Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If there was a war and conscription was mandatory would you go?

306 replies

visitingagain · 20/11/2021 16:33

Do people think the government has the right to conscript people? Should people who won't comply get punished?

OP posts:
MrsFin · 21/11/2021 09:21

@WhatHoMarjorie

Well, what's your opinion? Or are you just gathering them for an article?

Of course the govt doesn't have the moral right, and should never have the legal right, to force people to fight some bullshit war.

But what if it wasn't a bullshit war? What if our own liberty was at stake?

What if the Falklands weren't a few little islands nobody has heard of (as they were at the time Argentina invaded), and they were just off the coast of the U.K. mainland like Anglesey or the IOM, or the Shetlands?
If our armed forces didn't have the manpower to protect somewhere like that, would you just allow them to be taken over?

PicsInRed · 21/11/2021 09:16

@madisonbridges

To be honest, I don't suit green so the army's out. I look good in blue but I get airsick and seasick and I'm claustrophobic. So, on the whole, I'd probably have to come down against conscription.
Iirc, durng ww2 they provided anti nausea pills for that.
CounsellorTroi · 21/11/2021 09:02

I expect conscription would include women as well as men if they had it now. But it couldn’t be the entire adult population as some people would have to keep the country going (like the women did in the past). So they’d have to be some sort of system

There were reserved occupations in WW2 where you didn’t have to join up

www.bbc.co.uk/history/ww2peopleswar/timeline/factfiles/nonflash/a6652019.shtml

Arethechildreninbedyet · 21/11/2021 08:50

[quote alienbaby]@Arethechildreninbedyet
Whats the series and is it good?[/quote]
It’s called the defeated and it’s about two different police officers dealing with crimes in the city and they’ve got their own secrets going on. I’ve seen the first two episodes and it’s quite graphic and dark but I really enjoyed them. Going to carry on next weekend when DH is next off.

visitingagain · 21/11/2021 08:41

@CheeseMmmm

I'm still pretty fucked off by the OP drawing a comparison between conscription here for the world wars esp ww1 which was horrific, and Jabs and face masks which are not even sodding compulsory.

Plus all those around the world now in atrocious situations with civil war/ extremists wanting to take over/ between countries, and more.

Child soldiers, rape, murder, torture. Homes destroyed. Imprisonment with no charge. Bombings. I mean it's horrific.

@CheeseMmmm I think you've misunderstood me completely! I'm more interested in peoples opinions on conscription and the idea of something being mandatory and where their responsibility to society lies. Mainly because so there was so much pp on the Austria and other threads who said they would never comply with vaccines , the state has no right, bodily autonomy etc etc. But interesting to see loads on here who accept that in some way they would contribute to a war situation and basically accept the state can mandate things. Even people who are pacifists would contribute. I don't think it's the same group of posters on this thread!
OP posts:
alienbaby · 21/11/2021 07:57

@Arethechildreninbedyet
Whats the series and is it good?

UseOfWeapons · 21/11/2021 07:54

I’d go if conscripted, but think I’d be too old. I’d be happy to help in another capacity, and would be happy to volunteer for that. Every male in my family has been in the Armed Forces, so the idea doesn’t seem unreasonable to me.

Arethechildreninbedyet · 21/11/2021 07:46

[quote BlueFlavour]@CheeseMmmm
Russian soldiers were notorious for rape.[/quote]
There’s a new series on Netflix about life in Berlin in the immediate months after WW2. It’s really quite harrowing.

The treatment of German citizens especially women and children by the forces of all fronts, mainly Russians but also America, French, British etc, was indefensible.

Peace43 · 21/11/2021 07:45

I’m a pacifist. I’d be a nurse or something similar but I’m fundamentally opposed to killing my fellow man - no matter what the political leanings of his commanding officer. I would intervene to try to stop violence happening right in front of me but couldn’t train to go out and shoot people.

Arethechildreninbedyet · 21/11/2021 07:44

@WhatHoMarjorie

Even during wwii we didn't totally trust USA and certainly not USSR!

And yet despite the popular British narrative that WWII was won by GB and GB alone, without Russia you'd have been fucked.

Quite.

The success of WW2 was almost entirely due to the Americans and the Russians. British Troops were withdrawn during the Dunkirk Evacuation and were losing spectacularly until the Americans arrived in 1942.

Following the D-Day Landings it was the war on two fronts that eventually overpowered Hitler, led by Russia and mainly the Americans. British Contribution whilst invaluable was not the driving force.

