Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not understand how people don't learn?

132 replies

EdenFlower · 21/11/2021 19:20

A few weeks ago DH offered to make the mash to go with the dinner I was making. He made it in a non-stick pan using a metal masher- ruined the pan and the mash was grey and full of bits of the non- stick and we had to start again.

This weekend we have been talking about buying some new non-stick pans because at least one of them is now ruined.

Tonight, DH offers to peel the potatoes for the mash. I go into the kitchen and he's put the potatoes into the non-stick pan he ruined a few weeks ago. I say- "errr, don't you remember what happened last time?"
He says, "but I chose that because it's the biggest pan" (it's not)-
I say "but you can't mash in that pan"
He says "yes, but I'll put them in another pan to mash them"

Is there no learning? And where is the logic in that?
He's sulking now because I said "but that's pointless- why not just choose a pan you can cook them in and then mash in afterwards?"

How am I supposed to have patience with this shit? I feel Like I spend my life trunk to teach people stuff which they can't retain- DD is exactly the same- it takes years to learn a simple fact and apply it logically.

OP posts:
Scarlettpixie · 22/11/2021 14:17

If yiu had thrown away the pan after the coating came off last time, this wouldn’t have happened. If I saw someone reheating something in a pan where the coating was coming off, I would have a similar reaction to the one you did when you DH chose the pan (as in WTF?).

If you want to use metal utensils you really need stainless steel pans. If you insist on non stick pans, get some plastic ones. Problem solved.

FinallyHere · 22/11/2021 14:17

@madmomma

been trying to teach her the same simple things for well over ten years and she just doesn't absorb it at all.

In the absence of special needs, I'd suspect there was some learned incompetence going on here.

Are they all equally motivated?

I used to ignore anything my mother tried to teach me. I knew if I was sufficiently incompetent I would eventually be chucked out of the kitchen and sent to do homework. I much preferred homework to what I thought of as kitchen slavery.

The first time my mother visited me in my own flat, she was totally gobsmacked to discover I could cook and had actually taken in what interested me of what she tried to teach me.

Ring any bells?

PicassoInAtoolbox · 22/11/2021 13:44

Margot really doesn't like non stick pans! GrinGrin

MargosKaftan · 22/11/2021 13:06

I mean, you could flip it around OP, after the bit-filled mash, why didn't you learn that non-stick pans are generally an inferior product? Why did you insist on buying exactly the same rubbish pans that dont work with your utensils after you'd seen how rubbish they are and easily broken?

RavingAnnie · 22/11/2021 12:26

@BrilliantBetty

Well, I understand your frustration OP. My DH appears to the outside world like a fairly smart chap, I expect. He is in a professional job and well regarded. Knows a lot of stuff about certain things. But bloody hell some of the simple things at home he is just useless at, no common sense sometimes. The example you've given could be something my DH has done / would do. In fact we have just had a small row because he has washed poorly DC's sickroom bedding on a 30degree short cycle with no disinfectant. Who is now going to have to put it all back in and wash it properly.. me, I expect.
That's the sort of thing my DH would do. He also does a "big job". It's so frustrating. I have to try to second guess all the random things he might do and make sure I've told him not to do them before he starts. And remind him every time he does that job. He's also massively inconsistent so sometimes will do things perfectly, and then suddenly does something completely random.
BoredZelda · 22/11/2021 12:07

This is deliberate incompetence OP. It's something that men do so that you won't ask them to do it again.

Except he offered to do it in the first place. Or are you also suggesting men will offer to do something they haven’t been asked to do, just so they can do it badly in case you might ask them to do it again in the future? In which case, it seems you have had some very bad experiences wit men.

MargosKaftan · 22/11/2021 10:06

@spacerader - because the OP insists on non-stick pans, if you want not very good pans that need specific utensils, and have already had one ruined because the utensils you have dont work with them, then at the same time you pick a non-stick pan, you need to get the utensils.

But the bigger issue is that the OP felt it wasn't enough that her dh didn't ruin the new pan, he also had to cook entirely her way. She wouldn't use that pan for boiling potatoes so he was in the wrong. His solution was fine. I cant stand the sort of person who thinks there are only 2 ways to do things their way and the wrong way.

DappledThings · 22/11/2021 10:03

From the description he had a plan, which was to use a different pot to mash them in. OP may not have thought that was the best option, but that's how he planned to do it. He had learned from his mistake, and had a ready answer and a plan on how to avoid it. It's incredibly controlling to suggest it must only be done a certain way, even if that is the more obvious option.
Exactly. As long as he is then going to do the washing up of the unnecessary extra pan I don't get this issue

cookiemonster2468 · 22/11/2021 09:44

Because I am intelligent enough to remember said pan made grey mashe so assume other adult family members- especially the one who made the grey mash, would be also similarly intelligent enough to not make same mistake twice! Said pan is sevicible enough for a bit of reheating something or boilings stuff until we can afford to replace it for now

OK... but he was only going to boil the potatoes in that pan and then put them in another one to mash?

