Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for a warm cruelty free parka

60 replies

Teaandlipstick · 22/11/2021 15:07

Writing here for traffic. Please suggest me a warm no animal parka. I would prefer knee length, slim fit. I am also short with 159 cm, so if you are around my height, do you have recommendations for brands or models you prefer?

Thank you so much in advance. I spent hours looking online. My budget is about £300.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WaltzingBetty · 25/11/2021 00:16

[quote EerieSilence]@Teaandlipstick - I have an issue with people who will proudly wear something that's cruelty free but don't care about where it came from.
I don't have an issue with vegans per se. I have an issue with their hypocrisy that's so obvious whenever you talk to them. They don't care about the welfare of the people. They're happy to buy products which were produced by people working in bad conditions as long as they're not animal based.
So let's be precise - vegans don't want cruelty free products. They want non-animal based products. There's a difference.[/quote]
@EerieSilence

Could you answer my questions and share your knowledge then please ?

For someone that 'doesn't have an issue with vegans per se' you've criticised them on every post you've made, made assumptions about all of them as if they're a homogeneous population and provided no constructive advice or recommendations to help any of us make better choices

Do you actually have any ethical recommendations that you could constructively share? Or are you just here to criticise the ethical principles of others whilst doing nothing to actually support the issues you're criticising others for not caring about?

KeflavikAirport · 24/11/2021 17:05

I have to say I'd have concerns about how animal-friendly synthetic alternatives are in terms of production. There are so-called ethical down producers out there but IDK if they make coats. Vintage is probably the most ethical alternative, as someone pointed out.

Mercurial123 · 24/11/2021 16:39

They don't care about the welfare of the people. They're happy to buy products which were produced by people working in bad conditions as long as they're not animal based.
So let's be precise - vegans don't want cruelty free products. They want non-animal based products. There's a difference.

You've spoken to every vegan that might have taken quite some time? In reality you are basing your "research" on probably one or two people.

EerieSilence · 24/11/2021 15:38

@Teaandlipstick - I have an issue with people who will proudly wear something that's cruelty free but don't care about where it came from.
I don't have an issue with vegans per se. I have an issue with their hypocrisy that's so obvious whenever you talk to them. They don't care about the welfare of the people. They're happy to buy products which were produced by people working in bad conditions as long as they're not animal based.
So let's be precise - vegans don't want cruelty free products. They want non-animal based products. There's a difference.

WaltzingBetty · 24/11/2021 05:01

[quote EerieSilence]@WaltzingBetty - Aigle's manufacturing is in France. Fjallraven e.g. is in China.
If I were after a completely cruelty free clothing, I would go for one made locally from non-animal fibres.

I really love how vegans are bothered that ducks get their throats slit to be eaten and their feathers are used for making jackets but have absolutely no problem with wearing clothes made by workers who often work 7 days a week, with barely any break and women are frequently sexually abused by the bosses. But that's fine, because no animal suffered in the process.[/quote]
@EerieSilence
Could you recommend some please?
It would be great to have brand recommendations that meet ethical principles that you mention. I've recently stopped buying from h and m etc because of their use of forced labour in China. You're clearly passionate so I assume you have constructive suggestions from your own purchases? If you could actually share them that would be helpful.

I think in general sharing information is more helpful than blanket assumptions that vegans are fine with workers being sexually assaulted. It is entirely possible to care about more than one thing at a time and I don't think criticising others based on inaccurate assumptions is the best way of engaging people in these issues, assuming your focus really is on encouraging ethical purchases rather than just slagging off vegans.

givethatbabyaname · 24/11/2021 02:11

How warm do you need it to be?

tallduckandhandsome · 24/11/2021 00:06

Do your knees not get cold? Grin

At that price I would want the coat to shin length Wink

Teaandlipstick · 23/11/2021 23:29

@noedica, thank you. It's quite nice. I love Seasalt.

@TheBitterBoy, this is exactly the look I like, sadly it has fur collar. Would ask the company if it is from recycle material. It is a fab coat. Thank you!

Thank you all. I have a good list of labels to research from. Really appreciate your help :)

OP posts:
TheBitterBoy · 23/11/2021 23:09

Joules Cherington cost is lovely www.joules.com/Women/Clothing/Cherington/Showerproof-Longline-Padded-Coat?size=10&id=214361|MARNAVY|10

nordica · 23/11/2021 23:04

I love my Seasalt Plant Hunter coat and it's good for rainy days too. Knee length on me, I'm 5ft3. Seasalt is an ethical company and their coats last for years so are very good from a sustainable perspective.

Teaandlipstick · 23/11/2021 23:00

@DukkaDukka, @cadburyegg, Thank you for suggesting Superdry. These parkas look great Smile

OP posts:
Teaandlipstick · 23/11/2021 22:58

@GrrrlPwr Cruelty to helpless animals I meant but I also care for human welfare and environment sustainability. I agree it's very hard to find a product ticking all the boxes.