BlueFlavour · 21/11/2021 07:42

@CheeseMmmm
Russian soldiers were notorious for rape.

BlueFlavour · 21/11/2021 07:40

I think the Russian winter was pretty devastating for Axis.

Pixxie7 · 21/11/2021 06:41

If there is another world war conscription would probably come back and yes I would do my bit. Although most wars are about religion and or political ww2 was about far more than that not to mention the thousands of innocent people killed it was above the ravings of a maniac who wanted to control the world. If brave men and women hadn’t gone to fight Jews, travellers, homosexuals to name a few would have been eliminated.

garlictwist · 21/11/2021 06:33

I'd go if I had to but I'd just hide at the back making soup or something.

Letsallscreamatthesistene · 21/11/2021 06:20

@greenpolkadot55

im too old but if i was young enough if join the Wrens,,,,nice uniform
Doesnt exist anymore! Sorry. Youd have to join the Navy
Yusanaim · 21/11/2021 06:12

I would think the power of social media could convince a fair number of young people to sign up for some wokeypokey something they have been convinced is a deserving cause.

Thinking about it I can see the glorifying of killing and defeating (ISIS ?) some BAAad people (according to the social media trope/nutter on tiktok) would be a cause very many, considering it's global reach, would risk death for.

madisonbridges · 21/11/2021 06:08

@WhatHoMarjorie
I did history o level in the 1970s. I spent 2 years doing nothing but studying WW2. I know about flipping Mussolini, and Hitler and Russia and Hitler breaking the pact and invading Russia and making the same mistake as Napoleon. Blah, blah, blah. Of course you hear about Russia in the war. There's tons of programmes about that on TV.

The allies might still have won without Russia, but without the commonwealth countries, we might not even have lasted long enough to see the USA enter the war. Still, it's good that Hitler betrayed Stalin because I'm not sure how many western countries could have withstood the loss of life that Russia did and not have collapsed under public opinion.

Penners99 · 21/11/2021 05:59

I believe that a form of National Service (military or civilian) should be required, before access to the right to vote, benefits, and healthcare is allowed.

kavalkada · 21/11/2021 05:24

As somebody who has been through a war as a child and saw first hand rich people sending their kids to western countries to study so they do not have to go to war, I am 100 per cent sure that if another war comes I'll do everything in my power to protect my family from going to army.

My mother during the 1991. - 1995. war worked in a restaurant, cooking for an army. One wall of that restaurant was looking at a harbour with many yachts. She had to work every day if she didn't want to end in prison or withoout her job and look all those rich people run with their yachts to Italy to be safe. Usually, they were the biggest warmongers in our community.

They had zero intention of risking the lives of their children and their own, but had zero trouble sending other people's children to risk their lives.

So, if there is any way I can help it, no.

CheeseMmmm · 21/11/2021 05:12

Imo dropping nukes was an atrocity. Yes reasons I'm sure but like I say not great on history.

Nukes though are just... Incomprehensibly awful.

USA only country to have done it.

CheeseMmmm · 21/11/2021 05:10

Just looked Russia lost 26 million in ww2.

Fucking hell.

Conditions appalling. I mean I'm not great on history tbh but that scale of loss and the way they were treated.

More should be known about all sides.

Including the atrocities committed.

alienbaby · 21/11/2021 04:58

Yeah I'd go. I'd figure at least I would be doing something interesting. And even if I die, at least history will wrote about me - not me personally, but us. Assuming peace would come again, I wouldn't be able to bear the idea that I hadn't helped make it that way. Some of my friends would inevitably die and I wouldn't be able to bear the idea that they had died and i had ducked out.

I would probably need to take a lot of cocaine to get me through it though.

WhatHoMarjorie · 21/11/2021 04:53

@madisonbridges

Just because you need someone, it doesnt mean you have to like or trust them. I don't know anyone who thinks GB could have won without the US. But equally the US couldn't have won without its allies too.
Russia.

It was Russia who helped win the war in the end.

But you never hear that in the endless UK WWII commentary. Your average UK citizen is most likely oblivious to that fact.

CheeseMmmm · 21/11/2021 04:48

Whole narrative exemplifies history written by Victor. So much is just not mention mentioned. Or hardly ever. Also impact on women has only been talked about s bit in mainstream recently..eg rape of Berlin.

madisonbridges · 21/11/2021 04:24

Just because you need someone, it doesnt mean you have to like or trust them.
I don't know anyone who thinks GB could have won without the US. But equally the US couldn't have won without its allies too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread