Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Buggy on escalator

143 replies

CassandrasCastle · 21/11/2021 20:47

is this a huge no no? I did it in John Lewis today because I couldn't be bothered walking all the way to the lifts, and the woman behind me told me to be careful 😬 I told her thanks for the advice, although may have been slightly sarcastic in tone. I've taken the buggy on escalators in the tube etc. as well

OP posts:
Chocolatewheatos · 22/11/2021 08:30

I would only do it when there was no lift. I was going to say not at all. Bit people saying stations on the tube have no lift (what about disabled people) then what other choice would you have? But it would feel insanely dangerous and I'd feel like a right idiot.

Amberflames · 22/11/2021 08:30

@Fomofo

I used to do it all the time and why do people need to pass you on an escalator
Clearly not from London then.
FestiveMayo · 22/11/2021 08:25

@Fomofo

I used to do it all the time and why do people need to pass you on an escalator
Because you're too slow. Because they want to get off the escalator quicker as they don't like them. Becuase they are scared your buggy is going to fall on them and cause a life changing accident.
FestiveMayo · 22/11/2021 08:24

As a parent you have to do whatever you think is the best choice at the time. I personally would hate to have to explain to my child that they fell down an escalator because I was too lazy.

Fomofo · 22/11/2021 08:21

I used to do it all the time and why do people need to pass you on an escalator

MrsLargeEmbodied · 22/11/2021 08:19

i have seen people doing it,
but what a risk!

headintheproverbial · 22/11/2021 08:12

I used to do this all the time.

londonrach · 22/11/2021 07:58

The accident I saw was in a bank at 11am the poor man was not drunk!

londonrach · 22/11/2021 07:56

Having seen someone been killed on an escalator its vvvv dangerous. It was an awful sight as the person missed the step at the top and fell. The risk of the buggy catching that top step or you not holding on is high. No buggy on escalator as vvv dangerous for baby and those under you. Never ever seen anyone put a buggy on an escalator. If you seen the accident I saw you never ever ever do it. Fold the buggy every time. I dont like using escalator s now and have a problem getting on. Yabu and vvvvvvv dangerous. Can't believe you never seen the no buggy sign. Please take the lift.

mynameiscalypso · 22/11/2021 07:07

@dandydear

No *@CheeseMmmm* better to act like an adult and a parent and plan your journey, so you're either getting to a step free station / using bus / using baby carrier etc. Sometimes being a parent means your journey is longer and yes there will always be those shitty situations where the lift is out and you have no choice , but as someone who uses a (now) crowded tube and train station, this is mostly just laziness.
But the risk is absolutely tiny. 5000 odd accidents out of 1.3bn journeys (although clearly not every journey involves an escalator). I've used the tube daily for 25 years and the only accidents I've ever seen are when people are drunk.
ThreeLocusts · 22/11/2021 07:05

Since I used a lot if public transport with kids and had 3 of them I've taken buggies on escalators 1000s of times. No accident ever and no comments either.

That said, it obviously could go very wrong and I'm glad those days are over.

dandydear · 22/11/2021 06:44

No @CheeseMmmm better to act like an adult and a parent and plan your journey, so you're either getting to a step free station / using bus / using baby carrier etc. Sometimes being a parent means your journey is longer and yes there will always be those shitty situations where the lift is out and you have no choice , but as someone who uses a (now) crowded tube and train station, this is mostly just laziness.

AlternativePerspective · 22/11/2021 06:43

It's also too wide on tube escalators to allow others to safely pass. in fairness here, while I still don’t agree that people should take buggies on escalators, nobody needs to get past anyone on an escalator.

As a guide dog owner we specifically require people not to pass because if they stop at the end the dog may not have enough space to run off which could cause injury to the dog.

I was once sworn at by someone who felt it was his god-given right to get past me on an escalator. I very calmly said that I was very sorry, and that next time I would ask the station staff to stop the escalator for me so that I, and any others who wished, could walk up/down it. A process which would take about 10/15 minutes by the time permission is granted for the escalator to be stopped, a barrier is placed at the top/bottom to ensure people don’t get on while it’s being stopped, and the person is then able to walk up it.

To be fair most people are very understanding, but you do encounter these people from time to time.

CheeseMmmm · 22/11/2021 06:41

Your view is that anyone with a pushchair should also restrict themselves to stations that are accessible for those who use wheelchairs?

That's an interesting view.

