Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find this odd ? Disabled parking spaces.

167 replies

itsgettingwierd · 20/11/2021 18:20

So today ds and I travelled to a sporting event for para sport somewhere we've not been before.

We knew there were lots of public car parks.

So we arrive, park, and I do to the machine to buy a ticket for 4-6 hours.

Note: car park is 24 hours and all ticket options available.

At the machine it says blue badge holders get 3 hours free. Fab I think and ask the attendant if I have to come back after the 3 hours to pay for the remaining time or how does it work.

Nope - I'm allowed 3 hours in the car park only. That's it.

It seemed really odd to me. My county allows 3 hours only if you park on double yellows which I've never done but all car parks you've paid as everyone does and can have as long as you need. At sports centres we've never been limited to time and it's been free like it's free to everyone.

The attendants reasoning was "to make it fair". But I don't get that. How's it's fair if you're disabled you can only stay somewhere for 3 hours but if you're able bodied you can stay all day?

I'd be happy to pay as don't think disability is a reason to need free parking - but it is a reason to need accessible parking so you can actually get out of the car!

OP posts:
ikeptgoing · 22/11/2021 06:02

I agree with you @itsgettingwierd. It is inequitable - it forces disabled drivers to leave after 3 hours and not other non disabled drivers who can pay for more time to stay.

If the time limit was 3 hours in total for all users that would be fairer. However it still disadvantages disabled people given all day events are held (including para type sporting events) - are booked with agreement of park owner, which disabled people attend who cannot move their cars elsewhere after 3 hours, further afield at to "walk" back.

It is a breach of The Equality Act 2010 as disabled users are treated less favourably than non disabled users without reasonable adjustments.

The first step is to complain to the provider of the car park.

Then contact

www.equalityhumanrights.com/en

www.equalityhumanrights.com/en/advice-and-guidance/avoiding-discrimination-physical-environment

There's a time limit to go to EHRC so you may need to report to them not long after stating you have made a complaint and it is still in process but you write so it falls within statutory timescales

itsgettingwierd · 22/11/2021 05:01

@Marvellousmadness

But imagine the reverse What if there are a few disabled parking spots and those people decide to stay all freaking day and therefore leaving you without a place to park? So I get the limit. Because if you wanna park there a day long, you're excluding someone else from parking there.
And every other person who could park there all day in a space was excluding someone else from using it!

The point is the inequality of the 2 types of spaces. Able bodied people could park all day. Disabled people couldn't.

My local council manages to have equality. You park in a BB nay for as long as you need and you pay the time like everyone else.

And just like anyone else if there's no BB nay available you find alternative car park.

But to have to leave an event midway through to move the car isn't equality when able bodied people aren't required to do the same.

OP posts:
Marvellousmadness · 22/11/2021 02:57

But imagine the reverse
What if there are a few disabled parking spots and those people decide to stay all freaking day and therefore leaving you without a place to park?
So I get the limit. Because if you wanna park there a day long, you're excluding someone else from parking there.

WizardHowl · 22/11/2021 02:23

Some shocking ableism on this thread.

Lots of blasé suggestions of ‘Can’t you just…’. Well, no. Disabled people generally can’t ‘just’ - that’s kind of the point, and why accessible accommodations need to be provided in the first place!

In the social model of disability, people with impairments are rendered disabled by barriers in society. What OP is describing is such an example of that.

HappyDays40 · 22/11/2021 02:02

I think that was probably his interpretation of the rules. Very odd.

2020isnotbehaving · 21/11/2021 23:27

It is surprising when having a disability is the largest “other” minority in the country and unlike religion race nationality or sexuality can drop on you from a great height on any day of your life without notice. Yet still people thing is will never happen to them.

Voice0fReason · 21/11/2021 23:02

It's clear from some of the posts on this thread that some people think that blue badges and free parking are a cool perk.
That we should pay our way and be grateful for the tidbits that get thrown our way. That we should just try harder to fit in.

The amount of time we have driven around a car park wanting to go shopping or a restaurant etc, but had to turn around and go home because there wasn't a BB space available. We CAN'T just park somewhere else. My DH is a blue badge holder, I can't drive so I can't drop him off and park elsewhere. We just want to have the same ability to access places that everyone else takes for granted.

itsgettingwierd · 21/11/2021 22:02

• Blue Badge holders can park for free in designated disabled spaces in surface car parks
• For non-disabled bays standard charges apply
• Maximum stay in a designated disabled bay in a car park is three hours
• Parking is chargeable for all users in our multi-storey car parks

This is from the website of the council.

It's clear. Max stay is 3 hours.

OP posts:
itsgettingwierd · 21/11/2021 21:59

Btw in my home town centre car park I pay the same as everyone else. No issue with that. But I park in BB space.

If we had a limit of 3 hours I'd never be able to do cinema etc with ds.

OP posts:
itsgettingwierd · 21/11/2021 21:57

@Hboo31

I agree with *@Whitefire* It reads to me that you get 3 hours free. If you want 4 hours you pay for 4 hours, not just the extra hour. The OP says they asked if they could pay for extra and the answer was no but it wasn't explained that you must pay for the whole time.
I was told I couldn't pay for any time. I could only stay for 3 hours. That's it. No option to pay at all or pay to extend.
OP posts:
itsgettingwierd · 21/11/2021 21:55

@Whitefire

The policy is fine and makes sense, the attendant was wrong.

It doesn't say a BB holder can only stay for three hours, just they don't have to pay if they stay for up to three hours. I would then take it to mean that a BB holder wanting to stay for 4hours would need to pay for the full lot.

Except I was told I couldn't. By the traffic warden. I was told they only had 5 BB spaces and so they limit time to make it fair. Except it's not "fair" when able bodied people can stay all day and beyond.

