Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If there was a war and conscription was mandatory would you go?

306 replies

visitingagain · 20/11/2021 16:33

Do people think the government has the right to conscript people? Should people who won't comply get punished?

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 20/11/2021 18:05

@visitingagain

It's interesting because there are so many people on other threads arguing that they will never comply with mandatory vaccines *@PearlclutchersInc* that was the Austria thread. Mumsnet at its finest
Ohhhhhhh I see now! It’s the boring old hypocrite argument!

No, I don’t think many people would want mandatory vaccines. I think you’re mad not to get it, but ultimately I think you should have the right to choose.

shiningjustforyou · 20/11/2021 18:05

No, I'd rather go to prison.
I would never comply with a government ordering me to fight.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 20/11/2021 18:05

@PainterInPeril

I refuse to kill or terrorise others so I'd be a conscientious objector. And yes, I'm aware that I'd probably be jailed. My late Great-Aunt was a conscientious objector (she was one of Jehovah's witnesses, like me) during WWII and was jailed. I'm so proud of her.
If everybody else refused to do it, though, going by WWII, both you and your late Great Aunt would have been murdered for your beliefs, along with a shedload of other people. Maybe you are fine with that, but it's not right that people who didn't want to be exterminated like cockroaches would meet the same fate.

I think that conscripts would be more of a liability than anything else now.

Onetraumaatatimeplease · 20/11/2021 18:04

Not a prayer. And none of my children would go either. I'm not putting my life on the line so rich men can have a dick waving competition. The people who start wars are never personally effected. So if op is a journo or secretly polling the public on behalf of boris my answer is absolutely fucking not.

GoodnightGrandma · 20/11/2021 18:03

No I wouldn’t.

DismantledKing · 20/11/2021 18:01

Do you care how many the Romans killed? no.

I’m sorry, this is the most idiotic thing I’ve ever seen on here. ‘History doesn’t carry on’ for the millions dead.

RJnomore1 · 20/11/2021 18:00

It’s very different from mandatory vaccines.

With a war you are actively sending people into mortal danger.

With the vaccine all of the science tells us it saves lives and reduces risk for everyone.

I don’t believe in mandatory vaccines either tbh but conscription to fight is a very very different thing.

Octavia174 · 20/11/2021 18:00

@DismantledKing

Over time, would it have mattered? Look at the USSR, they took over much of eastern europe after 1945, killed millions, yet now, these countries are flourishing and the Soviets are distance memory. Tough for those who died and lived under the Soviets but they don't all speak Russian... which is odd because apparently we would now all be speaking German had we lost.

Chances are, the Germany empire would have folded by now and who knows what would have happened?

Are you kidding?! It would certainly have mattered to the Jews of Europe, who would have all been murdered. And everyone else that the Nazi’s had set out to kill.

Do you care how many the Romans killed? no.
Octavia174 · 20/11/2021 17:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

ilovesooty · 20/11/2021 17:58

@iklboo

Ironically I noticed that the elderly weren't too happy about sacrificing themselves and putting their lives at risk in the national interest during the pandemic so that we could maintain our way of life. So bollocks to them if they think I'll do it to protect them!

And the rest of the population? Children? People with disabilities?

Gotta love MN ageism.

Yes, exactly.
ilovesooty · 20/11/2021 17:56

@visitingagain

I hope that's a joke *@stairway*
I doubt it, unfortunately.
GnomeDePlume · 20/11/2021 17:55

Yes I would.

Though at my age and general lack of fitness I suspect my service would be more on the home front. I would happily dig for victory.

TheQueef · 20/11/2021 17:55

It depends on the war really.
If we we're invaded, and they were desperate enough I'd attempt to fight.
For some insane war over dubious reasons, I'd rather go to prison.

DismantledKing · 20/11/2021 17:52

Over time, would it have mattered?
Look at the USSR, they took over much of eastern europe after 1945, killed millions, yet now, these countries are flourishing and the Soviets are distance memory.
Tough for those who died and lived under the Soviets but they don't all speak Russian... which is odd because apparently we would now all be speaking German had we lost.

Chances are, the Germany empire would have folded by now and who knows what would have happened?

Are you kidding?! It would certainly have mattered to the Jews of Europe, who would have all been murdered. And everyone else that the Nazi’s had set out to kill.

ElvisPresleyHadABaby · 20/11/2021 17:49

@DismantledKing

The government would award all the conscription contracts to all their mates, so the Russians would be marching up Whitehall before the notices went out (and privatised Royal Mail would take a fortnight to deliver them anyway)
Grin
ColinTheKoala · 20/11/2021 17:47

@Mysterian

I think a war should be voted on, and only those who voted for it should have to fight.
This.

I have no desire to die for my country (or even to do military or jury service). My only obligation as a citizen is to pay my taxes and not break (reasonable) laws.

It's usually male politicians who cause wars. So they can sort them out.

ElvisPresleyHadABaby · 20/11/2021 17:47

Oh just seen PP mention being nurses/hospital based, I'd definitely do that!

ThroughThickAndThin01 · 20/11/2021 17:47

@Mysterian

I think a war should be voted on, and only those who voted for it should have to fight.
So you’d be happy for Germany and it’s allied to have won, and all Jews, Gypsies, disabled, SN, all systematically killed after their war victory.

Because you and millions or others wouldn’t have been prepared to fight for their freedom.

You are pathetic.

Twentypast · 20/11/2021 17:46

@Octavia174 It might have mattered to the Jewish posters on here. Who wouldn't be here if Hitler had won and/or invaded Britain.

ElvisPresleyHadABaby · 20/11/2021 17:45

Thankfully think me and my brood would be medically exempt (possibly the only time it would be a good thing), but if not I don't know what I'd do. Obviously would volunteer if DC could stay at home but don't think it works like that. DH would love it though.

Octavia174 · 20/11/2021 17:44

@Babdoc

Hmm. So you would have preferred Britain to lose WW2? Assuming you were against conscription for all the Allied forces. It’s an easy moral stance during peacetime, but rather different for a government facing the invasion of its country and the mass murder of its citizens, if it doesn’t rapidly conscript sufficient troops for defence purposes.
Over time, would it have mattered? Look at the USSR, they took over much of eastern europe after 1945, killed millions, yet now, these countries are flourishing and the Soviets are distance memory. Tough for those who died and lived under the Soviets but they don't all speak Russian... which is odd because apparently we would now all be speaking German had we lost.

Chances are, the Germany empire would have folded by now and who knows what would have happened?

Its easy to view world events through a very narrow telescope of our own perspective.

DismantledKing · 20/11/2021 17:43

[quote iklboo]@Ted27 - of course not. But the poster had said they doubted the WW1 & WW2 conscripts wanted to join up. I was just saying they did at the time. They had no way of knowing what it was really like - most thought it would be a big adventure. Unfortunately, as we know now, it was anything but. [/quote]
If someone really wants to join up, the can volunteer before they’re conscripted. To actually have to be conscripted shows a certain reticence to do so.

upinaballoon · 20/11/2021 17:43

Did some Quakers work on the battlefields, collecting up the wounded and so on, but not directly fighting?

DismantledKing · 20/11/2021 17:42

The government would award all the conscription contracts to all their mates, so the Russians would be marching up Whitehall before the notices went out (and privatised Royal Mail would take a fortnight to deliver them anyway)

romdowa · 20/11/2021 17:42

Only if I could press the button that launches the missiles!

Swipe left for the next trending thread