Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To confront parents about my childhood?

161 replies

Whipittillitpeaks · 20/11/2021 21:32

I had a lot of happy moments in my childhood, but also a few experiences that stay with me, that I’m starting to feel angry about, a child shouldn’t have been subjected to them.
It’s been in my mind more since having my own Dd, and looking back I can’t believe some of the things I went through when I was young and innocent and should have been protected.

I remember one incident when we were on a camping holiday when I was around 9 and my dad was drunk and pushed my mum over, he was saying all sorts and I remember feeling so scared and asking if they were getting a divorce and holding my mums hand all night until I went to sleep.

Then at 13, I was woken up by my dad going on and I heard him say he’d ‘Kick the shit out of’ my mum. I was hysterical on the landing upstairs and my mum came to comfort me, my dad was saying to her ‘See what you’ve done now’ he was drunk.
I remember feeling fear when my dad used to get home some Saturdays after going out with my uncle/his friends. He’d be drunk but acting really silly, but I felt the fear, it wasn’t a comfortable feeling, I dreaded him coming home. He usually just fell asleep.

My dad used to sometimes come to me room when I was going to sleep and talk nonsense about he wished he didn’t have to grow up, like Peter Pan. Other times, he’d tell me about other girlfriends he had when young.

Sounds ridiculous, but in other ways he was a good dad, great fun, caring etc, but he had moods and days of silence and we walked on eggshells at times.

My mum, I know loves me, but she never showed it. I remember one time coming back from being away for the first time ever with Brownies for a couple of nights. All the other mums ran to their kids and picked them up or hugged them, my mum didn’t hug or kiss me, just got our bags.

Looking back, I realise my upbringing was dysfunctional and I still see it is in many ways, even though my parents are still together and love each other massively.

As a teenager I was a nightmare and never home, I felt more comfortable in friends houses and friends became like family to me.

I never told anyone until I was around 22 and drinking quite heavily. I couldn’t take my drink (much like my father) and got really emotional and let it all out to my now Dh, who was gobsmacked.

These things have never been mentioned, is that weird? Would these moments have affected the person I am?

Now I’m a mum, I’m petrified of ever putting my Dd through any of that.

I don’t understand how my mum could

OP posts:
IWishToAnswerInTheAffirmative · 21/11/2021 13:30

I also find it so, so embarrassing when they drink three bottles of wine between them and my mum is slurring her words and becoming argumentative. It makes me not want to go there.

IWishToAnswerInTheAffirmative · 21/11/2021 13:29

I think I’m going through a period of questioning a lot of things from childhood that I thought up until recently were quite normal.

My parents were/are big drinkers. Not to the point of vomiting, child abuse etc. but they certainly enjoy their wine. I’ve recently realised that their relationship with alcohol is so unhealthy. It always has been. But I actually think it’s getting worse now.

I haven’t had a drink since 31 October. I’m trying to reset my own relationship with alcohol, for my girls’ sake. My mum absolutely cannot believe this and will not stop going on about it. Like it’s a gigantic big deal.

I worry for them.

SheWentWest · 21/11/2021 13:04

To those who are tempted to minimise this and put it down to slightly crap parenting there is a large body of evidence showing how profoundly some people can be affected by growing up with an alcoholic parent. Largely down to the child never feeling emotionally safe, feeling responsible for eveything bad. Missing out on attention from both the alcoholic parent and the co dependant.

JustLyra · 21/11/2021 12:58

It's not a total shitshow.

And this is massively minimising.

The OP lived in fear of her father on many many occasions. That is a total shit show.

JustLyra · 21/11/2021 12:57

@Alcemeg

You don’t accidentally scare your kids by threatening to kick the shit out of their mother. Realising that was very wrong isn’t focussing on idealised parents. It’s realising your Dad was an alcoholic violent bully.

But dismissive labels like that are an oversimplification, aren't they?

OP says "in other ways he was a good dad, great fun, caring etc" -- and "my parents are still together and love each other massively."

It's not a total shitshow. Just knowing that your parents love each other must be rather wonderful. I mean, my dad never threatened to beat up my mum (or at least, not within my earshot); his cruelty was, and continues to be, of a different kind. Whether they love each other has tormented me for a lifetime.

