Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's weird that our school only has pictures of white children on its website?

179 replies

BruhWhy · 21/11/2021 10:52

Just that really. We live in an area that's increasingly ethnically diverse and my own children are mixed.

There is a mix of white, black, Asian and mixed children in every class, in every year.

They just updated their website and have taken lots of new pictures of pupils to put onto it, but they've chosen only white children.

I know it's not massively important in the grand scheme of things but it did make me sit there and think 'oh, this might have been a decision that was made' and it's made me feel a bit funny.

OP posts:
itsgettingwierd · 21/11/2021 18:29

Dame fanny it was my quote about tokenism. That was how one of 5 black students in ds school described what the school put on their brochure as 40% of the photos had one of the black students and they were 5 in a population of 1200. It was the black personality the self describing it as tokenism.

He had an excellent point that showing the few black kids doing PE, drama, music, science and English didn't show a diverse school. It didn't show realism. The fact the showed more girls doing science, maths and PE he also felt fixed.

He had a good point that as a black kid he didn't think "I can do all these clubs despite my race" because of the photos. He thought "do the 5 of us really join all the clubs when the other 1195 probably do 1 at most!".

He made an excellent point that he felt he could do anything in the school but in general staff and students didn't make him feel different due to his race. That culture and ethos make for better equality than set up photots on a brochure everyone knows aren't realistic and representative.

DameFanny · 21/11/2021 17:57

Well that's taking the worst-faith reading I guess

PlanDeRaccordement · 21/11/2021 17:49

@DameFanny
It is exploitation of current students in order to attract new students, usually white ones whose parents think their children need “exposure” to minority children like mine for their “moral development”

It’s not really saying anything reassuring at all to me as a minority myself. I see it as exploitation for benefit of mostly white families.

By “it” I mean a school with 1% minority students advertising to give the impression they are more like 25% or 40% minority students. It’s the obvious exaggeration/lying that makes it exploitation. If the pictures reflected reality at the school...one minority face in a hundred...that’s better. That’s the actual truth about the school. I have no objection to that.

We always visited the schools and took a tour during the school day simply because advertisement of any kind cannot be trusted to be an accurate reflection of the reality. So I’ve never sent a child to a school based on advertisements. I don’t know anyone who would either....

DameFanny · 21/11/2021 17:40

Is it exploitation, or is it saying there's space for you here? If you've got room for 10 kids in a photo, why wouldn't you make one of them black even if they were 3% of the school population not 10%?

How comfortable would you be sending a minority kid to a school with exclusively white publicity photos? Especially if you knew there were non-white students there already? Wouldn't you feel like they were making a point to exclude you?

PlanDeRaccordement · 21/11/2021 17:29

@DameFanny

Actually, I agree with @EightWheelGirl that a school that disproportionately over displays ethnic minority children to exaggerate their actual real life diversity is in fact doing tokenism.

It is also very common in the west that this happens.

I was one of the reasons why I withheld permission for my DCs photos or videos to be taken or displayed in any format whatsoever for any reason whatsoever. Because I knew they’d become the poster Asian Chinese children for the school.

Are you saying this does not happen? That minority children are not ever exploited to advertise schools in a way that misleads other parents on a school’s real life diversity?

DameFanny · 21/11/2021 17:22

@EightWheelGirl

but felt it insulting to have 40% of photos showing a black student in a school where there were less than 1% of the population - and that the school made more an an issue of his race than he experienced in day to day life.

Exactly. It’s just patronising tokenism driven by middle class guilt at the fact the MC sphere is incredibly non diverse.

I used to listen to all the diversity nonsense working at FTSE companies where there were pretty much only white people in senior roles. Now I work in construction and see British WC lads working alongside Eastern European’s, Sikhs, Muslims, British Jamaicans, etc, every day. Also meet plenty of small businesses run by Indians etc. No need for all the smoke and mirrors because it’s actually a fairly diverse environment by UK standards.

It's not patronising, it's not tokenism, it's not guilt - it's saying that there's a place for non-white British children. Why would you think it was anything else?
LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 21/11/2021 17:22

The school seems to be in the wrong here except if it is something like 90% white pupils / only 3 photos on the website, in which case it is representative and I would imagine they just chose the nicest photos.

UnsuitableHat · 21/11/2021 17:18

I completely agree with you and would raise it. A school’s publicity should reflect its ethnic mix, not least so it has a better chance of engaging with members of those groups.

IWentAwayIStayedAway · 21/11/2021 17:16

Needs brought up with head and governors. I doubt every non white child refused to have photo taken

Boombastic22 · 21/11/2021 17:12

It’s not weird.

At best it’s unconscious bias and quite frankly sounds like racism. I’d be shouting from the rooftops it’s absolutely unacceptable.

MatildaJayne · 21/11/2021 17:08

Sound like subconscious bias. If accidental. Teachers at my school get training in trying to counter subconscious bias.

