Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If there was a war and conscription was mandatory would you go?

306 replies

visitingagain · 20/11/2021 16:33

Do people think the government has the right to conscript people? Should people who won't comply get punished?

OP posts:
BrilliantBetty · 21/11/2021 20:54

Yes I think I probably would.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 21/11/2021 18:51

I hope that I would do what I believe to be morally right.

If it is a just war then I hope I would not wait to be conscripted. I have huge respect for the women in WW2 who could have done their service in the relative safety of an office, factory or farm but instead risked their lives, such as the women of the SOE. I hope that I would be brave enough to put what skills I might have to the best use.

If it is not a just war then I certainly wouldn't volunteer, and would use whatever legal means possible to avoid an active role in the war. How far would I go though? Would I be prepared to go to prison? What if objecting put my family at risk?

I suspect realistically most would pick the least worst option and try to get a non-combat role and put up with it.

HappyDays40 · 21/11/2021 18:09

I would be a conscientious objector although they wouldn't use my skills for combat. I would probably be job exempt. Not quite sure who would look after my son though.

ALongHardWinter · 21/11/2021 18:06

Well apart from my age (58) I don't think I'd be forced into conscription due to numerous health problems and the fact that I'm registered disabled.

TonTonMacoute · 21/11/2021 18:01

If this country was dependent on 60 year old women to fight then I would say we were pretty much fucked anyway!

The thing is we are not at war and all but a few of us (possibly) have any idea what it is like.

During the last war people were really afraid that Nazi Germany might win and were happy to do whatever it took to prevent them.

PussyCatEatingPigsInBlankets · 21/11/2021 17:55

Not a chance.
They can lock me up in a nice warm prison and feed me.
I wonder if I can claim some of my TV license back...

TheHateIsNotGood · 21/11/2021 17:52

A very true song Rosetti - been some time since I've been in an Army Camp (as a visitor) but even in my early 20s I noticed how so young the soldiers were and that so many came from 'deprived' areas of the UK and the Army (Forces) gave them their only chance to better themselves.

And they did get a lot out of it, fine young men (it was the early 80s) who were rightly proud of themselves. I comforted myself that there weren't too many 'spheres of conflict' at that time. Of course the main one was NI back then.

DGRossetti · 21/11/2021 17:40

And as always, there's nothing new under the sun ...

What makes you go abroad, fighting for strangers ....

TheHateIsNotGood · 21/11/2021 17:36

Absolutely not and I have held that view for 50+years. I would try and dodge conscription and help my dc dodge conscription too.

This is what I would do and is completely separate to the great respect I hold for anyone that has fought in any war; it is so, so damaging. Many generations of my family, close family, and close friends have fought and lived through wars and none of them, not one, think and thought that war is the answer to anything.

However, would I fight hard and tough to defend against and resist a violent oppressor nearby, absolutely yes I would.

But never will I be willingly conscripted into fighting and killing.

DGRossetti · 21/11/2021 17:14

Really, pacifism should be our default setting, and anybody who isn't a pacifist really needs to take a long hard look at themselves.

There is a world of difference between actively defending yourself and your society (which is instinctual and natural) and actively allowing yourself to be shipped across the world to kill another human being.

over2021 · 21/11/2021 16:44

@Stompythedinosaur

I would be a conscious objector. Pacifism is important to me.
It's conscientious objector, though to be fair, most were also conscious.
SlamLikeAGuitar · 21/11/2021 16:37

Depends on the situation.
I am ex-army, so I feel like I can see this from both sides of the coin.
Would I rejoin the army by choice now? No way.
If we had another situation like the Nazis sweeping the continent, massacring innocent people? 100% yes I’d willingly do my bit.

HeadPain · 21/11/2021 16:19

For truly defence of our country, way of life and fellow citizens, if there was an invasion going to happen here or in countries nearby, especially by those like Nazis or ISIS (if they ever had an armed forces in Europe rather than random terrorist attacks), yes, absolutely.

DGRossetti · 21/11/2021 14:21

Are you really saying that if a group of people came to your town and said "we're claiming this town as our own", and forcibly ousted the mayor and the council, and brought in their own oppressive laws, you'd sit and watch them?

Especially as for some people, life in the UK already feels like that.

housemdwaswrong · 21/11/2021 14:09

I wouldn't be ble to medically. But I'm against it 100%. It's mandatory I S. Kore where I lived for a year, and it had a devastating effect on some, and some were allowed not to do it and do tied stare service instead, doctors etc. That's horrifically unfair. I think the govt should fund the armed services and reserve forces properly. Many young men would volunteer if it came to it I think, but conscription, no.

MrsFin · 21/11/2021 14:00

I would be a conscious objector. Pacifism is important to me.

Easy to say. I think pretty much everyone in their right mind is a pacifist, other than some religious zealots, who have usually been groomed in one way or another, so you could argue not in their right mind.

However, if someone threatens me and mine, be that my nuclear family, my larger family, my friends, my country and my way of life, I would bloody well fight them off as best I can.

Are you really saying that if a group of people came to your town and said "we're claiming this town as our own", and forcibly ousted the mayor and the council, and brought in their own oppressive laws, you'd sit and watch them? Or you'd sit and watch while this happened in the next town along?

Stompythedinosaur · 21/11/2021 13:50

I would be a conscious objector. Pacifism is important to me.

BubbleCoffee · 21/11/2021 13:34

Knowing of someone and knowing them are two different things...

Lots of people say they know Jesus...

BubbleCoffee · 21/11/2021 13:29

I refuse to kill or terrorise others so I'd be a conscientious objector.

What would you do if a large number of people were set on killing and terrorising you and your family? For example if you were Jewish in WW2? You wouldn't defend yourself or even your loved ones?

BubbleCoffee · 21/11/2021 13:27

I think a war should be voted on, and only those who voted for it should have to fight.

In that case, perhaps only those who voted for it should benefit from the freedoms it maintains and protects.

BlueFlavour · 21/11/2021 13:22

Thank you for that @Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g

Courtier · 21/11/2021 13:20

Pretty sure my fainting would mean I was exempt. Happy to help in another way though - comms, land army, watching for planes etc.

If they forced me to go and fight I'd be dead within a day so there's just no point.

Courtier · 21/11/2021 13:17

Nope. I faint when I see blood so I'd be useless.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 21/11/2021 12:36

Just wanted to put in a word for this incredible film if you've not seen it.

www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b0brzkzx/they-shall-not-grow-old

Peter Jackson and a huge team turned lots of archive film and later voice recordings of WW1 soldiers' experiences into something that looks and sounds like it would if recorded now. It makes what you see and hear far more immediate and relatable. Includes horrifying pictures of dead and injured men in places, but otherwise it would be a sanitised version of what they went through.

At the start a lot of them talk about how happy they were to volunteer for the army. Given what they went on to experience, it seems incredible to me that quite a few say it was the making of them. Recorded much later in life for the Imperial War Museum - my guess is probably in the 1950s/60s/70s, so they'd had time for reflection. Of course, what we don't hear is what their families and friends would say. A great many ex-soldiers who've been through combat are left with PTSD, or shell shock as it was labelled in WW1, and treatment/support for sufferers back then was almost non-existent, so there would have been serious long-term problems for both the ex-soldier and his loved ones.

Wellarentyouacleverdick · 21/11/2021 12:34

Haha. The government can't even make people have a jab, wear a mask or keep two big steps away from others. No way would be people actually do it even if they were ordered to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread