Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Store refunded me then sent the goods ....

259 replies

veredd · 21/11/2021 15:49

I ordered some Christmas presents from a well known online retailer.
It cost £150
The parcel was meant to be here last Monday and it didn't arrive.
They said it was lost and refunded me £150 (it's back in my bank ) so I re ordered the items.
Now the first parcel has turned up that I've been refunded for.
What would you do?
Do I tell them?
Or do I return the second order and get a refund and keep this order that's already been refunded
Or is that awful ?

OP posts:
TractorAndHeadphones · 21/11/2021 22:29

@Noseylittlemoo

I work in a store but during the lock down I worked for the online returns department. I was surprised at the amount of "lost " orders. Esp with Hermes deliveries which showed photos of the parcel being delivered and ppl saying not me /not my house etc,( even when Google maps showed identical looking house) 90% of people requested a refund rather than a replacement sent and I wondered whether some of those people were asking for a refund for something that they did actually get...
I've never gotten a refund straightaway. I've always been told to wait while they check with the courier. Or advised that delivery has been delayed and call again to check in X weeks. By the time they agree to give a refund I've bought the item elsewhere and therefore don't want a replacement. If there's a photo it's an instant rejection - company says 'it was delivered here's photo as proof' and washes their hands of the matter.

I'm surprised that your company is so nice as to unquestioningly give people refunds... what company is this can I shop there please

Iamanicepersonreally · 21/11/2021 22:12

I think you've had a really hard time OP. Calling you a scuzzy thief is way over the top.

When it's happened to me in the past, I've contacted the retailer, but it's up to you

Concestor · 21/11/2021 21:38

OP you are a scuzzy thief if you do what you're proposing. There's not justification for you doing this, it's vile behaviour.

Noseylittlemoo · 21/11/2021 21:29

I work in a store but during the lock down I worked for the online returns department. I was surprised at the amount of "lost " orders. Esp with Hermes deliveries which showed photos of the parcel being delivered and ppl saying not me /not my house etc,( even when Google maps showed identical looking house)
90% of people requested a refund rather than a replacement sent and I wondered whether some of those people were asking for a refund for something that they did actually get...

Amillionnc · 21/11/2021 21:26

@Mondaymanic

I'd absolutely keep it if it was a big retailer. No guilt. If it was a small retailer I'd return it without question.
Small local businesses do sell on Amazon though.

Echoing other posters, I’m not sure why the OP has posted. It doesn’t seem like she has any intention of of being honest and truthful. I’m still surprised why if she only had £250 she spent £150 of that on presents.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 21/11/2021 21:19

@Mondaymanic

I'd absolutely keep it if it was a big retailer. No guilt. If it was a small retailer I'd return it without question.
The big retailer won’t take the hit on their profit line - a percentage of the price their customers pay is to cover overheads - staff, utilities, overheads - and shrinkage, which is loss due to theft, re aka gel or spoilage, loss in the post etc.

So you wouldn't be sticking it to a big corporation - that money comes directly from ordinary customers.

SusieBob · 21/11/2021 21:18

" I wouldn't put it in the same category as actively stealing (e.g. taking someone else's lunch from the office fridge), which I would never do. "

It's exactly the same, morally.

TractorAndHeadphones · 21/11/2021 21:18

@TuftyMarmoset

This happened to me with some stuff from Dunelm - I had a refund for missing stuff which eventually turned up (but I hadn’t reordered, their customer service just resent it I think). I just kept it because they claimed it off the delivery company.
Also this is another point - it could be claimed off the delivery company. If this keeps happening it's on them to improve operations which would be a win win anyway. Of course assuming that's whay they do and not just hike prices up until people get fed up
TractorAndHeadphones · 21/11/2021 21:16

[quote girlmom21]@TractorAndHeadphones but they've refunded their original error. OP chose to place a second order. She's now expecting a refund on the second order which is completely legitimate and was fulfilled correctly. [/quote]
But you can return orders for any reason!
This is actually the bit I'm confused about.
Trying to get item for free - fair enough. I don't think it's completely above board although it can be justified. Like telling a white lie. It's in my category of 'things I might do in certain situations'. I wouldn't put it in the same category as actively stealing (e.g. taking someone else's lunch from the office fridge), which I would never do.

However - people seem more het up about her returning the second item. This is the bit I don't understand. People return things for a multitude of reasons. They don't like it, decide they don't want it anymore etc etc. So what if the second order was legitimate and fulfilled correctly? Returning it puts the OP in the EXACT same situation as if she had never made the second order and decided to buy elsewhere.

Also a lot of people are getting confused saying that returning the second order would flag up fraud etc. Again there's no basis for this. People can return orders for any reason and receive a full refund within 28 days if the items are unused. So if she never received the first there's no reason to suspect something wrong if she returns the second.