BurntO · 21/11/2021 17:01

@BruhWhy even “accidentally” it’s just racially ignorant. Perhaps they didn’t sit there and think oh let’s not include x or y due to skin colour, but some (even subconscious) part of them has lead them to only represent white children and that is part of the problem.

BruhWhy · 21/11/2021 16:59

When I say the majority of the school population is white, that's not to say there isn't quite a sizeable minority that isn't.

We're not talking just my kids and a few others dotted about, it's fairly mixed for our area. It's one of the reasons I'm not considering moving them to a closer school when we move in a few weeks, even though it means a pain in the arse school run in the morning - I like my kids to rub shoulders with all sorts of different people, and some that look similar to them.

So yeah, I'll raise it and see what they say. Glad to know I'm not BU.

OP posts:
BurntO · 21/11/2021 16:58

^TwoMuchTwoYoung

I think it IS massively important and I would definitely ask them why^

100%

Please raise this with them OP

BruhWhy · 21/11/2021 16:53

@Briony123

The total opposite of every other school in the country. Since the 80s, if there's been a non-WASP pupil then they've been front and centre of the school prospectus.
Yeah my DH was one of those kids, front and centre on everything because he went to a naice white school and they were keen to show how diverse they were.

The fact that so many have pointed out how unusual this is leads me to believe they've done it completely by accident.

OP posts:
EddyF · 21/11/2021 16:52

I was driving the other day and a bus was in front of me with an advertisement of a sixth form college. All white children. I thought it was odd as this was in London and it just made me think badly about the college.

GreyTS · 21/11/2021 16:50

@Glitteryone

Every child in our school is white so it wouldn’t be strange for us.

However, if your area and school is ethnically diverse then this is very off!!!!

Every single child in your local school is white?!? 😱 where do you live? I'm in the back end of nowhere in the Irish countryside and the local school is very diverse
Briony123 · 21/11/2021 16:47

The total opposite of every other school in the country. Since the 80s, if there's been a non-WASP pupil then they've been front and centre of the school prospectus.

DriftingBlue · 21/11/2021 16:44

That is very odd and really not ok. The photos should represent all the school children. I suppose it could happen innocently if the page is only featuring photos from a single event that happened to skew towards one demographic and it is a page that gets rotated regularly so when the next set of photos is loaded it should be a different sampling. But I’m really reaching to create that scenario as a legit explanation.

It is normally the reverse. Our area is almost exclusively white, but all the schools feature a diverse cast of children on the glossy brochures and websites. It’s only when you start touring that you realize they all do it.

PlanDeRaccordement · 21/11/2021 16:43

It is worth asking the question. But for the record, we always withheld permission for our DC’s photographs or video to be taken and published on ANYTHING done by the school whether online or on paper/posters.

My DC would have been photoed a lot as quite often they were the only Chinese ethnic child in their class or year. I didn’t want them to be come the poster child to advertise “diversity” and also we have strict safety practice of none of our children’s photos ever being online. We never posted any pictures of them growing up.

KittenKong · 21/11/2021 16:40

DS and one of his friend were on the schools website in a few places (they both did music and martial arts and happened to pop up a few times) - now you may look at him and little pal (this was when they were in little school) neither classified as white (ME and North African). Their classmate was also on the homepage - she is Turkish, again you wouldn’t necessarily think she is white. A Lebanese boy was also on one page (pale skin and hair with green eyes).

Last week DSs current school has photos taken of all the students for a school event for the school website. Two white kids appeared on the website (one of these twice) and the rest mostly asian and some black student (ds said he hid when the photographer was about as he didn’t want to be on the site). If you just saw the site you would have no idea where it was located.

Sometimes it just depends on who is around when the photos are being taken and who wants to be photographed (and of their parents allow photos to be used).

thaisweetchilli · 21/11/2021 16:40

Say you’re a racist without saying you’re a racist 🙄

What statistics and evidence to you have to back up these claims

Seashor · 21/11/2021 16:38

Well I for one don’t believe you!

EightWheelGirl · 21/11/2021 16:35

but felt it insulting to have 40% of photos showing a black student in a school where there were less than 1% of the population - and that the school made more an an issue of his race than he experienced in day to day life.

Exactly. It’s just patronising tokenism driven by middle class guilt at the fact the MC sphere is incredibly non diverse.

I used to listen to all the diversity nonsense working at FTSE companies where there were pretty much only white people in senior roles. Now I work in construction and see British WC lads working alongside Eastern European’s, Sikhs, Muslims, British Jamaicans, etc, every day. Also meet plenty of small businesses run by Indians etc. No need for all the smoke and mirrors because it’s actually a fairly diverse environment by UK standards.

5zeds · 21/11/2021 16:34

My children are mixed race and in our almost entirely white primary were usually in photos. We used to laugh about it. They are VERY beautiful though (not bias at all obv).Grin

Swipe left for the next trending thread