Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If there was a war and conscription was mandatory would you go?

306 replies

visitingagain · 20/11/2021 16:33

Do people think the government has the right to conscript people? Should people who won't comply get punished?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Octavia174 · 22/11/2021 13:01

Apologies if this has been posted before but whenever i hear supporting conscription, i think of this poem, Kiplin was a keen supporter of thios until his son was killed...
A Dead Statesman
I could not dig: I dared not to rob:
Therefore I lied to please the mob.
Now all my lies are proved untrue
And I must face the men I slew.
What tale shall serve me here among
Mine angry and defrauded young?

madisonbridges · 22/11/2021 12:15

@ChurchofLatterDayPaints

In answer to OP's question no I would not join up so it'd be field punishment, bread and water for me.

Fight for King Charles and country?? fuck off.

In answer to OP's question no I would not join up so it'd be field punishment, bread and water for me.

Or a bullet!

OnGoldenPond · 22/11/2021 10:46

Hell, they'd have to be desperate for cannon fodder to call me up! Grin

ColinTheKoala · 22/11/2021 10:29

@iklboo

I doubt most of those conscripted during WW1&2 wanted to do it,

On the contrary - most saw it as their duty. Lads lied about their age to join up, there were queues at the conscription centres. It was a huge stigma not to join up.

Well fortunately we've moved on since then. Stupid middle aged women who didn't need to fight, calling young men cowards. Completely disgusting.
ColinTheKoala · 22/11/2021 10:28

I actually think a kind of compulsory social “National Service” for all young people at 18, where you spent time working for the benefit of society, rather than toting a high powered assault rifle, so perhaps worked in schools, hospitals or local councils. or worked with older people, on various placements for a year or two for a basic salary, would really be transformative for society, teaching empathy, renewing the social contract, helping people understand the importance of community etc. And it would give people a real sense of national identity

The people who want this are always the ones too old to do it.

What about making well off early retirees do it instead?

ColinTheKoala · 22/11/2021 10:26

And WW2 only maintained freedoms for some anyway. Didn't do much for Eastern Europe - just changed dictator.

ColinTheKoala · 22/11/2021 10:26

@BubbleCoffee

I think a war should be voted on, and only those who voted for it should have to fight.

In that case, perhaps only those who voted for it should benefit from the freedoms it maintains and protects.

Ha ha most wars don't maintain freedoms. You cant judge every war by WW2.
ColinTheKoala · 22/11/2021 10:21

During the last war people were really afraid that Nazi Germany might win and were happy to do whatever it took to prevent them

That wasn't the last war - there have been loads since then and I maintain I would not get myself involved in any of them. For goodness sake just live alongside others. Wars generally happen when people (men) decide they want to tell others what to think, and/or steal their land. The Balkan wars are a case in point - lived alongside each other for decades and then once Tito was gone decided to murder each other? And for what? Wars are a pointless waste of money and lives.

HarrietsChariot · 22/11/2021 10:15

I like to think I've made myself unselectable for conscription due to my lifestyle choices. However, I think if I were forced into the military, I would shoot some colleagues and then myself the first chance I got - it would save all involved a lot of pain and suffering in the long run.

The trouble with people saying it would depend on the nature of the war is that often the truth of the matter isn't known until long after the fact. With WWII, the atrocities of the Germans weren't known in 1939 - the worst of the atrocities weren't even carried out until 1941/2. If you think conscription in 1939 when the Germans invaded Poland was OK, why not conscription more recently when Russia stole the Crimea?

notimagain · 22/11/2021 09:31

That's academic. Conscription is unthinkable except in the case of a world war and national survival being at stake.

In the context of a world war this whole debate is especially academic….there simply wouldn’t be enough time.

In the event of an all out war, say in Europe, involving somebody like Russia verses the west there wouldn’t be enough in conventional ammunition in the bunkers to stop one side or another having “fired out” of ordinary ordnance with a matter of a few days (where “few” was really not many) and I’ll leave what happens next to the imagination, but AFAIK it doesn’t involve conscription, certainly didn’t used to.

