilation that reduces the risk of infection doesn't require classrooms to have doors and windows wide open and children freezing all day. It's about air circulation. Windows open a small amount - with an adequate increase in heating to compensate and keep the temperature stable at an acceptable level - would work perfectly fine.
Starlightstarbright1 · 22/11/2021 23:33

I have a secondaty school child it is a challenge to get him to wear a coat 🙄

Mistressiggi · 22/11/2021 23:31

@OwlIceCrem

It’s bullshit. I’ve got rid of my CO2 monitor. I can’t teach and kids can’t learn in those conditions. If it’s a choice between pneumonia and COVID I’ll choose COVID- I’ve been vaccinated against that.
Do you get to make that decision for yourself? Can you overrule whatever health and safety policy is in place? Pretty sure that is a false dilemma by the way Smile
GreenLakes · 22/11/2021 23:29

Personally I am vehemently anti lockdown, restrictions and especially school closures. I think it was a huge mistake to close schools.

However, I do think we should be using common sense measures like ventilation and hand washing to help get through the winter period.

Having windows open in a classroom is a common sense measure at this time.

ThousandsOfTulips · 22/11/2021 23:29

Right. So all of their parents should give up the jobs which pay the taxes to have schools and teachers in the first place?

Mistressiggi · 22/11/2021 23:27

@Thatsplentyjack

It's an absolute joke. Children should not be expected to sit in freezing cold classrooms all day. Nowhere else is doing this but once again children are bottom of the pile and expected yo just suck it up.
Well quite. Maybe they should all be working/learning from home where it can be nice and warm.
ThousandsOfTulips · 22/11/2021 23:27

Ok. I will try that. Thank you.

noblegiraffe · 22/11/2021 23:26

If you email them and ask for your complaint to be passed to the Secretary of State for Education, you should get a response from the DfE.

ThousandsOfTulips · 22/11/2021 23:25

@noblegiraffe

How fucking dare they let these little kids be freezing all day long?

Well exactly. It’s not a barrel of fun for teachers either, tbh and I don’t think adults in offices would put up with it.

Like I said upthread, email your MP and ask why windows are open instead of CO2 monitors and air cleaners to identify ventilation issues and fix them.

And then email them again about school funding.

The government won’t listen to teachers, it needs to be parents kicking up a fuss if there’s any hope of change.

I kick up a fuss about certain things to my MP. Unfortunately she is a Boris Bot, ignores my letters and has blocked me on social media for asking "annoying questions".
noblegiraffe · 22/11/2021 23:24

Do you not realise that teachers/schools can do no wrong on mumsnet?

You must be on a different Mumsnet…

ThousandsOfTulips · 22/11/2021 23:24

Hahaa @Peas252 sorry, I must have missed the memo! My bad. Grin

noblegiraffe · 22/11/2021 23:23

How fucking dare they let these little kids be freezing all day long?

Well exactly. It’s not a barrel of fun for teachers either, tbh and I don’t think adults in offices would put up with it.

Like I said upthread, email your MP and ask why windows are open instead of CO2 monitors and air cleaners to identify ventilation issues and fix them.

And then email them again about school funding.

The government won’t listen to teachers, it needs to be parents kicking up a fuss if there’s any hope of change.

Peas252 · 22/11/2021 23:22

@ThousandsOfTulips

And to be clear *@noblegiraffe* I am furious at the state of school funding, SEN provision, class sizes etc in general. I do agree with most things I see you post. I just feel that when it comes to providing even a warm room for the children to be in and we're now told that's too much to expect... well, my rage goes off the charts. How fucking dare they let these little kids be freezing all day long? While also policing what they can and cannot wear? It's so far beyond unacceptable, it's disgraceful.
Do you not realise that teachers/schools can do no wrong on mumsnet? It's always someone else's fault.
ThousandsOfTulips · 22/11/2021 23:22

@Peas252

How can hospital wards continue operating with the windows closed, but classrooms can't?

Something to do with wearing masks maybe?

Unlikely. If you look at the statistical reduction in transmission from mask wearing in closed environments like this, it is small.

Ventilation makes a big difference but it does not require all doors and windows wide open. Just a small amount to allow air circulation.

The pertinent questions would be why are hospitals NOT opening windows a little to allow ventilation?

And why are schools letting kids freeze rather than providing the small amount of airflow to optimally balance reducing the risk of transmission while also keeping the room heated to an acceptable temperature of 20 celsius +

Answers on a postcard!