Maybe I'm being nitpicky but I wonder what the responses would be if OP had never mentioned the second order at all and just asked if she should keep the first. But then again I find all of the responses very interesting

TuftyMarmoset · 21/11/2021 21:08

This happened to me with some stuff from Dunelm - I had a refund for missing stuff which eventually turned up (but I hadn’t reordered, their customer service just resent it I think). I just kept it because they claimed it off the delivery company.

SusieBob · 21/11/2021 21:00

@Mondaymanic

I'd absolutely keep it if it was a big retailer. No guilt. If it was a small retailer I'd return it without question.
Why is it ok just because it's a big retailer?
SusieBob · 21/11/2021 20:59

@TractorAndHeadphones

Also to add with the neighbour analogy there's no relationship between me and whoever picked the money up. The fate of my money is in their hands.

In the OP's case the company (the supposed 'victim of theft') was the one who decided to refund her. This was not the mistake (late delivery). This was their choice.

The OP didn't receive the first order and received a refund. Fair enough.

She then re-ordered, received BOTH orders and now thinks she should return one of the two for a full refund to get the goods for free.

It doesn't make a difference whether it's a big online company or mum and pa's corner shop down the road, it's a fucking scummy thing to do. If the OP has money problems she shouldn't be spending £150 on this stuff in the first place.

Mondaymanic · 21/11/2021 20:54

I'd absolutely keep it if it was a big retailer. No guilt.
If it was a small retailer I'd return it without question.

girlmom21 · 21/11/2021 20:53

@TractorAndHeadphones but they've refunded their original error. OP chose to place a second order. She's now expecting a refund on the second order which is completely legitimate and was fulfilled correctly.

TractorAndHeadphones · 21/11/2021 20:48

Also to add with the neighbour analogy there's no relationship between me and whoever picked the money up. The fate of my money is in their hands.

In the OP's case the company (the supposed 'victim of theft') was the one who decided to refund her. This was not the mistake (late delivery). This was their choice.

TractorAndHeadphones · 21/11/2021 20:46

[quote girlmom21]@TractorAndHeadphones yeah they've written the first one off but the second one should've been a legitimate sale.

If you lost £20 in the street and accepted it was lost, then found out your neighbour down the road picked it up and kept it, you'd still be pissed. [/quote]
Company could have done any number of things:

  • Checked with the courier
  • Advised OP to wait longer (most websites have the 'delivery might be delayed' etc etc disclaimer).

Instead they chose to refund OP. The mistake is one thing - but they chose to write it off. Therefore they bear the consequences of that choice.

The parallel to your analogy would be me losing £20, not bothering to report it or ask anybody , then realising that someone had picked it up.

videovixen · 21/11/2021 20:43

fuck that send the 2nd back and get a refund.

Honestly😂😂

NFLBingo · 21/11/2021 20:26

This happened with Ryman’s last year. I ordered a coffee machine in their black Friday sale, they kept changing the date for delivery and then on the 22nd December cancelled it.
I asked for a refund and I bought another machine for my DH’s Christmas present.
2 weeks later the right machine arrived direct from the supplier and whilst it was beautiful I didn’t need it anymore and felt it right to give it back.
I advised them what had happened and the person on the other end of the live chat said to keep it. I was dubious about the likelihood of keeping it based off the word of one employee (I’d have sold it or regifted) and it’s a good thing I was as Parcleforce or whichever courier it was showed up about 3 weeks later to collect it!!

Iamanicepersonreally · 21/11/2021 20:16

This happened to me. I paid for one case of wine and two were delivered. I told the company and they let me have the second one half price

tootyfruitypickle · 21/11/2021 20:14

Actually this has happened to me twice ! Once I got a refund and it turned up. Second time for some reason I got sent two . Both huge cos. Not bothered - their mistake .

GettingItOutThere · 21/11/2021 20:13

fuck that send the 2nd back and get a refund.

if its the company starting with A, i doubt they would miss a few million frankly!

tootyfruitypickle · 21/11/2021 20:12

Same happened to me and I sent one back for a refund. No way of getting through on the phones easily , so not my problem . If you feel bad give the second one to charity . I'm not bothered if it's a big company. I wouldn't do it to an Etsy seller but this was a large co

marchingtotheend2021 · 21/11/2021 19:48

@veredd

Maybe I am not as honest as you all here but I'm not exactly rolling in money so I'm going to return the second order for a refund and keep first
So you have been refunded once already? And now want a second refund and too keep the items.. and send one back seems so much messing around.
SunShinesBrightly · 21/11/2021 19:46

This happened to me with a rug.
I ended up with the ‘lost’ rug which was refunded AND the replacement rug which I paid for.
I phoned them up and they told me that they were going to send me a return label so that I could either return it in store or arrange for a courier collection.
They didn’t.
A few months later I unrolled the second rug and put it in another room.

girlmom21 · 21/11/2021 19:46

@TractorAndHeadphones yeah they've written the first one off but the second one should've been a legitimate sale.

If you lost £20 in the street and accepted it was lost, then found out your neighbour down the road picked it up and kept it, you'd still be pissed.