It's not the way you would do it but would work fine.

I think you are being overly controlling and critical.

I think you need to leave him to it and don't say anything until the finished result, which probably would have been absolutely fine. If it was grey again then fair enough - just throw the bloody pan out.

But just because he does it in a different way to you does not mean it's wrong.

Gohaveanap · 22/11/2021 09:27

I feel for you, OP. I have one of my own and we will be separating. I don’t think other people understand that this is just one small example in days filled with this kind of crap. It’s utterly exhausting to have to be ‘on’ all the time, and it’s very easy for others to say let him make the mistakes or forget things etc.when they aren’t the ones who are constantly missing out/being neglected/having to rectify the wrongs that result from this behaviour. Sorry you’re dealing with this.

Animood · 22/11/2021 06:47

@AlohaMolly

My 40 year old, lived on his own in a very tidy, organised house until he was 35, DP, asked me how to get the washing from the machine out to the line a few months ago.

The same week, he asked me how he should get his repeat prescription. He’s been on it for 20 years, lived on his own as mentioned above, and I’ve only put it in for him in the last year.

It’s absolutely a conscious decision on many men’s part, to be ridiculous.

This is so unsexy.

It's so very very unattractive.

aprilanne · 22/11/2021 02:14

Sorry op but if I had sent my husband for red jelly for an accompaniment for meat and he brought back a kids strawberry jelly pudding pot I just would have wet myself laughing I couldn't be angry because its so daft. Honestly

N0tfinished · 22/11/2021 02:12

@Clymene

This is deliberate incompetence OP. It's something that men do so that you won't ask them to do it again. It's why they can't operate washing machines

I don't blame you for being furious. Bet he wouldn't do it at work.

Agree. They do it because they don't believe they should have to do these awful menial jobs.
mizzmelli123 · 22/11/2021 02:10

Dear God!! Millions have died in the pandemic and you are fussing about mash? Get a grip! On a plastic masher and a new pan and do it yourself in future

PurpleSapphire · 22/11/2021 01:27

But...but...surely it should have been obvious in the FIRST place that you dont use metal utensils in a non stick pan?

Did no solution to the non stick pan/metal masher problem occur to him? Use a mixing bowl to mash? It's really not that difficult!

I'm with you on this one op Grin

immersivereader · 22/11/2021 01:24

This is not normal.

He must be really stupid.

^^ tell it like it is Grin

Bortles · 22/11/2021 01:23

I do agree OP that it's frustrating to have to do all the thinking, all the time.
Sometimes I do, 'just pretend I'm invisible for a few hours' or spend a very long time in the bathroom, but, without leaving him with orders, nothing happens.

immersivereader · 22/11/2021 01:21

This reminds me of the time I sent DH out for birthday bunting. He returned with muffin cases because that's all he could find... thought I'd said "birthday bun tins
^

Omfg dying
GrinWine

MobyDicksTinyCanoe · 22/11/2021 01:02

You sound hard work tbh...... And the fault lies with the person who bought a metal masher in the first place.

GodIsAVegan · 22/11/2021 00:24

But he said he was going to mash them in a different pan, so he had learnt. Do you mean you don’t believe that?

I’m presuming this isn’t the only thing he’s done that you feel makes him incompetent. Why are you with him then? If he’s useless, which I would have no time for, then get rid of him.

madmomma · 22/11/2021 00:21

I agree with the poster who said some people find it very hard to learn. I've seen this with my children,rather than my husband. Two of them learn from the first time you teach them something or correct them, the third, I've been trying to teach her the same simple things for well over ten years and she just doesn't absorb it at all. It's incredibly, incredibly frustrating.

PicassoInAtoolbox · 22/11/2021 00:20

My husband is the same OP. If I don't point out the obvious (like cleaning the tumble dryer filter so the house doesn't burn down) he doesn't do it, and if I do point out the obvious he says "I know that!" I feel your pain.

GertietheGherkin · 22/11/2021 00:15

@Luredbyapomegranate

Just let him make the mistake a few times then. He'll pick it up. Is this the first couple times he's cooked mash if your marriage - if so, why? if not, what happened before?

What's I notice is you're talking about your 16 year old daughter in the same way, which is OTT.

I made this same point in a post a bit further back.

It would seem the OP's husband has only just decided to start cooking or the OP has spent years and years having crap mash.

The fact that the OP described her Daughter as pretty useless too strongly suggests that the OP has been playing the martyr all these years and probably never let anyone do anything as she's the only one who can do it properly.

Now, she's creating because it's all being done wrong, and still exerting control by insisting it's all done her way.

She can't have it all ways, she's played her part in this situation. No point moaning now.

GreyhoundG1rl · 22/11/2021 00:11

@Clymene

And women on here - particularly on AIBU - think any man is better than no man.

It's pitiful how low they set the bar.

Jesus! Confused.
sbhydrogen · 22/11/2021 00:07

I .. I just... Non-stick pans. Metal. Come on, man.

Ruined food plus expensive pans they need replacing? I'd be pissed. YANBU.