They told me on street parking was free all day. The signs did not say this. There weren't any spaces.

Plus it's not safe for a wheelchair user to be getting out of the car into a wheelchair with the door wide open onto busy traffic. The other alternative is to cross head first onto traffic and reverse in facing the wrong way.

It's just all the jumping through hoops disabled people have to go through to access facilities able bodied people can.

OP posts:
itsgettingwierd · 21/11/2021 21:50

[quote SmaugMum]@itsgettingwierd, so sorry for the very annoying and random derail.

My DD has a BB as she falls into a priority category; if only I had a pound for every time I’ve heard ‘I’ll only be five minutes’ as a disabled parking space is blocked once again by a non-disabled, non-Blue Badge holder.

The ableism here continues…[/quote]
Not a derail at all.

I think this thread highlights that we all need to tell our stories and get the understanding out there.

Absolutely right if a homosexual person was refused parking equally people would be up in arms.

You don't choose to be disabled anymore than you choose to be homosexual.

OP posts:
RockingMyFiftiesNot · 21/11/2021 21:37

[quote Hboo31]@SmaugMum no, a free 3 hours if they want a short visit. If not, they pay the same as everyone else. Not a curfew, they can stay as long as they like but they pay for the full time.

I did not make the rules, nor am I saying I agree with them. I'm just giving my interpretation of the restrictions.[/quote]
But that is not actually what the information says (although it is ambiguous), However the parking warden verified that they can ONLY stay 3 hours. It's not to do with paying, it's how long you are allowed to stay in the disabled spaces.

SmaugMum · 21/11/2021 21:27

[quote BlusteringBoobies]@SmaugMum That is beyond shocking on the teacher's part.

I am furious just reading this and it's not even my daughter!

Not wanting to derail this thread too much but please update tomorrow. And I hope the response is somewhere along the lines of a grovelling and unending apology.[/quote]
@BlusteringBoobies, thanks so much for your concern. l intend to let my DD’s qualified teacher for the visually impaired (QTVI) fire the metaphorical bullet at school; they never listen to me as I’m only the parent. Fortunately, my DD’s QTVI is a shit-hot ninja assassin…

SmaugMum · 21/11/2021 21:22

Oh, I give up…the haters gonna hate, hate, hate. The dickheads gonna dickhead, dickhead.

SmaugMum · 21/11/2021 21:16

Too many posters on this thread (the non-disabled?) seem to see this as a money issue (ie pesky disabled people getting all the freebie perks in life) rather than a mobility/access/attempting to have a life issue. Ableism strikes again.

SmaugMum · 21/11/2021 21:09

But the OP says this was not possible, according to the parking attendant.

Hboo31 · 21/11/2021 21:07

@SmaugMum no, a free 3 hours if they want a short visit. If not, they pay the same as everyone else. Not a curfew, they can stay as long as they like but they pay for the full time.

I did not make the rules, nor am I saying I agree with them. I'm just giving my interpretation of the restrictions.

SmaugMum · 21/11/2021 20:26

@Hboo31

I agree with *@Whitefire* It reads to me that you get 3 hours free. If you want 4 hours you pay for 4 hours, not just the extra hour. The OP says they asked if they could pay for extra and the answer was no but it wasn't explained that you must pay for the whole time.
So, a curfew on the disabled, lest they get in the way of the important non-disabled people beyond their allocated time slot. And a piss-take of a nod to being disabled friendly?
Hboo31 · 21/11/2021 20:23

I agree with @Whitefire
It reads to me that you get 3 hours free. If you want 4 hours you pay for 4 hours, not just the extra hour. The OP says they asked if they could pay for extra and the answer was no but it wasn't explained that you must pay for the whole time.

LuluBlakey1 · 21/11/2021 19:54

@knittingaddict

It's a mess obviously. My suggestion only works if you have an able bodied person with you who can move and pay the extra.

I'm not trying to be a pain. I just misunderstood the situation at first. My mum has a blue badge, so I'm not unsympathetic.

I would write to someone, may be the newspapers. You can't have been the only one to be massively inconvenienced by this.

I don't understand your point. OP has a son who uses a wheelchair and can not exit or enter the vehicle without the surrounding space of a disabled bay. It's not about paying - she is happy to pay. It is about only being allowed to use a disabled space for 3 hours and then having to leave or move to a space where her son could not get in or out if the vehicle.
SmaugMum · 21/11/2021 19:44

@Chocolatewheatos

So I'd say it's unclear. Pay the full parking time and stay as long as you paid for. 🤷‍♀️
The OP has a child in a wheelchair who needs wider access. Disability spaces are typically wider than normal spaces for this reason. The OP (and child in a wheelchair) wanted to spend longer than the three hours allocated doing life stuff. They couldn’t park in a ‘normal’ space due to wheelchair requirements but the parking attendant wouldn’t permit them to spend ‘free’ three hours in the BB space and then pay for their extra time.

And breathe….😅

Chocolatewheatos · 21/11/2021 19:37

So I'd say it's unclear. Pay the full parking time and stay as long as you paid for. 🤷‍♀️

Chocolatewheatos · 21/11/2021 19:36

Wait. So you weren't allowed to pay for the full parking time at all? I understood that you couldn't have 3hrs free then pay for more?
If the rule is "disabled people aren't allowed in the car park more than 3hrs" then that's absolutely unfair.

Whitefire · 21/11/2021 19:34

The policy is fine and makes sense, the attendant was wrong.

It doesn't say a BB holder can only stay for three hours, just they don't have to pay if they stay for up to three hours. I would then take it to mean that a BB holder wanting to stay for 4hours would need to pay for the full lot.

Swipe left for the next trending thread