Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To send my children to state school?

145 replies

chasingkites · 21/11/2021 20:53

Anyone else went to a top private school themselves and not sending their children to private school?

Both myself and DH went to two of the very best private schools in the country. We're very aware that we've lived in a cushy little privileged bubble- DH works in finance at a firm that pretty much exclusively hires oxbridge graduates and pretty much everyone knows each other.

I've 'only' become a state school teacher (which I genuinely love); a career I'm sure I could have done without my parents spending a fortune on schooling, but am because of it perhaps more aware of some of the advantages my academically selective own school gave to me.

My children are pre primary age currently but we're hoping to move to our 'forever' home soon and, being a teacher, schooling is very high on our list of priorities. In our area the state schools are arguably much better than the private schools, as because the private schools aren't academically selective in any way, and as secondary state schools are outstanding most parents here seem to fight to get their kids into state instead.

There is a town about 40 mins away where the private schools rival some of the best in the country and we could choose to move there, but know no one who lives there (and I would be giving up my 5 minute commute!)

I love the school I teach and do think my dc would thrive there, but as all of my closest friends went to top private schools themselves I worry that in the future when their children all inevitably attend private schools I'll feel like I'm letting my own children down.

Anyone out there who grew up in the private school bubble who sent their own children to state through choice, not because they couldn't afford it?

OP posts:
Earwigworries · 21/11/2021 21:29

I was privately educated , my background was modest though and I was bullied . My children are both in state secondary - though one is in a selective school . My preference was always that they meet children from all walks of life and learn to get on with anyone . So far I’m happy that we’ve made the right call

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 21/11/2021 21:29

Having the funds for private gives you he luxury of choice. When they are at the appropriate age, look at the various options and chose what is best for them.

I'm very happy with the state school my 10yo most likely will be attending next year. I'm ot sure the local private school,good as it is, would be best for her.. she has some additional needs and the vocational courses could be perfect for her.

De88 · 21/11/2021 21:29

Ask yourself if you're really worried about "letting them down" (you're not) as much as you might be worried about keeping up with the Joneses?

Wherever they go, if they're going to do well, they'll do well. They'll make their own choices about what they'll do after school of their own accord.

There's nothing unreasonable about wanting the best things for your children, but you've already said in your original post, private is a privileged and closed bubble which does not give people a realistic view of the world, and not necessarily best. So what is your worry really about?

Hollyhead · 21/11/2021 21:28

Just adding to this, both of my DC go to a small, mediocre state primary. They’re still happy and thriving, doing very well for their ages etc. We top up with a few extra curricular activities ourselves.

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 21/11/2021 21:28

@canyoutoleratethis

From your last post, my overriding thought is that it makes me sad for your children that you’ve already decided that going to Oxbridge is so important for them. Perhaps you could let them decide what they want for their own lives?
I agree with this, the fact that you think not going to Oxbridge is in anyway something deficient in anyone's life does indicate a remarkably blinkered view of the world that only someone who was educated in a tiny unrealistic bubble would have.

Over 1/2 a million children born in the UK every year do really think that all but the few thousand who go to Oxbridge have been let down by their parents?

PurplePizzaCake · 21/11/2021 21:26

@HairyToity

I was privately educated, but badly bullied, and parents were always working.

DH and I could just about afford to privately educated, but we'd need to be much more careful with money. No more impromptu lunches out. Too be financially secure I'd probably have to work full time to help pay for it.

We've chosen not to. I work part-time. We have no money worries, and our children are very happy at their local state school. I don't think private necessarily leads to a lifetime of success. From my cohorts I can think of one that since school has gone bankrupt twice, another has a drug addiction and a third developed bulimia at university.

Follow your gut.

I'm not sure developing bulimia has anything to do with this
Rockandgrohl · 21/11/2021 21:24

I went to a private secondary. Left 19 years ago...it now costs more per term than it did per year when I was there! We just cant afford it...it is what it is although I'm sad that I can't provide for my DC what my parents provided for me but have cone to terms with it. Having said that my sibling did very well although to most people I have probably "wasted" my education!

changingchanges2 · 21/11/2021 21:24

It's a tough one.

I'm guessing you and your DH are Benenden / Harrow types?

We are similar, although i grew up abroad.

We are thinking State till 8 for our DC. There's an unbelievably fantastic state primary near us, looks and feels like a private school, and it would be silly throwing away £20k a year (per child) on private school for early years when we have such a great alternative near us.

