Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Compulsory Vaccine - What does it mean?

287 replies

WheresYourIndicator · 21/11/2021 19:13

Sorry for posting in AIBU but I know most traffic is here.

So reading the latest news headlines, Austria and Germany are making vaccines compulsory.

Can someone explain what this actually means? What are the consequences if someone refuses to be vaccinated. I appreciate I may sound thick here so I apologise in advance.

I am double vaccinated myself and will be booking my booster for January but I strongly disagree with people being forced to take something they don't want. Surely it sets a precedent for the future. What will the government try to force next?
Scary times ahead!

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 21/11/2021 22:27

@Cheerychirpy

The chances of getting severe Covid or death are not 32% higher but 32 times higher. A massive difference.

I had a needle phobia until I got a life threatening disease, and I quickly realised how ridiculous I had been.

Yes, you obviously speak for everyone with a needle phobia. So we should all bow down to you, not.
hamstersarse · 21/11/2021 22:26

It is very well documented that obesity is a huge risk factor for taking an ICU bed

Some estimates are as high as 78% of hospitalisations see here

It’s strange that we don’t see that in the same way that we do unvaccinated people because yes, there may be some people who have medication related weight gain, but I am very sure the 67% of adults in the uk who are overweight / obese are not fat because of that. It’s poor eating, junk food for the most part…a choice, exactly the same as being unvaccinated
The only people I know who aren’t vaccinated are extremely fit people who have almost zero change of being hospitalised.
If you are obese and unvaccinated, that’s doubly dumb.

Cheerychirpy · 21/11/2021 22:25

The chances of getting severe Covid or death are not 32% higher but 32 times higher. A massive difference.

I had a needle phobia until I got a life threatening disease, and I quickly realised how ridiculous I had been.

alienbaby · 21/11/2021 22:24

@Mynameismargot
You need to do some more thinking

jailby · 21/11/2021 22:24

@Mynameismargot I was left on a trolley in 2014 and almost died because of it. Not sepsis but similarly life threatening situation that could have easily been prevented if I'd been seen quicker by the GP and taken to hospital earlier and not left in a corridor because they were rammed.

Why are people acting like this has never been a thing in the NHS until now?

Were you just not paying attention...?

It's shocking but covid is just exposing the problems that so many people have been experiencing for years. I'm trying to think of a single time anyone I know has had a good, quick, efficient, etc experience of the NHS and I can't. Waiting lists of 2 years, no GP appointments, being sent to the other side of the country for surgery, hours waiting on ambulances, post-natal care you wouldn't give to your dog.......

Mynameismargot · 21/11/2021 22:21

[quote alienbaby]@Mynameismargot
Yet two years ago you probably didnt give a shit about the number of emergency beds taken up by binge drinkers and drunken accident cases.[/quote]
There were beds there then, people weren't being denied treatment. I'm not sure what your point is really?

frumpety · 21/11/2021 22:20

And that is exactly why the NHS must treat everyone. No discrimination at all. Peoples lives are complex

And that is what the NHS is trying to do, but it is stretched resource wise and will be even more so over the next few months as we enter the season of usual Winter pressures.
Even before covid this was the case, but people rarely ask why ? Why is the NHS running at a unsafe bed capacity level for a quarter of the year ? What impact does that have on patient care during those months and the knock on effect that has when routine treatment has to be cancelled ?
Why were there limited beds or social care packages available for those people who are medically fit to be discharged but were unsafe to be discharged home by themselves pre pandemic ?
None of these issues are new.

alienbaby · 21/11/2021 22:17

@Mynameismargot
Yet two years ago you probably didnt give a shit about the number of emergency beds taken up by binge drinkers and drunken accident cases.

