Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask has anyone else been able to do this in life?

42 replies

flamebuoy · 20/11/2021 09:45

Woman I work with has claimed she has never had...
A credit card
A loan of any sort, student, car, personal etc
Or A mortgage (she owns a house outright)

I know it's possible I suppose, she's not loaded etc...but is it more common than I think?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
User3443525643 · 20/11/2021 11:29

Yes this is possible. My parents earned fairly well (not millions, but around 100K per year) and were frugal. They saved a lot of money to buy property outright because in our culture there's a certain stigma attached to loans. Cars were also bought in cash, not leased or loaned. My parents had no financial support from family at all as they were first generation immigrants. However this was in the 90s/early 20s where property prices were more reasonable than now.

We did end up getting credit cards for practical reasons since the rise of online shopping meant you had to have a CC to purchase or book things online. The card is linked with a direct debit so the amount is automatically paid off each month.

TableDesk · 20/11/2021 11:29

Prime example - my parents.

Both early 60's
Not university educated.
Bought a small piece of land when they got married, lived in a mobile home while they saved & built house accordingly.

Never a mortgage, loan, car loan, finance, credit card, everything paid off, in full.
Mum doesnt even have a debit card, so I have to purchase everything on line for her.

Dad self employed mostly paid by chq.
Mum employed paid into building society.

Live by the motto if you cant buy it you can't afford it Hmm

Very disappointed when I said I have to get a mortgage to purchase a house. I was 22!

Movinghouseatlast · 20/11/2021 11:22

My friend didn't have a credit card until she was 45. She has never had a loan and no mortgage because she rents. She also has no pension or savings, lives hand to mouth really. She's 62 now.

BillMasen · 20/11/2021 11:07

@MurielSpriggs

Loans don't mean you have any more money in your life. They just redistribute the income from one point in your life to another (and cost interest, so in fact overall you have less). If you've got a pretty stable income they're not necessary.
This is a great post and a great way to think of it. You’re just moving money from the future to the present, not getting any more of it.

Sometimes you need to do that to buy a large asset though. You have a stable income but need to move money from the future flows to be a lump now. I think that’s fine as someone else said, you have an asset so your balance sheet is ok.

Trisolaris · 20/11/2021 11:04

I don’t consider this aspirational. Even if I could afford not to have a mortgage (technically I could just not where I live) I would still have one, because it’s cheap credit and I would invest the money and get a better return on it.

I can get a 0% credit card and it gives me better protection for buying eg holidays etc.

Likewise I’d rather get a 0% finance agreement for things like phones, windows etc when available and in the meantime the money is earning me interest.

However, that’s very different from spending more money because you can via credit eg getting a nicer car on credit.

NovemberNovemberDarkNights · 20/11/2021 11:04

Never having a credit card is nothing to boast about.

Being able to manage money is more important than never having a mortgage or credit card.

Marrying someone who has capital is lovely, but it's not success. I'd be more impressed with a 30 yo who had bought a house with a mortgage in her name & hadn't got into unsecured debt 💁🏻‍♀️

vampirethriller · 20/11/2021 11:00

I've never had a credit card or a mortgage and my only loan was my student one.

trappedsincesundaymorn · 20/11/2021 10:59

DP has never had a credit card, loan or a mortgage. He only owns 50% of a house outright (paid cash no mortgage), though, his brother has the other 50%.

starrynight21 · 20/11/2021 10:58

I don't know why it would matter. Getting credit to purchase a house or other necessities is just a way of getting what you need when you need it. I've had mortgages, credit cards, personal loans , heaps of things like that. It meant that I've had a comfortable life and I continue to do so. I don't see it as a medal of honour to have no credit history.

starrynight21 · 20/11/2021 10:55

[quote flamebuoy]@CounsellorTroi she says she saved and then met her dh who had a mortgaged property so he sold (at a profit I presume) and then they pooled their money and bought outright...very plausible I suppose [/quote]
So she married money. Not everyone can do that !

MurielSpriggs · 20/11/2021 10:53

What’s the position with inheriting a house that was not your home? Would you have to pay capital gains tax, or would you if you sold it?

Tax-free if the total value of the estate (including the house) was below the inheritance-tax nil-rate band (currently £325k, or £500k if left to direct descendants).

Saz12 · 20/11/2021 10:48

ConsellorTrol, no, but there’d have been inheritance tax on the value of deceased estate.

But I don’t understand how someone in her mid-30’s could have gone to uni without racking up any student debt?