OP posts:
Teaandlipstick · 23/11/2021 22:54

@Teaandlipstick, i.e. you only apply the cruelty brand to animals but don't give a damn about how the workers are treated in the factory where it was produced? In that case you have a very wide range of products.

Aigle's manufacturing is in France. Fjallraven e.g. is in China.
If I were after a completely cruelty free clothing, I would go for one made locally from non-animal fibres.
I really love how vegans are bothered that ducks get their throats slit to be eaten and their feathers are used for making jackets but have absolutely no problem with wearing clothes made by workers who often work 7 days a week, with barely any break and women are frequently sexually abused by the bosses. But that's fine, because no animal suffered in the process.

@EerieSilence, I don't get your last 2 angry posts. I didn't say I don't care for employee welfare, and at least wait for me to respond to one accusatory post before you launch another.

Most parkas use down feathers, so I wanted to specify that I don't want animal product, is there a problem with that? Usually the brands which care for 'bottom of hierarchy' helpless animals, also care for human welfare, so how did you jump to conclusion that I am ok with workers being sexually assaulted?
You seem to have some issue with vegans, which some meat consuming posters on mumsnet do and hence reacting on 'cruelty free'. I don't want any living being killed for my jacket but I am not asking you to choose a product based on my values, and I don't need you to tell me what I should care for.

Also, if you care so much about employees rights, I am hoping you don't buy from average high street brands. Not every employer in China is horrible, and unless you are using any electronics, you should not be telling people buying a jacket made in China is worse than one made in France. People work for bad employers because they have no other options and you suggesting people choose a French manufacturer over China is NOT caring for desperate workers willing to work in poor conditions.

OP posts:
KittyDee · 23/11/2021 21:41

I got a nice wax cotton parka from whistles last year - think it might be out of stock now but this looks like the latest model:

www.johnlewis.com/whistles-gracie-faux-fur-trim-hooded-coat-black/p5746030

I’m size 10 and 5ft 3 and size small fits me with room for thick jumper underneath. It has drawstrings to pull waist tighter and is quite flattering as not bulky, but is warm.

Nairobiblue · 23/11/2021 20:26

This one is Vegan and really warm.

www.hunterboots.com/gb/en_gb/womens-jackets/womens-insulated-rubberised-long-puffer-coat/black/6212

HPandTheNeverEndingBedtime · 23/11/2021 19:32

I bought Dd the Superdry everest coat, it comes in a range of lengths and is lovely and warm. With recycled bottles making the filling the coat itself seems very ethical no idea about the company though. If you buy from surfdome it was on sale for £91 instead of £130

GrrrlPwr · 23/11/2021 19:24

Cruelty to whom?
Creatures in the down industry. Or humans in the textiles industry?
Or the planet for using more polyester?

B corp companies are probably the only ones ethical. Don't know if any sell coats.

HarlanPepper · 23/11/2021 15:56

[quote EerieSilence]@Teaandlipstick, i.e. you only apply the cruelty brand to animals but don't give a damn about how the workers are treated in the factory where it was produced? In that case you have a very wide range of products.[/quote]
Is it possible, I wonder, to care about... both? Or does that not serve your argument?

WhatAWasteOfOranges · 23/11/2021 15:52

Patagonia

Remytherat · 23/11/2021 13:52

Pressed post too soon Blush

All choices are causing suffering somewhere, including "cruelty free" and most ethical brands. There's always a conpromise. The best choice you can make is to buy something that you love and will wear until the end of its life. There's no point buying something ethical only to wear it for a year or two then buy another one.

Remytherat · 23/11/2021 13:43

Patagonia do down coats made with recycled down, and they're fairly made too.

Cruelty free just depends where you're happy for the cruelty to begin, really.
Synthetic down, unless recycled, is made from petrochemicals that have probably killed/caused suffering for far more animals through loss of habitat and toxic byproducts.

And like a pp said, what about cruelty to the humans who make the coat, too.

EerieSilence · 23/11/2021 13:22

@WaltzingBetty - Aigle's manufacturing is in France. Fjallraven e.g. is in China.
If I were after a completely cruelty free clothing, I would go for one made locally from non-animal fibres.

I really love how vegans are bothered that ducks get their throats slit to be eaten and their feathers are used for making jackets but have absolutely no problem with wearing clothes made by workers who often work 7 days a week, with barely any break and women are frequently sexually abused by the bosses. But that's fine, because no animal suffered in the process.

HappyToPayForAdultSocialCare · 23/11/2021 12:45

@Teaandlipstick

Thank you all Smile Will check these labels. Has anyone tried Save the duck jackets?
I have a Save the Duck coat. Warmest coat I've ever get had and fits beautifully
Mercurial123 · 23/11/2021 12:05

66 North seem to be ok with employee welfare

www.66north.com/uk/circular/people-places