NuffSaidSam · 21/11/2021 21:23

I wouldn't worry about secondary school at this point. See how they develop, what sort of kids they turn out to be and then make a decision from there.

uneffingbelievable · 21/11/2021 21:22

You can always change - I was dead set on state all the way.
Eldest was failing so badly in his state primary, his health was not great lot of bullying, he was a shadow and we did what I always swore I would not - moved him private.
Best decision emotionally for him - he grew and was happy. Academically he did ok but happy child beat academic brilliance.
Come secondary - he has gone private and when you get it right you know you have- thriving, flying academically in a way he never had - confident happy child.

Second followed eldest into private primary - now in state secondary - suits them, happy thriving child.

Be prepared to adapt to the child - not your beliefs. Eldest would shrivel in state school that youngest goes to.
One size does not fit all

randomsabreuse · 21/11/2021 21:22

DH and I both went to middling private schools. Can't afford private for ours without a major scholarship. We chose our location for decent state schools.

Very few of our friends' kids will be going private and those that are are due to being tied to areas where the state schools are pretty limited (rural south west).

HairyToity · 21/11/2021 21:20

I was privately educated, but badly bullied, and parents were always working.

DH and I could just about afford to privately educated, but we'd need to be much more careful with money. No more impromptu lunches out. Too be financially secure I'd probably have to work full time to help pay for it.

We've chosen not to. I work part-time. We have no money worries, and our children are very happy at their local state school. I don't think private necessarily leads to a lifetime of success. From my cohorts I can think of one that since school has gone bankrupt twice, another has a drug addiction and a third developed bulimia at university.

Follow your gut.

canyoutoleratethis · 21/11/2021 21:19

From your last post, my overriding thought is that it makes me sad for your children that you’ve already decided that going to Oxbridge is so important for them. Perhaps you could let them decide what they want for their own lives?

Luredbyapomegranate · 21/11/2021 21:18

I think you want to have choices.

For some kids, a state secondary can work brilliantly - for others they don't, but a private school does. So keep your options open.

wishiwasonholiday30 · 21/11/2021 21:17

I went to a top private school. I am also a teacher, I teach in the private system but primary. My son is at my school but he'll go to a state secondary as it's just too expensive now.
Out of 8 friends from school who have children, only 1 is sending their children private.
If I'm being completely honest, I have struggled coming to terms with the fact my son won't go to a private secondary, but I would rather be around for him and for us to spend time as a family going on holidays, eating out, theatre etc. Things would be too tight to do the things we like to do as a family if we sent him private.
The schools near us are very good but I do still have pangs of guilt that he won't have the education I had.

chasingkites · 21/11/2021 21:14

@bluejelly

I think going to a state school has so many advantages. It's free It allows your children to develop a realistic understanding of the world and their place in it Many of them are excellent Even the average ones are usually good enough.

I went to a very bog standard comp and got into a top uni, have a high status job. Going to a state school never held me back in the slightest and I think it has enriched my life.

Thank you.

See, this is what I would love for my children.

The reality is that in the outstanding, highly sought after state schools that I teach in, only a small handful of students gain places at oxbridge every year.

At the school I went to about 20% of the year group went to oxbridge.

It just makes me feel like I won't be setting my own children up for the best start in life!

But I also so want to just relax and plan to send them to state school.

OP posts:
ACupOfTeaSolvesEverything · 21/11/2021 21:12

We both went to very well respected private schools and both had SEN that were completely missed by everyone. As adults we have done ok but have really struggled in many ways and have not achieved in a similar way to our peers at all despite both being extremely intelligent. Had we had more support in our formative years I suspect things may have turned out rather differently. DS has identified and supported SEN (the same as ours in fact) and is going to an inclusive, supportive state school.

bluejelly · 21/11/2021 21:10

I think going to a state school has so many advantages.
It's free
It allows your children to develop a realistic understanding of the world and their place in it
Many of them are excellent
Even the average ones are usually good enough.

I went to a very bog standard comp and got into a top uni, have a high status job. Going to a state school never held me back in the slightest and I think it has enriched my life.

chasingkites · 21/11/2021 21:03

Thank you for replying.

I should clarify- I see absolutely no benefit in private primary- it's secondary school I'm worrying about.

OP posts:
hopingforabrighterfuture2021 · 21/11/2021 21:01

Yes, I went to a very ‘good’ private school and to be honest I don’t think it did me any particular favours! We sent our kids to state primary and I also work in the state primary system and have no real interest in working in private.

We have sent eldest to private secondary though, and will do for the second one too. Various reasons.

Swipe left for the next trending thread