Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Compulsory Vaccine - What does it mean?

287 replies

WheresYourIndicator · 21/11/2021 19:13

Sorry for posting in AIBU but I know most traffic is here.

So reading the latest news headlines, Austria and Germany are making vaccines compulsory.

Can someone explain what this actually means? What are the consequences if someone refuses to be vaccinated. I appreciate I may sound thick here so I apologise in advance.

I am double vaccinated myself and will be booking my booster for January but I strongly disagree with people being forced to take something they don't want. Surely it sets a precedent for the future. What will the government try to force next?
Scary times ahead!

OP posts:
Fossie · 22/11/2021 20:40

@SomewhereEast

I'm going to play the history PhD card and say that Covid isn't "unprecedented". It isn't even a particularly 'bad' pandemic in the grand scheme of history (Spanish Flu was much worse in all sorts of ways). In fact one reason why we find Covid so awful is that we're actually remarkably protected from infectious disease in the contemporary West, to a degree which would be unimaginable to people living even a century or two ago (and that's even with Covid circulating...it's actually much less brutal than typhoid / Scarlet Fever / cholera or a whole bunch of other things people used to routinely live alongside). I'm not complaining about this, but we'd probably benefit from a bit of perspective. We really aren't living through The Worst Thing Ever. In fact one reason why I'm uncomfortable with compulsion around vaccination is that I think we need to store up consent and goodwill around vaccines for The Much Worse Thing which could come along in the next few decades.
Yes. This.
Chocolatewheatos · 22/11/2021 14:52

@521Jeanie

Does Singapore have a better idea - to bill you for your healthcare if you're unvaccinated by choice and you end up in hospital needing treatment for Covid? I don't feel comfortable forcing people to have vaccines, but surely it's reasonable to say that with their choices come consequences? The NHS shouldn't have to be forking out thousands of pounds to save people who had been offered a free, simple vaccine which could have stopped them being admitted to hospital in the first case.
But then where does it end. Smoking, obesity, fighting, falling over drunk, extreme sports, less extreme sports. Most of the things people end up in hospital for they've had a hand in causing it. Bloody pregnancy!

Handing over rights to your body to the government is never going to end well. Do you trust your government with your body?

fournonblondes · 22/11/2021 14:25

Friend working in healthcare is worried he’ll lose his job because he doesn’t want to be vaccinated. He said he’s going to look for someone to get the vaccines for him. Am sure this will become a trend.

I really hope that people who attempt or do this go straight to jail.

IHateFlies · 22/11/2021 12:32

When I got covid, my only symptom was a severe 3 day headache. I’m so thankful that it only lasted 3 days so I really feel for you @Siriisatwat and believe that it could also be triggered by the vaccine.
Scientists aren’t gods and don’t know everything. There are differing opinions amongst them as well.

Siriisatwat · 22/11/2021 12:26

Both agreed I should not have the AZ again. But could only say that I should have another. They said their hands were tied with anything else.

Siriisatwat · 22/11/2021 12:25

An HCP can give an exemption if they believe there is a causal link. Those HCPs clearly can’t demonstrate that.

Not the ones I have spoken to. GP wouldn’t get involved as I am umber consultant care and two consultants have said they cannot, they can only say that I can have another make of vaccine.

Siriisatwat · 22/11/2021 12:17

@BoredZelda

Total coincidence that I came down with a 5 month long headache 12 hours after the AZ vaccine, despite never suffering from headaches before.

Could be. It happens.

Would have happened that day anyway, right?

Do you have a record of everything else that happened that day or that week? Any number of things could be the cause.

Every HCP I have seen said they have seen the same thing in other people after AZ who have come to them, but that they can’t give an exemption.

An HCP can give an exemption if they believe there is a causal link. Those HCPs clearly can’t demonstrate that.

No, I just have the record of the vaccine I took that sparked a headache 12 hours later that a lot of people, even on mumsnet, complained of, only mine has never gone away.

Why is it so hard to believe for a second that some people have lasting issues? Why the blind faith?

BoredZelda · 22/11/2021 12:11

Total coincidence that I came down with a 5 month long headache 12 hours after the AZ vaccine, despite never suffering from headaches before.

Could be. It happens.

Would have happened that day anyway, right?

Do you have a record of everything else that happened that day or that week? Any number of things could be the cause.

