Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Melanie Sykes has revealed she's autistic

236 replies

Latenightpharma · 20/11/2021 09:37

She was diagnosed at 51. Christine McGuiness also shared an autism diagnosis recently, and I wonder how I feel about all this. On one hand I think it's great that people like her are coming forward and are increasing representation, on the other hand I'm worried that others might underestimate how much the condition affects me (also have autism) at work because news outlets tend to report on stuff like this with an air of 'no big deal'.

To be clear, I'm not trying to suggest that Melanie or Christine are less affected by being autistic than I am, I don't know how much it affects them on a daily basis. What I'm trying to say is that someone like my boss might look at this and go 'oh, see, no big deal, do you really need accomodations to work or are you just being difficult? These people manage just fine.' AIBU?

OP posts:
SweeneyPlodd · 20/11/2021 10:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

OhDear2200 · 20/11/2021 10:56

@JaniieJones

God, its like anxiety and depression everyone seems to have it so the ones that actually do have it then struggle to access services.

Who cares if she is autistic. She seems to be living a full and happy life surely she could focus on that.

Ha! My DC very much appears to be living a ‘full and happy life’ to the outside world. Because they hold it together in the ‘outside world’ at home I promise they don’t…..

My bet that this is the same for these two women. I’m assuming that they wanted some answers to why they found life so bloody difficult. For example (my life yesterday) hysterical crying over a minor difficulty that everyone manages day one day out. Or last weekend trashing the whole house due to finding times tables overwhelming.

SueSaid · 20/11/2021 10:53

Absolutely @HousethatChunkbuilt

Cakeandslippers · 20/11/2021 10:53

I think there might be two separate issues here. It seems women are underdiagnosed for lots of reasons so to see women coming out with their diagnoses and being able to show the world that you don't have to be a white boy to be autistic is surely a good thing.

The issue, I think, might be more that people generally lack an understanding of what autism actually is. They either see it as someone who is non verbal and struggles to function in many ways, or rain man. I recently referred to Greta Tunberg being autistic and the people I were talking too just wouldn't have it as she doesn't seem it apparently.

So I fully see your dilemma / issue here but I do think that more women 'coming out' as such will only help further the understanding of autism which hopefully in turn will give opportunities for wider awareness about how much of a spectrum it is and also how much women in particular can mask their struggles.

HousethatChunkbuilt · 20/11/2021 10:49

I don't think it's the case with Mel or Christine, but dare I say there is a bit of a trend at the moment for women to suddenly claim they're neurodiverse.
I was at a dinner party the other day and two women were giggling about their 'ADHD' think 'oh yes it's awful isn't it when I need to do housework but just end up looking at my phone instead!' I thought 'we all do that, we all procrastinate and get distracted and think about a million things at a time'. It's a symptom of modern life!
I wish they could see my dd who physically shakes when she has to sit at a desk and can only read whilst kicking her legs at hummingbird speed, who loathes school and will never be able to be in class independently without a full time aid keeping her on track. Even when I get private help they ask to stop the sessions as they can't keep her focussed.
I can't help but think some of this is a bit similar to when everyone was 'gluten intolerant' or 'dairy intolerant' a few years ago. I know that it was under-diagnosed years ago but I tend to think it's over diagnosed now due to private 'gun for hire' psychiatrists.

ancientgran · 20/11/2021 10:48

@x2boys

Well it's great she feels able to talk about her diagnosis ,but it does nothing for autism awareness for those that are most severely impacted ,when they had that chase presenter ,whose name escapes me on I'm a celebrity a few years ago ,I got into Facebook discussions,with people they were saying autism definitely isn't a disability ,I pointed out that for my non verbal severely autistic son it definitely is .
I understand. I used to work in a setting with autistic adults who will spend their lives in care and non verbal. Autism truly is a spectrum.
PingedPotato · 20/11/2021 10:48

God, its like anxiety and depression everyone seems to have it so the ones that actually do have it then struggle to access services. so you're doubting all their diagnosis?! How do you know there aren't that may people who "actually do have it"?

Lucyinthesky07 · 20/11/2021 10:45

I do understand what you are saying.

I was a child of the 1980s and had all the classic signs of autism - I struggled to make eye contact, couldn't cope with hugs, "rocked" back and forth to music and sometimes during lessons would rock on my chair, withdrew from friendships, couldn't cope with changes, struggled with busy/ noisy environments.
My brother (2 years younger) also had signs.

My brother chose to seek a diagnosis as an adult, and says it really helped him to have that clarity. It said it was like a huge release to him and that everything made sense.

I on the other hand have chosen not to.
I still have a lot of the traits I had as a child - social anxiety, struggle to make eye contact, can't cope with busy places etc.
Two of my children are on the spectrum and I do feel a lot of unjustified guilt.

I think everyone feels differently about it, but I'm just happy being me.

SueSaid · 20/11/2021 10:42

God, its like anxiety and depression everyone seems to have it so the ones that actually do have it then struggle to access services.

Who cares if she is autistic. She seems to be living a full and happy life surely she could focus on that.

icedcoffees · 20/11/2021 10:41

@EatSleepRantRepeat

I think part of the problem here is the removal of the term Aspergers in favour of a wider autism description. I've often felt that my 'type' of autism does severely intellectually impaired people a disservice, because others in my community at work have said their bosses have unfavourably compared their coping abilities to mine.

I worry about the 'you wouldn't guess' / 'surprise!' tone of these articles - masking is painful and incredibly stressful, I regularly melt down at home after a long day holding it together at work. If I wasn't expected to copy NT behaviours to hold down my job (eye-contact, large meetings, face to face networking) my life at home would be far more restful - WFH has been a godsend for that.

I agree.

