Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Compulsory Vaccine - What does it mean?

287 replies

WheresYourIndicator · 21/11/2021 19:13

Sorry for posting in AIBU but I know most traffic is here.

So reading the latest news headlines, Austria and Germany are making vaccines compulsory.

Can someone explain what this actually means? What are the consequences if someone refuses to be vaccinated. I appreciate I may sound thick here so I apologise in advance.

I am double vaccinated myself and will be booking my booster for January but I strongly disagree with people being forced to take something they don't want. Surely it sets a precedent for the future. What will the government try to force next?
Scary times ahead!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MRex · 26/11/2021 09:09

What a load of waffle. You posted fake news, the people who supposedly gave the information have said they did not and it's lies. Drop the conspiracy sources from your social media, there are more than enough real problems in the world and it's not good for you nor anyone else's mental health to sit about fretting over imagined events.

Ecina · 26/11/2021 08:35

I won't @ as I feel it lends to a tone I don't want to take. But there are overarching issues here which I would urge people to think about.
Whenever two contrasting pieces of evidence are considered, it is tempting to narrow focus (how many times does a PP argue against a point by simply saying 'are you a virologist?'!) but in febrile David and Goliath arguments, it is wrong to ignore the structural power relationships which colour the views of the majority.
So in the example of anthropogenic climate change, we seem finally to have reached a point where people at least pretend to care. That is a success for those of us who have battled for decades, but think of the way in which key figures are still treated by some: Greta Thunberg is always presented by those fighting to hold on to their power as a puppet, someone used to spread fear and false information. She is just the latest tool in a smear campaign which started with the 'hockey stick' graph - the argument being 'this one thing is wrong therefore all of it is wrong' - and carried on through the 'academics are paid to say this so can't be trusted'.
These views still exist, and in a substantial minority.
That is because those peddling them have a great deal more power and money than those they oppose, and it should not come as a shock that the media is complicit.
This is understandable at this end point of capitalism because media has to make money and some groups have more money than others. Most media will channel the cognitive dissonance of their audience, so eg will pretend to care about climate change but manipulatively link energy price rises to the 'green agenda'.
Or take the #metoo movement. Again, like climate change, the basic premise is now accepted: women tend to be believed. But that is recent, and secrets were kept for so long, again, because of the structural power relationships in play and enabled by the media.
Governments, global corporations, oligarchs, the rich and the powerful are not always on the right side of history. It is uncomfortable to human beings to fully accept that (as opposed to paying lip service to it) because we are herd animals and we need to be able to trust leaders - our equivalent of the gorilla silver back - to protect us.
However hard it is, it needs to be done. The growth of inequality over the last 20 years has been hastened disastrously over the last 20 months, where the largest ever transfer of power and wealth from poor to rich has been taking place at a rate and in a way that is still almost unimaginable. When the dispossessed speak against a prevailing narrative, all of us should be open to the possibility that there could be a grain of truth in what they say.

MRex · 25/11/2021 17:18

Might be a good idea to change some of your sources @Ecina, it looks like you're being fed false news.

PAFMO · 25/11/2021 16:58

[quote MRex]@Ecina - can you provide a link about Australia doing that please?[/quote]
www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2021/nov/25/tinfoil-hat-wearing-tossers-nt-chief-minister-and-aboriginal-elders-hit-back-at-covid-false-information

Needless to say. Wink

Ecina · 25/11/2021 15:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

MRex · 25/11/2021 15:23

@Ecina - can you provide a link about Australia doing that please?

Ecina · 25/11/2021 15:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

IHateFlies · 25/11/2021 15:02

Obviously, that’s down to vaccination but even at the height of covid, the majority of people were still recovering at home.
Those with comorbidities were at much higher risk of hospitalisation than those without.

IHateFlies · 25/11/2021 14:53

The rate of covid patients that are hospitalised is 7.57 per 100,000 people (in the week ending 14 November 2021 From Office of National Statistics)
I’m not trying to downplay it and at different times the number may be higher. The majority of people recover without being hospitalised.

