Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the hotel is in the wrong?

317 replies

MiddayMass · 22/11/2021 14:31

My sister and her husband had their 10 year anniversary party at a local hotel yesterday. They had a free bar on them, £1500 tab.

Dsis was suspicious over some things as tab was sucked dry very quickly and she’d seen people at the bar and yet not with a drink at the table, so she asked for a receipt of everything ordered throughout the night.

It’s turns out somebody (or several people) were buying full bottles directly from the bar. Not just wines but spirits, one cheeky fucker bought an entire bottle of Remy Martin. Others only got chance to have a lime and soda or a coke on the tab before it was sucked up. A few late-arrivals got fuck-all.

Me and Dsis both suspect who the culprits are but we can’t really prove it.

Dsis has spoken to the manager who confirmed that people were buying bottles on the tab (this amazes me, surely it breaks some kind of licensing law) and that they did not see it as a problem as Dsis and her husband never specified that they wanted it limited. Dsis feels it was a given. We’ve also heard from a family friend that one of the bar staff was telling people “You can buy the bottle if you’d like?” when they ordered the same spirit more than once. We feel it was an obvious attempt to suck the tab dry quickly to get people buying drinks again. The bar staff looked barely 18 so I imagine the manager had told them to upsell bottles.

Whilst people were cheeky fuckers, AIBU to think the hotel was in the wrong?

OP posts:
SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 22/11/2021 19:59

To clarify what I meant above if a group ordered 10 double vodkas, instead of putting through 20 shots, many "old school" hotel managers push staff to put this through as a bottle which is 28 shots to account for "wastage". Especially if they don't think the bill will be scrutinized

katem22 · 22/11/2021 19:59

While I do think the hotel should have gone over the terms of what would be offered, the same applies vice versa. No-one on either side thought to specify, so you can't blame the hotel entirely for simply selling what was on offer.
The blame mostly lies with the guests who took the piss. I'd definitely be having a rethink about inviting the 'suspects' to any future events!

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 22/11/2021 19:55

Former events manager at a hotel here.

In UK you can sell bottles of spirits providing you check that the bottle is for a number of people rather than an individual.
We had people at loads of events who would want bottles of spirits on tables with mixers.

Was the tab setup ahead of the event with the events team or was it on the night?
The events team should have checked if there was any restrictions on the bar tab. It's part of basic training in this role. The operations team could have been made up of the F&B manager and floor/bar staff who, typically, follow orders from the BEO (events handover sheet), so if there were no restrictions identified on there, they wouldn't questions it as they would assume it had been discussed with the events team in advance and, tbh, would fear a complaint if they went against the sheet.

If the tab was setup on the night, was it setup with a manager who was running the event? If not, a duty manager could be any of the hotel managers, including a housekeeping supervisor or manager who wouldn't necessarily know to ask about restrictions. If it was the manager running the event, they should have asked but again, if they are inexperienced, they might not realise they need to ask. Many would assume the organisers would flag if there was something they didn't want on the tab.

Now, OP, I would genuinely question if everything on the tab was actually consumed in that way. I've had some terrible managers who used to tell us to always add extra pints to a bar tab (to cover "wastage") and if several people were buying the same spirit, ie a group ordered a round of double vodkas, they may have put it through the till as a bottle. It's awful but this does happen.

The problem is, there is no way to really know if this happened unless your sis raises a proper complaint with the hotel and asks them to investigate. Even then, the hotel will cover their own back as much as they can, but she may get some compensation if the above is true.

Thehop · 22/11/2021 19:54

@BorsetshireBanality

It smacks of "sharp-practice".

Is this hotel very local to them - they need to shame it on social media!

I agree, I’d be writing a review on their Facebook page and sharing on other SM.
Cherrysoup · 22/11/2021 19:51

I wouldn’t have thought to specify no full bottles because I can’t imagine any normal bar allowing it or my mates/family being such cfs as to do that! Utter arseholes.

Abraxan · 22/11/2021 19:48

@ANameChangeAgain

I like the idea of an email to all guests, just checking if anyone could confirm the hotel had definitely given them expensive bottles of wine or spirits, stating that you're concerned the hotel is trying to pull the wool over your eyes. absolutely do this. People will soon tell tales if no one owns up.
I suspect no one would own up and the OP's family member wouldn't find anything out. But part of me just likes the idea of making the person who ordered the expos-naive bottle squirm a bit. I know that in reality it's probably better to just chalk it up as one of those things and do nothing.
BeaLola · 22/11/2021 19:48

I like the idea of an email to all guests, just checking if anyone could confirm the hotel had definitely given them expensive bottles of wine or spirits, stating that you're concerned the hotel is trying to pull the wool over your eyes. absolutely do this. People will soon tell tales if no one owns up.

