Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To confront parents about my childhood?

161 replies

Whipittillitpeaks · 20/11/2021 21:32

I had a lot of happy moments in my childhood, but also a few experiences that stay with me, that I’m starting to feel angry about, a child shouldn’t have been subjected to them.
It’s been in my mind more since having my own Dd, and looking back I can’t believe some of the things I went through when I was young and innocent and should have been protected.

I remember one incident when we were on a camping holiday when I was around 9 and my dad was drunk and pushed my mum over, he was saying all sorts and I remember feeling so scared and asking if they were getting a divorce and holding my mums hand all night until I went to sleep.

Then at 13, I was woken up by my dad going on and I heard him say he’d ‘Kick the shit out of’ my mum. I was hysterical on the landing upstairs and my mum came to comfort me, my dad was saying to her ‘See what you’ve done now’ he was drunk.
I remember feeling fear when my dad used to get home some Saturdays after going out with my uncle/his friends. He’d be drunk but acting really silly, but I felt the fear, it wasn’t a comfortable feeling, I dreaded him coming home. He usually just fell asleep.

My dad used to sometimes come to me room when I was going to sleep and talk nonsense about he wished he didn’t have to grow up, like Peter Pan. Other times, he’d tell me about other girlfriends he had when young.

Sounds ridiculous, but in other ways he was a good dad, great fun, caring etc, but he had moods and days of silence and we walked on eggshells at times.

My mum, I know loves me, but she never showed it. I remember one time coming back from being away for the first time ever with Brownies for a couple of nights. All the other mums ran to their kids and picked them up or hugged them, my mum didn’t hug or kiss me, just got our bags.

Looking back, I realise my upbringing was dysfunctional and I still see it is in many ways, even though my parents are still together and love each other massively.

As a teenager I was a nightmare and never home, I felt more comfortable in friends houses and friends became like family to me.

I never told anyone until I was around 22 and drinking quite heavily. I couldn’t take my drink (much like my father) and got really emotional and let it all out to my now Dh, who was gobsmacked.

These things have never been mentioned, is that weird? Would these moments have affected the person I am?

Now I’m a mum, I’m petrified of ever putting my Dd through any of that.

I don’t understand how my mum could

OP posts:
Whipittillitpeaks · 21/11/2021 09:00

@Changechangychange But there was absolutely no sexual talk? It was more about his sadness and losses, completely not what he should have been talking to his daughter about, I really don’t understand why he did

OP posts:
Whipittillitpeaks · 21/11/2021 08:58

But I started to remember lots possibly around 1 onwards

OP posts:
Whipittillitpeaks · 21/11/2021 08:58

My Dd is 3

OP posts:
Muttly · 21/11/2021 08:44

I agree with many other posters on here about the likely outcome of confronting your parents. They were raised in a time where emotional problems were swept away and not confronted. They had absolutely no confrontation skills that were not dominance based physical agression/hurling abuse. They had nobody to teach them about how to manage emotions and how to vent frustration positively. Couple that with likely great shame they are most likely to use denial as a coping mechanism and project their shame onto you as wrongdoing on your part.

From my own experiences in an abusive family of origin (CSA) the time to confront people is if the relationship needs to end (i.e. after a lot of consideration and action to try everything you have decided to go no contact) and then it is not for reconciliation purposes any longer it is to use a voice that has been stolen from you and to reclaim that voice.

I will be honest with you though and I think it will take you tome to see things clearly. From what you wrote your mother was a victim of domestic abuse and she still focused on soothing you after she had been abused in the circumstances you wrote about. I think you blame of her sounds misplaced from what you have written.

MauraandLaura · 21/11/2021 08:25

OP the good thing about being an adult is that you get to choose what happens in your adult life.

You can absolutely say no to visits.
You can absolutely bring up how you felt as a child and the effect its had on you.
You can absolutely dictate how you want the relationship to progress.

I have gone NC with both my parents because I had a similar upbringing. Mother had mental health issues and was a drinker and my dad was too.

