Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Melanie Sykes has revealed she's autistic

236 replies

Latenightpharma · 20/11/2021 09:37

She was diagnosed at 51. Christine McGuiness also shared an autism diagnosis recently, and I wonder how I feel about all this. On one hand I think it's great that people like her are coming forward and are increasing representation, on the other hand I'm worried that others might underestimate how much the condition affects me (also have autism) at work because news outlets tend to report on stuff like this with an air of 'no big deal'.

To be clear, I'm not trying to suggest that Melanie or Christine are less affected by being autistic than I am, I don't know how much it affects them on a daily basis. What I'm trying to say is that someone like my boss might look at this and go 'oh, see, no big deal, do you really need accomodations to work or are you just being difficult? These people manage just fine.' AIBU?

OP posts:
DietrichandDiMaggio · 20/11/2021 13:30

@SoupDragon

I'm a similar age to Melanie Sykes and when I was a child' autism didn't exist in the same way it does now. It was all down to being naughty or whatever. The same with ADHD - looking back, the "naughty boy" in my primary classes very clearly had ADHD.
Autism existed at that time, but people like Mel Sykes, and indeed probably all of the people who are able to respond on here who have a diagnosis of autism, would not have met the diagnostic criteria for autism. The children who would have been diagnosed with classic autism would have been nowhere near a mainstream school, and many would have been institutionalised.
TheOriginalEmu · 20/11/2021 13:29

If you read Christines book you will see how not fine she has been and how much it has affected her life, I don’t see any of these people saying it’s fine.
I was diagnosed aged 40 after a life time of thinking I was just a failure of a human, we need more women to be open about it to realise how many of us are out there.

Oblomov21 · 20/11/2021 13:27

Cansu: "All this guff about her autism being the best thing about her and completely rebuilding the education system so children can learn in nature. "

I agree. I don't agree with her views. I don't feel that way about it. I'm all for raising awareness of autism. But the way she feels about it, I don't.

LonginesPrime · 20/11/2021 13:26

someone like my boss might look at this and go 'oh, see, no big deal, do you really need accomodations to work or are you just being difficult? These people manage just fine.'

I can see why you're worried about this if you already feel that your workplace isn't particularly accommodating in terms of disability, OP.

But if your boss or colleagues aren't taking your disability and the ways it affects you seriously, the media they've digested that have caused them to form those opinions about your condition is completely irrelevant to the actual issue of how they are potentially discriminating against you, which would be illegal.

It doesn't matter if they've read an article or listened to a podcast about autism or whatever - if they aren't making the reasonable adjustments they're required to make or are harassing your due to disability, then you are protected under law, regardless of what some random news article says.

NettleTea · 20/11/2021 13:26

@gogohm

Kind of annoys me too... my dd was diagnosed at 2.5 because she was so behind, she's now a young woman at university but within a few minutes in her company you can tell. If you can get to 30+ without a diagnosis and only get one because a private psychiatrist who is being paid by you to tell you what label you have diagnosed you, it's not really a diagnosis is it? The fact they went public makes me even more uncomfortable. Autism is lifelong, I could tell at just weeks old she was different
dont forget that for many of us, autism was not recognised when we were still young, and Aspergers was not in the DSM until 1987. I left sixth form in 1984.

And even more recently, it was really uncommon for girls to be considered, unless they fell down the extreme end, and Ive seen reports that many assumed they had brain damage, not autism, as autism was for boys.

So yes, you may find women in their 40s and 50s getting a diagnosis. I am one of them. And despite being artistically and academically gifted, being the child at 15 voted 'most likely to be a success' , I cannot hold down a fulltime job for more than 2 years without having a breakdown. And I cannot function in a corporate role at all.

CallMeBettyBoop · 20/11/2021 13:23

@OhDear2200 no problem. I've been misunderstood a lot over the years - quelle surprise Grin

NettleTea · 20/11/2021 13:19

@EdenFlower

And where exactly are these people suddenly getting their diagnosis's from?

I work in a school and I know how difficult it is to get a child diagnosed on the NHS and it's a lengthy process surrounded in bureaucracy with a long waiting list.

Not sure I would trust the outcome of any private' assossociations that are clearly there to make a profit.

yes, and thats exactly what the B*H of a referal unit head told me about my daughter

'you will get the diagnosis you pay for'

and I took her to the most experienced man I could find - recommended 7 years ago as an expert with girls, ex trustee for NAS, ex head of childrens MH services, expert witness. And then our NHS assessment came through and I took her to that too.

why would a professional stake their career on dishing out some fake diagnosis - to what benefit? They dont charge more for a fake one. The process is the same, its just carried out over just shy of a week in a 1-2-1 setting, it is in fact possibly more thorough. They have waiting lists too. Why risk their professional reputation, risk being struck off. Because once youve been through their door, they dont make any more out of you.