Conscripts aren’t a lot of use in the modern military anyway, which is why the practice stopped, certainly generally across Europe quite some time ago, reason being time to train to even the poor bl* infantry to a decent standard, cost/practicalities of equipping and provisioning. Last time I had any interaction with a part of the European military that used conscripts the poor sods were working as waiters in the mess or as gate guards….

ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 22/11/2021 08:20

The "off" being directed at the monarch, just to clarify.

ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 22/11/2021 08:10

In answer to OP's question no I would not join up so it'd be field punishment, bread and water for me.

Fight for King Charles and country?? fuck off.

ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 22/11/2021 08:07

Prison, forced alternative labour, ostracism and ridicule, usually.

The men were put in solitary confinement, demeaned and tortured, released and continually re-arrested for the duration of the war.

wri-irg.org/en/story/2010/they-said-no-war-british-women-conscientious-objectors-world-war-ii

Tumbleweed101 · 22/11/2021 07:06

Depends why. If we were about to be bombed in our homes as we were in the world wars it is a very different thing to travelling and fighting in war that doesn't directly impact our families and homes.

I think I'm too old to be much use on a front line somewhere but I'd be terrifies for my young adult children who are perfect ages to be picked.

MyDogLovesBiscuits · 22/11/2021 03:59

@stairway

Problem is government propaganda will make it look like a just war.
I think it would be harder to control the population via propaganda in a situation like because of the internet etc. There are so many different ways of communicating with each other and they are so much faster now.

I'm not saying it couldn't be done but I think the government would be fighting against information leaks left right and centre.

Platax · 22/11/2021 00:53

@LittleDandelionClock

As has been said, I wouldn't have any choice! Not if it was mandatory!
Presumably there would be some sort of provision for conscientious objectors.
MrsSkylerWhite · 22/11/2021 00:33

Depends on the justification, obviously.

eg: WW1,no, absolutely not. WW2, yes, justified.

Fahrenheist · 22/11/2021 00:29

Courtier
Pretty sure my fainting would mean I was exempt. Happy to help in another way though - comms, land army, watching for planes etc.

Ooh, I never thought of that - I've got quite into flightradar24 since we started having all the lockdowns so I'd be up for a bit of plane watching too.

Fahrenheist · 22/11/2021 00:24

Do they still reject you for having flat feet? If so I wouldn't have to do it.

If I did have to do it I'd make sure I got a job cooking or making chairs or something. Or being a fatal spy, preferably in France, sending secret messages on bits of parachute silk and shagging Frenchmen.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 22/11/2021 00:18

I'm ashamed to say that I'm hugely relieved they wouldn't want me due to a medical condition! But I would want to help in another way of course. A Bletchley Park scenario perhaps. Though I wouldn't be a star there, a very very very supporting junior! I remember 9/11 vividly, panicking that a world war would start and my brother would be called up for mandatory service. It was the first time I really realised an ounce of how families must feel sending their boys and men to war. Unthinkably terrifying.

DdraigGoch · 22/11/2021 00:02

@Pumperthepumper

I don’t think they could ever have conscription again in Britain. People wouldn’t do it, and they’d be right. It’s a fucking horrible part of our history.
People volunteered by the million before conscription was needed.

These days though, this country can't even get people to wear masks (even by threatening granny's death.)

DerAlteMann · 21/11/2021 23:54

@stairway

Problem is government propaganda will make it look like a just war.
That's academic. Conscription is unthinkable except in the case of a world war and national survival being at stake.
DerAlteMann · 21/11/2021 23:52

If the situation was so dire conscription became necessary, people would go. They always have. Even the Oxford Union. They said they wouldn't - but in the end, they did.

stairway · 21/11/2021 23:37

Problem is government propaganda will make it look like a just war.

rslsys · 21/11/2021 22:09

I voted for a Government. They can get in a boxing ring with the Government they are at war with. I'll abide by the result.

Swipe left for the next trending thread