Every HCP I have seen said they have seen the same thing in other people after AZ who have come to them, but that they can’t give an exemption.

An HCP can give an exemption if they believe there is a causal link. Those HCPs clearly can’t demonstrate that.

GodIsAVegan · 22/11/2021 11:38

People who are overweight ("fatties" - how ignorant you sound) do not infect other people, they only damage (possibly) themselves.

Go and read all of my posts. Cos my point has gone whoosh, right over your head.

thenightsky · 22/11/2021 11:36

If that's what they choose, so be it.

So the rich get a choice, but the poor don't? Wow.

Florianus · 22/11/2021 11:31

@user1745

No healthcare professional will be required to give a vaccine without informed consent. In Austria nobody will be vaccinated against their will. They will be fined for refusal and, in extreme cases, if they refuse to pay the fine they will go to prison.

Is informed consent really informed consent if the only alternative is a fine or a prison sentence though?

If that's what they choose, so be it.
user1745 · 22/11/2021 11:24

No healthcare professional will be required to give a vaccine without informed consent. In Austria nobody will be vaccinated against their will. They will be fined for refusal and, in extreme cases, if they refuse to pay the fine they will go to prison.

Is informed consent really informed consent if the only alternative is a fine or a prison sentence though?

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 22/11/2021 10:50

isn't even a particularly 'bad' pandemic in the grand scheme of history (Spanish Flu was much worse in all sorts of ways)

There was some guy on TV the other night, saying if we projected Spanish flu figures into today’s population, it would be the equivalent of 250 million who died.

Florianus · 22/11/2021 10:49

@thenightsky

if they refuse to pay the fine they will go to prison.

And if they cannot afford to pay? The rich will pay, the poor will be thrown into jail?

If they cannot afford to pay the fine they should think again about refusing the vaccinations that more than 5 billion of the rest of us have had.
Lavender24 · 22/11/2021 10:40

@ItsSnowJokes

The Singapore analogy you can't use as Singapore charge for all treatment anyway. It was only covid that was treated for free.

I don't agree with mandatory vaccination, but would agree with restrictions for the unvaccinated. No holidays, no using public transport etc...... unworkable in practice probably but it would be better than mandatory vaccination.

No using public transport? Really? So how are people meant to get to work? Or should they not be allowed to work either? Should they be made to live on benefits or do you think they also shouldn't be allowed those? Therefore leading to poverty and crime?
SomewhereEast · 22/11/2021 10:28

@thenightsky

if they refuse to pay the fine they will go to prison.

And if they cannot afford to pay? The rich will pay, the poor will be thrown into jail?

Basically. It will have a massive socio-economic bias, and no doubt a racial bias given people of recent migrant /refugee origin are unsurprisingly less affluent on average.
SomewhereEast · 22/11/2021 10:20

@gofg

But we mustn’t treat the fatties like second class citizens, that’s a special thing reserved for unvaccinated people. Just no.

People who are overweight ("fatties" - how ignorant you sound) do not infect other people, they only damage (possibly) themselves.

Actually they do, in that they take up a disproportionate amount of healthcare resources. Ditto smokers, heavy drinkers, people who sex lives put them at greater risk of STIs etc etc. If we start dividing people with health needs into deserving / undeserving categories it's going to be very hard to stop. Also once governments learn that they can deflect frustration at healthcare inadequacies away from themselves and onto unpopular low status subgroups, they won't stop. So in Austria all the focus is on the unvaccinated, rather on asking how Austria ended up so much worse off than - say - England despite not-actually-much-lower vax rates
thenightsky · 22/11/2021 10:14

if they refuse to pay the fine they will go to prison.

And if they cannot afford to pay? The rich will pay, the poor will be thrown into jail?

SomewhereEast · 22/11/2021 10:13

I'm going to play the history PhD card and say that Covid isn't "unprecedented". It isn't even a particularly 'bad' pandemic in the grand scheme of history (Spanish Flu was much worse in all sorts of ways). In fact one reason why we find Covid so awful is that we're actually remarkably protected from infectious disease in the contemporary West, to a degree which would be unimaginable to people living even a century or two ago (and that's even with Covid circulating...it's actually much less brutal than typhoid / Scarlet Fever / cholera or a whole bunch of other things people used to routinely live alongside). I'm not complaining about this, but we'd probably benefit from a bit of perspective. We really aren't living through The Worst Thing Ever. In fact one reason why I'm uncomfortable with compulsion around vaccination is that I think we need to store up consent and goodwill around vaccines for The Much Worse Thing which could come along in the next few decades.

gofg · 22/11/2021 10:10

But we mustn’t treat the fatties like second class citizens, that’s a special thing reserved for unvaccinated people. Just no.