I agree with this. Who buys a whole bottle of brandy at a do ??? I guess they wont be inviting the same people to their 20th anniversary party

ITSSSSCHRISTMASSS · 22/11/2021 19:46

All these people saying the bar staff are not to blame, seriously! The hotel should have set the rules with DSis and BIL at the time, they are the ones who do this regularly as part of their jobs. The bar staff were also actively encouraging people to buy bottles. I agree it sounds like they were trying to run the tab dry quickly. Any decent bar manager would have raised the issue of bottles being taken as soon as it happened. Had they done this, then DSis could have addressed and guests being CFs at the time.

ANameChangeAgain · 22/11/2021 19:46

I like the idea of an email to all guests, just checking if anyone could confirm the hotel had definitely given them expensive bottles of wine or spirits, stating that you're concerned the hotel is trying to pull the wool over your eyes. absolutely do this. People will soon tell tales if no one owns up.

ANameChangeAgain · 22/11/2021 19:42

I think its 50/50. The guests buying bottles of spirts were being absolute shits, but as an everyday person you not expect them to do this. The bar staff were technically not wrong to serve what they asked, but manager would have seen it all before in terms of shitty behaviour, and should have gone through or suggested rules.
I remember a charity bring a bottle party we attended. The host put out a few crates of wines and beers to ensure there was plenty, but was disappointed that some of the guest were helping themselves to take homes, and hiding bottles under their tables!

Smorgasborb · 22/11/2021 19:38

@whynotwhatknot

so even though in the op it says shes been told it was the hotel asking do you want the bottle instead of a single its stil the sil fault?

sorry but the hotel were taking the piss out of them trying to get more sales

I doubt this very much. Hotel Bar staff don't give a shit how many drinks they sell. They would never see that extra income given they aren't given a profit share nor are they paid by how many drinks are sold that night. They have no skin in the game on selling more drinks.

What is most likely is the bar tab payers failed to set conditions on drinks that were included and there were some inexperienced minimum wage bar staff or they have previously experienced 'anything goes' type tabs and in the absence of instructions thought they were being helpful. I've been to many corporate hotel events where the drink types were unlimited, particularly when there are clients there, and getting a bottle of bubbles to play 'host' with your group Is totally fine.

I think it's down the bill payer to be clear about restrictions. Seriously who sets up a bar tab and doesn't think to themselves ' what if someone mainlines the Dom Perignon in the first half hour.. I'd better set some conditions'. Most people are indeed sensible and courteous with a tab but do you seriously think that everyone will queue nicely and choose only the reasonably priced drinks to sip over a couple of hours when they are probably already a bit tipsy from the meal?

One only has to see behaviour at buffets to realise that some humans are just grabby fuckers and they have to be legislated for.

I once shouted a dinner for my team and we met at the restaurant bar half an hour before we sat down. I told the bar staff to add the drinks to the bill. A couple of the younger team members kept leaving the table together while we were eating which I thought was odd. It turned out they were going up to the bar and doing more and more expensive shots every 20 minutes. It added £500 on the bill! Was it the bar staffs fault? Absolutely not!

Abraxan · 22/11/2021 19:38

@CrimbleCrumble1

I’ve never, ever heard of anyone ordering a bottle before. What an absolute CF.
I've seen people order bottles of wine - shared with a group it'd be cheaper than individually glasses overall usually. And only when it's been pre-agreed.

However, not bottles of spirits, especially not vintage or top end ones.

But bottles of anything should definitely be checked with the tab holder and not be an expectation. And even then, say if wine was allowed, just a normal amount not a very expensive or vintage type. And not champagne unless pre-agreed.

It's like everything - most people are sensible and fair and don't take advantage. But you always get a significant minority who will take advantage of any situation.

I like the idea of an email to all guests, just checking if anyone could confirm the hotel had definitely given them expensive bottles of wine or spirits, stating that you're concerned the hotel is trying to pull the wool over your eyes.

supremelybaffled · 22/11/2021 19:36

What price was charged for the bottles of spirits? They didn't charge by the tot and round it up to the total number of tots in the bottle, did they?

Offmyfence · 22/11/2021 19:31

@BorsetshireBanality

It smacks of "sharp-practice".

Is this hotel very local to them - they need to shame it on social media!

Agreed
BorsetshireBanality · 22/11/2021 19:29

It smacks of "sharp-practice".

Is this hotel very local to them - they need to shame it on social media!

Offmyfence · 22/11/2021 19:29

I would've expected when they booked the hotel, that the hotel would've asked probing questions like. ...

Do you want to restrict to single measures for spirits

Do you want to allow shots

Do you want to allow champagne

IMO the hotel are hugely unprofessional and should know and warn the paying person the potential pitfalls.

As for encouraging bottles....

They've been massively unprofessional IMO.

LadyEloise1 · 22/11/2021 19:28

The person who you suspect of taking the bottle of Remy Martin home- are they a friend, a relative or an in law ?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 22/11/2021 19:26

When a customer orders a measurable drink — one that isn’t available in a set volume (a bottle of beer, for example) — and doesn’t specify a volume, they should be made aware of all serving volumes, including smaller amounts, either by being told verbally or directed towards a list or menu.

