Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that it bothers me how much he spends at Christmas?

320 replies

GrownUPChicken · 20/11/2021 23:01

My husband spends what I feel is a stupid amount of money at Christmas on his children.

AIBU that it bothers me? I gave up a long time ago contributing much at all to their Christmas presents because it's just ridiculous imo and I don't want to spend my money on it.

It just bugs me every year when be starts mentioning everything he's going to buy but I don't know if I'm being unreasonable because obviously he can spend "his" money on what be likes.

We have sort of joint finances but still have our own accounts.

He typically spends his entire works bonus on Christmas presents for the children and I'm left spending mine on everyone else's / taking on more of the shopping etc to cover it.

OP posts:
TooMuchPaper · 24/11/2021 09:49

Not paying for presents for his family does not leave the OP short. It only leaves her not in control of exactly how he spends his money and deals with his family.

Why are you ignoring the fact that he has a 3rd child who he buys nothing for?

JustLyra · 24/11/2021 09:44

@Coronawireless

I don’t get the food thing. How much food does she need? Don’t they normally eat food every day anyway? Who is she cooking for? Need answers!
That’s one of the most disingenuous posts I’ve ever seen on here.

Everyone knows that the vast majority of people buy different or more food for Christmas dinner than your usual Saturday afternoon meal.

Coronawireless · 24/11/2021 09:35

I don’t get the food thing. How much food does she need? Don’t they normally eat food every day anyway? Who is she cooking for? Need answers!

aSofaNearYou · 24/11/2021 09:14

@Coronawireless

Not paying for presents for his family does not leave the OP short. It only leaves her not in control of exactly how he spends his money and deals with his family.
Not paying for their joint child or for the food required for Christmas does leave her short, though.

You've been ignoring this since the beginning of the thread. Why?

Coronawireless · 24/11/2021 08:22

Not paying for presents for his family does not leave the OP short. It only leaves her not in control of exactly how he spends his money and deals with his family.

BluebellsGreenbells · 23/11/2021 22:16

I do think it's up to him how much he spends on his children as long as he's not leaving you short

Well he is! He’s not paying for the joint child or Christmas food or presents for his family.

Did you read the OP?

nimbuscloud · 23/11/2021 21:54

@winnieanddaisy
Did you read the op’s post? Where she says that he spends all his money on his 2 children from his first relationship and nothing on their shared child?

winnieanddaisy · 23/11/2021 21:47

Sorry , I don't think £600 is a huge amount. My DDS is 15 and his mountain bike is £500 alone , without anything else and my 16yo DGD gets at least £1500 this year, including an apple laptop which she needs for college . She'll also get perfume and Pandora jewellery etc etc . Her parents can afford it without getting into debt so why not. I do think it's up to him how much he spends on his children as long as he's not leaving you short .
I was very short of money when my children were young and could hardly afford presents for them and I'm glad that they have done so well in life that they can spoil their children once a year.
By the way DGD never asks her parents for anything , no Christmas list etc , and is happy with whatever she gets and is a lovely happy , well behaved girl .

cannockcandy · 23/11/2021 16:50

To start off I was really cross, however, now I realise you literally mean you are paying for everything other than that! That isn't acceptable! Put your foot down and explain you expect him to pay for half of the expenses. Especially presents for your child together and presents for his family.
My partner buys for his family, I pay for mine, we put together for everything else.

MammaMacgill87 · 23/11/2021 11:21

Darling husband, this year I'm ONLY buying for DC and paying for the Christmas food shop. Every year I'm overwhelmed with not only paying for but sourcing a whole families gifts and also keeping enough cash to get us through December. This year I just want to enjoy it without worrying about money. So you better add gifts for your family to your list so noone is missed out. Leave it at that and stick to it. If come Christmas he's miffed that you didn't organize and sort it all remind him that you told him it was his responsibility. How much he spends on his children as a giant middle finger to his ex (let's be honest that's exactly what this is, he wants the gifts to be better than their mum's ones) is not the point, the point is that he's neglecting your shared child and also devaluing your input into family life by presuming you will just carry on and sort everything else. I can Understand why it's pissing you off tbh

aSofaNearYou · 23/11/2021 09:26

@jontyl

Some people just like christmas
And getting other people to pay for theirs?
jontyl · 23/11/2021 08:27

Some people just like christmas

Iziz · 23/11/2021 07:58

I think it’s too much too but it’s very tricky to approach as they are not your kids and you might come across bad and if the amount he spends on them drastically goes down it will be obvious and I bet anything you will be blamed for it , I think let him spend what ever he wants but them come up with a budget for all the other presents and split the cost in half but don’t pay for his kids presents as he spends enough already or pay for your side and he can pay for his side of the family and split food cost in middle

Ddot · 23/11/2021 07:38

You need to make it clear that your not paying for gifts for his family this year. He needs to at least put half towards all the gift buying and the cost of food.. he can then work out how much is left and blow that amount on his older children. I also think he should be spending same amount on all the children, maybe put that amount in account for when the kids hit 26

Jengnr · 23/11/2021 03:11

@BluebellsGreenbells

I think you both have the same attitude.

He buys for the kids through guilt

You buy for his family through guilt.

He’s not going to stop until you stop.

It’s a cycle you are helping perpetuate

It’s not guilt, it’s one upping the mother. That’s why he has so much glee about it when he doesn’t for all the other presents that need buying.

The Disney Dad Christmas Special.

It’s a shit state of affairs to think your child will only get a decent present off him if you divorce.

Mirw · 23/11/2021 02:09

You can't buy your children. He will realise that when they ask for things he can't give. Presents do not get rid of the guilty conscience. He should look to cut back on the presents and spend quality time with them instead.

Foxylass · 23/11/2021 00:31

This is crazy! You are amazing to have put up with it.
I have a stepchild and we have 3 together - all 4 get the same budget.

Way to move forward - write a list of people you'll (as in you and your OH) be buying gifts for, special foods and drinks you'll be buying, any new decorations etc.
Share the list with him and ask him what he thinks is a suitable budget and agree with him that you'll be paying 50/50.

If he suggests silly money for the older children and a lesser amount for the younger - point out the discrepancy and suggest it be balanced by a contribution to a savings account.

Good luck.

Stressybetty · 22/11/2021 23:47

£600-900 is a ludicrous amount to spend and agree it does smack of guilt. I would wonder how the SC's mother reacts to the gifts and money spent and if she's simply telling him what the kids want/need each year and encouraging him to spend? My DH has not seen his DD for a few years at her choice and only had communication through his ex which has also now ended. We have had years of him overspending on birthdays and Christmas. This year as she is getting older he has re thought the situation and just sent a birthday card with some heartfelt wishes and we will see if she chooses to contact him.

suzy2b · 22/11/2021 23:22

tell him you need the money before he buys his kids presents or there will be no christmas in your house and yes it's a stupid amount of money

Dibbydoos · 22/11/2021 22:50

If it affects your household budget then he should reign it in. He may be spending that much through guilt. You should talk to him.

Good luck

altiara · 22/11/2021 22:37

£600-900 each! That’s a ridiculous amount to spend when they are getting presents from their mum as well. How you can spend that on an 8 or 12 year old every year is astonishing!
If he’s got eg £1500 to splash, then he can easily buy all 3 DC big presents (doesn’t have to be absolutely equal) and put money away to save for eg driving lessons or something. They’ll be so much happier when they’re older. And still have money to spend on his family.

AnnieSnap · 22/11/2021 21:59

[quote Mellowyellow222]@anniesnap for families who can afford it £500 is easily spent on a child. Some years it’s a bike which can cost A couple of hundred quid, plus a couple of Lego sets, some computer games, board games, a few bits of clothes, pjs etc/. It adds up very quickly. A laptop for a teen will also cost a few hundred easily.

Also buying more expensive items isn’t necessarily worse for the environment: and I don’t think many people are buying an iPad each year![/quote]
I agree that these more expensive things are appropriate. I have bought them for my own kids. My point is £500 plus is crazy every year and people are saying this is what they spend every year.

ChargingBuck · 22/11/2021 21:57

how important it is for him that they perceive dad as making things amazing for them

& how amazing for his 3rd child, who he doesn't buy anything for, leaving it up to OP, & not even knowing what she has bought their DC.

He is not dipping into your day to day living costs or joint account

Yes he is, @Madreamigajefa. He overspends on his own 2 DC in the knowledge that OP will have to step in & pay for his 3rd child's, all his family's, & all the extra food & xmas expenses out of her own money.

you may find that it gets heated and is seen as you trying to assert your importance above theirs

As opposed to him spending all his cash on his 1st 2 DC, so asserting their importance over his 3rd DC, who he doesn't buy anything for?
How have you got this so twisted?

Mellowyellow222 · 22/11/2021 21:47

@anniesnap for families who can afford it £500 is easily spent on a child. Some years it’s a bike which can cost A couple of hundred quid, plus a couple of Lego sets, some computer games, board games, a few bits of clothes, pjs etc/. It adds up very quickly. A laptop for a teen will also cost a few hundred easily.

Also buying more expensive items isn’t necessarily worse for the environment: and I don’t think many people are buying an iPad each year!

AnnieSnap · 22/11/2021 21:39

@Madjakelmum

That’s not a stupid amount. Games consoles are £500 plus. Games £60 plus Trainers £100 plus Clothes can also be really expensive

I spend about £500 each on my 3 children and £300 each on grandchildren

It is a stupid amount. Kids don’t need a play station or an iPad every year. No wonder the planet is dying. Justify it all you want, but it is a ridiculous amount which just feeds materialistic attitudes and consumerism in the next generation.
Swipe left for the next trending thread