*I offered a really attractive remuneration package for the very reason that I don't wish to have to go through this again in the very near future. But to do all this for a temp replacement, I'd find that extremely unfair.
You haven't addressed the ideas raised in this thread of having an existing staff member act up for a while (which would be less 'hassle' as presumably they'd be at least partially trained for the role); or the fact that specialised agencies exist, with people on their books who would be more ready to step straight into highly skilled positions.*
Because in practice this is often not feasible. In my business, there is no one who could step into the role of the main skilled workers full time, though I could get by for a day or two if the key worker called in sick. And I think you overstate quite a bit the availability of temps in specialised agencies.
As I wrote, my recent new hire was a huge hassle and took up many hours of my time.
I'm all for hiring the best candidate, I just disagree that I should be obligated to keep a position open for 6-12 months for someone who makes a personal decision to have a baby. Why should it be my responsibility to ensure she has a job if and when she decides to return?
The way I see it, I hire someone to do a job, I'm obligating myself to pay and they're obligating themselves to work. If they decide to leave, well they're not my slaves, so I wish them good luck and we part ways.
Everyone understands that if a worker decides to take a sabbatical or a round the world trip, I am not obligated to keep their position open for them if and when they return. I might decide to do that voluntarily, because they're such good workers, but it's neither a moral nor ethical duty.
So why when that worker decides to go and have her baby - something that is entirely her choice and doesn't involve me in any way - is it suddenly my duty to keep her job waiting? How have we switched from a simple contract of labour for money, to a duty to care and support her in all her choices?
And to those saying it's good business practice, so is service with a smile. But that isn't enshrined in law.