Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you eat at a restaurant that didn't serve alcohol?

488 replies

Yearn · 22/11/2021 02:40

If a restaurant served only soft drinks and alcohol-free beers/wines/cocktails would you eat there on an evening? Even on a Friday/Saturday night. No BYOB either.

YABU - Yes, I would eat there even on a weekend night.
YANBU - No, I wouldn't eat there on an evening.

OP posts:
ufucoffee · 24/11/2021 13:05

No, no and thrice no.

Alaimo · 24/11/2021 12:13

DH barely drinks as he gets terrible hangovers, even after just a single beer. I'd love to be able to go a restaurant with him where he has more options than just Heineken Zero or Coca Cola. Equally, I've been interested in trying alcohol free wines and non-alcoholic gin, but am reluctant to buy a whole bottle. I'd consider your restaurant to be the perfect opportunity to try out a few different non-alcoholic wines or spirits.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 24/11/2021 12:09

@RaisedByPangolins

I think the point isn’t that a glass of wine with dinner is an addiction, but that even if the food in a restaurant was amazing, you wouldn’t go there because you can’t drink that points to an addiction. Once you associate alcohol with eating and don’t enjoy eating without wine then the focus has become more about the wine than the meal.

I disagree.

About ninety percent of the meals I eat involve no alcohol.

But eating in a restaurant is, in a small way, an event. It’s about the company, the conversation, the atmosphere, the rituals, the food, the wine - and I’d like all those to be part of it. So I wouldn’t go to a restaurant where one of those wasn’t even possible. Just as I wouldn’t go to a restaurant on my own, because conversation wouldn’t be possible.

Actually, the food isn’t even that high on the list. I’ve had many great evenings in restaurants where the food was quite mediocre, and quite a few dull evenings in restaurants where the food was fabulous. One of Gordon Ramsay’s springs to mind.

lunarlandscape · 24/11/2021 12:05

I agree that a really interesting list of soft drinks would be such a welcome change. We went to a Sri Lankan restaurant the other day that served an iced tea flavoured with rose and cardomom and it wasn't sweet! DS and I were so happy. A good range of savoury or only slightly sweet drinks would be great.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 24/11/2021 11:38

Nope.

C8H10N4O2 · 24/11/2021 09:12

You could have a beautiful restaurant in a great location with amazing food and an exciting soft drinks menu and still lose out to the place with the mediocre food and bad service just because it has a wine list and 30 gins

The vote is a forced binary. Its hardly surprising that if people do only go out occasionally and its a special event then yes, wine or a cocktail is part of that overall evening.

What is the market you want to capture? Every day casual diners or people who maybe eat out once a month or less often?

In terms of food if you don't want to have alcohol in the restaurant then middle eastern, south or east Asian restaurants are at least associated with teas as well as alcohol.

The tedious range of non alcoholic options in most restaurants doesn't help. Nothing that might interest a customer to try instead of wine - just the lowest common denominator, single note sweet drinks to fill a menu gap for non drinkers.

I'm sure there are some with "exciting" ranges of soft drinks but the only time I've come close to seeing one was a vegan restaurant in Oz with a range of kombuchas on the menu - complex and non sweet with recommendations to go with the different dishes. I nearly wept with happiness as usually the choice is coke, fizzy orange or sweet fruity juices which are glorified squash.

Mommybean · 24/11/2021 08:57

Big shut out to any one that's trying to stop drinking acholol. Such a hard thing to do especially if it's became a problem. Proud of you.

Mommybean · 24/11/2021 08:34

Alcohol is sold everywhere from super markets, post office and now even petrol stations. I know of people that have alcohal problems and it's no fair. To have a restaurant that's alcohol free that they can take their family too would be great. Big shut out to my local Nisa they got in alcohol free beer, So my friend can join in with his pals. I would differantly drink in a alcohol free restaurant. Show our next generation you don't have to have alcohol to have a good time. You will always have people that don't no when to stop. Don't no their limit. Personnsonly throwing up, sore head, making a fool of myself doesn't sound like a great night. More achohol free places please

Would you eat at a restaurant that didn't serve alcohol?
FirewomanSam · 24/11/2021 08:28

I think a lot of people like to kid themselves that they always pick a wine that compliments the food because it improves the meal when in reality 95% of people pick the wine they drink/like the sound of the most, or even the one that's cheapest, in my experience.

I agree with this. And I think a lot of people (including myself in my pre-sober days) would rather drink mediocre or even crap wine than no wine at all, so the idea that everyone chooses the perfect pairing, only drinks ‘for the taste’, or because it enhances the taste of food always makes me raise an eyebrow. I’ve yet to see anyone leave a glass of wine unfinished when it turned out to be a bit rubbish, or didn’t go with the food as well as they hoped it would, which suggests there are other factors at play in the choice to drink wine.

I have a relative who was once training to be a sommelier and he will pore over a wine list for a good 20 minutes to pick out the perfect wine to pair with everyone’s meal choices but I’d say he’s the exception rather than the rule. I always just chose the ‘house’ wine every time, to be honest, and would finish a bottle whether or not it turned out to be good.

Mother87 · 24/11/2021 07:45

Yes of course

keffie12 · 24/11/2021 07:34

[quote BasiliskStare]@keffie12 - hope I have not said anything amiss - great friend of mine is 15 years sober - not for one moment do I think there is anything weird about that. She can be around moderate drinkers - because she comfortable with that. Actually at a few sporting occasions may have encountered some more bibulous types. But no-one thinks she is weird.[/quote]
@BasiliskStare

Hi! No I didn't mean you. I thought I had done a quote post on the person who had either taken what I had said wrong or was being confrontational.