Anycrispsleft · 21/11/2021 22:17

If it wasn't for the people who are going to need emergency healthcare this winter for unrelated illnesses, I would say let it rip. We have had two hard lockdowns here in South Germany and we put up with it because it was the only way we could protect the vulnerable. But now we have the vaccine, we shouldn't need to. I'm not seeing my kids back under bloody house arrest, learning shit German off their English speaking mother again, just because there are people out there who could have the vaccine but are too selfish to do so.
Here in Germany the tendency is always to place a high value on the freedom and privacy of the individual, not least because of the history- the Nazis, and then the Stasi in the east. But I sense that the national mood is changing, and while I don't think we will end up with impflicht (for corona - the kids already have to be vaccinated against measles to go to school) I do expect that the unvaccinated will be more and more excluded from normal life.

jailby · 21/11/2021 22:17

I do think the obesity thing is a red herring

It's not a red herring in the context of posts like this though...

But they are still more likely to need hospital treatment than a vaccinated person of the same age and health.

The CDCs study on 150,000 patients who were hospitalised showed 80% of them were overweight or obese.

We're blaming a certain cohort now for taking up beds but this has been the case throughout the pandemic.

I'll state that I really, really do not care what other people do with their bodies - smoke, drink, deliberately overeat, that's your prerogative. But we can't just start sectioning off members of society and treating them like second class citizens. It's not right.

Everyone is looking for someone to blame but the truth is it's a virus. Best to worry about yourself imo.

Mynameismargot · 21/11/2021 22:15

The unvaccinated are playing Russian roulette with their lives but it's a choice and we should respect it. Those of us who are double vaccinated have nothing to fear.

Unless we need a transplant op and can't have it because there are no icu beds of course. A few months ago I needed emergency surgery and was in ICU with sepsis. I dread to think what would happen now. Oh wait I know exactly what would happen because the same situation happened to someone I know a few weeks ago, needed an op, got sepsis. Got no treatment for sepsis for 48hrs just left on a trolley, the only reason they got care is because they checked themselves into a private hospital. Luckily for them they had the funds to do that. I would probably be dead.

AJGranny · 21/11/2021 22:15

@samthebordercollie

You don't know how lucky you are in the UK. You have twice the infections daily and 5 x the Covid related deaths that we have in France, no social distancing, no vaccine passport and your PM doesn't give a shit. Is Europe panicking or is the natural immunity being built up in the UK the best way to go?
We are lucky because we have 5 times the Covid19 deaths? Are you aware of what you've typed here?
alienbaby · 21/11/2021 22:10

This is so incredibly fucked up. Of course we cant tell people what to do with their own bodies.

What if we enforced abortion past the first child on the basis that any more is harmful to society and the planet?

The unvaccinated are playing Russian roulette with their lives but it's a choice and we should respect it. Those of us who are double vaccinated have nothing to fear.

We are seeing an erosion of civil liberties veiled under the fig leaf of "the common good"

gulliblestravels · 21/11/2021 22:09

If we accept a drain on the state’s finances is a good enough reason to overrule body autonomy, do we accept forced abortion for those who cannot to keep the child, or perhaps forced sterilisation of persons on benefits? Perhaps euthanasia of persons who cannot pay care home fees? Do we make smear tests mandatory, fine or refuse treatment to those who won’t have them?
What happened to my body, my choice? Mandatory tattooing of the unvaxxed? Where does it end?

It cannot be that the vaccinated feel at risk of catching the virus, so it can only be that certain people are prepared to see another human’s bodily autonomy forcibly violated....because of money.

GodIsAVegan · 21/11/2021 22:06

there are a myriad of factors that effect peoples health.

And that is exactly why the NHS must treat everyone. No discrimination at all. Peoples lives are complex.

user1471443411 · 21/11/2021 22:04

I don't think some of these figures being quoted add up. Someone said you were 32% more likely to die of covid if unvaccinated? And ICUs were full of the unvaccinated. This may have been true months ago, when hardly anyone was classed as fully vaccinated, but I don't see how it can be true now.
For example, Waterford in Ireland. 100% of adults are vaccinated. Are the ICUs all full of children?
The rates per 100000 are presumably higher amongst the unvaccinated but I don't see how the absolute numbers can be. Fullfact did a fact check about this fullfact.org/health/economist-vaccination-status/

PurpleDaisies · 21/11/2021 22:03

But they are still more likely to need hospital treatment than a vaccinated person of the same age and health.