AlternativePerspective · 22/11/2021 06:34

But we’re not talking about a handful of steps at tube stations! Get out of the tube at Highbury and Islington say, you have a couple of steps, but then there are escalators only! You wouldn’t get someone to help you up the emergency stairs (not even sure if you’re allowed up them anyway!). Most stations are so far underground you’d have to do 100 steps to get up and down there, especially the older lines. I have no idea how people in a wheelchair get about. they don’t. As a rule wheelchair users have to take roundabout routes through London, either via stations with lifts or on buses which have wheelchair accessible spaces. Although ironically the wheelchair spaces are often full of buggies who feel it’s their god-given right to be there.

CheeseMmmm · 22/11/2021 06:31

Loads of places escalator and stairs no lift.

ikeptgoing · 22/11/2021 06:25

There are little lifts provided although they should be easily accessible and in place

But no buggies on escalations same way I can't use my wheeled rolator in escalator nor take large wheeled suits adds on one. Not just for safety aspect for me but all those behind me if they fall when trying to negotiate sudden departure joint at top. It'd take out all those travelling up behind you.

It's really difficult as lifts can take ages to get a space on

CheeseMmmm · 22/11/2021 06:02

@dandydear

Sorry but I think anyone issuing an escalator with a buggy is hugely selfish and irresponsible.

It just takes one slip up or down for an accident.

It's also too wide on tube escalators to allow others to safely pass.

So better to take the stairs? Loads of stations no lift.
Simonjt · 22/11/2021 06:02

I used to fold mine and put it on my shoulder (it had a strap) and hold my son while we went down. I saw a pram get wedged in at the bottom once on the tube, a fairly frail couple were injured as they both feel when being constantly pushed against the pram by the escalator. For some reason the parents didn’t press the emergency stop for ages. If that pram had tipped over a glut of people would have fallen with it, that could have been very serious for both the baby and the couple at the front.

CheeseMmmm · 22/11/2021 06:01

Tube-

Up to 5 million journeys a day. Two million passengers.

In a year over 1.3 Billion passengers.

Escalator injuries-

The number of accidents on escalators identified in 1 above for each of the last three years;

Year 2016 2017 2018 Total
Total 1737 1808 2105 5650

That's total. The biggest reason is people being drunk. And for a whole year.

A massive risk? Get rid of them all?

If we're getting rid of something that causes massive harm then escalators don't make the list.. Cars would be number 1 I think.

eurochick · 22/11/2021 06:00

As others have said, it's absolutely standard on tube escalators so most Londoners will have done it many times without thinking twice.

As for banning them, should we ban suitcases on escalators too? I've seen a big full one come bouncing down the length of an escalator when someone let go. What about banning long coats or abayas? They could easily get caught.

dandydear · 22/11/2021 05:54

Sorry but I think anyone issuing an escalator with a buggy is hugely selfish and irresponsible.

It just takes one slip up or down for an accident.

It's also too wide on tube escalators to allow others to safely pass.

CheeseMmmm · 22/11/2021 05:40

Graphista-

One elderly woman and your view is human sized shredding machines? Happens all the time? So dangerous should all be removed?

That's a really good example of humans being poor at assessing risk.

For elderly people what about.. Going to shop when been snowing/ icy? Loads of broken hips. V big deal when elderly. That means.. should never go out in that weather? Pavement based serious injury zones? Degloving is most associated with motorbikes. I'm guessing you want them banned as well.

Tube, millions of people literally every day up and down escalators. If they were death traps then everyone would know. They would do something about it.

Without escalators the tube system would be essentially not fit for purpose. Tube is great. Your plan means even more crowded, queues for lift mean essentially no point trying at certain times. Way more people will need lift if no escalator. Plenty will give up and take stairs holding others up (more queues) and exposing themselves to more risk.

Loads of places have no lift so back to just stairs again. Yay?

Yerroblemom1923 · 22/11/2021 05:07

I just strapped my dd to me when we went to London when she was a baby. The hassle of putting up/down a pushchair was too much of a faff and obviously you can't take it on the escalators anyway.
We did invest in a cheap one from Mothercare that was v basic and you could put up/ down with one hand and was light to carry. That was handy for buses etc. But no, you don't take a buggy on an escalator with the child in it.

ReggaetonLente · 22/11/2021 04:37

I've done it when I've had to. It's all very well places 'forbidding' it but when they put the lift out of service, or just don't have one, I have to just haul it up. Not fun and I wouldn't do it if a lift was available though.