And its not as if it actually offers you any extra support in alot of cases - once you have the ASD diagnosis, you are kicked off CAMHS, because its not a mental health problem. And the fight with the school for an EHCP is still the same - because thats all down to observation and intervention

Im sorry, but this attitude that you can buy yourself a diagnosis makes me really angry

TractorAndHeadphones · 20/11/2021 13:17

@HousethatChunkbuilt

So on MN you can self diagnose as being autistic or having ADHD because the NHS waiting lists are longer but you cannot self ID as a man or woman where waiting lists to start the process are longer. I feel sometimes we are sleepwalking into this place where rational thinking is becoming rare. Obviously if every professional you ever meet says 'yes you definitely have x' and it limits many aspects of your life (professional/social) then your diagnosis is more meaningful to you. Spending too much time on the internet means that you are more likely to think 'that's me' because we by nature we try to relate to things. My question is why are people not googling 'do I have bipolar or avoidant or antisocial personality disorders?' and getting a private diagnosis. Also what does a diagnosis give you at 40 years old? My friend is quite plainly on the spectrum and has no interest in getting a diagnosis. Her quote was 'what would change?'
How do you know they're not doing that? Also you're doing the same thing - taking an individual person on the spectrum and using them for everyone else.

Someone else could come along and argue that your daughter is still able to feed herself, doesn't try to injure herself and doesn't require 24 hour care - so why are you making such a big fuss?

Also you're lying again about the self diagnosis. You previously stated that it's over-diagnosed and you're suddenly changing your story to self-ID.

TractorAndHeadphones · 20/11/2021 13:14

@claymodels
so sorry you had to go through that!
This thread has indeed been eye opening.
We know now what everyone else thinks of us. Not just the general public but people who have autistic family members.

That we've spent lots of time, money and effort for no reason other than wanting a get out of jail free card (newsflash : it's the opposite).

That we're faking it, not neurodiverse enough, have no problems because nobody else sees it.

Maybe it's an NT thing - these people have family members that are ND, they themselves are not ND, so they don't understand how it works.

OhDear2200 · 20/11/2021 13:14

@CallMeBettyBoop 👍 sorry!

CallMeBettyBoop · 20/11/2021 13:12

@OhDear2200 My DD - who lives 30 miles away - is still waiting over 3 yrs later. I wasn't questioning what you said, just stating my own experience.

TractorAndHeadphones · 20/11/2021 13:06

@Flapjak

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.
Not true. And a point that relates to @Latenightpharma's concerns about the workplace. There are 3 broad categories of neurodiverse people:
  • Mask well/in an environment that suits their needs. Nobody even needs to know they're ND.
  • Can perform with adjustments.
This is the biggest category and again a lot of nuance. To what extent are adjustments worth hiring them? Some people just need adjustments like the sort of work given, the way things are said/interpreted. Some need constant supervision and telling what to do such that it becomes a huge element of someone else's work.
  • Will never be able to work no matter what adjustments would be put in place.

And the same applies to friendships and social behaviour.
Again DP and his group of friends are all ND. One person who is very rigid, insists on things going his way and tantrums when they don't. As a result nobody wants to play video games with him.

A diagnosis is not a free pass to behave however you like

OhDear2200 · 20/11/2021 13:05

@HousethatChunkbuilt isn’t it important to know whether you have PD or are autistic?

Many many women were wrong dx with BD when they were autistic. Leading to the wrong ‘treatment’ for many years.

claymodels · 20/11/2021 13:05

Also what does a diagnosis give you at 40 years old? My friend is quite plainly on the spectrum and has no interest in getting a diagnosis. Her quote was 'what would change?'

It gave me everything.

Quoting your friend is not really worth much, we are all different. She doesn't want to be assessed, fine. Lots of us both want and need that, so don't try to take away simply because others are not the same.

claymodels · 20/11/2021 13:03

@Flapjak

I think we could all meet the diagnosis for autism with a bit of knowledge of what to say. Once you have this diagnosis easy to use it to excuse difficult or unacceptable behaviour.