Yes, I totally agree but if you look at what I was responding to, you’ll see it needed pointing out.

GodIsAVegan · 21/11/2021 22:03

Not that I agree with fines or charging for treatment for anyone above paying their tax. It’s absurd. I was just making a point.

frumpety · 21/11/2021 22:03

I do think the obesity thing is a red herring, I am obese, although losing weight, because I work in healthcare and know that being obese potentially puts me at greater risk of complications, I have had all my vaccines. I haven't had covid yet despite looking after people who were symptomatically unwell with it.
Being obese isn't good for any of the systems in your body, it puts pressure on all of them, losing weight will be appreciated by all those various body systems, absolutely no doubt about that. The respiratory and vascular systems are particulary effected by covid and are already under significant strain if you are obese.
But health isn't as easy as obese = ill health and slim = good health, there are a myriad of factors that effect peoples health. Education, so knowing how to recognise worrying symptoms and knowing who to contact should you experience them, Social issues, so not being embarrassed by worrying symptoms and seeking help, Environmental issues, breathing in toxic car fumes is not good for your respiratory health, neither is living in damp conditions, Genetics, some people are dealt a shitty deal and no amount of healthy living is going to change that, Age , lets be honest the older your body gets the more likely it is to malfunction, stuff does simply wear out over time and cells can randomly end up dividing in malignant ways.
Obesity is one of the reasons people might become unwell with covid, but not the only reason.

Mynameismargot · 21/11/2021 22:02

Young unvaccinated people are still at lower risk of needing to go to hospital than some older vaccinated people.

But they are still more likely to need hospital treatment than a vaccinated person of the same age and health.

I just saw the stats there for covid icu beds in Ireland in October. 67% of patients were unvaccined, 3% partly vaccinated. That is 7 out of 10 people in covid ICU beds are not vaccinated. That 67% of patients come from the 7% of our adult population that aren't vaccinated. I'm no mathematician but those figures are shocking and completely avoidable by a free, easy to access vaccine. That strain that is being put on our health service that means that other peoples surgeries are being cancelled is down to the people that have chosen, for whatever reason they may have chosen, not to be vaccinated.

ILoveHuskies · 21/11/2021 22:02

@Dentistlakes

I’m pro vaccine but the idea of people being forced to be vaccinated gives me the chills. It will set a precedent for other things to be made compulsory and perhaps the removal of healthcare for other reasons (e.g lifestyle choices). Very worrying.
Same
GodIsAVegan · 21/11/2021 22:01

Obesity is an outcome of many medical conditions.

And if you read my post where I first mentioned this, you’ll see I wrote overweight/obese
(due to overeating) of similar.

Much obesity is caused by unhealthy lifestyles.

XenoBitch · 21/11/2021 21:57

A request to the unvaccinated: stop spreading diseases and stop spreading lies

I am unvaccinated, and not spreading any disease at all. I am also not spreading any lies.

XenoBitch · 21/11/2021 21:56

[quote Mantlemoose]@XenoBitch
I am obese because I took a drug to get a medical condition under control. A relatively new drug which I read had a high risk of cancer. My consultant assured me the risk was miniscule. I took the drug, I got cancer. The treatment put me into early menopause and the steroids massive weight gain. 5 years later I continue with long term effects of the cancer treatment. One of these effects reduces my mobility dramatically so I can't exercise properly. I eat normally and I have a sedentary office job. I walk my dogs daily as far as I can. I do couch exercises too. I'm still obese. That's my story.[/quote]
I am obese because of antipsychotic medication. If I did not take them,, I would be a further drain on the NHS.

Mantlemoose · 21/11/2021 21:54

@XenoBitch
I am obese because I took a drug to get a medical condition under control. A relatively new drug which I read had a high risk of cancer. My consultant assured me the risk was miniscule. I took the drug, I got cancer. The treatment put me into early menopause and the steroids massive weight gain. 5 years later I continue with long term effects of the cancer treatment. One of these effects reduces my mobility dramatically so I can't exercise properly. I eat normally and I have a sedentary office job. I walk my dogs daily as far as I can. I do couch exercises too. I'm still obese. That's my story.