Either way it’s very impressive to’ve never needed loans etc and saved up instead.

AliceWo · 20/11/2021 10:34

That doesn't sound common at all, and it's not like she achieved it all herself, as it sounds like a significant proportion of the house money was her DH's.

I'm 52, only ever had one loan for £3k, don't use credit cards, and used to have a sole mortgage. Easier for my generation than the current one because of lack of tuition fees and lower house prices in the past.

CounsellorTroi · 20/11/2021 10:12

@Idony

Never had a loan or credit card. I just use debit and spend what I have.

I knew a teenager with a house outright as her aunt had left it to her.

What’s the position with inheriting a house that was not your home? Would you have to pay capital gains tax, or would you if you sold it?
notanothertakeaway · 20/11/2021 10:08

I've never had a loan

Could live without a credit card easily. only ever use it for the added protection

Unusual to own a house without ever having a mortgage

Idony · 20/11/2021 10:05

Never had a loan or credit card. I just use debit and spend what I have.

I knew a teenager with a house outright as her aunt had left it to her.

StormyTeacups · 20/11/2021 10:04

She couldn't have done it without the purchase, sale and profit from another house, which required a mortgage. So that part is not overly remarkable

newtb · 20/11/2021 10:04

When the idea of credit scoring first became a big thing, 70s or 80s either the Telegraph or Which did a fictitious application applying the standard questions to Prince Philip showing he'd either get turned down for a loan or a credit card.

I know several orthodox Jewish families where it's their tradition to buy a house/flat for the newlyweds. Means there's no financial obstacle to starting a family. If you think when interest rates were 15% you were paying £120/month for a £10,000 mortgage over 25 years, you paid back £36,000. That's £26,000 in interest.
The reason banks and building societies like 25 year terms is that it makes them a shed load of money.
I got slung off a mortgage 'advisors' course. It was when people were borrowing 7 times their income and they were able to do it without any accountant's certificate if self-employed, just shove a number in a box, and loans were being given.

sjxoxo · 20/11/2021 10:02

We have a mortgage & a small student loan. Never had a credit card or any other sort of credit or loan. My parents have never had credit cards and to be honest I’d be frightened to get one! Idea of being tied to debt frightens me. Mortgage is essential but we are doing a renovation and beyond the hump of it now so technically house is worth more than outstanding mortgage so I don’t worry about that. xo

ArblemarchTFruitbat · 20/11/2021 10:02

this woman must have saved a hell of a lot if she had enough, together with the profit from her DH’s mortgaged home, to buy a house outright.

We don't know the proportions of their contributions, or how much the new house cost. She might have saved a lot, she might not.

MurielSpriggs · 20/11/2021 10:00

Not directly on the point, but mortgage debt is kind of different anyway. Although you borrow, you have an asset to show for it, which normally will at least hold it's value. In other words you might be £100k in debt, but you have a £100k asset, so in fact on your "balance sheet" you're no worse off.

If you run a credit card up to £10k on nights out and strappy sandles you're £10k in debt with nothing to show for it.

ArblemarchTFruitbat · 20/11/2021 10:00

[quote flamebuoy]@ArblemarchTFruitbat no the mortgage was his. She never lived in his old house as I don't think as it's in another city. He sold and moved to where she lives now with her. [/quote]
Yes - I said a mortgage was involved .

Her DH (I assume) wouldn't have been able to buy the house he eventually sold to finance the one they bought together without taking out a mortgage.

CounsellorTroi · 20/11/2021 09:59

I’ve had a joint mortgage with DH, and have a credit card, but never any loans or anything on finance.

This woman must have saved a hell of a lot if she had enough, together with the profit from her DH’s mortgaged home, to buy a house outright.

Fomofo · 20/11/2021 09:59

I don't have a credit card

SquishySquirmy · 20/11/2021 09:59

Not me!
I suppose the first 2 are fairly achievable, especially in generations without tuition fees, and of course lots of people don't go to uni. I've never had a car on finance or a personal unsecured loan etc.

Buying a house mortgage fee is much much more difficult without a large inheritance/family money I'd have thought.

I've not had many loans. But I have had:

  • Student loan (worth it in the long run, I now have a well paying career i wouldn't be able to have without my degree).
  • credit card for a short time while trying to build up a credit history, paid off in full each month (so not sure if that counts?)
  • Mortgage. Again, definitely worth it and I dont consider it "bad debt" iyswim.

But even though I've been very lucky in life, and I think I am reasonably responsible with money and financially literate,
I would never have been able to afford a house or a degree without a loan.