Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my sons love me but don’t respect me?

61 replies

OrchidPetalsFalling · 20/11/2021 21:43

They undoubtedly love me. They are 3 and 8 and are borderline obsessed with me!!

They just have no respect for me. I don’t shout at all but try the lowered voice, angry tone but they just don’t give a shit. When I’m disciplining them I have to resort to the ‘I’m going to tell your Dad’ shit and that makes them listen up.

What am I meant to do????!!!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
10
Pinkdelight3 · 21/11/2021 15:10

I have two sons and have found the opposite - that it's easier to get their respect because even though dad can be more forceful if needs be, mum is the more unpredictable one so they don't wanna antagonise me. It doesn't require a lot of shouting and such, but I find it helps if at least once, if they push you too far and you go batshit, then it doesn't happen again. By batshit I don't mean aggressive or abusive, but some shouting and a flouncey doorslam and such - something akin to a minor hormonal rage - shocks them into realising that you're not some mild doormat type to be taken for granted, but that your kindness and devotion is by agreement and not to be fucked with, ha ha. Lays the foundation for a little bit of fear and a lot of respect, then you can get on with being loving and fun for the majority of the time and they don't take the piss. I also never use DH as a threat or back-up. That automatically gives him status and takes it away from you.

Onelifeonly · 21/11/2021 13:47

Threats are never a good idea. Carrots are better than sticks. Upthread someone said something about finding out what motivates them and using this as the carrot for getting things done. You'll need that approach when they are teens and trot out the "you can't make me" line. Then it boils down to money, lifts and internet access. For now it could be a game, snack or visit to the park.

EmeraldShamrock · 21/11/2021 13:46

Don't demonise daddy, it's really horrible.

Agreed.

When my dad got home on a Friday after working away, we would avoid him.

DM would have threatened us multiple times throughout the week as DC we knew Dad would roar, we'd beg DM not to tell instead of looking forward to him coming home, she rarely told him.

She should have dealt with it herself, it had an impact on our relationship with our Dad.

I'm the enforcement person in this house.

BurbageBrook · 21/11/2021 11:22

If you threaten them with their dad you are literally telling them that you are less authoritative and he is in charge! Not very feminist Confused

thebabessavedme · 21/11/2021 11:14

Don't demonise daddy, it's really horrible. My DF was away all week working, the thought that he would come home and have to tell us off would have been awful for the whole family, he missed us, he wanted to come home and have us be pleased to see him.

TBH OP your family life with 2 young children sounds pretty normal, your children love you and want to be with you, if you remain firm and calm with your rules and expectations then they will learn and you will earn their respect as they grow older. IME respect from anyone in life has to earnt, you can't command it.

Practicebeingpatient · 21/11/2021 10:37

Quite apart from the many other good points on here this is so unfair on your husband. You get to be fun mummy who lets them have their own way and he is the fun sucker.

SalonSharon · 21/11/2021 10:01

Respect? Children that age don’t understand the concept of respect.

Stop treating yourself and your husband as separate units. If you feel the need to ‘threaten’ them with their father say “daddy and I need you to get dressed now”

GlamorousHeifer · 21/11/2021 09:58

You don't have to be brutal to command respect but you do have to expect it. At 8&3 they won't know the concept but they would understand rules and boundaries.
I have always expected respect from my children (and in return they get mine, it's a two way street after all).
I have never, ever 'threatened ' them with their dad/teacher/any other authority figure.....I don't need to because what I say goes and they have known from being tiny that I won't budge!
Without being rude OP are you a push over generally or just with the kids?

MizzFizz · 21/11/2021 09:43

You can never give in... It's hard but if they know they can get you to give in, psychologically they are wired to try and get their way. It's a facet of human psychology. It's hard but basically if you know you're going to give in, say yes right away instead. And if you say no, it has to always always be no. Doubly so if they're used to you giving in... they will push HARD because they don't believe your no really means no. My mom often gave in to me and we had a very fraught relationship growing up. It's not good for you or them.

Sleepyhungryfattyanddoc · 21/11/2021 09:41

@OrchidPetalsFalling

By obsessed I mean that from the moment they wake they expect and demand me to play with them. Setting out stuff isn’t enough I have to play it, and that onlyY can dress them, Fred them, drive them to school etc
But this is disrespectful too They make you do things for them that they could do themselves, They tell you what to do And then you make it clear by threatening with dad that if they’re not in control, dad is, but definitely it’s never you.

You need to figure out why they want your help/attention/pandering so much, or if actually they like the feeling of being in control or if they feel they need to because otherwise no one is
Why isn’t your husband helping
And why do you think they respect him? Compliance isn’t respect, it could be fear

Cocomarine · 21/11/2021 09:40

Every time you resort to the “daddy line” you outright tell your kids that you are not important at all.

If you only implement one thing - make it stopping thar ridiculous line!

liveforsummer · 21/11/2021 09:40

@TopCatsTopHat

I have a dead simple parenting approach which is that the answer is yes unless there is a good reason for a no, my no never becomes yes and if that word ever leaves my lips the kids just drop it because they know its a total waste of time even trying. We have a great laugh, share lots of fun, enjoy oodles of cuddles but the person in the driving seat is me (or dh). If I make a threat of consequences I always see it through. You need to be a rock not a leaf in the wind.
I follow the same approach however my kids still badger and nag. Especially the 8 year old will go on and on and on. Grumps and whines. I've never changed my mind or not followed through with a consequence- not once but it's still not sunk in after all this time 🙃. Glad it worked out for you though
liveforsummer · 21/11/2021 09:32

3 year old will need some help dressing (but should be doing most themselves). 8 year old should not need any assistance bar maybe tying laces if they haven't learned. Next time tell them you'll be leaving at X time regardless of what they are wearing so the might be going to school in their pants if they don't get a move on rather than threatening with dad

Onelifeonly · 21/11/2021 09:32

You don't need to shout or impose stringent punishments. Just decide what you expect and mean what you say. Don't give in and help if you have decided eg that one can dress themselves. Be patient, allow time for it to happen.

