Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inappropriate interview questions

347 replies

30andgrey · 22/11/2021 13:57

I just turned down a job offer because I deemed these questions inappropriate….AIBU?

  1. How many times have you been on maternity leave during your current employment?

  2. What are the details of your childcare arrangements?

  3. What does a normal day look like for you in terms of balancing raising a young family and a senior post?

The above questions were asked in a telephone conversation after a panel interview.

Anyone else think these are extremely discriminatory?

I turned down the offer that was 4 pay scales higher than my current role because it seemed like they were asking me to prioritise work if it came to it and I had to go over and above to assure them that being a parent would not hinder my ability to do the role.

Would love to know if I’m an idiot for turning down a whopping pay increase or if I am reasonable for thinking it would have been a nightmare to work for an organisation with this mindset.

OP posts:
Lovely13 · 23/11/2021 20:09

Sigh. Why is this still a thing? I was asked in an interview back in late 80s if I was planning on having a baby anytime soon. I blushed and said no. These days, I would have given them both barrels.
And yet, similar is still happening. Very depressing.

JennyForeigner · 23/11/2021 19:51

@HarrietsChariot

Given that they offered you the job I don't think you'd get very far claiming discrimination. Clearly your answers to those questions, or your refusal to answer them, sent out the right messages that you were the person for the role.
Not a given, discrimination is discrimination and the questions made it clear to OP she couldn't make the job work.

That's discrimination on grounds of sex.

FreddieMercurysCat · 23/11/2021 19:43

I don’t think they’re allowed to ask these questions…..

Tigger1895 · 23/11/2021 19:18

Nando’s ask a skin tone ethnicity question. I think that’s like profiling.
The questions you were asked sounds a bit unreasonable and possibly illegal.

DaisyStiener · 23/11/2021 19:08

It sounds like they didn’t want a female for the role and made sure they A: got their ( pretty sure illegal) questions asked and B: put you off anyways
Name n shame.
Ask for the transcript back - send it to ACAS or similar : we simply MUST stop this crap !
*probably would’ve tried to pay you less a woman, anyways. Fuck them. Onwards and upwards , Op Flowers

FeeLock · 23/11/2021 19:02

I'm fairly sure that these breach the Equality Act as I doubt a male applicant would be asked how many times he'd been on paternity, or shared parental, leave.

I'm also sure that it's not appropriate to ask about childcare arrangements (I doubt it's legal) - an employer says the hours are Xam until Ypm, located at Z, and an applicant then decides if they can accept those terms.

I think you have had a lucky escape as I definitely get the feeling you would constantly be viewed as 'the female manager', or have you work allocated to you according to someone else's concept of your abilities based solely on your gender. Flowers

thing47 · 23/11/2021 18:54

@beanii

A company has a right to know how you balance work and childcare - think about if YOU owned the company, would you want to employ someone who would likely be off on maternity leave soon after starting? Or absent frequently for childcare issues? It does work both ways.
Actually they don't Beanii. As you would know if you read some of the many links people have posted on this thread.
Yorkshirelass123 · 23/11/2021 18:48

Newyearnewtwatname is absolutely
Right.

They shouldn’t know if you have kids or are married!! These are personal not professional requirements. You shouldn’t put this on your CV or even refer to your personal life in an interview. It’s a job not a relationship!

cansu · 23/11/2021 18:48

They obviously have an agenda. You shouldn't have had to turn it down but they are clearly telling you they are not family friendly. I would be amazed if they had asked a male those questions.

Movinghouseatlast · 23/11/2021 18:47

Those questions are unlawful and you could actually take them to an employment tribunal.

If you can be bothered an employment lawyer could help you.

AnFiadhRua · 23/11/2021 18:46

@ThePlumVan

Bravo ! That was a dodged bullet !

Mine was ā€˜ what does your husband do for a living ?
Me - ā€˜I’m not married’
Interviewer - ā€˜ oh I’m sorry I thought you said you had a daughter’
Me - ā€˜I do’

Silence cringing all round Grin

What a Victorian train of thought!! Id be more embarrassed for him than for myself.
SpinsForGin · 23/11/2021 18:44

A company has a right to know how you balance work and childcare

Only if they also ask men these questions.

think about if YOU owned the company, would you want to employ someone who would likely be off on maternity leave soon after starting?

And this would be discrimination

Or absent frequently for childcare issues?
You shouldn't be asking these questions and if you did you need to make sure you are also asking men.