ThousandsOfTulips · 22/11/2021 23:18

And to be clear @noblegiraffe I am furious at the state of school funding, SEN provision, class sizes etc in general. I do agree with most things I see you post. I just feel that when it comes to providing even a warm room for the children to be in and we're now told that's too much to expect... well, my rage goes off the charts. How fucking dare they let these little kids be freezing all day long? While also policing what they can and cannot wear? It's so far beyond unacceptable, it's disgraceful.

Peas252 · 22/11/2021 23:17

How can hospital wards continue operating with the windows closed, but classrooms can't?

Something to do with wearing masks maybe?

ThousandsOfTulips · 22/11/2021 23:11

@CheshireChat

noblegiraffe I reckon it's because the cold is a lot easier to fix. Not that you don't have a point about everything else obviously.

One of the things I remember most (in a bad way) from my childhood is the cold. I still can't cope with being cold even now.

Same. I will never forget being cold for weeks on end with no respite, sleeping in my coat, dreading getting out of bed in the morning.

No child should have to go through being cold like that at school in 2021.

ssd · 22/11/2021 23:09

Poor wee buggers

ThousandsOfTulips · 22/11/2021 23:09

@noblegiraffe

Because being warm enough to concentrate is a percondition of a child being able to learn before any of the other stuff even comes into play.

Indeed, but that doesn’t mean that the other stuff is ok and parents should let it slide, does it?

There’s a thread at the moment where a parent pissed off that her kid doesn’t have a qualified teacher has people queuing up to tell her it’s just fine.

Threads about lack of school funding or similar get tumbleweeds.

Parents should be this angry about the state of schools, all of it, not just the bits that are cold.

I agree with you. I think all of that is appalling.

BUT a warm school environment is a very basic foundation upon which all of that needs to be built, otherwise the rest will be a waste of time for most children even if it was really good quality.

This really is now at the basic level of "is this a safe environment to leave my child in?". Which is shameful. That isn't to say that the "why isn't a decent standard of education being funded?" questions aren't valid. And important. Just that letting children freeze all day long is a new low, that makes all other efforts pointless.

CheshireChat · 22/11/2021 23:03

noblegiraffe I reckon it's because the cold is a lot easier to fix. Not that you don't have a point about everything else obviously.

One of the things I remember most (in a bad way) from my childhood is the cold. I still can't cope with being cold even now.

noblegiraffe · 22/11/2021 23:01

Because being warm enough to concentrate is a percondition of a child being able to learn before any of the other stuff even comes into play.

Indeed, but that doesn’t mean that the other stuff is ok and parents should let it slide, does it?

There’s a thread at the moment where a parent pissed off that her kid doesn’t have a qualified teacher has people queuing up to tell her it’s just fine.

Threads about lack of school funding or similar get tumbleweeds.

Parents should be this angry about the state of schools, all of it, not just the bits that are cold.

KatherineofGaunt · 22/11/2021 23:01

@Mantlemoose I assume it was voluntary though - school isn't voluntary

Cathedral choristers attend the cathedral school and rehearsals and services as part of their education. So for them, being at the cathedral is mandatory!

Teacher here. Classrooms generally colder in the mornings as teachers keep their outside doors open for children to arrive, but the rest of the time doors are closed and windows are open a little for air. All doors in the corridors leading you the playground are open all the time. Pupils are able to wear coats, hats, gloves or whatever but they're generally not required. My office is freezing but that's because the building is old and it's single-glazed and draughty and the radiators are rubbish! I keep spare socks and a coat in there at all times in case I feel particularly chilly.

No CO2 monitors, though, that I've seen, so no idea what the levels are in classrooms.

Thatsplentyjack · 22/11/2021 22:57

It's an absolute joke. Children should not be expected to sit in freezing cold classrooms all day. Nowhere else is doing this but once again children are bottom of the pile and expected yo just suck it up.

ThousandsOfTulips · 22/11/2021 22:56

@Hellolittlestar

I’m getting rather enraged to some of these answers. “Dress her warmly”, it’s the bloody School uniform rule that should be dismissed for this time. And I’m laughing at comparison with Scandinavian outdoor nurseries, have you seen what they are wearing? In the winter people wear down jackets and snowsuits and all that, not a polo shirt and a flimsy cardigan with an extra layer underneath.
Indeed. Hardly comparable to a polo shirt and polyester jumper with a thermal vest.

And for many of the parents who struggle, where are they meant to get money now for thermal undergarments?