Don't respond to requests immediately. Say you'll do it when you've done x. Repeat instructions/ requests calmly until they are complied with. The 'broken record' technique is a useful one.

And do read the book suggested. Or other parenting books. There are lots of useful strategies you can adopt - find what works for you. It's always helpful to have something you can re-read when things get out of hand again.

Oh and don't use DH as a threat - that reduces your power. Use him as backup. That doubles your power.

LoveComesQuickly · 21/11/2021 09:27

Yes unless there is a good reason for a no, my no never becomes a yes

100% agree with this

LoveComesQuickly · 21/11/2021 09:26

It really is about being consistent OP. Make it clear what the consequences will be for bad behaviour, give one warning, follow through every single time.

TopCatsTopHat · 21/11/2021 09:23

I have a dead simple parenting approach which is that the answer is yes unless there is a good reason for a no, my no never becomes yes and if that word ever leaves my lips the kids just drop it because they know its a total waste of time even trying. We have a great laugh, share lots of fun, enjoy oodles of cuddles but the person in the driving seat is me (or dh). If I make a threat of consequences I always see it through. You need to be a rock not a leaf in the wind.

TopCatsTopHat · 21/11/2021 09:19

@OrchidPetalsFalling

Lots of good points. I am always accused of giving in to them, especially the three year, and there is some truth in that. I give in because they grind me down too easily and I get lazy.
Every time you 'give in' you are training them how long they need to Badger you to get what they want. Everything that's bothering you is right here in this post. Short term easy is just that, you might get a quiet life for 5 minutes but your kids will think you're a joke when you try to push back against this norm you're creating. You need to turn this around or parenting the teen years will be a nightmare, they'll laugh in your face and you will have taught them that.
Practicebeingpatient · 21/11/2021 09:15

@pregnantncnc

I have no advice, OP (although the how to talk so kids will listen book is supposedly brilliant).

If it helps, my mum always had to use the "I'll tell your dad" line with me, and I was certainly scared of him - but I didn't respect him as a child, and I definitely don't as an adult (I still struggle with being desperate for his approval, though - but I'm working on it!). But then again, my mum could be a serious "yes woman" and I don't really respect her either. It is a hard balance to find.

This is such a good point. My mum was super strict and doled out brutal punishments and I was terrified of her (still am and I'm a pensioner). However I didn't respect her (and still don't). However a lot of that was down to her very bad and unpredictable temper. If you stay calm you can be a loving parent with firm rules and boundaries without being a tyrant.
Practicebeingpatient · 21/11/2021 09:10

You need to set rules, boundaries and consequences and be 100% consistent in maintaining these 100% of the time. If you are inconsistent they will be insecure and won't respect what you say. If you have been inconsistent in the past start enforcing the rules and boundaries from today. Tell them 'from now on we are going to do XY and Z in this way at this time' and do it. They will play up and test you. That's when you have to be strong.

TopCatsTopHat · 21/11/2021 09:10

Sounds like the kids calls the shots not you! You haveto play, you people please them and say its drafted in when a foot needs to be put down. They don't respect you because you're a lovely doormat. Start thinking things like 'I call the shots' 'no means no' 'since when did you make the rules'... y'know get the voice going in your head, live it each and every time they will realise you mean business. This doesn't mean being nasty, you can love them to the moon and back a still be the one who says what goes.

bucketsoflove · 21/11/2021 09:03

I would not worry about respect as such, but you do need to start parenting differently with firm boundaries and consequences. Kids don't get to decide who is driving them anywhere - I don't understand how this can even come about.
Treat the 8 yo differently to the 3yo - more independence, more responsibility and also greater consequences for not doing what they're meant to be doing. Natural consequences are best, not punishment for the sake of it.
Stop threatening with your DH and follow through the parenting decisions yourself.
The book pp recommended is a great place to start.

icedcoffees · 21/11/2021 08:37

You're causing some of the issues here.

Stop threatening to tell your husband and follow through/give consequences yourself.

workwoes123 · 21/11/2021 08:34

I agree with the pp who said that respect is a meaningless concept - certainly for the 3 yr old, and probably pushing it for the 8 yrs old.

I have two boys and I have never once had to threaten them with daddy: I’m scary enough 😂. It’s such an unfair thing to do to him, apart from anything else, forcing him into the role of disciplinarian. I’d be really pissed off if DH had done that to me any time he couldn’t get the boys to comply with whatever he needed them to do.

To make them listen: talk firmly and remove distractions. So if they are watching tv and you need them to get dressed, give them a warning that the tv is going off in t one minute then they need to come to the bedroom to get dressed. And follow through every single time. We has really strong routines for everything like this.

OrchidPetalsFalling · 21/11/2021 08:27

Lots of good points.
I am always accused of giving in to them, especially the three year, and there is some truth in that. I give in because they grind me down too easily and I get lazy.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread