Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Company using my baby's photo to advertise

38 replies

pinguwings · 21/11/2021 12:51

We went swimming this morning and there was a pool photographer. They took some photos of the kids as the grandparents love that kind of thing for Christmas.

When we went to look at the photos they had some already printed spread out on the desk as display. I did a double take and then realised that one of the photos was my DD as a baby - 4 years ago. Photo was taken by the same company but at a different pool. The photographer said we could take the photo away with us- and she doesn't think they have other copies.

I had never given any sort of permission for her photo to be stored or used for advertising. I feel really uncomfortable about it but am I just overreacting?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PugInTheHouse · 21/11/2021 20:33

I am laid back about my kids having their pics on FB and in school publicity pics etc personally however some friends of mine have an adopted child whose birth parents are very close location wise. They are not allowed to have his photos on any social media or any form of public pics. They would be extremely upset if this had happened. Whilst it is unlikely that the birth parents would see it, it most definitely isn't beyond possible that a similar situation would mean someone could see a child they are not allowed access to attends lessons in a specific location perhaps.

No photos should be used for advertising without permission. It isn't just about people being 'precious' about their kids. My DS is in the public eye to an extent and we have had to have social services and police involved in a situation involving him and an unhinged adult, there are some scary people around and obviously it is his choice to be involved in an industry where he has to be publicly seen so we were on the ball when something seemed off. If businesses are using photos of children without permission god knows what could happen.

SofiaMichelle · 21/11/2021 20:15

Not correct. The pool would be owned by the pool owners eg David Lloyd or Xxx borough council.

Public places means streets, public parks etc. This is why reporters and cameramen can stand on the pavement near someone's house and film their front door and drive, but the moment they step onto the front garden or driveway they are trespassing if they don't have permission.

I have no idea what you think the relevance of this is.

There's no dispute regarding whether the photographer has permission to be there.

ohtsmeagain · 21/11/2021 18:49

SofiaMichelle
Yeah, but it is a public place.
Unless it's a privately owned pool, of course.

Not correct. The pool would be owned by the pool owners eg David Lloyd or Xxx borough council.

Public places means streets, public parks etc. This is why reporters and cameramen can stand on the pavement near someone's house and film their front door and drive, but the moment they step onto the front garden or driveway they are trespassing if they don't have permission.

ohtsmeagain · 21/11/2021 18:46

The photographers would have had to have the following for this:

  1. Permission from the pool owners four years ago to come into the centre and take photos
  2. Permission from OP four years ago to photo her child
  3. Model release form four years ago to use the photo of her child for advertising. ie permission in writing.

The PP is correct that officially the photographer owns the actual copyright of this photograph unless they have signed that copyright over to you. So they could use the photo in marketing and advertising if they adhered to points 1, 2 and 3 above.

I would be asking them for a copy of the model release form from four years ago. If they cannot give it to you (because it doesn't exist) then they are breaching GDPR and can be fined. Or you could ask them to remove all copies of it from everywhere. I would personally be using the existence of the photo without your permission to get your current photos free of charge.

SolasAnla · 21/11/2021 17:36

SofiaMichelle
Yeah, but it is a public place.
Unless it's a privately owned pool, of course.

Using that logic what is preventing anyone from entering onto the floor of Parliament while a debate is being held?

AlbasJudgementalCrucifix · 21/11/2021 17:22

People’s ignorance on safeguarding in a case like this is a bit shocking tbh. I bet you’re the kind of people that don’t see the problem of taking photos at your kids school play even though the school have told you not to.

diddl · 21/11/2021 15:53

"Where does it say she didn't notice? Presumably the garndparents liked photos of the kids 4 year ago as much as the do today, I think it's safe to assume the OP choose to have the pictures then as well."

That's the way it came across to me I obviously misunderstood.

In which case surely they knew Op's details so that they could ask to use photos for their literature?

Shedmistress · 21/11/2021 15:48

I believe any photos they take are their copyright and not yours so they can do what they like with the photo
Incorrect.

In order to use someone's image in marketing [and not get sued] they needed to have obtained a model release form signed by a parent or guardian.

It is a well know thing, it even has a name. MODEL RELEASE FORM.

SolasAnla · 21/11/2021 15:31

@PurBal

Generally the owner of the photographs is the photographer so I wouldn’t have been that surprised. I do wonder if you should have signed a release though.
Even when it's a commissioned photo the photographer is (usually) the owner, however this photo of an identifiable human is a record of that human in a specific location at a specific date and time and taken only after the parent consented. So a data subject. A decent quality photo can collect biometric data e.g. using software age up a baby photo, and children are given extra protections under GDPR. In this instance the photo would have been commissioned by the OP who did not knowingly give permission for the image to be used for commercial purposes. Potential additional use of the data have to be clearly disclosed not hidden in the small print. The photographer opens a reputation risk by using photos without proper parental ok.
amazeandastonish · 21/11/2021 15:05

I believe any photos they take are their copyright and not yours so they can do what they like with the photo.

