Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be a bit wtf at this home bargains christmas jumper?

341 replies

Effinell · 21/11/2021 18:33

I seen this when I was in store today and it just didn't sit right with me. I do have a neurodiverse DD so that might be colouring my view slightly.

To be a bit wtf at this home bargains christmas jumper?
OP posts:
neondino · 23/11/2021 02:00

@TyphooMary

Ableist folks like those on this thread are why I have to specify 'autistic meltdown' instead of just saying meltdown.

Even then, folks who aren't neurodivergent still don't understand.

I am 39. I experience both autistic meltdown and autistic shutdown.

Neither are funny. Both involve a distressing lack of control. Frightening, distressing, embarrassing, shaming, soul destroying - these are all things other neurodivergent folk like myself feel about actual meltdowns.

A toddler tantrum might seem the perfect behaviour to describe with the term meltdown, but it very much is not the same. Similarities in places like reasons for, and processes, but they still are not the same.

The jumper would be something my two autistic children and my autistic self could laugh about between us, but I very much would not wish to encourage NT friends or strangers to join in on that because it's not appropriate.

I'm ND but not with autism. So am I ableist for saying autistic meltdown to differentiate from my ND meltdown that presumably presents very differently, and requires a different response, to yours? Or do you accept that actually, the word meltdown has different meanings, and that could maybe include non-medical ones?

FWIW I'd love this jumper, because when I'm not in the midst of a meltdown I like to try to make light of my meltdowns so they're not as scary - the whole taking-away-power thing. My therapist would very much approve of me finding something silly to focus on to help with that. I'd very much use this to prompt discussion about my condition with others.

saraclara · 22/11/2021 21:14

@Ivchangedmynameforthis

I work with autistic children and we are not allowed to use the term meltdown in relation to their behaviour. So this jumper wouldn't offend me or any of my young people in the slightest.
I'm recently retired from a long career teaching severely autistic children so a bit out of date on things already. I'd be really interested to know what the reason for that decision is. Not that I disagree with it at all, I'm just curious.
GodIsAVegan · 22/11/2021 21:00

She could certainly say the same about you

I said I wouldn’t use the word from now on. She felt the need to question that even though I hadn’t said anyone else needed to change their language, just that I was going to. I explained my reasoning and got called ‘hun’ and ‘loled’ at. But yeah, I’m the difficult one. 🤷🏻‍♀️

GreyhoundG1rl · 22/11/2021 20:56

If you act like this in real life, I don’t think people will want to be around you.
She could certainly say the same about you with more justification

GodIsAVegan · 22/11/2021 20:51

what part of my last post made you think I was in the slightest bit bothered by your choice?! Read it again

You picked up on my earlier post saying I was choosing to not use the word again and took issue with me saying it. It was my choice, I didn’t say others shouldn’t.
Then you replied to my explantation with ‘hun’. Yeah, you’re really not bothered or triggered by this at all. 🙄

If you act like this in real life, I don’t think people will want to be around you.

JMKid · 22/11/2021 20:38

Can't people take it for what it is. The snowman is melting down. Why has there always got to be more to it!!

shouldistop · 22/11/2021 20:31

I understand where you're coming from but if you Google the definition of meltdown then nothing about ASD is mentioned in the first result anyway. So maybe it's not widely known.

SecretKeeper1 · 22/11/2021 20:29

I didn't know meltdown was linked to autism either, but with that fact in mind I'd be more concerned if the image on the jumper was an upset or angry child.

It's a fucking snowman. They melt.

LowlandLucky · 22/11/2021 20:20

RumpoleoftheBaileys If you shake a tree it rustles,

Ivchangedmynameforthis · 22/11/2021 20:20

I work with autistic children and we are not allowed to use the term meltdown in relation to their behaviour. So this jumper wouldn't offend me or any of my young people in the slightest.

Inastatus · 22/11/2021 20:16

@GodIsAVegan

ok Hun, you do you, lol.

Why is it that you have an issue with OP trying to police peoples language but you think it’s ok to try to police mine? I’m not going to use the word again, that’s my choice. It’s weird that you’re so bothered by my choice. 🤡

@GodIsAVegan - what part of my last post made you think I was in the slightest bit bothered by your choice?! Read it again 🤓
Moulesvinrouge1 · 22/11/2021 20:12

@Innocenta thank you, and not at all! Hope you are doing ok too and sorry you are suffering ableism Flowers Cake

Moulesvinrouge1 · 22/11/2021 20:10

@Innocenta

Also, if you experience 'daily' ableism, I'm very surprised that your response to me presumed I wasn't disabled.
I’m very sorry if it came across that way, I was in no way assuming you were not disabled, but I was assuming (apologies) that because it wasn’t deemed offensive by some disabled people that that made it ok. What I was trying to get across is that people will find it upsetting or not but that doesn’t necessarily relate to their own level of disability, just their own attitude towards the distress of an autistic meltdown. We’ve had ND people on here saying they love it. Other ND people saying they don’t. Not trying to summarise, was just trying to say some people find it upsetting, which I tend to think makes it a bit of a shit Christmas jumper is all.
KarmaStar · 22/11/2021 20:08

Really?Confused ridiculous

Innocenta · 22/11/2021 20:07

[quote Moulesvinrouge1]@Innocenta thanks for your response, and apologies for confusion caused. My ‘them’ was intended to describe the people who thought this was a ridiculous thing to make a fuss about, rather than their status as ND or disabled, but I can see how it would read both ways.[/quote]
No worries, I'm sorry for my snappish reply! Hope you're doing okay Thanks

Darkpheonix · 22/11/2021 20:06

I totally agree with you - I don’t think the jumper is deliberately making fun of autistic meltdowns. But the fact that there is a thread about it means it’s upsetting to some people who are either affected by autistic meltdowns or feel empathetic to their upset. The jumper slogan has made light of something that some people feel is really debilitating. That’s why we’re all talking about it, surely.

