Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If there was a war and conscription was mandatory would you go?

306 replies

visitingagain · 20/11/2021 16:33

Do people think the government has the right to conscript people? Should people who won't comply get punished?

OP posts:
iklboo · 20/11/2021 17:42

@Ted27 - of course not. But the poster had said they doubted the WW1 & WW2 conscripts wanted to join up. I was just saying they did at the time. They had no way of knowing what it was really like - most thought it would be a big adventure. Unfortunately, as we know now, it was anything but.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 20/11/2021 17:42

The elderly and chronically sick shielded for at least 9 months so that everyone else could go about their business.

upinaballoon · 20/11/2021 17:39

@Vanishun

I imagine the armed forces wouldn't be best pleased to have to resort to it.

It would have to be a desperate last measure, and a weird one in the age of remote missiles and economic and virtual warfare etc.

At that stage, who knows? Maybe it would just be a desperate last thing that we'd all have to deal with somehow.

*Maybe it would just be a desperate last thing that we'd all have to deal with somehow."

Sounds like the 1939 scenario. Why did Neville Chamberlain go to see Hitler and come back and "wave a bit of paper at us and say 'Peace in our time'?"--because his generation had known the first WW and he didn't want to do it all again if he could help it, but Hitler wasn't the sort of darling you'd really want in charge of all of Europe and half of Africa...............................

Arethechildreninbedyet · 20/11/2021 17:39

@fantasmasgoria1

I walk with a stick so I doubt they would want me! 😂
I think you could bonk a nazi on the head with a stick! Might knock sense into them!

I'd have you in my platoon definitely!

naughtyfurballs · 20/11/2021 17:39

My grandfather was a conscientious objector in WW2 (Quaker). He avoided jail as far as I know, but ended up working as a mining engineer (so not right at the coal face); I don't know how voluntary that was, or if it was an option for conscientious objectors.

Germany had national service until about 20 years ago; you could opt for a shorter time (less than a year) in the armed forces or longer (about 18 months) doing a civilian role - the friend who explained this had worked as a carer for disabled adults. Offering a choice like that made service much more palatable to the general population.

Arethechildreninbedyet · 20/11/2021 17:37

I suppose it would depend on the war.

WW2 a fight against facism or a threat to our democracy and national safety? Give me my gun and where do I join up? It's my duty, I enjoy freedom and peace, so why should it be another to fight for me and not the other way around?

A war over foreign territory or oil? No ty, not my jam.

MilkTwoSugarsThanks · 20/11/2021 17:35

Given the way wars are fought these days I think conscription would be more trouble than it's worth.

JadeTrinket · 20/11/2021 17:35

@ArblemarchTFruitbat

A better idea would be to conscript people into customer service jobs for a couple of years. Then they might learn not to be arseholes to shop workers, waiting staff, call centre people etc.
Or they might run towards the front line after only a few days shouting ‘Kill me now!’?
DismantledKing · 20/11/2021 17:35

@iklboo

I doubt most of those conscripted during WW1&2 wanted to do it,

On the contrary - most saw it as their duty. Lads lied about their age to join up, there were queues at the conscription centres. It was a huge stigma not to join up.

Especially with dreadful women giving anyone out of uniform white feathers in 1914-18.
Ted27 · 20/11/2021 17:35

@iklboo

doing something willingly and being carried along by societal pressure and the consequences of not doing something are very different.

All of those young boys who signed up in 1914 had no idea what was in store for them. Do you really think 1000 upon 1000 of teenagers would have done so willingly if they had known about the reality of trench warfare?

iklboo · 20/11/2021 17:34

Ironically I noticed that the elderly weren't too happy about sacrificing themselves and putting their lives at risk in the national interest during the pandemic so that we could maintain our way of life. So bollocks to them if they think I'll do it to protect them!

And the rest of the population? Children? People with disabilities?

Gotta love MN ageism.

ArblemarchTFruitbat · 20/11/2021 17:33

A better idea would be to conscript people into customer service jobs for a couple of years. Then they might learn not to be arseholes to shop workers, waiting staff, call centre people etc.

DismantledKing · 20/11/2021 17:32

I’m too old to be conscripted.
Hardly likely though, is it?

MurielSpriggs · 20/11/2021 17:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

stairway · 20/11/2021 17:30

Visitingagain it isn’t a joke. I’ve always wondered why it was considered ok to kill off so many young men in these wars when they have their whole lives ahead of them, particularly WW1 society forcing all those healthy young men to their deaths. If we have to kill and mame anyone to settle disputes it would be better to do it to people who have already lived their lives. In all honesty though I don’t agree with wars at all and humans need to find a better way.

girlmom21 · 20/11/2021 17:30

@ThreeFeetTall

Surely we'd all be nuked before it came to that?
This is true. There'll never be another 'world war'. It'll just be whoever releases their nuclear missiles first. Everyone else is screwed.
Lasttraintolondon · 20/11/2021 17:29

Maybe if I was fighting Hitler, not so much the variety of foreign targets we've unsuccessfully fought in for the last thirty years. We have excellent armed forces but very poor politicians. I'd rather go to jail than fight for a single one of them.

fantasmasgoria1 · 20/11/2021 17:29

I walk with a stick so I doubt they would want me! 😂

ThreeFeetTall · 20/11/2021 17:29

Surely we'd all be nuked before it came to that?

GreenWhiteViolet · 20/11/2021 17:29

They probably wouldn't want me because of a physical disability, but no. I'd sooner go to jail than go to war (and I think jail would be awful, but here it's the lesser of two evils).

MurielSpriggs · 20/11/2021 17:28

@RedCarsGoFaster

Well, I'm 40, medically disabled, fat and very unfit. Can't imagine I'd be useful in the front line....

However, in terms of National Service, I'm a believer that it should be an OPTION for everyone (not a requirement). A short term stint in the military / as a hospital porter / in a public service (public sector) field could be positive for lots of people, especially if they aren't particularly qualified or interested in anything in particular. A 2yr contract could be great for lots of people.

👷Hard hat on!

It's an option for anyone right now.
Zilla1 · 20/11/2021 17:28

If ever conscription is run in anger, expect it to be deployed with lots of deferments and exemptions for the wealthy and well-connected.

PainterInPeril · 20/11/2021 17:26

I refuse to kill or terrorise others so I'd be a conscientious objector. And yes, I'm aware that I'd probably be jailed. My late Great-Aunt was a conscientious objector (she was one of Jehovah's witnesses, like me) during WWII and was jailed. I'm so proud of her.

visitingagain · 20/11/2021 17:25

I hope that's a joke @stairway

OP posts:
JadeTrinket · 20/11/2021 17:24

@Funnylittlefloozie

If things had got to the stage where conscription was extended to fat 49 year old women... I'd probably join up out of sheer desperation.
I think you’d be very dangerous!
Swipe left for the next trending thread