Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Melanie Sykes has revealed she's autistic

236 replies

Latenightpharma · 20/11/2021 09:37

She was diagnosed at 51. Christine McGuiness also shared an autism diagnosis recently, and I wonder how I feel about all this. On one hand I think it's great that people like her are coming forward and are increasing representation, on the other hand I'm worried that others might underestimate how much the condition affects me (also have autism) at work because news outlets tend to report on stuff like this with an air of 'no big deal'.

To be clear, I'm not trying to suggest that Melanie or Christine are less affected by being autistic than I am, I don't know how much it affects them on a daily basis. What I'm trying to say is that someone like my boss might look at this and go 'oh, see, no big deal, do you really need accomodations to work or are you just being difficult? These people manage just fine.' AIBU?

OP posts:
Thefartingsofaofdenmarkstreet · 20/11/2021 12:03

However, I do feel that having a bunch of rich people telling us how easy it is to get the support (specificially with mental health) when I have been sat on a list for 2 years is grating.

So many instagrammers at the moment are talking about their 'therapists', and how 'everyone should go to therapy' and how they will probably continue going for regular therapy for the rest of their lives as it's 'so important' etc.

All of them are clearly paying a fortune for private therapy, and not on an NHS waiting list for 6 sessions!

Branleuse · 20/11/2021 12:02

@EdenFlower

And where exactly are these people suddenly getting their diagnosis's from?

I work in a school and I know how difficult it is to get a child diagnosed on the NHS and it's a lengthy process surrounded in bureaucracy with a long waiting list.

Not sure I would trust the outcome of any private' assossociations that are clearly there to make a profit.

im pretty sure that you dont get a reimbursement on your assessment fees if you dont get a diagnosis, and I think thats quite a harsh thing to say about highly qualified psychiatrists and psychologists who are working in private practice. Private assessments are completely normal due to the underfunding in the NHS, but you cant just rock up and buy a diagnosis fgs. Lots of these people work for both the NHS and privately What profit is there to be made here?
ofwarren · 20/11/2021 11:58

@EdenFlower

And where exactly are these people suddenly getting their diagnosis's from?

I work in a school and I know how difficult it is to get a child diagnosed on the NHS and it's a lengthy process surrounded in bureaucracy with a long waiting list.

Not sure I would trust the outcome of any private' assossociations that are clearly there to make a profit.

A lot of the private ones do NHS diagnosis too. They follow the same pathway to diagnosis.
Branleuse · 20/11/2021 11:58

@HousethatChunkbuilt

How come people aren't lining up to come out as having personality disorders though?
because still a massive stigma about long term mental illnesses in general, and I expect it would very much depend on how it affected the person and whether they were aware and it was under control as to whether they felt able to be open about it, or if it isnt under control then theres not much hiding it in the first place, which youd need to be able to "come out". Obviously there is no medication for autism as its not an illness in itself, so it is not really the same as a personality disorder
EdenFlower · 20/11/2021 11:55

And where exactly are these people suddenly getting their diagnosis's from?

I work in a school and I know how difficult it is to get a child diagnosed on the NHS and it's a lengthy process surrounded in bureaucracy with a long waiting list.

Not sure I would trust the outcome of any private' assossociations that are clearly there to make a profit.

FancyAnOlive · 20/11/2021 11:53

The more people who are open about their autism diagnosis the better I think. I have two autistic daughters in their early teens and my older one is currently really struggling with her diagnosis. I know this sounds shallow but for her to see glamorous and successful women who are autistic is really really helpful.

Latenightpharma · 20/11/2021 11:51

@Branleuse

I think its nice that shes got some understanding and awareness of her life and struggles now, and inspirational that she has still managed to achieve what she has, considering the statistics of autistic people in employment in general. If someones boss says to you "well Melanie sykes is autistic and fine so therefore you dont need any accomodations" - which by the way, is extremely unlikely to happen, I guess you could say well so is elon musk, but im not about to start my own space mission either.