And its totally normal to be triggered because you are now in a normal functioning family and you can see the difference in how you was raised to how your children are raised.

From experience what you say will fall on def ears and probably cause offence - but who cares. If you want to say it - say it - but be prepared for a difference response to what you want.

dottiedodah · 21/11/2021 08:06

Tbh I would not confront them .you say they are still together. Every one thinks all families are almost perfect,children being put first. This is of course what should happen. Sounds like your dad had a bad time of growing up himself. Maybe he found becoming a parent difficult. Maybe worth some therapy to explore your feelings in depth. Thing is they are more than likely to minimilise the events which leaves you nowhere to go. If you get on well with your sister then maybe mention it .however again be prepared that she may be in a spot of denial as well.it is painful to confront our past if it is painful

Worldwide2 · 21/11/2021 07:31

I had a very rocky childhood. My dad was never violent to my mum but he did smash our house up. They were both very volatile and it was constant screaming matches between them. Me and my siblings would then be next. They were both incredibly violent to mainly me. My mum was very controlling and nasty, treated me completely different to my siblings. I left home extremely young (best thing)
I understand you keep thinking about it especially after children. I do too. It's always on my mind as in I couldn't imagine doing those things to my children or in front of them.
I have actually confronted my mum over it as she likes to try to write history which is infuriating to me. She clams up or makes out she can't remember. I'm not going to getting anything there. Plus her favouritism is still very much at play. I'm just not close to her and never will be.
In those days it's hard for women to leave a man (I'm not making excuses) so it may have been incredibly difficult for her to get away. There was no or little support back then. It may have been something she had little control over?
I think you should try to talk to your mum how you feel but i would have low expectations on what you may hear back from her.
I totally understand why you want your mum to know how you feel. It just may not go as what you think or hope for but it may make you feel better as you have said how you feel out loud to them. Speaking from experience.
Hope whatever you choose to do it brings you some peace of mind 💐

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 21/11/2021 02:13

(Posted too soon)

Maybe you'll get some sort of apology, more likely I think they'll minimise and dismiss what happened and you'll end up feeling worse. I think counseling is more likely to help you process everything and get some closure.

Both my parents had abusive parents. My Dad's father was physically abusive as well as mentally and emotionally abusive. My Dad did drink too much, but he was a sad drunk rather than an angry one. When drunk he told me things about the abuse he went through as a child, he would cry, be depressed. I was the kid that tried to fix it all, for my Dad and my mum and my sister and my brother. My siblings always came before me, their needs were greater and I'm good at coping. I'm used to it now and I really don't think there's any point challenging that . My Dad is a good person, he had a horrific childhood and he tried so hard to keep that from us. I know he would beat himself up if I told him what he's discussed with me when drunk, he has no memory of it. He is who he is, a loving father who was and still is deeply impacted by the trauma of his childhood. Adding to that burden wouldn't heal me, it would only hurt him.

TedMullins · 21/11/2021 01:57

I had a dysfunctional childhood for different reasons and personally I did feel better about confronting my parents. They did minimise to a degree but I didn’t do it for a reaction. I just wanted them to know that I felt they’d failed me. My mum was devastated when I told her this but I felt like she needed to know, as her actions contributed to the issues I had as an adult. We still get on but she knows how I feel and I prefer it that way. I’ve also had a lot of therapy.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 21/11/2021 01:51

[quote Flyonawalk]@Whipittillitpeaks I am so sorry that you went through this. It sounds awful. I am still badly affected by growing up in an alcoholic home, and your post resonated with me.

A drunk parent is unsettling and frightening for a child, and it is completely reasonable that you are still affected. I don’t think people who haven’t experienced it can really understand. Incidents which sound not very serious can stick with you and cause pain years later.

I don’t know whether confronting your parents would help, but seeing a therapist might. A massive Well Done for stopping the cycle and for protecting your own child Flowers[/quote]
This is a great post. You spent what sounds like a large part of your childhood walking on eggshells because of your Dad. I've seen many posts on here urging women to leave in similar circumstances because it's damaging for children to grow up in these relationships. It's understandable that this is still effecting you, but I don't think confronting your parents is likely to help. Maybe you'll get some sort of apology, more likely I think they'll minimise

Graphista · 21/11/2021 01:47

Ime you won't get an apology or even acknowledgment of the harm caused and that can hurt you all over again.