MuscariMuguet · 25/11/2021 13:25

IHateFlies
A slim healthy unvaccinated person is unlikely to need hospital treatment if they get covid. An obese person is more likely to need hospital treatment, possibly even if they are vaccinated
I'd rather go by what an actual nhs respiratory consultant says about who is in ICU with covid. Answer- unvaccinated people. www.theguardian.com/world/2021/nov/21/icu-is-full-of-the-unvaccinated-my-patience-with-them-is-wearing-thin?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

Or you could look at French figures if you prefer

Compulsory Vaccine - What does it mean?
LuaDipa · 25/11/2021 12:49

@IHateFlies

A slim healthy unvaccinated person is unlikely to need hospital treatment if they get covid. An obese person is more likely to need hospital treatment, possibly even if they are vaccinated.
I know a 37 year old who died earlier this year. She was unvaccinated but it was prior to vaccinations being widely available. She was slim and well. It was a complete and utter shock to her poor family who had of course assumed that she would be fine, even when she was admitted to hospital.

I don’t approve of compulsory vaccination but all of this nonsense about Covid only affecting obese people or those with underlying health conditions is bullshit.

Alondra · 24/11/2021 11:00

Answering the original post...

It means losing jobs, fines and being in lockdown for anything that's not basic - shopping for food, pharmacy and hospital.

The more people fight vaccination in the name of "personal choice" during a global health pandemic, the more countries are going to eventually make the vaccine compulsory.

I live in NSW (Australia) and we have 92% fully vaccinated over 16 and 76% over 12-15 years old. Our daily cases are between the high 100s and low 200s and we have a Covid passport. If a person is unvaccinated they can't go to restaurants, pubs or any shops that are not essential like shopping for clothes or shoes or TVs etc.

Work places are tightening the rules against the unvaccinated. A friend who made the choice not to have the vaccine has until February to do so, after that, she will let go. She's not working for government, she works in a private company without fronting public.

I said before and I will repeat again, that human rights are a political construct. We don't have them - just like people in Ethiopia don't have them. They can be taken away at any time during an exceptional public health emergency.

The more people see having a jab as a two second necessity when our economies, jobs and freedom movement depend on it, the less it will be necessary to make Covid vaccination compulsory.

It depends on us.

MRex · 24/11/2021 10:32

The NHS is and should be free, with treatment based on need. I don't care what Singapore does, but you won't have hospitals here turning people away who can't pay but need emergency care. It's a disgraceful suggestion that they should pay for their care, that's what taxes are for. My taxes get used for people having lots of children, for drunken injuries, for smoking-induced lung cancer and a raft of other "choices", limitation of services for citizens is not a good road to travel.

DickMabutt73962 · 24/11/2021 10:02

@XenoBitch

Yeah, if we do go anywhere with this, I'd say this was the best way to pay for the extra care we'll need

How will someone that is on a low income pay for their Covid treatment? Or will they be left to die?

They can pay for it in vaccination. Not saying I agree, but pointing out that there is an option.
MRex · 24/11/2021 09:53

The 1918 influenza pandemic virus had an R0of 1.80 (interquartile range: 1.47 to 2.27). That's lower than the R0 of any variant of covid and means it was less infectious.

TheElvishQueen · 24/11/2021 09:43

How do you know Covid is more transmissible than Spanish flu?

BoredZelda · 24/11/2021 09:41

In fact one reason why we find Covid so awful is that we're actually remarkably protected from infectious disease in the contemporary West, to a degree which would be unimaginable to people living even a century or two ago (and that's even with Covid circulating...it's actually much less brutal than typhoid / Scarlet Fever / cholera or a whole bunch of other things people used to routinely live alongside).

I understand the sentiment, but talking about things which happened centuries ago and suggesting we take off our modern lens is misjudged. Perspective can only happen when we use our lived experiences. We have proper healthcare which means those diseases are not a risk. When something comes along which threatens our healthcare services, the outcome is as bad as a cholera outbreak a hundred years ago. Arguably if Covid had been around in 1918, far more people would have died than they did from Spanish Flu because it is far more transmissible.

TheElvishQueen · 23/11/2021 23:21

@SomewhereEast

I'm going to play the history PhD card and say that Covid isn't "unprecedented". It isn't even a particularly 'bad' pandemic in the grand scheme of history (Spanish Flu was much worse in all sorts of ways). In fact one reason why we find Covid so awful is that we're actually remarkably protected from infectious disease in the contemporary West, to a degree which would be unimaginable to people living even a century or two ago (and that's even with Covid circulating...it's actually much less brutal than typhoid / Scarlet Fever / cholera or a whole bunch of other things people used to routinely live alongside). I'm not complaining about this, but we'd probably benefit from a bit of perspective. We really aren't living through The Worst Thing Ever. In fact one reason why I'm uncomfortable with compulsion around vaccination is that I think we need to store up consent and goodwill around vaccines for The Much Worse Thing which could come along in the next few decades.
Yes, absolutely this!
BoredZelda · 23/11/2021 22:08

Six months ago we were worrying about having the AZ vaccine because of the clot risk.