I think its clear that with autism being a spectrum, there are people that still manage to achieve their dreams, maybe in some ways because of their autistic tenacity and traits, and then theres also people that are so disabled by it that they wouldnt even have dreams to be able to achieve. Most autistic people are neither like rain-man, nor are they like Elon Musk. Im not sure why one person being diagnosed means they are supposed to represent the entire autistic population

I am aware that my boss is not going to tell me that Melanie Sykes is proof I don't need accomodations. However, it to me feeds into this wider thing at work. My employer (and probably quite a few in the UK) want to make this push to employ neurodiverse talent, but seem to believe that all that's needed to improve the amount of neurodiverse people at work is to simply hire some. When it comes to actually making it possible for those people to perform and remain in their jobs, they are generally baffled at the idea of needing to make actual changes or accomodations for individuals.

Stories portrayed like the Melanie one on BBC today worry me a bit because they might reinforce the idea that the only thing stopping autistic people from being successful at work is to not hire them because of discrimination.

OP posts:
dabbydeedoo · 20/11/2021 11:50

[quote Charley50]@EatSleepRantRepeat - I agree that it was a mistake to get rid of the Aspergers diagnosis. The spectrum of differences / difficulties under the diagnosis autism is now so huge as to be meaningless. From non-verbal, with learning difficulties who will never lead an independent life, to Chris Packham and Melanie Sykes and everyone in between. It should be named differently. [/quote]
But surely the entire point is that 'high functioning' doesn't mean high functioning in every way? Someone with a very high IQ with a PhD in Biochemistry could find relationships impossible and feel incredibly lonely and cut off from the world. Someone else might be able to have a happy successful relationship but be unable to hold down a job. I think it's very unfair to imply that traditionally successful people with high intelligence are somehow less affected. I think in some ways it can be worse - they have the intelligence to know how isolated and abnormal they feel all the time but the inability to do anything about it.

Lovemusic33 · 20/11/2021 11:46

I understand what you mean op, I hear it a lot when people are talking about my dd and comparing her to people they know with autism. People assume my dd is capable of things that she isn’t because “Chris Packham can do it”. I do think it’s great that people are talking about their diagnosis but I do think people need to be educated about the fact ‘Autism is a huge spectrum and each person is different’. My dd struggles hugely with communicating, she can’t tell me when somethings wrong and she can’t ask me for help but she’s a maths genius and great at taking things apart and rebuilding them 🤣, people assume she should be able to communicate because academically she is very able.

claymodels · 20/11/2021 11:46

I feel like getting an autism diagnosis now is a bit like getting a mental health diagnosis a few years back, whether that is because the stigma is lessening, in which case great, or whether it is the new trend.

Yeah; we are all getting diagnosed because it's trendy Sad

GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 20/11/2021 11:39

@Grimbelina

I am sorry you are struggling to make people understand how it affects you... but I am hoping the opposite, that it helps people understand that autism can present so individually and that struggles can be hidden.

I have a child like this: amazing masking but falls apart. Getting people to understand that they need accommodations is an ongoing struggle as they 'don't look autistic'.

I am also all for the higher visibility of older women with ASC as this group may well be under-diagnosed.

Oooh, I hear this!! Before we got DD's formal diagnosis, I had so many arguments with the school that went along these lines:

School: But she seems fine!
Me: She does, doesn't she? Do you have any idea how hard she works at seeming fine?

Sobeyondthehills · 20/11/2021 11:37

I feel like getting an autism diagnosis now is a bit like getting a mental health diagnosis a few years back, whether that is because the stigma is lessening, in which case great, or whether it is the new trend.

However, I do feel that having a bunch of rich people telling us how easy it is to get the support (specificially with mental health) when I have been sat on a list for 2 years is grating.

And like you OP, I get things like well xyz has anxiety and yet managed to perform infront of 5 billion people, makes me think people still don't understand, so I get that sometimes, the awareness aspect is not always as great as it could be

Malibuismysecrethome · 20/11/2021 11:35

I think it would be more helpful if they explained how their autism effects them. As a previous poster pointed out they are both successful so it would be helpful to know what aspects they struggle with. There are so many spectrums. I know they don’t owe me an explanation but it would clarify their proclamation that they are autistic.

Hodgehog · 20/11/2021 11:31

House - I absolutely agree. Milder forms are seen as socially acceptable but severe depression and things like BPD very much are not.

I really rate this article for summarising that.