I don't think they need permission as to how they use the photo but only to take the photo, especially if its kids. Not sure if permission needs to be in writing.

Obviously there are laws around child pornography and stuff, which this isn't.

I'd let it go tbh, its not that big a deal

ThinWomansBrain · 21/11/2021 15:01

I think I'd ask for a copy of the release form, and bring it to their attention that it's not reasonable to use the image without asking (and obtaining) permission.

GDPR refers to "images where the individual can be identified" - you could identify your baby from fours years ago - would anyone else be likely to? Might be better to check the legal implications before going in all guns blazing.

at the end of the day, it sounds like a small local company that needs to be made more aware - it's not a major international brand that is making megabucks and saving money on a photos shoot or paying for stock images.

& quite flattering that thye've taken your baby as one of the most attractive from the doubtless hundreds that they take every year.

SofiaMichelle · 21/11/2021 14:54

[quote sleepymidwife]@SofiaMichelle yeah a swimming pool isn't a public place though. It's private. [/quote]
Yeah, but it is a public place.

Unless it's a privately owned pool, of course.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 21/11/2021 14:50

I thought that photographers owned the photos and could do what they wanted with them? Unless they took it in a private place without your permission (spying essentially), which if it's a public swimming pool wouldn't qualify. I wouldn't really care unless your child was somehow identifiable from the picture (eg name)

Cheeseycheeseycheesecheese · 21/11/2021 14:48

Irc, the paperwork signed when having the photos taken/purchasing the pictures details concent for marketing purposes, however it is small print.

Personally, it's not something that would bother me, because I post photos of ds on social media. However, I completely understand those who would be completely not OK about it, there are so many reasons why it wouldn't be right for them to use images.

I'd follow @zingally advice, if you're ok with dd's image on the advertisements.

sleepymidwife · 21/11/2021 14:46

@SofiaMichelle yeah a swimming pool isn't a public place though. It's private.

Thefuturestory · 21/11/2021 14:42

@SofiaMichelle

A swimming pool isn’t a public space. A public space is the park, a street. Not somewhere you pay to go into or a shop ( where you are there at the invitation of the owner)
PurBal · 21/11/2021 14:38

Generally the owner of the photographs is the photographer so I wouldn’t have been that surprised. I do wonder if you should have signed a release though.

SofiaMichelle · 21/11/2021 14:37

I'd be reminded them in strong terms that they have in their possession pictures of young children, in various states of undress, and that they MUST ensure all their paperwork and legal obligations are water-tight.

What paperwork?

Unless you're suggesting they're indecent photos - which they definitely won't be - then the photographer won't have done anything wrong.

SofiaMichelle · 21/11/2021 14:35

www.avonandsomerset.police.uk/report/taking-photographs-in-public-places/

No problem as far as I can see.

SnackSizeRaisin · 21/11/2021 14:34

Pretty sure gdpr doesn't apply to photos. And there are no rules about photos in public places...so I doubt it's illegal. But annoying of them - it would seem more polite to ask for permission.

VeganCheesePlease · 21/11/2021 14:29

Some people are saying they don't care or couldn't get worked up, but it doesn't matter what they think. The fact of the matter is the photographer should 100 million per cent have had you sign a release form if they wanted to use your child's photo for advertising. This is, as some others have said, an absolute breach of GDPR. Its nothing to do with being offended or choosing whether or not to care.

dworky · 21/11/2021 14:24

@Luredbyapomegranate

They should have asked, but really - why do you care? They probably generally do but forgot. Don’t turn into one of those people who is looking to be offended all the time.
Bizarre response. Don't assert any boundaries for yourself or your children in case someone somewhere considers you unreasonable.
zingally · 21/11/2021 14:19

I don't think the OP is complaining about any short of covert taking-of-pics of the older DD. She's complaining about them being used for advertising without knowingly giving consent.

Personally OP, I would be content with having the copies that were on display, but I think I WOULD follow up with a Recorded Delivery letter asking for an explanation as to how/why my DDs image was being used. Baring in mind that it could be that you signed a small-print disclaimer when/if you ordered the prints of DD1 the first time.

I wouldn't take it any further than that personally, but I'd be reminded them in strong terms that they have in their possession pictures of young children, in various states of undress, and that they MUST ensure all their paperwork and legal obligations are water-tight. I'd probably cc. the swimming pool management in on this, as they are certainly getting some financial kick-back from the photographer for access in the form of a commission or % of sales.

Chasingaftermidnight · 21/11/2021 14:07

The ‘I can’t get worked up about this’ types make me laugh. Good for you for being soooo cool and laidback, but can you not rack your brains and think of a few reasons why there are laws governing the use of photos and why it might be quite important for photographers to take them seriously?

TheCanyon · 21/11/2021 14:00

My photos on all the old sea life centres posters/pamphlets etc as I am in a Norfolk broads holiday park pool picture. I couldn't say I particularly care, it's just a photo...

Swipe left for the next trending thread