People who are overweight ("fatties" - how ignorant you sound) do not infect other people, they only damage (possibly) themselves.

MrsBillyNoJagNoMates · 22/11/2021 09:56

You have a choice as a vaccine refuser in Germany: either get the vaccine, or continue to refuse, but be denied entry to non-essential businesses and services. Nobody is deporting you, confiscating your property, burning your homes and businesses, attacking you violently, separating you from your loved ones. Nobody is systematically killing you.

@ ChaToilLeam Yet?

I think it’s valid fo compare to the nazis, but we are very early stages of it. It’s not history repeating itself fully, but it ‘might’ be beating the same drum. We always say we should learn from history, never forget, and there’s a reason why many people are so uncomfortable with what is seen as an overstep in powers.

@hamstersarse thank you for pointing this out
I grew up in country where loads of Jewish people died during WW2
I still vividly remember my grandma telling me when I was a little child how people were still ashamed to let that happen. She was a little girl herself in 1920's and 30's but loads of people in her generation lived there lives secretly ashamed of their inactivity in early stages

I suppose people living in England/UK for generations didn't grow up with this kind of message from past so can't understand that some people can be genuinely scared of history repeating itself - to some extent

Harriet1216 · 22/11/2021 09:48

@SeemingSeamstress

I cannot believe the human rights abuses and coercive control measures ordinary EU states are implementing and making even more severe. I fear for the future, this is beyond some of the worst sci fi / dystopia fiction . Completely beyond acceptable and future generations will judge us for it.
A bit hysterical, I think. A pandemic like Covid is unprecedented. Mandatory vaccination against it doesn't automatically equate to human rights abuse. If you think it is, where are the human rights of the thousands of people who have died from it or suffer from long covid? I couldn't wait to have my vaccinations and I'm grateful to all the scientists who made them possible.
Siriisatwat · 22/11/2021 09:47

Yeah, you are right.

Total coincidence that I came down with a 5 month long headache 12 hours after the AZ vaccine, despite never suffering from headaches before.

Would have happened that day anyway, right?

Every HCP I have seen said they have seen the same thing in other people after AZ who have come to them, but that they can’t give an exemption.

BoredZelda · 22/11/2021 09:38

I always ask on these threads what people think of me.

I had the first vaccine. Ended up in hospital shortly after. Under neurology. I’ve had a headache for months since the first one.

My consultant told me that I will not be able to get an exemption for a second. I asked for another opinion, was told the same. No exemptions, just a letter giving me “permission” to have another make of vaccine going forward.

I had the first one and a week later I started getting alopecia patches. Never had it before and it is immunity related. By the time I was due my second one, I had a 5 x 5 cm bald patch on my head and a few other smaller patches. It is only just growing back 9 months later. I checked yellow card and found only a small number of reported cases and concluded it was unlikely to have been the cause, it was simply a correlation. I have more patches now since the second and I’m due my booster next week. I spoke with the GP and the dermatologist who have confirmed it is unlikely to be the cause.

In your situation I would say if the consultant has refused an exemption, they have looked at your symptoms, and the data, and concluded the two aren’t linked.

In my situation I decided even if it was linked, having the vaccine was the better option, even if it meant me going bald, where I previously had lovely long thick hair. You are free to make whatever decision you wish in terms of the second vaccine, only you can assess what risk you are willing to take, but not being provided an exemption in your case doesn’t mean there is some kind of reluctance to give exemptions where side effects are impacting on people’s lives, which is the conclusion think people might want to draw from your situation.

Tobchette · 22/11/2021 09:36

On the German news right now, health minister emphasizes there will be no compulsory vaccine in Germany. Only for certain professions (potentially).

The word for duty is the same so later it is emphasized there is a social duty to get vaccinated but that's different from compulsory vaccination.

An interesting play on words: next year 3G will change from vaccinated, recovered, or tested to vaccinated, recovered, or dead.

Basically that you can't hide from the virus, you either get it and recover or you get it and die. The vaccine being the only exception to that rule.