OhDear2200 · 20/11/2021 11:28

@Latenightpharma sorry massively derailed you thread…off to do housework now Smile

Branleuse · 20/11/2021 11:27

I think its nice that shes got some understanding and awareness of her life and struggles now, and inspirational that she has still managed to achieve what she has, considering the statistics of autistic people in employment in general. If someones boss says to you "well Melanie sykes is autistic and fine so therefore you dont need any accomodations" - which by the way, is extremely unlikely to happen, I guess you could say well so is elon musk, but im not about to start my own space mission either.

I think its clear that with autism being a spectrum, there are people that still manage to achieve their dreams, maybe in some ways because of their autistic tenacity and traits, and then theres also people that are so disabled by it that they wouldnt even have dreams to be able to achieve. Most autistic people are neither like rain-man, nor are they like Elon Musk. Im not sure why one person being diagnosed means they are supposed to represent the entire autistic population

OhDear2200 · 20/11/2021 11:27

@HousethatChunkbuilt oh sorry! My mistake.

Oh yes I can see you point 👍

TractorAndHeadphones · 20/11/2021 11:27

[quote HousethatChunkbuilt]@OhDear2200 I'm sorry but it's in the psychiatrists interests to give a diagnosis as they will then get more money for the medication and see you again for more appointments. Plus the one of the main problems with the whole of the nhs is the lack on consultants. If they work privately then that makes the problem worse, so the waiting times will get longer![/quote]
They can't medicate people who don't need it- it will cause adverse effects. It's not the US system where they can order a battery of tests etc that don't actually harm the patient while giving them more money.

Also consultants leave the NHS because they're underpaid ; plus there aren't enough training vacancies. Blame the government, not people seeking treatment

OhDear2200 · 20/11/2021 11:26

@CallMeBettyBoop you are very lucky. I know for a fact in our area it is 3 years.

HousethatChunkbuilt · 20/11/2021 11:25

@OhDear2200 sorry I should have been clear, I was referring to ADHD

OhDear2200 · 20/11/2021 11:25

@HousethatChunkbuilt but I absolutely agree with you about lack of consultants. But that is NOT the public’s fault. It is NOT their fault for seeking an assessment when the NHS is on its knees. It is the Government’s fault.

TractorAndHeadphones · 20/11/2021 11:23

@Latenightpharma

I think I didn't explain it well enough in my opening post maybe so sorry. I don't know how to feel about the way people in the public eye revealing they are autistic are being portrayed in the media. Their 'coming out story' basically.

I have no issue with them realising they are autistic or feelings about them getting diagnosed. That's great, happy for them!

OP I get what you're saying and you've seen evidence of this in the comments as well but maybe the opposite. Posters saying 'you're not as impaired as someone else, so you're making a big fuss over nothing'.

Both the women diagnosed do share their struggles though - Nikki even mentioned having meltdowns and having to go into isolation. The truth is a lot of these things can be explained away, some people succeed 'despite' it and some people are accidentally in the right environment.

There are some articles though like this one I know it's the sun but it includes other women and a paragraph from the national autistic society
www.the-sun.com/lifestyle/4105993/adult-autism-diagnosis-melanie-sykes-christine-mcguinness/

The important takeaway is that if more people realise the signs more will be diagnosed and get the help that they need. It doesn't need to even be a label or announced to everyone else but so that people understand themselves , and everybody else realises that an autistic person doesn't have a specific 'profile', so likely to believe you

OhDear2200 · 20/11/2021 11:23

[quote HousethatChunkbuilt]@OhDear2200 I'm sorry but it's in the psychiatrists interests to give a diagnosis as they will then get more money for the medication and see you again for more appointments. Plus the one of the main problems with the whole of the nhs is the lack on consultants. If they work privately then that makes the problem worse, so the waiting times will get longer![/quote]
Ha ha ha what medication?????

You can’t medicate ASD!

HousethatChunkbuilt · 20/11/2021 11:21

@Hodgehog yes that seems right but I feel that some mental illness is seen as acceptable and some isn't. Psychosis for example.

Hodgehog · 20/11/2021 11:18

House I imagine it’s because there is still enormous stigma even within the medical profession about personality disorders which has yet to be overcome.

Autism over the last few years has become better understood and somewhat less stigmatised. Not that there’s not still some way to go Ofcourse.