Don't be so fucking stupid Hmm

You don't just have a wee chat and walk out with an ASD diagnosis Angry

This thread is a real fucking eye opener, isn't it Sad

HousethatChunkbuilt · 20/11/2021 13:02

So on MN you can self diagnose as being autistic or having ADHD because the NHS waiting lists are longer but you cannot self ID as a man or woman where waiting lists to start the process are longer.
I feel sometimes we are sleepwalking into this place where rational thinking is becoming rare. Obviously if every professional you ever meet says 'yes you definitely have x' and it limits many aspects of your life (professional/social) then your diagnosis is more meaningful to you. Spending too much time on the internet means that you are more likely to think 'that's me' because we by nature we try to relate to things. My question is why are people not googling 'do I have bipolar or avoidant or antisocial personality disorders?' and getting a private diagnosis.
Also what does a diagnosis give you at 40 years old? My friend is quite plainly on the spectrum and has no interest in getting a diagnosis. Her quote was 'what would change?'

OhDear2200 · 20/11/2021 13:01

@claymodelsFlowers

claymodels · 20/11/2021 13:00

I have been sitting fizzing over the comment that a diagnosis isn't a diagnosis of it has been done privately.

Let me tell you my story (short version)

Had a horrific childhood due to being autistic and no understanding or intervention. Got worse in my teens, started to drink to cope, ended up with an alcohol problem, an eating disorder and still struggling. I was targeted because I was vulnerable but because I had no idea I thought these people 'loved' me. One of them was 62 and he raped me repeatedly for months when I was 16. Nobody was there for me because they all thought I was a the bad apple in the family. Nobody understood me. Everybody thought I was weird, horrible, not right and a bit of an idiot. Every day of my life I put on a face and tried to be normal - and it goes on

Fast forward to my realisation, which by the way came about because knowledge and understanding is much greater nowadays, not because I wasn't autistic when I was 2 like your child, that I was possibly autistic. It took me 5 years to pluck up the courage to go to the GP, because I don't do things like that but I did and he told me I couldn't be autistic and refused to refer me because I had a husband and a job and DC. I then had an absolute breakdown a year or so later and DH convinced me to seek a private assessment because that's what it is by the way, you don't pay for a private diagnosis you pay for an assessment, which may or may not lead to diagnosis. I spent months researching obsessively over who should do this assessment and finally found someone who also worked in the NHS and had been part of the team who developed SIGN 145. I was assessed using exactly the same method that is used by the NHS to diagnose adults and by one of the top people in the country. It was worth every penny, but again I paid for assessment, not a diagnosis - that was the result of the assessment I paid for. You don't just rock up and hand over money for a diagnosis.

Since having the diagnosis I have been able to reframe my life, my experiences, to be more self aware and less harsh. I have stopped doing things to try and prove I am 'normal' and if o need time out I simply take it. Going forward I can protect myself from abusive people and maybe not end up getting repeatedly raped as I now have the understanding that I do very much needed all those years ago.

gunnersgold · 20/11/2021 12:57

She has an autistic son too!

OhDear2200 · 20/11/2021 12:56

Also do people really believe that families are paying thousands for assessments because they ‘want a label’ people are absolutely desperate! Desperate to get the right education, desperate to stop their family member harming themselves (or others) desperate to sleep desperate to get their child to eat etc.

Christ have some compassion

AlfonsoTheUnrepentant · 20/11/2021 12:54

I am glad that Ms Sykes was assessed properly and didn't self-diagnose.

Hospedia · 20/11/2021 12:54

I think we could all meet the diagnosis for autism with a bit of knowledge of what to say. Once you have this diagnosis easy to use it to excuse difficult or unacceptable behaviour.

What absolute rubbish.

OhDear2200 · 20/11/2021 12:54

@EdenFlower I find your suggestion that people who only ‘know’ that their child was different at 2.5 massively offensive. That’s your experience not everyone’s. It’s a crass opinion that hugely ignores the years of confusion and worry for people.

I would have hoped a parent of an autistic child would understand that.

Jericha · 20/11/2021 12:53

@gogohm I was diagnosed privately. The person who diagnosed me works diagnosing autism in the NHS as their main job.

I know of a person who approached them and after their initial one hour appointment was advised it was unlikely they'd fulfil the diagnostic criteria if they underwent the full assessment. The assessment is the expensive part. I don't think they'd tell people this if they were just after a quick buck.

TractorAndHeadphones · 20/11/2021 12:53

@EdenFlower

*What profit is there to be made here?*

Errr.....quite a lot, I would think!

There may be profit - but are you actually saying that everyone gets a diagnosis because they paid? Also that the help people receive as a result of their diagnosis that enables them to understand that better - a complete waste of time?