If you make a recruitment decision based on any of this information then it would be a clear case of discrimination.

ThePlumVan · 23/11/2021 18:22

Bravo ! That was a dodged bullet !

Mine was ā€˜ what does your husband do for a living ?
Me - ā€˜I’m not married’
Interviewer - ā€˜ oh I’m sorry I thought you said you had a daughter’
Me - ā€˜I do’

Silence cringing all round Grin

Bertiebiscuit · 23/11/2021 18:22

Those questions were discriminatory and illegal - complain and threaten to sue

itbereet · 23/11/2021 18:21

Wow! But you'd be surprised how often these questions are asked.

I work in HR and was once quizzed at an interview by two women about when I was going to have kids.

Several (male and female) managers have openly told me that they won't employ women in their 30s as they get pregnant and it costs too much to cover their maternity.

Female workers are often told to concentrate on their kids as they won't want a career when they work part-time.

It's a constant battle...

Sparklfairy · 23/11/2021 18:21

I had a reply that said that this suggestion is ā€œbaseless and insultingā€

"So were your questions..."

I don't know if I'd actually do this, but I'd be tempted to email them saying further to our telephone conversation I am writing to confirm that I have to decline your job offer due to xyz questions being asked, legalese discrimination quote blah blah.

Then send them a discrimination questionnaire from acas to fill out and give them a lot of paperwork to do Grin give them a headache even if I didn't sue!

titchy · 23/11/2021 18:19

@beanii

A company has a right to know how you balance work and childcare - think about if YOU owned the company, would you want to employ someone who would likely be off on maternity leave soon after starting? Or absent frequently for childcare issues? It does work both ways.
Jesus. Read the thread. A COMPANY DOES NOT HAVE THE RIGHT TO ASK THOSE QUESTIONS UNLESS THEY ALSO ASK MEN.Angry
Bubbles90 · 23/11/2021 18:15

ignore my question I see it's been answered.

Bubbles90 · 23/11/2021 18:13

Is it legal to ask such questions?

beanii · 23/11/2021 18:13

A company has a right to know how you balance work and childcare - think about if YOU owned the company, would you want to employ someone who would likely be off on maternity leave soon after starting? Or absent frequently for childcare issues? It does work both ways.

divface · 23/11/2021 18:11

You could leave an anonymous review of your experience on Glassdoor

divface · 23/11/2021 18:06

Absolutely awful

Name and shame. Go on!

Please tell them precisely why you have rejected the offer

They are discriminating against you due to family circumstances

angelineMcqueen · 23/11/2021 18:03

It makes me so angry that such discrimination still exists. In recent interviews I have been asked (by more than one company) what my child care arrangements are generally, who will look after the kids if they are unwell, whether I've considered that I'd have to travel on a busy motorway every day and would I be okay with that, and whether I could drop everything at short notice to work in another part of the country for a few days if they deemed it necessary (this had not been mentioned as a requirement of the job in the advert, job description or first interview!). I withdrew my application and set out exactly why.
My husband is equally responsible for our kids. He has never, not once, been asked anything of the kind.
You've dodged a bullet OP, sorry you've experienced such discrimination - make sure you call them out on it.

JaninaDuszejko · 22/11/2021 20:49

@TillyTopper

You can only prove it's discriminatory if you can prove they didn't ask these or similar questions to male candidates.
Precisely how many males do you think were asked this question?

How many times have you been on maternity leave during your current employment?

TeenyQueen · 22/11/2021 20:16

This is absolutely ridiculous! Time and time again evidence has shown that women who are treated well in the workplace are more likely to be loyal to their employers than their male colleagues. Hiring a young man might seem like a good investment but young men are statistically more likely to move jobs faster and use a job as a springboard for their next job. You might train a young man for a job and he might be gone in a year or two.

I'll be going on my second maternity next year, I feel very happy and respected in my workplace so I can't see myself wanting to leave anytime soon. Furthermore, my colleague who has older children has been on long term sick leave since September.

Since becoming a mother I'm definitely more efficient. The tasks that used to take me hours take me half the time now. I've only had a handful of instances I've had to pick DD up early or keep her at home due to illness, and as others have pointed out it may well be the dad who can WFH or take time off.

A much more sensible question would have been something like "Are you able to work flexibly?" or "Where do you see yourself in 5 years' time?", and these question should apply to all candidates equally.