Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Please look at this and voice your thoughts

133 replies

DoubleTweenQueen · 22/11/2021 12:05

Ok, so, it has come to my attention lately that gender-questioning is becoming more prevalent - particularly with pre-teen and teen girls.

DD2 seems to be questioning her own identity - doesn’t surprise me. Consider it a normal part of painful adolescence, particularly how women are portrayed and treated.
She has just turned 12. Was bullied when she was 9. Developed GAD; changed schools. Felt better, made new friends, more relaxed with life.

Then the pandemic - fear, worry, social isolation, introduction to tech for education and contact, her older sister succumbed to an eating disorder which has been a source of pain and more worry, and continues to be.

DD2 got into minecraft and you tubers who did minecraft. From there she has acquired quite a grounding in the toxicity of gender politics, mostly from the US it seems.

She seems to have been facilitated by school in her new thoughts about herself - she says she is demi-female, wants to change her pronouns to ‘they’ and her name. This is the first I’ve heard of it, by accident. No-one has mentioned anything about her questioning her identity or any upset from her at all. School have not talked to me at all regarding what else might be going on in her life - first term of senior school. I have filled them in. They are backpedaling.

What I have learned very quickly is that schools appear to be counselling children who are gender questioning, by affirming their thoughts through counselling in school - which is confidential and not shared with parents because the current thought seems to be - once a child questions their gender, they are identified as a ‘protected minority’ and supported and affirmed. Some schools are also enabling children to change their pronouns and name in school - step towards social transition.

This is counter to current thought regarding providing a safe neutral space for children to question and grow, without enabling or influence a move in a trans direction, and one they could feel unable to renege upon at a later date.

More worrying, there is a bill currently being drawn up in Parliament regarding the ban on ‘conversion therapy’ - heavily lobbied for by LGBT+ groups.
This wouldn’t seem to be an issue, apart from this does actually impact the field of child psychology in that when a gender-questioning child goes for therapy or support, the counsellor or psychologist may not look for co-morbidities, i.e. delve deeper to question whether the gender-questioning is a symptom of some deeper issue - anxiety, trauma, neurological-diversity. This is just bonkers! But look at what happened at The Tavistock clinic.........

I aam posting here, because most (including me) were blissfully unaware of the stealth by which this ideology is creeping into our schools and soon nurseries - under the guise of inclusion and anti-bullying. That our children have just gone through two years of difficulty and over-exposure to tech and social media. That their mental health has truly suffered.

If you have older children in secondary school - ask them if they hear of students declaring they are non-binary, interested in changing name or pronouns, interested in Communism and vegetarianism - it seems to go together.
It is very common now. Social contagion as bad as eating disorders, and potentially as damaging, if enabled to move down the pathway of puberty blockers, hormones, surgery!

Please look into this, and make yourselves heard!!

www.transgendertrend.com/conversion-therapy-legal-opinion/

Also - look at Genspect, and the Bayswater Support Group.

These are children, who are vulnerable and neuro-plastic. They are influenced heavily by SM. Please make yourselves aware, before this becomes law, and when your gender-questioning child goes for any sort of counselling, they will be met not with in-depth discussion about what has led them to their belief about themselves being wrong, or weird, or ‘other’ (so normal for adolescents!!) - but affirmation of a trans identity, and not looking for co-morbidities, because it will be against the law Hmm

Thanks for reading.

Put here for traffic, but MN can move wherever they like.

I would like to see MN also look into this, as an important parental issue (if they dare Sad)

Vote - YABU - you’re hysterical
YANBU - you might be on to something

OP posts:
3scape · 22/11/2021 13:52

My child is quesonng their identity. What school can provide or afford to provide this counseling you mentn though . Even sue a sucide attempt the NHS / MIND can't come u with counselin. Sorry. But your post suggests ifiniteresources that simply do not exsist

JoyOrbison · 22/11/2021 13:48

It's a fucking nightmare, all dc friends are flag wavers for the LGBTQ+ and most have declared how they identify, what gender they are, what name they use.... All good and well for those who are dropping it into their daily lives as its the latest Co trend... Not cool for dc with zero confidence and under camhs because why address your issues when you can be someone else?

The only good thing is they do homework in the lgbtq+ club.

NothingSafe · 22/11/2021 13:42

interested in Communism and vegetarianism - it seems to go together.

Grin Grin Grin

"Is YOUR child saying they love animals and think capitalism is bullshit? Beware, they might be being turned trans!"

EsmeSusanOgg · 22/11/2021 13:38

I find myself horribly divided!

I think it is positive that children can access support and discuss issues. I also think that being accepting of people who are genuinely trans or non-binary is something we should do as a society.

BUT.

I am accutely aware that as a child I would have been steered down this path - despite not being trans or non-binary.

I am autistic and didn't want to get big boobs (like all my family have, and indeed did happen) because I liked playing sports and didn't want sexual attention. As a preteen I expressed that I didn't want to go through puberty. Which is pretty common, especially amongst neurodiverse people.

That discomfirt with a woman's body, were I to express it now in a school setting, would be seen as an indicator of gender dysphoria - not that I was uncomfortable with puberty/ growing up.

I want to know what safeguards exist to help support children, with a range of different mental and physical issues, to prevent misdiagnosis? And how does that work if parents/ guardians are not involved?

DoubleTweenQueen · 22/11/2021 13:29

oops - *except, not accept. Apologies.

Feminism board - love it, but came her for thorough exhibitionism, and reach/exposure :D

OP posts:
DoubleTweenQueen · 22/11/2021 13:26

Was hoping this crazy post would be a bit more effective than crossing fingers :D and that getting more folk interested might help with the momentum.

I don’t think children should be recognised as being trans accept for the evidence of a thorough psychological evaluation of all factors which may be affecting them.
This is not what’s happening, and is at risk of being denied to them, due to conflation with the LGBGT+ human rights/inclusion interests, with which I have zero argument, but that it must not reduce the protections of other vulnerable groups, as you say.

OP posts:
sashh · 22/11/2021 13:08

Come on over the the feminism boards, you will find advice and support.

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights

CharlotteMaytimes · 22/11/2021 12:37

Agree with all this - lots on the feminism board about it, but also lots of TRAs like to come here and tell us all that Mumsnet is a pit of transphobic bigoted scum. Think it’s slowly shifting though, after all the companies pulled out of Stonewall’s Gender Diversity Scheme, and their CEO did an absolutely disastrous interview on Woman’s Hour last week. It’s finally filtering through to enough people, so the tide is turning against the blind removal of the rights of women and girls, not to mention lesbians (a protected group Stonewall has chucked fully under the bus in the name of ✨gender ideology✨).

Fingers crossed this momentum keeps gathering and we can protect and support trans people the way they need, without dismantling valuable protections for other (much, much bigger) groups who need theirs too.