We all get our dose of fucked-upness, tailored specially for us, as Larkin says. Even the most doting, caring parenting can backfire spectacularly, with kids who grow up anxious for more space and freedom.

An alcoholic who hits his wife and scares his children is an alcoholic violent bully. How is that in any way debatable?

The fact he was in other ways a good Dad doesn’t change that he was an alcoholic violent bully.

Just as the fact my Dad was a decent Dad to my siblings when they were young didn’t mean his violence or cruelty didn’t make him an abusive prick.

You are massively over simplifying the OP’s parents because of your own situation, which doesn’t help anyone. The fact the Op thinks her parents love each other doesn’t change the past.

Good parents don’t scare their children with violence on multiple occasions. They just don’t.

Crunchingleaf · 21/11/2021 12:25

OP after I had my son. I found myself reevaluating my relationship with my mother following a highly dysfunctional childhood. I keep her at a distance now. I know she has her own issues that led her to have a relationship with an abusive drunk. I will never get an apology from her and I have accepted that. I also needed to realise that as a child none of what happened was not my fault and I deserved to be protected. My focus is on my boys and raising them in a loving, safe home. It was a long road adjusting from a dysfunctional home environment to a calm one.
It’s perfectly normal what your going through OP but it’s unlikely to help confronting your parents. People struggle to acknowledge their failures in life and don’t appreciate it being pointed out to them.

Alcemeg · 21/11/2021 12:18

You don’t accidentally scare your kids by threatening to kick the shit out of their mother. Realising that was very wrong isn’t focussing on idealised parents. It’s realising your Dad was an alcoholic violent bully.

But dismissive labels like that are an oversimplification, aren't they?

OP says "in other ways he was a good dad, great fun, caring etc" -- and "my parents are still together and love each other massively."

It's not a total shitshow. Just knowing that your parents love each other must be rather wonderful. I mean, my dad never threatened to beat up my mum (or at least, not within my earshot); his cruelty was, and continues to be, of a different kind. Whether they love each other has tormented me for a lifetime.

We all get our dose of fucked-upness, tailored specially for us, as Larkin says. Even the most doting, caring parenting can backfire spectacularly, with kids who grow up anxious for more space and freedom.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 21/11/2021 11:33

[quote Whipittillitpeaks]@saraclara why though?[/quote]
Cognitive dissonance is one possible reason. It refers to the mental conflict that occurs when a person's behaviors and beliefs do not align. For your parents to recognise their behaviour and apologize, they first have to acknowledge that they behaved in ways that don't match their idea of what a good parent does. Denying and minimising allows them to go on believing they were good parents.

JustLyra · 21/11/2021 11:33

@Alcemeg

Unless they were deliberately cruel, I don't think it's fair to confront our parents with their failures, unless we also thank them wholeheartedly for their efforts.

It took me years to realise that despite fucking me up in various ways, my mum and dad also provided many important forms of care that other parents can neglect. Besides, as well as inheriting some of their annoying weaknesses, some of the ways I take after them have ended up serving me well.

Different stages of life give us wholly new perspectives, and sometimes tunnel vision. Yours at the moment is very much focused on ideal parenting, with your DD centre stage. If you now find your parents lacking, I'd keep this revelation to yourself for now. Family life is often a messy business and the deep intimacy of the parent/child relationship doesn't lend itself to the kind of close monitoring and performance feedback we might be used to from work.

That’s a great post for people who grew up in normal households with parents trying their best.

That doesn’t apply to the OP though.

You don’t accidentally scare your kids by threatening to kick the shit out of their mother. Realising that was very wrong isn’t focussing on idealised parents. It’s realising your Dad was an alcoholic violent bully.

lunarlandscape · 21/11/2021 11:23

@Alcemeg

Unless they were deliberately cruel, I don't think it's fair to confront our parents with their failures, unless we also thank them wholeheartedly for their efforts.

It took me years to realise that despite fucking me up in various ways, my mum and dad also provided many important forms of care that other parents can neglect. Besides, as well as inheriting some of their annoying weaknesses, some of the ways I take after them have ended up serving me well.

Different stages of life give us wholly new perspectives, and sometimes tunnel vision. Yours at the moment is very much focused on ideal parenting, with your DD centre stage. If you now find your parents lacking, I'd keep this revelation to yourself for now. Family life is often a messy business and the deep intimacy of the parent/child relationship doesn't lend itself to the kind of close monitoring and performance feedback we might be used to from work.