I was diagnosed with Asperger's and it's very different (imo) from severe autism. Yes, both conditions may be on the same scale but using one word to describe both does people at both ends of the spectrum a huge disservice imo.

EatSleepRantRepeat · 20/11/2021 10:32

I think part of the problem here is the removal of the term Aspergers in favour of a wider autism description. I've often felt that my 'type' of autism does severely intellectually impaired people a disservice, because others in my community at work have said their bosses have unfavourably compared their coping abilities to mine.

I worry about the 'you wouldn't guess' / 'surprise!' tone of these articles - masking is painful and incredibly stressful, I regularly melt down at home after a long day holding it together at work. If I wasn't expected to copy NT behaviours to hold down my job (eye-contact, large meetings, face to face networking) my life at home would be far more restful - WFH has been a godsend for that.

cansu · 20/11/2021 10:21

I read an article about what she has been saying and I felt v pissed off. All this guff about her autism being the best thing about her and completely rebuilding the education system so children can learn in nature. She seemingly doesn't see or want to see the many people with autism whose autism has blighted their lives. I have a dc with severe non verbalautism and v severe learning difficulties and epilepsy. I don't really see his autism as a gift and the best thing about him.

Latenightpharma · 20/11/2021 10:20

@user1478172746

But they are not managing everything ideally, that's why they seek diagnosis. What is the alternative? Are they not entitled of diagnosis? Should they keep that a secret? Should media ignore this life event of celebrities? Seing representatives in all walks of life could give hope to young autistics and help their self-esteem. Self-esteem is the most important thing in any success - big or small. It would do you good as well, if you would stop and saw the good things in your life. Being employed for the start. That's success.
When did I say that I thought I was a failure, or that there are no good things in my life? I was talking about needing accommodations and media reports about this glossing over how much it can affect you and that maybe influencing people like my boss.
OP posts:
AutumnInBustletown · 20/11/2021 10:20

I was really happy to see Mel go public with her diagnosis. There is still a lot of stigma around autism I'm women.

PingedPotato · 20/11/2021 10:17

Getting adjustments at work always ends up being a little like people looking at you and rolling their eyes behind your back whilst thinking you just need to get a grip. is it really like this or do you think you are reading it wrong? I only ask because I felt similar when I put in my flexibile working request but actually HR said at the end they were really pleased I'd asked and hoped I'd encourage others to apply.

Hospedia · 20/11/2021 10:17

Christine and Mel may be truly autistic.

What exactly is "truly autistic"? Hmm

x2boys · 20/11/2021 10:16

Well it's great she feels able to talk about her diagnosis ,but it does nothing for autism awareness for those that are most severely impacted ,when they had that chase presenter ,whose name escapes me on I'm a celebrity a few years ago ,I got into Facebook discussions,with people they were saying autism definitely isn't a disability ,I pointed out that for my non verbal severely autistic son it definitely is .

SoupDragon · 20/11/2021 10:16

I'm a similar age to Melanie Sykes and when I was a child' autism didn't exist in the same way it does now. It was all down to being naughty or whatever. The same with ADHD - looking back, the "naughty boy" in my primary classes very clearly had ADHD.

Hospedia · 20/11/2021 10:16

I agree @user1478172746 and I would hope that it encourages more employers to take a chance on autistic job applicants rather than just dismissing them out of hand as well as showing young autistic people that disability shouldn't be a barrier. These two celebrities disclosing their diagnosis isn't a magic fix but it contributes to small steps being taken in the direction of acceptance and equity.

SoupDragon · 20/11/2021 10:13

A lot of people hear "Autistic" and think "Rainman". Isn't it better to have people in the public eye showing that that isn't always the case? It brings the "spectrum" part of the condition to the front.

Christine and Mel may be truly autistic.. Are you doubting their diagnosis?

WholeClassKeptIn · 20/11/2021 10:13

CorBlimey exactly! I can do eye contact and have empathy therefore cant be autistic. U thought this my self for ages...

But adult women have learnt to mask and despite several very good degrees my life is a mess rather than successful and I struggle every single day.

jewel1968 · 20/11/2021 10:11

As someone who managed a person with autism (making adjustments etc....) this would have had little or no impact on me. It might have triggered a conversation and that might have led to greater understanding for me. I have not read any articles but it might educate people.

Latenightpharma · 20/11/2021 10:10

@Grimbelina

I am sorry you are struggling to make people understand how it affects you... but I am hoping the opposite, that it helps people understand that autism can present so individually and that struggles can be hidden.

I have a child like this: amazing masking but falls apart. Getting people to understand that they need accommodations is an ongoing struggle as they 'don't look autistic'.

I am also all for the higher visibility of older women with ASC as this group may well be under-diagnosed.

I hope that too! I'm just worried. I did not really know who these two women were before the news reports, but I'm glad they can show a different face of autism if that makes sense, especially due to the assumption that autistic adults in the workplace are mostly men who love code.

Getting adjustments at work always ends up being a little like people looking at you and rolling their eyes behind your back whilst thinking you just need to get a grip. So I'm concerned that whilst this is great for representation, it does little about understanding.

OP posts:
user1478172746 · 20/11/2021 10:09

But they are not managing everything ideally, that's why they seek diagnosis. What is the alternative? Are they not entitled of diagnosis? Should they keep that a secret? Should media ignore this life event of celebrities? Seing representatives in all walks of life could give hope to young autistics and help their self-esteem. Self-esteem is the most important thing in any success - big or small. It would do you good as well, if you would stop and saw the good things in your life. Being employed for the start. That's success.

Emmelina · 20/11/2021 10:09

@Sleepyblueocean

"I don’t know much about Melanie Sykes. I do know that Christine McGuinness has three children, all with autism, and she has long blamed herself for their condition for various reasons"

Melanie Sykes has a child with autism.

As I said, I don’t know much about Melanie :)