Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Store refunded me then sent the goods ....

259 replies

veredd · 21/11/2021 15:49

I ordered some Christmas presents from a well known online retailer.
It cost £150
The parcel was meant to be here last Monday and it didn't arrive.
They said it was lost and refunded me £150 (it's back in my bank ) so I re ordered the items.
Now the first parcel has turned up that I've been refunded for.
What would you do?
Do I tell them?
Or do I return the second order and get a refund and keep this order that's already been refunded
Or is that awful ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
dreamdoll123 · 05/12/2021 19:23

So, did you get the refund OP?

liveforsummer · 24/11/2021 16:07

[quote Almostmenopausal]@veredd The company will soon know the original item has been delivered and you may be reported for fraud Hmm[/quote]
You really believe that? Grin

SofiaMichelle · 24/11/2021 14:57

You only have to read some responses to other scenarios on MN to realise how dishonest a lot of MNers are.

There's barely a thread goes by in AIBU without a long list of people whose advice is to lie about whatever the situation is. Usually accompanied by that favourite "just say..."

And then claims of "It's a white lie." from people who don't want to think of themselves as liars, despite that being exactly what they're advocating.

Very odd.

Almostmenopausal · 24/11/2021 12:34

@TokyoDreaming

I'd keep both or get the second one refunded but then I don't care about companies that earn millions of pounds a year.
That's the problem with society today. Can you imagine if f everyone had this attitude?! The companies don't swallow the loss, they pass the cost onto the consumer in price increases. Also, with most large retailers, it's the management of that department who has to answer to the losses. So if it's a small household appliance then the dispatch manager of the small appliance department who has to answer to why X number of parcels have 'gone missing' on his watch. So many occurrences and that man gets disciplined and/or fired! Hmm
Almostmenopausal · 24/11/2021 12:29

@veredd The company will soon know the original item has been delivered and you may be reported for fraud Hmm

videobaby123 · 24/11/2021 01:49

We all know know the actual reason.

What do you think the reason is? @SusieBob

SusieBob · 23/11/2021 23:02

Yeah, because that is the thought process of people doing this.

Hmm

We all know know the actual reason.

TractorAndHeadphones · 23/11/2021 20:50

@videobaby123

I've asked multiple times. Yet to get an answer.

I'm thinking maybe because big retailers have claims/refund processes set in place and are making that money back at a rapid speed. I imagine a small business does not and will gain a bit more sympathy from people

A small business is at the mercy of the courier . once an item has been shipped there’s little they can do to influence it. They’re often given the runaround as much as domestic users.

Big business have multimillion dollar contracts complete with service standards and their own account managers. They may also be able to claim from the delivery company depending on terms. If too many parcels are lost they’re actually able to do something about it.

@SusieBob if you’re still interested…

videobaby123 · 23/11/2021 18:41

I've asked multiple times. Yet to get an answer.

I'm thinking maybe because big retailers have claims/refund processes set in place and are making that money back at a rapid speed. I imagine a small business does not and will gain a bit more sympathy from people

DrSbaitso · 23/11/2021 18:39

@Iamanicepersonreally

Hmm. I think that a lot of the people who are outraged by the OP’s behaviour are just jealous of the fact that this hasn’t happened to them
Even though many of them have said that it has?
Iamanicepersonreally · 23/11/2021 18:37

Hmm. I think that a lot of the people who are outraged by the OP’s behaviour are just jealous of the fact that this hasn’t happened to them

SusieBob · 23/11/2021 18:25

@videobaby123

Can anyone say why they'd return it if it was a big retailer but keep it if it was a small business?? I'd happily return it for both but I do think I'd feel a bit bad (and maybe even consider being honest) if it was a small business. Just wondered what the reasoning was for returning and getting the money back if it was from a big retailer
I've asked multiple times. Yet to get an answer.
SusieBob · 23/11/2021 18:25

[quote TractorAndHeadphones]@SusieBob you’re not really engaging with what I said are you?
Fare dodging ; direct correlation between service used and revenue. Obviously wrong.
I have already explained why this isn’t necessarily the case for a late parcel.

Happy to accept more reasoned examples engaging with my points but the fact that you’ve had an emotional reaction to my post just proves what I said earlie[/quote]
It really doesn't.

Excuse it all you want; the fact is the op is knowingly deceiving the retail and/or the courier out of money and that is a dick move.

DontBeCatty · 23/11/2021 17:44

I have had this happen a lot of times and I always let the retailer know. Often I’m told to keep the item. I think it’s stealing to keep the item if you haven’t been told you can. It’s weird how people have different morals. It just wouldn’t cross my mind to keep it. Luckily I think most people are honest.