This is a brilliant post.
Whipittillitpeaks · 21/11/2021 11:21

@MauraandLaura Yes, I definitely had that too from my dad, he shouldn’t have talked to me, a child, about past girlfriends and how he loved them and wished he stayed with them. He shouldn’t have talked about problems in their relationship. It’s baffling to me how he couldn’t see how wrong that was.

I also don’t agree that they were only trying their best, they weren’t! (Dad at least) how was that his best?

I’m 43, not sure why it’s coming to the forefront more now, likely having a young Dd as I said.
It’s also cropped up more during times of stress, I thought much more about it both times I moved house, for some reason
I also live abroad, so even if subconsciously, I wanted to get away from it all.

I’ve said what I’d like to achieve, just for them to know and acknowledge how bad that was for me. But again, I don’t think I could, for fear of upsetting them and making them feel guilty.

Im definitely not a ‘Perfect parent’ of course I lose my temper, get stressed, will maybe drink too much in the future. But I work really hard on those things, especially I wouldn’t want to be out of control and drunk in front of my Dd.
My Dh had issues of his own in childhood, that really to me aren’t issues at all, we all had them, but I think mine in comparison to his weren’t right at all.

OP posts:
SheWentWest · 21/11/2021 11:09

It sounds like you are having a perfectly normal reaction to growing up in an alcoholic household. You are not alone and it is much more common than you think. Why not do some reading around adult children of alcoholics and see if any of that resonates. Some talking therapy might help because you sound like you could do with some validation of your experiences and feelings. It's painful and difficult but it does get easier with time, especially as it can suddenly explain alot about the way you handle emotions! I would advise getting your head around it before you decide whether to confront. You feelings around your dad drinking now tell you alot about how you felt about it as a kid.

MauraandLaura · 21/11/2021 10:57

[quote Whipittillitpeaks]@Changechangychange But there was absolutely no sexual talk? It was more about his sadness and losses, completely not what he should have been talking to his daughter about, I really don’t understand why he did[/quote]
Its called parentifying ( I think) My mother did it with me, telling me about her child sex abuse and my step father beating her up when I wasn't there.Then my step father would tell me about her drinking and her affairs. I was 14 at the time. Its massively inappropriate and completely down to their own emotional immaturity and impairments.

I am years down the line from where you are. Counselling did not help for me - it only made me feel worse. But what I have learned is too accept it, that they were not the parents I would have liked or needed and I have moved on - facilitated by going NC with both of them. Tbh my mother wasn't arsed but my dad took great umbrage at it and played the victim.

I pour love in to my children and I get it back ten fold. I dont need my parents.

JustLyra · 21/11/2021 10:38

@Oblomov21

You keep avoiding direct questions. Re what you are hoping to achieve. And re counselling.

How old are you? Why is it only now that you've had a dd that you are thinking about this. Didn't this occur to you before? Would you say you are open emotionally?

It’s very common for childhood issues to rise to the surface when you have children of your own.
Oblomov21 · 21/11/2021 10:28

"I honestly can’t see how they’d blatantly deny it or be so awful as to somehow turn it back on me though? That’s pretty horrific"

This is incredibly naieve. You don't seem to have had the life experience, or now have the emotional maturity to recognise what a complex issue this is.

Please talk to someone in RL who you trust, and book some counselling.

Oblomov21 · 21/11/2021 10:22

You keep avoiding direct questions. Re what you are hoping to achieve. And re counselling.

How old are you? Why is it only now that you've had a dd that you are thinking about this. Didn't this occur to you before? Would you say you are open emotionally?

CoveredInSnow · 21/11/2021 10:14

They were only doing their best

I agree with much of your post but I do take issue with this. So often parents in these situations WEREN’T doing their best - they put themselves first, they didn’t bother to think about the effect their behaviours had, they did nothing to address issues and left others to pick up the pieces.

Sometimes a perceived “best” really means “I couldn’t be bothered to do better” and it’s OK to acknowledge or want acknowledgement that it actually wasn’t good enough.

ThinWomansBrain · 21/11/2021 10:07

WHat do you hope to gain from it - and what happens if your parents don't come out with the response that you'd like?
They could deny the incidents happened - anything really; it's bound to cause a lot of hurt.