So if somebody asks for 'a whisky' and the bar staff tell them that it's available by the bottle, are they not technically doing this?

I'm not saying they shouldn't have tailored what they told customers based on it being a pre-paid bar, but lots of places will advertise or tell you that it might work out 'better value' for you to buy the whole bottle. If most of their events are customers each paying for themselves, this may already be an ingrained upselling technique for them, just like when the assistants in WH Smith try to sell you a bar of chocolate or bottle of water along with whatever you're buying.

justaftb · 22/11/2021 19:25

Both are to blame, but really, what kind of people go to their friends'/family's party and shaft them by ordering full bottles of spirits and taking them away? How would that ever cross your mind? When I've been to a party where the hosts were picking up the drinks tab, it's made me more aware of what I am drinking as I don't want to take advantage.

KenAdams · 22/11/2021 19:24

Open bars are common in my culture.

However, the bridal party always set parameters beforehand. They can be, for example:

  • a "bar menu" of included drinks
  • house wine, beer, single spirits with mixers, no shots, doubles or bottles permitted
  • a drinks pass for immediate family or list of names provided to the bar of those who can order whatever they want then drinks vouchers for everyone else
  • agree a flat corkage charge with the venue and provide your own drinks. No bottle rule still applies.

However, people there are used to how open bars work now so don't tend to take the piss (the piss takers are usually identified at earlier events and not invited to subsequent events...).

You don't know what the situation was. If the bar staff said "oh you might as well just take the bottle" to someone who was ordering a round who was unfamiliar with open bars, they might have thought that was how it worked.

Did the guests know there was a tab or did they just assume it was an unlimited open bar?

Expensive lesson for your sister but I think everyone was in the wrong slightly.

I'd definitely be following this up with the hotel though. The idea to ask guests if anyone had ordered bottles because there was an issue with the bar tab is a good one, just in case the venue are pulling a fast one. If anyone owns up, you'd get clarity on how the situation of them walking away with a bottle came to be.

theremustonlybeone · 22/11/2021 19:17

i find it shocking that folks would order bottles, does seem rather odd to me. At a recent wedding the bride and groom had to go to he bar to inform the staff they had put 1500 on a tab so guests could have a drink on them. Not one person went off and ordered large bottles of spirits etc.

Whoever has done that are shit bags

Doubleraspberry · 22/11/2021 19:12

How is it 'part of the job' to advise you to buy less from them? Is it part of Tesco's job to tell every customer presenting a 'Finest' item at the till that they could swap it for a 'Value' one instead and pay much less?

The Licencing Act obliges bar staff to ensure that a customer ordering a drink is aware of the smaller measures available. All recent revisions to the law are designed to minimise consumption and encourage people to drink more responsibly, so the actions of the bar staff at this event were directly the opposite of that.

See this explanation:

Provision of smaller measures

Providing smaller measures of alcohol can play an important part in making sure your customers can keep their consumption to a minimum, should they wish. According to guidance, the licensee or designated supervisor must make sure that there are smaller measures available for the following:

Beer or cider: Half-pint glasses
Gin, rum, vodka, or whisky: 25ml or 35 ml measures
Still wine: 125ml glasses
The availability of these smaller measures must be clear on menus, price lists or other printed materials, and these must be accessible by customers on your premises.

When a customer orders a measurable drink — one that isn’t available in a set volume (a bottle of beer, for example) — and doesn’t specify a volume, they should be made aware of all serving volumes, including smaller amounts, either by being told verbally or directed towards a list or menu.

Cas112 · 22/11/2021 19:10

It's not the hotels fault, it's whoever ordered the bottles

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 22/11/2021 19:05

to be fair, a free bar restricted to cheap drinks isn't really in their financial interests

So they shouldn't take one on then hmm

Businesses make deals or headline offers all the time in a the hope of securing the trade, but they aren't going to fall over themselves to let you take full advantage of it, are they?

If a supermarket has loss-leaders on bread and beans, they aren't going to tell you to put the uncompetitively-priced goods back and buy more beans, are they? They'll encourage custom with a 3-for-1 deal, but if you then buy two items at £10 and one item at £2, they won't urge you to grab another £10 item to get free and then just pay separately for the cheap one.

It would have been helpful for them to have suggested putting limits in place, but it isn't incumbent on a profit-making business to deliberately put themselves out in order to limit the amount of profit they end up making.

Not 'helpful' –part of the job.

How is it 'part of the job' to advise you to buy less from them? Is it part of Tesco's job to tell every customer presenting a 'Finest' item at the till that they could swap it for a 'Value' one instead and pay much less?

ImInStealthMode · 22/11/2021 19:05

The people who took the piss are largely to blame, but it's pretty standard for the person paying the tab to put stipulations on it. I've worked the bar at many a private party with a tab and it's usually no doubles, no shots, house wines only etc. Others, usually corporate / finance companies have been no limits whatsoever, complete free for all.

A lesson for next time for sure.

Swipe left for the next trending thread