TBH I’ve more time for people who are honest about being thieves, it’s the people (like the OP) who try to justify it that I find the scummiest.

videobaby123 · 23/11/2021 17:28

Can anyone say why they'd return it if it was a big retailer but keep it if it was a small business?? I'd happily return it for both but I do think I'd feel a bit bad (and maybe even consider being honest) if it was a small business. Just wondered what the reasoning was for returning and getting the money back if it was from a big retailer

Hetyanni · 23/11/2021 17:09

@veredd

Maybe I am not as honest as you all here but I'm not exactly rolling in money so I'm going to return the second order for a refund and keep first
That's what I would do tbh. If it is a big retailer rather than a small business.
TractorAndHeadphones · 23/11/2021 16:58

@SusieBob you’re not really engaging with what I said are you?
Fare dodging ; direct correlation between service used and revenue. Obviously wrong.
I have already explained why this isn’t necessarily the case for a late parcel.

Happy to accept more reasoned examples engaging with my points but the fact that you’ve had an emotional reaction to my post just proves what I said earlie

SusieBob · 23/11/2021 16:38

[quote TractorAndHeadphones]@melj1213 Come to think of it it’s not actually clear whom the parcel belongs to.
Because in this case there’s a pre-existing contractual obligation. Not the same as shoplifting, or picking someone’s lost money up or any of the other examples.
When you return something it’s very clear that the refund is for an exchange of goods.
When you’re refunded for a non-delivered item however you don’t know whether they’re acknowledging
a) Non receipt of the item alone
b) Non receipt of item within an agreed time frame .

If the company had sent the OP a replacement it would be clearly a) but it’s not.

Therefore it’s not something that clearly doesn’t belong to the OP.[/quote]
Amazing how some people try to justify people being arseholes.

"It wasn't murder, he just fell on this knife I happened to be carrying".

SusieBob · 23/11/2021 16:37

[quote TractorAndHeadphones]@Bookworm20 so much emotion wonder whether these people insisting on their honesty are insecure[/quote]
Swing and a miss.

Some people just have actual morals, and get annoyed at things like this because where do you think the money to cover the OP's refund is coming from?

It's like people who claim that fare dodging is a victimless crime. It's not. It just results in fares going up for everyone. So thanks for that.

videobaby123 · 23/11/2021 16:31

Yes, honestly couldn't get so worked up over this. I have good morals and am honest and am happy that I am overall a good and decent person. But a lost parcel turning up which the company had already refunded and had been written off? Yep, I'd be keeping it.
*
Exactly this. I personally think it's not the end of the world🤷‍♀️
*
Mind you I did 'steal' a carrier bag from Tesco once. Perhaps I've entered the slippery slope to a life a crime and am in fact the scum of society after all

😂 I actually never pay for a carrier bag so I'm definitely the thief of the century according to this thread

TractorAndHeadphones · 23/11/2021 16:29

@melj1213 Come to think of it it’s not actually clear whom the parcel belongs to.
Because in this case there’s a pre-existing contractual obligation. Not the same as shoplifting, or picking someone’s lost money up or any of the other examples.
When you return something it’s very clear that the refund is for an exchange of goods.
When you’re refunded for a non-delivered item however you don’t know whether they’re acknowledging
a) Non receipt of the item alone
b) Non receipt of item within an agreed time frame .

If the company had sent the OP a replacement it would be clearly a) but it’s not.

Therefore it’s not something that clearly doesn’t belong to the OP.

melj1213 · 23/11/2021 15:46

@Bookworm20

Yes, honestly couldn't get so worked up over this. I have good morals and am honest and am happy that I am overall a good and decent person. But a lost parcel turning up which the company had already refunded and had been written off? Yep, I'd be keeping it.

Mind you I did 'steal' a carrier bag from Tesco once. Perhaps I've entered the slippery slope to a life a crime and am in fact the scum of society after all.

If you are happy to knowingly keep items that don't belong to you without making any effort to return them then you do not have good morals nor are you honest because you are literally stealing.

You can justify it however you like but at the end of the day you are still keeping something that is not yours and if you are happy to do that without a second thought then you are demonstrably not honest.

Bookworm20 · 23/11/2021 15:39

Yes, honestly couldn't get so worked up over this. I have good morals and am honest and am happy that I am overall a good and decent person. But a lost parcel turning up which the company had already refunded and had been written off? Yep, I'd be keeping it.

Mind you I did 'steal' a carrier bag from Tesco once. Perhaps I've entered the slippery slope to a life a crime and am in fact the scum of society after all.

TractorAndHeadphones · 23/11/2021 15:27

@Bookworm20 so much emotion wonder whether these people insisting on their honesty are insecure

melj1213 · 23/11/2021 15:22

Same here. Its hardly the crime of the century.
I think everyone I know in real life would just keep the lost parcel.

Keeping a £150 parcel that you know was reported lost and refunded is theft. To then send back the "lost item" for another refund whilst keeping the replacement is fraud. Whether it is from Amazon or Beryl on Etsy, it is still dishonest.

It doesn't matter how you dress it up or what justification you give it is theft and I don't understand why some people are so proud to be a thief and seem to think it is a deficiency for someone to have basic morals and be honest.

If you contact the company to inform them of the error and they choose to let you keep the item then it is different, but to just unilaterally decide to keep something that you know does not belong to you is morally and legally wrong.