Doesn't excuse the things that you remember - confronting them might bring the apoloogies or whatever you're after - or could cause a rift and a lot of bad feeling.

Also, you state that both your parents had happy childhoods - maybe they only told you the good bits? What you see of your grandparents isn't necessarily how they were as parents; you've seen how other people have reacted to your 'revelations' about your childhood.

You chose to have children after your childhood - try and bear in mind how your memories are making you feel as your go forward being the perfect parent, never losing your temper/being stressed/never having too much to drink.

Cryalot2 · 21/11/2021 10:05

Sorry op what you went through.
Believe me you were far from alone.

Yes parents are supposed to love and protect you. In real life so few adults ever knew they were loved or protected.

Dh and I had very different up bringings and yet neither of us ever were told we were loved or cared for. One of us got no birthday cards or presents and only christmas presents up until they were about 9/ 10.
The other had a drunken father. So much violence and beatings, yet some happy times .
There was poverty and pain.

But all we can do is live our lives the best we can .

The past is behind us, we cannot change it. Enjoy the present for what it is, and not worry about the future.

If things are dragging you down see a counsellor or therapist, but do not mention to your parents. They were only doing their best

CoveredInSnow · 21/11/2021 09:52

OP I absolutely get why you’d want to confront your parents. I want to confront mine, to ask why on Earth they thought treating us like they did was acceptable, why they thought repeating the crap/struggling parenting they’d experienced was acceptable, why they treated us like we were an inconvenience. Why, why, WHY?

But I know, deep down, what would become of it. My mother would do her martyr act, banging on about how much she struggled (yes, but you didn’t do much to address it, did you?) but she was always there. Except “being there” didn’t achieve anything other than making sure we were quiet, didn’t trouble her too much and didn’t want to do anything extravagant like have our friends over or go anywhere.

My father wouldn’t have a word of it, he can’t bear criticism and he would back my mother to the hilt. It would probably descend into aggression to the back drop of my mother’s weeping and a completely ruined relationship.

So I just step away, keep them at an emotional arm’s length and just deal separately with how I feel about it all.

Flowers
Durbeyfield · 21/11/2021 09:45

Excellent post Alcemeg

Alcemeg · 21/11/2021 09:43

Unless they were deliberately cruel, I don't think it's fair to confront our parents with their failures, unless we also thank them wholeheartedly for their efforts.

It took me years to realise that despite fucking me up in various ways, my mum and dad also provided many important forms of care that other parents can neglect. Besides, as well as inheriting some of their annoying weaknesses, some of the ways I take after them have ended up serving me well.

Different stages of life give us wholly new perspectives, and sometimes tunnel vision. Yours at the moment is very much focused on ideal parenting, with your DD centre stage. If you now find your parents lacking, I'd keep this revelation to yourself for now. Family life is often a messy business and the deep intimacy of the parent/child relationship doesn't lend itself to the kind of close monitoring and performance feedback we might be used to from work.

billy1966 · 21/11/2021 09:24

OP,

Your childhood sounds absolutely horrendous.

Your father was a nasty abusive drunk.

You sound as if you lived on your nerves thoughout your childhood and are quite traumatised by it.

It really sounds awful.

I think speaking to someone would be helpful.

You are very generous to have them in your life, but I certainly wouldn't want them staying in my home.

You are anxious when they stay with you so I would stop that.

See less of them would be my recommendation.

They doubtfully will admit anything but I think if you want to say you had a deeply traumatic childhood do.

They no doubt will minimise it, but they aren't very nice people.

Your father sounds like a very nasty piece of work.

Mind yourself and do not minimise how awful this must have been.

Because it does sound terrifying for a child and deeply scary.

Flowers
Lunificent · 21/11/2021 09:08

I don’t think confronting them will help as they won’t be able to reflect on themselves in the way you would like them to. They will see it as you being difficult, and that impression will be reinforced between them so that they don’t have to face the truth that’s somewhere repressed in the backs of their heads.
But you can protect yourself from them now and feel under no obligation to them whatsoever. See them when you want to on your own terms.

Fomofo · 21/11/2021 09:07

It must have been a difficult decision for your mum to stay with a man like your dad but I'm guessing she did it for what she thought would be more stability for the family, rightly or wrongly

Swipe left for the next trending thread