Pleased to hear about your friend too. Yes we can be around moderate drinkers if we are comfortable with it.

We choose not to be around anything more because why would we want to be! Its unpleasant experience when people are hammered and you aren't.

Not that I want to be hammered. Every morning starts well cos I know what I did last night.

Thank you for taking the time to response and check in 🙂

BasiliskStare · 24/11/2021 03:42

@keffie12 - hope I have not said anything amiss - great friend of mine is 15 years sober - not for one moment do I think there is anything weird about that. She can be around moderate drinkers - because she comfortable with that. Actually at a few sporting occasions may have encountered some more bibulous types. But no-one thinks she is weird.

Ineke · 24/11/2021 03:18

Depends on the food and the occasion. Wine compliments some food, with others menus, water or mint tea is fine. However, a social meal with friends seems to me to be more fun if a glass or two of wine goes down with the meal.

keffie12 · 24/11/2021 02:20

If you are referring to me please read my post properly! I said I was in a 12 step program. That means I am also sober/in recovery whatever you wish to call it in A.A. Yes I am 18 and a half years sober.

You don't know me if any of that was aimed at me. If others want to drink that's fine. My post was about the reasons people don't drink alcohol.
There is also nothing worse either than people who think its weird because you don't drink.

That's one article. Fine it's out of date. There are plenty of places like it still going.

winnieanddaisy · 23/11/2021 23:59

Yes. I'm teetotal .

BasiliskStare · 23/11/2021 23:41

Well I like a glass of wine with my meal ( could not be arsed to go a bar afterwards if not an option with meal - either meal no alcohol or don't go. I'd go if chosen by friends ) but really - there are drinkers and drinkers. Those who are drinkers with a problem or cause others a problem in a restaurant. and those who enjoy a glass of wine or a G&T at the weekend and equally - those who just do not like the stuff or have made a conscious decision not to drink alcohol at all or designated driver etc

I think lumping "drinkers" into one category of loud , roistery , problematic people is lazy.
Personally we are going out for a celebratory meal this weekend & I will enjoy a glass or two whilst looking at the menu & eating. ( I can promise MN I will not be shouting or banging the table. Grin ) It is a fairly rare occasion for me where I can get a bit scrubbed up and go somewhere nice. It is a treat.

Caoilinsmum1 · 23/11/2021 23:39

Yes, why do they have to serve alcohol?

Yearn · 23/11/2021 22:45

@h1nch

Either this is a joke question or you seriously need to evaluate your relationship with alcohol?
No, it's not a joke. The way I labelled the vote has nothing at all to do with my opinions on alcohol.

Did you read at least some of the thread? There are a surprising amount of people who would flat out refuse to dine at a dry restaurant, no matter how good the food is. I do find that surprising, but at the same time I don't. I think a lot of people like to kid themselves that they always pick a wine that compliments the food because it improves the meal when in reality 95% of people pick the wine they drink/like the sound of the most, or even the one that's cheapest, in my experience.

Personally, I don't think a dry restaurant is viable, at least not as an evening/dinner place. Breakfast and lunch, sure, but unless you are in an area with a large non-drinking population (which is usually for religious reasons so you would have to cater with halal rules etc. in mind) I think you'll be hard pressed to get the foot fall in the evenings, especially at the weekend.

Most restaurants fail in their first year, for a variety of reasons and I do think alcohol sales are, with their huge markup, a great way of making money. It's about an 80% margin, whereas food is generally 60-67% margin. Even if you only have 10 customers one night you'll barely even break even on the food but if they're buying mixed drinks or wine by the glass then you'll most likely have most of your wage costs for the night covered.

Discussing this with friends who are also in the industry it was pretty evenly split between "I'd only go if someone else chose it" and "food is what matters". Whereas amongst the general public I think it's a definite "Nah, especially not a weekend!" despite what this vote shows. You could have a beautiful restaurant in a great location with amazing food and an exciting soft drinks menu and still lose out to the place with the mediocre food and bad service just because it has a wine list and 30 gins.

OP posts:
Fleshmechanic · 23/11/2021 22:38

I never drink alcohol at a meal so wouldn't notice if they did or didn't sell it anyway.

shiningjustforyou · 23/11/2021 22:32

If I was going out for a mid week meal and driving or was maybe meeting a friend who doesn't drink then yeah. Friday or Saturday night then no, I'm out for the night and that would mean wine and cocktails.

Harmonypuss · 23/11/2021 22:27

Considering that my partner is teetotal and I only have 1 or 2 drinks maybe 3 times a year, yes, of course we'd eat somewhere that doesn't serve alcohol, why wouldn't we?

Cheeko69 · 23/11/2021 22:26

I'm a complete booze hound but I'd definitely eat at a teetotal restaurant if the food was good.

pollymere · 23/11/2021 22:22

I hate eating in restaurants where the only low calorie drinks are water or diet coke. I still do it though if my friends want to eat there. I prefer restaurants with a good choice of any drink myself though. You are BU if it's the odd occasion and you are there to enjoy the food are you not?

NiellyNoFive · 23/11/2021 22:14

For lunch I wouldn't mind but not for dinner no

Fluffmum · 23/11/2021 21:37

Of course. Not a big deal

Swipe left for the next trending thread