Six months ago some were worrying about AZ because of an over hyped media storm about a tiny number of possibly linked side effects. Then governments had no choice but to take unnecessary action to make people feel they were being protected.

3.3 billion fully vaccinated people and another billion have had a single dose. People aren’t dropping like flies because of it. How much evidence do people need that there is minimal risk from the vaccine?

I wonder how many people citing facts and figures about deaths “from the vaccine” are the same ones who have been downplaying the numbers of “deaths from Covid”

tttigress · 23/11/2021 22:05

I'm not really sure how enforceable this will be.

Could be a phycological tactic, tell everyone they have to get jabbed, a certain percentage will completly, them nearer the date cancel the initiative.

BoredZelda · 23/11/2021 21:57

No, I just have the record of the vaccine I took that sparked a headache 12 hours later that a lot of people, even on mumsnet, complained of, only mine has never gone away.

That’s exactly the point. You did one big thing that day so made a correlation when there could be a dozen things that triggered it.

Why is it so hard to believe for a second that some people have lasting issues? Why the blind faith?

I don’t have blind faith, I check the actual data and look at the actual information and draw conclusions.

Why the blind faith that is HAS to be the vaccine, and why not do what your own consultants suggest and have a different second one? Or do you know more than they do?

Both agreed I should not have the AZ again. But could only say that I should have another. They said their hands were tied with anything else.

Because on the information they have, there is no reason to give an exemption. Not because they think it’s a problem.

Scientists aren’t gods and don’t know everything. There are differing opinions amongst them as well.

Do you know how science works. Of course scientists don’t know everything. If they did, they would stop. But they do know more than Linda who read something on Facebook that her auntie shared.

ColinTheKoala · 23/11/2021 10:34

If they cannot afford to pay the fine they should think again about refusing the vaccinations that more than 5 billion of the rest of us have had

The vaccine is neither 100% safe nor 100% effective. You cannot force someone to have something injected into them that may kill them. Or make them seriously ill. The risks are low but I am not going to tell someone else what to do. I also hope that the Austrian government has robust vaccine damage compensation legislation in place. Remember people have died after having the vaccine. Yes, many many more have died from the illness but the vaccine is not risk-free and I am fed up with people rewriting history. Six months ago we were worrying about having the AZ vaccine because of the clot risk.

ColinTheKoala · 23/11/2021 10:30

@GodIsAVegan

People who are overweight ("fatties" - how ignorant you sound) do not infect other people, they only damage (possibly) themselves.

Go and read all of my posts. Cos my point has gone whoosh, right over your head.

They (and other people who do things knowing they are injurious to their health) take up resources that could be employed for people who do look after themselves but get ill through no fault of their own.

However, it's where you stop with that line of argument.

anon2334 · 23/11/2021 09:39

@fournonblondes

Friend working in healthcare is worried he’ll lose his job because he doesn’t want to be vaccinated. He said he’s going to look for someone to get the vaccines for him. Am sure this will become a trend.

I really hope that people who attempt or do this go straight to jail.

I tell you those that go jail and stand trial will be those pushing vaccines on those That don’t want it. You are a free human being and how dare anyone push a crap vaccine done in less than a year on anyone. Thank God we have people speaking out even though there are at time being censored. We aren’t having so be prepared to see who really goes to jail when this is over . History comes about again. Not anti vax here mumsnet had all jabs but this one bag! Too many lies, manipulative coercive behaviour that doesn’t sit right with many of us.
RAFHercules · 22/11/2021 21:39

@521Jeanie

Does Singapore have a better idea - to bill you for your healthcare if you're unvaccinated by choice and you end up in hospital needing treatment for Covid? I don't feel comfortable forcing people to have vaccines, but surely it's reasonable to say that with their choices come consequences? The NHS shouldn't have to be forking out thousands of pounds to save people who had been offered a free, simple vaccine which could have stopped them being admitted to hospital in the first case.
Completely agree.
Swipe left for the next trending thread