I was raised in an abusive home and neither parent has ever really said sorry or voiced anything approaching regret or remorse

Therapy can help, but ultimately nothing will really heal you.

But therapy can get you to a place where you can accept that and move on.

How recently did you have dd? I was shocked at what came spilling out just after I had my dd, I dumped a load on a hv one time and then I was like "omg I'm so sorry" abs felt embarrassed

She said she was used to it, that it happened ALL the time as that's when people examine their parenting and childhood most.

they told me it never happened or that I was twisting things

That's the response I mainly got, there was csa in my case which my mother and sister still deny

They fuck you up, your parents do’ (along those lines)

That's Philip Larkin This be the verse LOVE larkin generally but yes especially this one.

I've been in therapy a lot. It helps but it's not a miracle cure. It just helps you to cope with what's happened not totally lose the effects of it. Nothing can

And of course nobody is all bad. Just as nobody is all good so there will be aspects of your parents that you like and admire even, just you're aware of the other stuff too.

tallduckandhandsome · 21/11/2021 01:39

@Toloveandtowork

We are all only human and being a parent can be massively stressful. Not sure you have anything to gain by confronting them. Sounds like something to talk about in therapy.
Yes, because it’s ‘only human’ to push your wife around, threaten to ‘kick the shit out of her’ and come into your young daughter’s bedroom at night to talk about his girlfriends when young and how he wishes he was Peter Pan.
Changechangychange · 21/11/2021 01:33

Incidentally I’m not saying that was necessarily what your father was up to - just explaining why I found that particular story concerning.

Changechangychange · 21/11/2021 01:22

OP, this is what I was referring to:

amp.mindbodygreen.com/articles/the-insidious-type-of-sexual-abuse-you-might-be-ignoring--23980

Inappropriately sexualised conversations about your father’s previous girlfriends or his other “needs”. Unfortunately it’s often the precursor to sexual abuse - the parent is testing the waters/grooming you.

Cameleongirl · 21/11/2021 00:30

I do understand, btw, that my Dad was ill when he did what he did (and there were other incidents) but I also know that I could never put my child in that position, IYSWIM.

Volhhg · 21/11/2021 00:30

I don't know when these events happened but it's never been easy to leave and abuser and it's not easy now. Our parents are of their time and until fairly recently there really wasn't much support for women in these situations, maybe she really had no option. Maybe she was scared that if she left your dad that you children would be alone and in his care sometimes. Maybe she thought he would hurt one of you and her. Maybe she was right. These are still reasons why women don't see a way out and there isn't in some cases. I would be bringing this up in private to mum and helping her to leave this abusive alcoholic now. I wonder if your mum was miserable because of your dad and it's not that she didn't love you.

Cameleongirl · 21/11/2021 00:25

@Comtesse

They won’t be able to sit with shame of behaving so badly and mistreating you so will deny everything and project it right back at you. Try reading Toxic Parents - I think it might be helpful Flowers
I'm afraid I agree with @Comtesse, they probably won't be able to deal with it and will project it back at you. If they could deal with it, they'd have apologized to you by now.

My Dad had some serious MH issues during my childhood and did some awful things, including a suicide attempt timed so I (then a child) would have found him. He's completely blocked his behaviour out and I've never raised it with him. Since I've been an adult, he's made a few decisions that he now regrets and has decided to blame me for! Luckily I was already married to my DH so he can 100% confirm that they were nothing to do with me so I have some back up!