However, just because some people find something offensive or triggering, Doesn't mean its offensive.

I find the 'be kind' slogan offensive. For many reasons. Including that people who are ND often get the shitty end of that stick. But also because it's incredibly sexist. It's only ever said to women. Men aren't expected or told to be kind.

Its also something my abusive ech would say to me if I stood up for myself. I wasn't 'kind' to him.

Again, that doesn't mean it can't be used. It doesn't mean some people can't like it. It doesn't mean that some people won't get why I dislike it. Some people love the message.

Just because someone finds something offensive or triggering, it doesn't mean they are right and that it should disappear.

Imo, if ypu know someone who is upset by it, you should be trying to explain that that word is not exclusive to the ND community and it is nor aimed at them. As people have done here.

This thread shows that quite a lot of people believe, incorrectly, that it is a medical term and/or exclusive to the ND community. Thata where the problem is, imo.

One poster even said its been appropriated by people who are NT, which is factually incorrect.

Moulesvinrouge1 · 22/11/2021 20:03

@Innocenta thanks for your response, and apologies for confusion caused. My ‘them’ was intended to describe the people who thought this was a ridiculous thing to make a fuss about, rather than their status as ND or disabled, but I can see how it would read both ways.

Innocenta · 22/11/2021 20:02

Also, if you experience 'daily' ableism, I'm very surprised that your response to me presumed I wasn't disabled.

Innocenta · 22/11/2021 20:01

I'm not sure why you're trying to summarise the thread, @Moulesvinrouge1 - I have read it, just as you have. What I see is a reductive and controlling attempt to limit language usage, even though in this instance there isn't even any medical precedent for the term in question being linked to autism. There are grey area words where their usage now is offensive because of their origin, but almost no one currently using them has that in mind (e.g. 'moron'), but 'meltdown' just... is not what people are claiming. The claims being made in this thread are not true.

Doingtheboxerbeat · 22/11/2021 19:59

@GodIsAVegan

It isn’t an unacceptable term - 85% have voted that the OP is being unreasonable.

About 200 people have said OP isn’t. I can use another word so what’s the problem. It doesn’t impact you what I do. HTH.

I voted yabu before reading, but now I think this might be a word I will only use with my nearest and dearest 😬. Definitely not on MN.
Moulesvinrouge1 · 22/11/2021 19:59

[quote Innocenta]@GreyhoundG1rl This whole thing is so silly, isn't it? It's just a jumper! And the joke isn't even about autism - I can see why someone might be offended if it was, but... it isn't.

Makes me think that people who take offence at this kind of thing have no idea what it's like to face actual difficulties or prejudice due to life-changing disability, tbh. Ableism is real, but this isn't ableism. (And I know not every disabled person will agree with me, which is fine!) [/quote]
@Innocenta I have seen and experience daily ableism. I don’t think the jumper is ableist particularly, but what we are all talking about is that it’s making a joke, and some people find that joke painful, as it reminds them of something difficult in their life or that of their children or loved ones.

That’s the nuance we are debating.

Innocenta · 22/11/2021 19:53

[quote Moulesvinrouge1]@GreyhoundG1rl please show me where I said I wasn’t disabled[/quote]
While you didn't overtly say you were not disabled, you did describe disabled people as 'them', and worded several posts in such a way as to other us, not as if you were included. Sure, maybe some poor wording - we've all been there! But you can't really blame the other poster for reading it that way. You also presumed I wasn't disabled in the way you responded to me, which, if you yourself are, isn't great...

Moulesvinrouge1 · 22/11/2021 19:53

@Darkpheonix

Meltdown is a common usage word, but it also has an added meaning that can and is commonly used to describe something distressing for people who are already marginalised. I’m agreeing with the OP that I don’t find it funny. Which I’m absolutely allowed to do. So many folk on this three saying ‘well I don’t understand why it’s not funny to some people so clearly it’s fine’

I don't recall telling you, you can't.

I am just addressing your points. Its common use outside the ND community, is far wider reaching the the ND use.

Infact, said snowman is having a meltdown closer to a nuclear meltdown than anything else.

Because a community uses a word it doesn't mean any usage of that word is making fun of them. That would mean the ND community have exclusive use. Which we don't.

I totally agree with you - I don’t think the jumper is deliberately making fun of autistic meltdowns. But the fact that there is a thread about it means it’s upsetting to some people who are either affected by autistic meltdowns or feel empathetic to their upset. The jumper slogan has made light of something that some people feel is really debilitating. That’s why we’re all talking about it, surely.
Innocenta · 22/11/2021 19:50

@GreyhoundG1rl This whole thing is so silly, isn't it? It's just a jumper! And the joke isn't even about autism - I can see why someone might be offended if it was, but... it isn't.

Makes me think that people who take offence at this kind of thing have no idea what it's like to face actual difficulties or prejudice due to life-changing disability, tbh. Ableism is real, but this isn't ableism. (And I know not every disabled person will agree with me, which is fine!)

Moulesvinrouge1 · 22/11/2021 19:50

@GreyhoundG1rl please show me where I said I wasn’t disabled