Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Buggy on escalator

143 replies

CassandrasCastle · 21/11/2021 20:47

is this a huge no no? I did it in John Lewis today because I couldn't be bothered walking all the way to the lifts, and the woman behind me told me to be careful 😬 I told her thanks for the advice, although may have been slightly sarcastic in tone. I've taken the buggy on escalators in the tube etc. as well

OP posts:
Thinking2041 · 22/11/2021 04:31

I live near a station with no lift and a long escalator. It is stark to look at and the idea of a baby falling down it is too horrific to contemplate.
But I sometimes have to use the tube.

I always go when it’s non-peak and I use the escalator when it’s a quiet moment. I don’t enjoy it but I also don’t really stress over it. I know that the major risk comes down to how I manoeuvre the buggy. I feel in control of it and generally trust myself.
I think statistically my baby is in greater danger on the bus on the way there surely?!
That’s when I would feel less at ease. My baby’s safety is then dependent on a bus driver - who I don’t know - and a ton of road users. All of these strangers are using machines with much higher accident rates. And all of us on that bus, including my baby aren’t strapped in.

I would always take a lift if I could over an escalator, for sure.

Graphista · 22/11/2021 04:19

Yabu!

It's very dangerous not only to you and baby but others on the escalator.

I have a bit of a bugbear about this as when I was in nurse training I saw the effects of someone caught by an elevator through misuse - not for the faint hearted trust me!

The rules are there for safety reasons, please don't do it again

www.newsshopper.co.uk/news/314100.infant-topples-down-escalator/

amp.theguardian.com/uk/2008/apr/05/1

Not a myth!

The incident I saw involved a trapped foot and "degloving" (seriously don't look this up unless very strong stomached) injury the affected child has to lose part of their foot.

Ever since I frequently caution people and am very careful using them myself

They're basically human sized shredding machines! Not to mention the height and layout can be dodgy sometimes

I've witnessed someone hit the emergency stop on one occasion due to an elderly lady got stuck getting off as she couldn't lift her feet high enough/in time and her shoe got caught. They luckily managed to stop it before her foot was too!

Staff attending the incident said it happens far more often than they'd like. Awful things actually they should be done away with and lifts or stairs only

CheeseMmmm · 22/11/2021 04:09

Oh sorry dock totally misread!

Yes and I don't understand why it would be seen as a risk too far!

CheeseMmmm · 22/11/2021 04:08

Some shops have stairs and escalator no lift.

And yes accidents can happen all the time.. But generally don't unless doing something really inadvisable.

If you live your life thinking about any thing that could happen. You wouldn't be able to function.

Incidents involving cars are numerous and cause all sorts of damage. Rarely reported in news.
One young child dies because of really bizarre thing. All over the news.

Humans are terrible at assessing risk. All of us. It's a whole studied area.

Statistically. I tried to Google but didn't get far. I have no doubt that babies being harmed in escalator incidents are way way way way way not s thing to worry about at all in terms of incidence.

DockOTheBay · 22/11/2021 03:37

@Jujujuly

I’d never do it in a shop - there are always lifts and it’s just not necessary, plus there are signs saying not to do it. I have done it on the tube on occasion because I’ve had to - many many stations don’t have lifts. Like a pp I have a bugaboo bee which I can lift if needed and it has a wrist strap. I still hate doing it and will often put the baby in the sling so I can drag the buggy. Accidents happen and it doesn’t bear thinking about!
Accidents of all sorts happen all the time. Surely with baby in a sling on an evaluator you could trip and fall down getting on our off, is that more or less likely than the pushchair falling?
thickthighs73 · 22/11/2021 03:30

@ISpyCobraKai

I did it, admittedly 20 years ago but nothing bad happened. I just put the back wheels on with it tilted.
Exactly what I did was never a problem
CheeseMmmm · 22/11/2021 01:02

I mean I've not had or seen an accident with either with a pushchair in 45 years of using the tube an awful lot.

So not IME wrong word! In my common sense view.

CheeseMmmm · 22/11/2021 01:00

In situations with escalators or stairs, no lift.

Then IME using the escalator is less likely to result in an accident than using the stairs. Partly depends on circs sure but in general. Escalator is sensible choice.

This choice exists in some tube stations so it's a real life scenario.

CheeseMmmm · 22/11/2021 00:51

I do understand totally your FFS at that incessant.

Usual point on MN though that not everyone with mobility issues it's obvious.

I mean in situations where the escalator is broken/ it's only stairs and lift to choose from and things like that.

IncessantNameChanger · 21/11/2021 23:38

Too many able bodied people in the lifts means I have done this a handful of times. Waiting and waiting for a lift while a entire family goes in with one person in the wheelchair. Not sure why they need 6 people with them in the lift. I would never have a pram on the elevator but a buggy I have after waiting for five lifts.

Sometimes I got the baby out and carried the pram in one hand and baby in the other which isnt much safer

TurnUpTurnip · 21/11/2021 23:34

I would never do this, not with my child in it anyway, the shopping centre near me has a pole at the bottom to stop people from doing it

MissMaple82 · 21/11/2021 23:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

RobinPenguins · 21/11/2021 23:25

I’ve done it once on the metro when I didn’t realise until I got off that the lift was broken. No one around to help me carry it up the stairs, and I was in a hurry so didn’t want to wait for the train to the next station. About half way up it began felt like the worst idea ever and I was practically sweating by the time I got to the top. And that was going up - the idea of going down with one is fucking terrifying.

AntiHop · 21/11/2021 23:16

I used to take my buggy on escalators until one time when a wheel got caught. Buggy was broken.

Now I take my sling with me if I'm going on the tube. If I'm bringing the buggy aswell, I fold it to take it on the escalator. If I'm somewhere with a lift, I always choose the lift.

Cherrytart23 · 21/11/2021 23:12

I always done buggy on escalators. Why i always done it was because lifts are always busy and there is always a cue of people waiting for lift that could use the escalators but for some reason won't.

ErrolTheDragon · 21/11/2021 23:12

@TheOpen

I think there has been a change in guidance due to accidents as other posters are describing.

10 years ago (where I lived) buggies on escalators were completely standard. No signage like there is now. You just had to carve out a bit of space and pay attention. I never had any trouble but obviously things have changed. I sympathise with having to wait in queues for lifts.

20 years ago where I live, signs telling people with buggies to use the lift and not the escalator were the norm.
CheeseMmmm · 21/11/2021 23:07

Oh sorry yes but I do agree!

CheeseMmmm · 21/11/2021 23:06

'22:53Sandinmyknickers

mynameiscalypso

I think if you live in London and take the tube, you get used to carting a buggy around on an escalator and then it seems strange that every other non-tube escalator seems to ban them.

I would say that's only in the last few decades. People didn't take buggies on busses or tubes in London late eighties/early nineties (and if you did, they would have to be collapsible and you would collapse it first. On a bus there was literally no where to put it if you didn't collapse it immediately to stow behind the conductor.) Parents seemed to manage fine'

80s loads of stations only had steps and some still do.

I suspect parents got around it as best they could eg bus instead.

It's much better now with improved access (far from great they have real constraints though with space etc).

For those not as mobile, disabilities, parents with children, so many people.

Having to take kid out, carry and bags and kid and pushchair up or down a ton of stairs, put it all back together again can't have been too much fun!

Generally when with pushchair now if anyone around they pick up the other end and help.

TheOpen · 21/11/2021 23:03

I think there has been a change in guidance due to accidents as other posters are describing.

10 years ago (where I lived) buggies on escalators were completely standard. No signage like there is now. You just had to carve out a bit of space and pay attention. I never had any trouble but obviously things have changed. I sympathise with having to wait in queues for lifts.

CheeseMmmm · 21/11/2021 22:58

Common on tube and I think it's fine there. Seem to remember sign saying lift over there (if there is one) or be v careful.

Suppose as not many have lifts that's that.

Sandinmyknickers · 21/11/2021 22:53

@mynameiscalypso

I think if you live in London and take the tube, you get used to carting a buggy around on an escalator and then it seems strange that every other non-tube escalator seems to ban them.
I would say that's only in the last few decades. People didn't take buggies on busses or tubes in London late eighties/early nineties (and if you did, they would have to be collapsible and you would collapse it first. On a bus there was literally no where to put it if you didn't collapse it immediately to stow behind the conductor.) Parents seemed to manage fine
greenlynx · 21/11/2021 22:51

No, I wouldn’t take buggy on a escalator. There were 2 accidents in our local M&S involving escalator during last 5 years. There were small accidents when it’s stopped and no one was injured but still…accidents do happen.
I also wouldn’t go on a escalator behind (if going up) or in front ( if going down) someone who’s got a buggy. I was in quite a few situations in a public transport when people lost balance or transport stopped and their buggies/children/they themselves fall down on me. It’s not pleasant at all.

nimbuscloud · 21/11/2021 22:49

I still have flash backs to a buggy-escalator accident dh and I were involved in a few years ago. Woman with buggy going down an escalator. 3 people after her. Then us. As she got to the end the buggy somehow slid sideways and got jammed. The people in front of us tried to go back up. Dh took about 4 escalator steps in one go and yanked the buggy off the escalator. 1 of the 3 people immediately behind overbalanced and fell hitting his face on the edge of the step. There was complete pandemonium. Luckily a staff member was nearby and stopped the escalator.
Completely avoidable situation. I never get on one now if there is a buggy in front of me.

PinkSyCo · 21/11/2021 22:45

Maybe the lady advised you to be careful because she’s witnessed, or had a close call, buggy/escalator accident herself. But hey if it saves you a few steps it’s worth the risk right OP?

AnnieSnap · 21/11/2021 22:45

I have 3 children (all adults now), born in ‘76, ‘80 and ‘82. I never thought twice about taking a buggy on an escalator. Front wheels on going up, back wheels coming down. Always easy and felt absolutely safe. No issues, no one thought twice! YANBU