Some people just can't face their actions and there's no point confronting them, tbh. As PP's have suggested, talking to a therapist might be helpful to get those feelings out and lay them to rest. You have your own child now and you're bringing her up differently, leave the past where it is. Flowers

likeafishneedsabike · 21/11/2021 00:15

My childhood was a bit weird due to unhappily married parents. Dramatic rows - Sundays were unpredictable to say the least. Nothing as bad as described here but my sibling suffered much more than me (spent 3 more years at home as younger and also much less emotionally equipped to handle their ridiculous drama). He had a lot of therapy. My brother then talked through that therapy with me. It was fascinating and so helpful. The gist was that my brother had no power to change their behaviour but had power to change his own. Sounds simple but it was quite transformative for him.
You won’t get what you need from them if you confront them.

saraclara · 21/11/2021 00:08

if they didn't have the insight to see how their behaviour impacted you in the first place, they aren't going to see it many years later.

Exactly!

You're being really naive to think that they will own their behaviour, admit it and apologise, OP. They wouldn't have done these things in the first place if they thought it was wrong.

I have never yet heard of a conversation like the one you plan to have, going well.

Coronawireless · 21/11/2021 00:06

Unless your childhood was very abusive or the abuse is ongoing I think it’s better to accept that they were flawed and weak like many humans and unlikely to have deliberately tried to hurt you. It’s a funny thing when you first realise that your parents are not all-powerful and all-knowing. That you in fact might be better at parenting than they were. It can be destabilising as it reframes your childhood somewhat. I agree with pps that confronting them will not get you the closure you want and may cause hurt either to them or you. Talk it through with someone else, see them for the flawed people they are, forgive them, let them go as your superiors, become an adult in your dealings with them.

littleowls83 · 20/11/2021 23:54

I would agree with those people that said confronting the shit parents gets you nowhere. From personal experience, if they didn't have the insight to see how their behaviour impacted you in the first place, they aren't going to see it many years later.

Switch82 · 20/11/2021 23:48

Speak to a therapist

What you want from speaking to them?

FallingStar21 · 20/11/2021 23:47

I had a difficult childhood due to abusive father and a distant, passive mother. As an adult, I confronted my mum in a very "black and white" way. Her response was simply that she'd/ they'd made some mistakes. That was literally it.
With my dad it's way worse - 0 emotional intelligence and compassion shown, he's never in his life admitted to having done anything wrong; always blaming everyone else and judging them really harshly, making them feel awful about themselves.

The outcome: very LC with him. My mother, despite the above account, has actually been great as a friendly and even loving presence in my life and my DC's lives.

So my advice is, do what you feel is right and what you need for yourself. I hope it helps you heal, but don't expect they will understand or even acknowledge your experience the way you'd want them to x

IcyBlonde15 · 20/11/2021 23:46

As someone who has had plenty of moments stay with me when my childhood looked idyllic from the outside, confronting them is pointless. You will only feel invalidated. My mum and dad had a huge argument when driving about 70mph one night. I was six and my brother was two. My mum pulled the hand break in bad temper and the car spun. We are very very lucky there didn't happen to be another car on the road. I have memories of her throwing plates of food and me having to clean up the mess, which is really poor behaviour to model to children. My mum ripped up an exercise book that belonged to school when I was 10 and told the teacher I did it. My dad had a heart attack when I was p7 and about to transfer schools, and I got into a disagreement with my mum about what school to go to which resulted in her pinning me to the wall and telling me if I didn't go where she said my dad would have another heart attack and it would kill him. I remember that terrified me. But of course she completely denies any of this happening but I swear on my children's lives it is all true. It took years of therapy for me but I did get to a stage where I just accept it for what it is: I had a shit mother. An apology or confrontation won't change it. I know I am a much better mother-far from perfect but I will never ever treat my kids like that. And if they ever do come to me and say they were unhappy with the way I handled something , I will be honest, admit I don't get it right every time and apologise.

spaceghetto · 20/11/2021 23:45

I have a similar experience, although both my parents drank heavily. I carried a lot of guilt as I was a very depressed teenager and it took me time to realise my feelings were in response to their drinking. I've never confronted them about it. Now I have my own children I wouldn't want to rock the boat but it does amplify the issues even more now as I couldn't imagine putting my children through some of the experiences I had.

Swipe left for the next trending thread