Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be a bit wtf at this home bargains christmas jumper?

341 replies

Effinell · 21/11/2021 18:33

I seen this when I was in store today and it just didn't sit right with me. I do have a neurodiverse DD so that might be colouring my view slightly.

To be a bit wtf at this home bargains christmas jumper?
OP posts:
saraclara · 21/11/2021 23:56

Tantrums have a goal and can be stopped willingly. Most people grow out of tantrumming once they can understand and communicate.

No they don't. Most two year olds having a tantrum can't just stop. Certainly my Dd couldn't. Screaming because they can't have some chocolate and stopping when you give it to them is one thing, but many toddlers don't operate that way at all. They are simply overwhelmed in the same way that an older child with autism is.

A child who is NT does grow out of them as their communication improves, (and many of my autistic pupils also had far fewer meltdowns as our work on their communication came to fruition). But while the effects of an older ND child's meltdowns are much worse and more dramatic and difficult to manage), the emotions behind them are not so different from some 2 year olds'.

Porcupineintherough · 21/11/2021 23:44

@HonestwithHope1 in order to change the meaning of a word or phrase you need the whole of society to agree. What doesnt work is a small group co opting a phrase then getting in a strop that the rest of society doesnt just fall in line.

GreyhoundG1rl · 21/11/2021 23:37

we have started using meltdown to refer to ND/Disabled peoples ... Responses
But not exclusively.

HonestwithHope1 · 21/11/2021 23:35

@22:40BertramLacey

Haha oh hun. But that isn't what's being discussed. This thread has turned into non disabled/neurotypicalpeople moaning that language dare change and that there's an adequete word to describe something that ... Previously didn't have a word due to these people being isolated from society and not ever seen.

It's simple

Tantrum: something small children do in moments of frustration, not having communication skills to explain, lacking emotional regulation skills due to immaturity wanting something

Something a spoiled adult can throw for effect, manipulation, to get own way ect

Tantrums have a goal and can be stopped willingly. Most people grow out of tantrumming once they can understand and communicate.

Meltdown: something only neurodivergent/disabled people do. It is for most part uncontrollable and can lead to disproportionate responses, self harm ect. Meltdowns can be 'triggered' by anything that overwhelmes, frightens ect a person. Once in a meltdown, it cannot be stopped. The person themselves 'burns out' temporarily dus to meltdown and some people may not actually remember* their meltdown

There's more to it but that's the basics. So yeah. The ableistic attitude towards ND/Disabled people daring to appropriate a word is ableistic.

@saraclara

And i'm now terribly confused. How on earth can you use gay-happy example.... When I'm here saying

In modern times we have started using meltdown to refer to ND/Disabled peoples ... Responses. Not tantrum

We started using that word professionally and soccially because disabled people/ND are now more present in society and we needed an adequate word to describe. See above for diff definitions and why tantrum wouldn't be appropriate

You yourself seem to agree words change with meaning/context and change who uses them in what situation so i honestly don't know wtf you are on about ...

Cocomarine · 21/11/2021 23:32

Gay and Meltdown aren’t really comparable in terms of where they are in stages of language use changing.

Gay predominantly means homosexual to most people now, and even a dictionary will tell you that the happy meaning is outdated.

Whereas from the same dictionary, meltdown in the autism use isn’t in the first 2 definitions.

Not claiming that this one dictionary is definitive on current language use… but I do think it’s a fair example.

Maybe in a few years time meltdown will primarily be associated with specific behaviour related to autism. At that point, maybe we should look for other words. But today, that is not the case. In fact, perhaps those with autism will decide that they don’t like the term, because of the association with disaster and tantrum - and will prefer a better term. When I was a child, even the Spastics society used the word “spastic” - it’s completely unacceptable now. Perhaps those with autism will choose not to use the word meltdown 🤷🏻‍♀️

To be a bit wtf at this home bargains christmas jumper?
To be a bit wtf at this home bargains christmas jumper?
saraclara · 21/11/2021 23:09

@HonestwithHope1 would you still describe something cheerful and fun as 'gay'? I grew up with that, then at some point had to find synonyms because it no longer worked.

saraclara · 21/11/2021 23:07

[quote HonestwithHope1]@saraclara

So you have the same attitude towards other words and meanings... Yes?[/quote]
You have to. Of course you do.

Sometimes it's annoying, of course, if a word you use often is lost from your vocabulary because it's appropriated elsewhere. But English has always done this. presumably you've read stuff written 100/200/300 years ago?

GreyhoundG1rl · 21/11/2021 22:52

[quote HonestwithHope1]@saraclara

So you have the same attitude towards other words and meanings... Yes?[/quote]
Confused

HiJenny35 · 21/11/2021 22:48

I think professional need to take some responsibility here. Meltdown was a long accepted term used by society not in reference to autism, we've only been using it widely in this way for the last 10 years and it really isn't helpful. When things are so important to a community they should use the medical term or a new term to describe them, using an established term only causes resentment on both sides, as seen here. Brainstorm for example was established for years in both work and education, in around 2004 we were told not to use it anymore because it could be offensive to nd communities, it was suggested we use thought shower instead.

Couchbettato · 21/11/2021 22:43

I imagine if I was a sentient snow man, and the temperature was constantly above melting point, and I was having an existential crisis I would definitely have a meltdown.

I'm ND, but I do see the humour in this jumper.

I would wear it.

HonestwithHope1 · 21/11/2021 22:42

@saraclara

So you have the same attitude towards other words and meanings... Yes?

PinkSyCo · 21/11/2021 22:40

Yeah you need to chill, much like the snowman on that jumper does OP.

saraclara · 21/11/2021 22:40

I do understand, though, when people get upset at the use of expressions such as 'totally OCD' to describe someone who, say, likes their books in alphabetical order, as Obsessive Compulsive Disorder is a recognised medical condition. Using this expression minimises the seriousness of OCD. But 'meltdown' is simply a description. Nobody owns it.

Exactly.

Over and over and over again, it's been explained that meltdown, both in the nuclear sense and in the 'losing it' sense has been around for far longer than autism has been a diagnosis. And those of us who've been in the field since the early days can pretty much pinpoint when it started being used informally to differentiate an autistic response, from a toddler response to stress and overwhelming emotion.

But the point in time when it started being used that way did not signify that the word was now owned by the autistic community. Language changes.
I get that if you have an autistic child of school age you'll have heard the word used specifically for people with autism since you started on this journey. But it's not formal, it doesn't define the word in any way, and just as the language developed into using the word in this way, it's continuing to develop and expand into the neurotypical community. And that's okay.

You can't build a fence around the word and claim that it's yours.

BertramLacey · 21/11/2021 22:40

Please please kindly educate yourself

Honestly the ableism on this site is weird.

There's nothing ableist about pointing out the etymology of the word 'meltdown'. It initially referred to the melting of metal. It was then used by ice-cream manufacturers to describe the rate at which ice-cream liquefies. By the 1950s it was used to describe meltdowns in nuclear reactors. It has been used broadly synonymously with tantrum until the last 10-15 years when it has been given a more specific meaning. But you can't just erase the past meanings of the word or stop people using it.

I know what an autistic meltdown is. I'm not offended by people using the word 'meltdown' in other contexts. The jumper is tacky and nasty, but it's not ableist.

HonestwithHope1 · 21/11/2021 22:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Marcipex · 21/11/2021 22:36

RockNRollMartian
People have been using the term "meltdown" long before it was ever associated with autism. Sorry if it offends someone, but that's just life!

That’s true.

GreyhoundG1rl · 21/11/2021 22:30

I remember being told a few years ago to not use the term "brainstorm".
Seriously? That term has been in use in a business / creative sense since forever. Why is it suddenly verboten?

All this policing of language and claiming offence at words that have been in common usage for aeons gets right on my tits.

HalfCakeHalfBiscuit · 21/11/2021 22:26

@HonestwithHope1 agree with you. A tantrum is an uncontrolled outburst of anger and frustration, typically in a young child.

A meldown is an accident in a nuclear reactor in which the fuel overheats and melts the reactor core or shielding. This can result in thousands of deaths and a large area becoming uninhabitable. This word being used in any other context is massively offensive.

Lindy2 · 21/11/2021 22:25

My daughter has ASD.

I find the jumper quite funny.

Clearly the jumper isn't referring to an autistic person it is using a word to make a funny pun on a Christmas jumper.

Why take offense when none is meant? I don't have the time or energy to be so easily and unnecessarily upset.

AnkleDeep · 21/11/2021 22:25

@HonestwithHope1

People! your neurotypical child is having a tantrum most commonly because they are little and cannot either/both, communicate/emotionally regulate as efficiently as adults, leading them to be overwhelmed and tantrumning.

When they learn how to handle emotion/communication tantrums become lesser... Obviously

Huge 100% difference between that and a meltdown

Please please kindly educate yourself

Honestly the ableism on this site is weird.

Person!

You are the one in need of education. The origin of the usage has been explained several times.

You may not like the truth but you're stuck with it. Meltdowns have been used to describe behaviour for a lot longer than autism has been recognised.

That's just the way it is.

GreyhoundG1rl · 21/11/2021 22:24

Please please kindly educate yourself
Oh, stop it Hmm

DontTellThemYourNamePike · 21/11/2021 22:23

Well, considering that the word 'meltdown' isn't a medical term, I can't get too worked up about its appearance on a comedy jumper.

I do understand, though, when people get upset at the use of expressions such as 'totally OCD' to describe someone who, say, likes their books in alphabetical order, as Obsessive Compulsive Disorder is a recognised medical condition. Using this expression minimises the seriousness of OCD. But 'meltdown' is simply a description. Nobody owns it.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 21/11/2021 22:23

@RockNRollMartian

People have been using the tern "meltdown" long before it was ever associated with autism. Sorry if it offends someone, but that's just life!
This is true.

I think the use of meltdown in relation to autism is useful to describe the difference from a NT child having a tantrum, however it is not a word I ever remember being used until fairly recently. When my son was diagnosed in the mid 1990s it wasn't a term anyone used to describe his behaviours.

HonestwithHope1 · 21/11/2021 22:20

People! your neurotypical child is having a tantrum most commonly because they are little and cannot either/both, communicate/emotionally regulate as efficiently as adults, leading them to be overwhelmed and tantrumning.

When they learn how to handle emotion/communication tantrums become lesser... Obviously

Huge 100% difference between that and a meltdown

Please please kindly educate yourself

Honestly the ableism on this site is weird.

HalfCakeHalfBiscuit · 21/11/2021 22:16

@Mandarinsatsuma

I agree with you. A proper meltdown is incredibly upsetting. People are just a bit ignorant, like how it would previously be seen as acceptable to have a tshirt saying "I'm mental."

They'd probably appreciate the feedback tbh.

Too right it is upsetting. A proper meltdown means thousands of deaths, hundreds of thousands of people being evicted from their homes at a moments notice and thousands of square miles of Eastern Europe being uninhabitable for hundreds of years.

It is a term that has been appropriated by ignorant people